HELP Tyre choice
Author
Discussion

Martin Stiles

Original Poster:

13 posts

172 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Havent posted for a long while, however still very much in love with my Monaro 2005 CV8, recently I replaced the 2 front tyres,
the current tyres fitted all round were 18" Goodyear F1, I had the new tyres put on the rear and moved the well worn rears to the front.
I had the geometry completely checked/adjusted at the same time.
On driving the car I found that it had been transformed into a rather scary ride, I first noticed it changing lanes on the m/way,
the car would roll from the rear, giving an impression that it was oversteering not one you felt that you should steer into,
when I then drove the car on a bendy road even at low speeds I could produce the same uncomfortable roll.
The car was booked in at Monkfish for a gearbox upgrade, I asked them about the problem Roger said its tyres!
This was a surprise as I had replaced exactly like for like F1 Goodyear EL with the exact same load/speed index!
I asked Monkfish to switch the tyres front to back therefore putting the worn rear tyres back where they were before the problem arose.
No more problem! Drove perfect again so problem solved, but the tyres are close to being below the limit, now my question
what do I do to replace the tyres and not get the problem back, Roger said the car originally came with Bridgestone RE040,
which were produced especially for the car, these are no longer available, RE050 were the next evolement, but these I can only
find in Porsche NI and NO fitment, I understand Michelin Super sport may be the way, ANYONE have the definitive answer??

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
I think the worn tyres were the problem, because they were worn, and so the profile wouldn't match what the front wanted to do with them. I would put a new pair of Goodyears on the back, to go with the new ones on the front.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
ARAF said:
I think the worn tyres were the problem, because they were worn, and so the profile wouldn't match what the front wanted to do with them.
+1

Gear box upgrade you say ?

Monaros are very fussy with tyre yes

the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Martin i feel for you. i had a set of goodyear f1 types on my Monaro CV8 and had exactly the same problem. i would never use them on the monaro again, i believe although its the same brand / model tyre as your old ones they are made in different factories to different tolerances..

i have fun dunlop sport MAXX TT with no such issues and im now running vredestein vorti and there just great.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
the_ferret82 said:
im now running vredestein vorti and there just great.
Best mid price tyre for the monaro it seams.. If you can run the cost and the quicker wear rate, then PSS biggrin

the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
007 VXR said:
the_ferret82 said:
im now running vredestein vorti and there just great.
Best mid price tyre for the monaro it seams.. If you can run the cost and the quicker wear rate, then PSS biggrin
last time i looked they dont make PSS in the right size for the 18 inch wheels wink

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
the_ferret82 said:
last time i looked they dont make PSS in the right size for the 18 inch wheels wink
Think they do PS2/3

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
I had my 05 CV8 from new. Yes they had RE040s from new and I had a second set. I'm now just about to change my second set of RE050s. They seem the same other than the RE040s were directional, the 50s are not, and the RE040s had better rim protection. Tread pattern looks pretty similar.

I'm thinking of new tyres and have always been under the impression that all tyres are a much of a muchness, which seems to be re enforced by the EU rating system that puts almost all 235/40ZR18s as E or F for economy (poor), B or C for wet whether grip (good) and 72dB for noise. My Nissan Leaf has eco tyres and these are generally quieter than the Monaro, the Monaro seams more susceptible to the road surface type.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
£112 seams like a bargin smile
http://www.camskill.co.uk/m61b0s322p111421/Vredest...

Or PS2/3 @ £142

bigwheel

1,640 posts

245 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Martin Stiles said:
Havent posted for a long while, however still very much in love with my Monaro 2005 CV8, recently I replaced the 2 front tyres, the current tyres fitted all round were 18" Goodyear F1, I had the new tyres put on the rear and moved the well worn rears to the front.
I had the geometry completely checked/adjusted at the same time.
On driving the car I found that it had been transformed into a rather scary ride, I first noticed it changing lanes on the m/way, the car would roll from the rear, giving an impression that it was oversteering not one you felt that you should steer into, when I then drove the car on a bendy road even at low speeds I could produce the same uncomfortable roll.

Switched the tyres front to back therefore putting the worn rear tyres back where they were before the problem arose.

No more problem! Drove perfect again so problem solved.
Exactly as above....
For me, same car. Same tyres. Same scenario.

Bought new Conti Sport Contact 5 because F1's on the front were worn on very narrow strip, inside shoulder. (BMW forum showed same wear problem with F1's)
Moved worn rear F1's to the front and thought I was doing the safe thing with new tyres going onto the driven axle.

This instantly gave me the same very scary ride as the OP.

So swapped front to back etc.

Transformed to a safe and very controllable drive, especially when making progress.

Despite common knowledge that all 4 tyres should be the same, the car now feels more balanced with these 2 differing makes in this combination. A bit like the VXR8's having different sized tyres F/R.



Edited by bigwheel on Saturday 7th September 23:53

jet_noise

6,111 posts

213 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Dear MS,

I've got RE050 on the back and they are N0 or N1 I forget which. Very, very good.
Tip: don't try Nexen N6000 on the back although they're fine on the front,

regards,
Jet

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
What suspension do you have ? I had MF put pedders low all round and it transformed the car, very good mod indeed, standard suspension is quite Knackered after 35k miles

Martin Stiles

Original Poster:

13 posts

172 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
007 VXR said:
+1

Gear box upgrade you say ?

Monaros are very fussy with tyre yes
Std Monaro box exchanged for VXR box

Martin Stiles

Original Poster:

13 posts

172 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi, Bigwheel, Nice to know someone with the exact same problem, including the worn inside strip on the replaced front tyres,
however it seems you still have the same problem, of what you will do when the rears need replacing?
At this moment in time I leaning toward Mr.Jets advice, also that of Roger at Monkfish,and go for the RE050
would appreciate if Jet could let me know if its NI or NO he has fitted?
Cheers, Martin

Thanks to all who have thus far contributed!!
bigwheel said:
Exactly as above....
For me, same car. Same tyres. Same scenario.

Bought new Conti Sport Contact 5 because F1's on the front were worn on very narrow strip, inside shoulder. (BMW forum showed same wear problem with F1's)
Moved worn rear F1's to the front and thought I was doing the safe thing with new tyres going onto the driven axle.

This instantly gave me the same very scary ride as the OP.

So swapped front to back etc.

Transformed to a safe and very controllable drive, especially when making progress.

Despite common knowledge that all 4 tyres should be the same, the car now feels more balanced with these 2 differing makes in this combination. A bit like the VXR8's having different sized tyres F/R.



Edited by bigwheel on Saturday 7th September 23:53
N


Edited by Martin Stiles on Sunday 8th September 11:12

Martin Stiles

Original Poster:

13 posts

172 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
jet_noise said:
Dear MS,

I've got RE050 on the back and they are N0 or N1 I forget which. Very, very good.
Tip: don't try Nexen N6000 on the back although they're fine on the front,

regards,
Jet

Hi, Jet Would be grateful if you could check if you are NO or N1,
Thank you Sir.
Martin

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Martin Stiles said:
Std Monaro box exchanged for VXR box
Are some one gone the same way as me then, correcting Vauxhall's build errorsmile

jet_noise

6,111 posts

213 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Dear MS,

Martin Stiles said:

Hi, Jet Would be grateful if you could check if you are NO or N1,
Thank you Sir.
Martin
I can't see the rears in the garage (big car, small garage!). I'll be using it tomorrow eve so will have a look then,

regards,
jet

bigwheel

1,640 posts

245 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi MS, when the F1's need replacing on the rear, I'll follow the advice from Wormus and MR KD and fit 2
more Conti's.


bigwheel

1,640 posts

245 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi MS, when the F1's need replacing on the rear, I'll follow the advice from Wormus and MR KD and fit 2
more Conti's.


Martin Stiles

Original Poster:

13 posts

172 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
jet_noise said:
I can't see the rears in the garage (big car, small garage!). I'll be using it tomorrow eve so will have a look then,

regards,
jet
I would be very grateful!
Cheers, Martin