I do get bored easily... Pic heavy
I do get bored easily... Pic heavy
Author
Discussion

Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
So I started spending a lot of hard earned on parts. This is all being done ready for one last stage to be added bit later to make use of all that I did.












Sent the heads off to a lovely company called CTM, used them in the past always been impressed with their work so seemed rude not to use them once again.

Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Pathetic little chain. But needs to be off to make way for a Monkfish magic cam. Also after seeing the standard chain guide it made me nervous. So opted for the later Vxr8 example.



May also notice the anti roll bar, worth the agro.... Cam!



See the difference in the guides



All back in/on





Heads are back... Shiny





Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all


Whilst I was waiting on the heads me and the boy, set about tidying a few visual things, rocker covers, coil mounting plates, w/p, chain cover, disc bells, and heat wrapping the exhausts. And also some cosmetic wrapping by my mate Tony.








Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all








That's it for now, just waiting on my new roller rockers, the in the new tax year the manifold will be off again and replaced with something a bit trick along with a mapping session.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Looking good smile

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Great work

stevieturbo

18,107 posts

278 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Probably not what you want to hear.....but the chain guide with the tensioner...ie the clean one in the photo, creamy/brown colour...

Is the one that is more prone to problems and was discontinued after a short time. In theory yes it is a better idea though.

The "dampener" as they call the basic one that bolts inside the chain...well, nothing to go wrong really.

Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Doubtful. Monkfish supplied it to me so are highly unlikely to sell me something that is only worthy of the bin. The original damper was a crock of st, didn't really do feck all. Chain, through no fault of its own was slack beyond belief. I didn't feel confident in fitting it back like that. This set up I much prefer. Chain is now under tension as It should be in my eyes.

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Nice work there Craig, always good to see this sort of work covered by photos too.

jameshsv

5,844 posts

191 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
GREAT WORK Craig that should go pretty well.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Craig1984 said:
The original damper was a crock of st, didn't really do feck all. Chain, through no fault of its own was slack beyond belief.
I think that's the difference between a chain guide, and a chain tensioner. Do they need to be under tension though? As has been said, as long as there's not too much slack, a guide has less to go wrong, so will be more reliable (as it's not doing so much).

stevieturbo

18,107 posts

278 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Craig1984 said:
Doubtful. Monkfish supplied it to me so are highly unlikely to sell me something that is only worthy of the bin. The original damper was a crock of st, didn't really do feck all. Chain, through no fault of its own was slack beyond belief. I didn't feel confident in fitting it back like that. This set up I much prefer. Chain is now under tension as It should be in my eyes.
You may think the standard one does nothing, but it does. And one thing it doesnt do...is break.

just google "broken ls3 tensioner"

There is no lack of responses, images, threads etc etc.

And as said, GM discontinued that design. It will probably survive for a good while with standard cam/valvetrain and standard rpm limit though.

Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
With the rotation, one side is offered up to slack. Adding tension removes this. Now saying with this it has potential to break but at same time chain has potential to stretch and jump a tooth. Just a more smoother running. This is my preferred option. At the same time anything is subject to failure so I will take my chances with what I feel is the more suitable option, I'm taking this from my mechanics point of view, I wouldn't allow that on my customers cars so why my own. It's all half of one, 6 dozen of the other at the end of the day ;-)

KMud

2,924 posts

187 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Are you spinning high, or particularly binary with the accelerator pedal? I'm adding a damper to my LS1, but a slack chain seems normal with LS engines and it doesn't seem to be a pronounced problem (from what this philistine has read) even with no chain control. I'm probably giving it attention for the same reason, better sleep.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Craig1984 said:
With the rotation, one side is offered up to slack. Adding tension removes this. Now saying with this it has potential to break but at same time chain has potential to stretch and jump a tooth. Just a more smoother running. This is my preferred option. At the same time anything is subject to failure so I will take my chances with what I feel is the more suitable option, I'm taking this from my mechanics point of view, I wouldn't allow that on my customers cars so why my own. It's all half of one, 6 dozen of the other at the end of the day ;-)
After Steve highlighted the fact, I went searching. As he says, there have been breakages, but usually on highly tuned motors.
Both the tensioner and the previous damper will make the engine run quieter, so I guess that's why they were added.

Interestingly, nothing was fitted prior to about 2006 - so not fitting either will be 100% reliable! smile

Craig1984

Original Poster:

323 posts

203 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
I yeah I did do my home work. Had a chat at length with Roger. I'm happy with it, he's happy with it, win win. Plus I like being different ha

stevieturbo

18,107 posts

278 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Craig1984 said:
With the rotation, one side is offered up to slack. Adding tension removes this. Now saying with this it has potential to break but at same time chain has potential to stretch and jump a tooth. Just a more smoother running. This is my preferred option. At the same time anything is subject to failure so I will take my chances with what I feel is the more suitable option, I'm taking this from my mechanics point of view, I wouldn't allow that on my customers cars so why my own. It's all half of one, 6 dozen of the other at the end of the day ;-)
Show me one instance of a jumped tooth with a chain...and no tensioner at all.
There simply is none, it would be pretty much impossible.

Most likely if/when the tensioner does break, bits will just fall into the sump and you'll be left as per older engines with no tensioner or control of the chain at all..
Worst case, it will break and get caught in the chain maybe breaking it. Although havent heard too many reports of that scenario.

The tensioner is good in theory, I nearly bought one myself. But no sense adding a piece that will break in a short period of time and offer zero benefit. No way was I taking the risk with such high failure rates.

The black plastic one does remove chain slop by limiting it's movement on the slack side, and it cannot break...ever.



ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
No way was I taking the risk with such high failure rates.
High rates, or just a perception from the posts in internet forums? scratchchin


stevieturbo

18,107 posts

278 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
High rates, or just a perception from the posts in internet forums? scratchchin
Well when there are multiple threads on multiple forums from multiple different people over a few years.....

That seems high enough for me.

I havent see one single instance of a problem caused by no tensioner, or the simple black "dampener"

Seems a no brainer really.



ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
ARAF said:
High rates, or just a perception from the posts in internet forums? scratchchin
Well when there are multiple threads on multiple forums from multiple different people over a few years.....

That seems high enough for me.

I havent see one single instance of a problem caused by no tensioner, or the simple black "dampener"

Seems a no brainer really.
I hold great respect for people like you who have done it, rather than just talking about it. I've seen your Granada run at Thunder Road, and was very impressed. For that reason it is more difficult for me to argue this point.

I'll agree that no tensioner or damper is fine. I'll agree that the damper cannot fail, because of it's design - but that it cannot be doing much either (apart from softening the blow when the chain lashes it). However, I cannot agree that the tensioner has a high incidence of failure, when you compare the number of units made to the number of reported failures. If there were a high incidence of failure, I would have expected at least 30 on here or VXROnline, but haven't seen one from around 288 LS3s imported.

Yes, they will fail more than either of the other options, but then they do more than either of the other options to quieten the engine, and give the chain an easier life. I bet they even extend the life of the chain by it not flapping around, or banging into the damper.