MonkFish or walkinshaw performance
MonkFish or walkinshaw performance
Author
Discussion

NST

Original Poster:

1,523 posts

274 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
neighbour has a R8 6.2 manual in silver.

he is my new best friend! he is on the fence about supercharging the beast.

which of the two is better? He is thinking of getting the 2300 supercharger.


ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
NST said:
neighbour has a R8 6.2 manual in silver.

he is my new best friend! he is on the fence about supercharging the beast.

which of the two is better? He is thinking of getting the 2300 supercharger.
6.0 in Nickel Silver, or 6.2 in Evoke Grey? scratchchin

As for which is best, I'm not sure if you mean the equipment that they install, or the way they work.

I use Monkfish, but that all started because they work Saturdays, and have curtesy cars. I've always been happy with the quality of their work, so have no reason to look elsewhere.

I have used Walkinshaw once - for the first service on our old car. Very happy with it, but not enough contact to form an opinion.


If by 'best' you are on about the equipment that they supply, then those who have already made the choice will have to answer.

DaciaBumdart

22,454 posts

241 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
both are good workshops both know the cars

distance from you and cost are whats between the two.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
Ask for an all inclusive FIXED PRICE cost. Then select.
I believe both do the 2300 units, so it will then be down to cost and convenience.

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
I seem to remember Walkinshaw dressing it up under the bonnet a little differently to Monkfish. As has already been said, both have excellent reputations.

Sarge 4x4

2,371 posts

236 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
WP.

Tattooboy

7,946 posts

209 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
I've only ever used Monk Fish and have never had a complaint, car always well looked after in their work shop.

Have never used Walkinshaw so can't comment, but some have.

As alreay mentioned, fix price cost and ease of location would be the governing factors.

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Monday 27th January 2014
quotequote all
Monkfish as only they do the Heartbeat Charger. Why would you want an old school 2300 now? wink

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
ringram said:
Ask for an all inclusive FIXED PRICE cost. Then select.
I believe both do the 2300 units, so it will then be down to cost and convenience.
Both are capable companies, BUT - get it in writing too. The last time I got a verbal quote was for a key replacement with WP. They quoted me £80 on the phone and when I got the bill it was double that.

I'd get the warranty in writing on the quote too, not all conversions go smoothly.

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
I seem to remember Walkinshaw dressing it up under the bonnet a little differently to Monkfish. As has already been said, both have excellent reputations.
The walkinshaw setup was from edelbrook & monkfish used magnusson which has now changed to the heartbeat set up.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
ringram said:
Ask for an all inclusive FIXED PRICE cost. Then select.
I believe both do the 2300 units, so it will then be down to cost and convenience.
Both are capable companies, BUT - get it in writing too. The last time I got a verbal quote was for a key replacement with WP. They quoted me £80 on the phone and when I got the bill it was double that.

I'd get the warranty in writing on the quote too, not all conversions go smoothly.
I wont break the rules, but have used Monkfish for 6 happy years.

NST

Original Poster:

1,523 posts

274 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Evoke Grey! i had a little google!

I know his car is completely standard.

This has me thinking.. Is the VXR8 a robust car that can take miles?

I wouldn't mind a VXR8 6.2 (LOL)

what are the weak points?
Electrics? clutch? Diff? engine?
does the supercharger (i'm thinking ahead now!) add to the general reliability of the car?
What do i need to look for in buying a 6.2?
Auto or Manual?

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
neiljohnson said:
The walkinshaw setup was from edelbrook & monkfish used magnusson which has now changed to the heartbeat set up.
Heartbeat doesn't sound quite as masculine as Magnusson or Edelbrock somehow. I know, I just re-read what I just typed and it sounds daft, but I know what I mean! laugh

Tattooboy

7,946 posts

209 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
neiljohnson said:
The walkinshaw setup was from edelbrook & monkfish used magnusson which has now changed to the heartbeat set up.
Heartbeat doesn't sound quite as masculine as Magnusson or Edelbrock somehow. I know, I just re-read what I just typed and it sounds daft, but I know what I mean! laugh
I know what you mean, when someone says, "I love the new Heartbeat" you automatically think there's a new series of the drama based on 1960's police in Yorkshire !! hehe

NST

Original Poster:

1,523 posts

274 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
what is a heartbeat supercharger? how is it different to a regular Eaton TVS2300?

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
NST said:
what is a heartbeat supercharger? how is it different to a regular Eaton TVS2300?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6gTQq6vn4w&feature=share


ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
NST said:
what is a heartbeat supercharger? how is it different to a regular Eaton TVS2300?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6gTQq6vn4w&feature=share
Are you not giving an opinion on the original question? hehe

Well_Fans

4,193 posts

255 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
neiljohnson said:
The walkinshaw setup was from edelbrook & monkfish used magnusson which has now changed to the heartbeat set up.
ironically it was tuner_b who first supplied and fitted the magnusson chargers when monkfish were still fitting the harrop chargers ..... thing is aren't they all based on the same design just with different interpretations/casings? Hence why when one of them brings out a new model the others all follow with their own versions.

Tattooboy

7,946 posts

209 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Well_Fans said:
neiljohnson said:
The walkinshaw setup was from edelbrook & monkfish used magnusson which has now changed to the heartbeat set up.
ironically it was tuner_b who first supplied and fitted the magnusson chargers when monkfish were still fitting the harrop chargers ..... thing is aren't they all based on the same design just with different interpretations/casings? Hence why when one of them brings out a new model the others all follow with their own versions.
But the Harrop just sounds so much better biggrin

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Edlebrock follows the lsa (oe) design with the charge cooler above the charger
The maggie design has the charger in top of the cooler

The harrops sit on top of the cooler like the maggie

The heartbeat is the new set up from magnusson where they have reverted to the cooler above the charger as the lsa & edlebrook & monkfish have just fitted the first (afaik) in the country i believe it's only currently available for ls3 fitment & looking at how high it sits I doubt it will fit under the bonnet of a Monaro