I'm told my engine is running too lean, is this a bad thing?
I'm told my engine is running too lean, is this a bad thing?
Author
Discussion

pah250

Original Poster:

3,270 posts

186 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Afternoon,

I went to a group rolling road day in Leeds yesterday and the guy running the rollers told me that my engine is running too lean. He didn't elaborate too much, but he seemed to indicate that this is a bad thing that needed to be fixed ASAP. I re-ran the AFR probe in the other tail pipe for comparison and got pretty much the same reading.

I know nothing about these things and the guy doing the rolling road doesn't see too many LS engines, so I thought I'd canvas here for other opinions. It's an LS3 manual, N/A with Walkinshaw wild cam, CAI, headers, high flow cats, full WP exhaust and re-map, all work done by Walkinshaw.

Car has winter tyres on. The guy tells me that they will probably zap about 20bhp from the overall figure.

Graphs below - comments welcome smile





I'm gonna call WP tomorrow and send them the graphs to see what they think.

Cheers,
Paul.

pah250

Original Poster:

3,270 posts

186 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Forgot to add, it's fed with Shell Nitro+ super unleaded

jonnM

1,102 posts

170 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
There's definately something amiss there. 360 rwhp for a cammed LS3 sounds very low, should be nearer 400.

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Thats very lean. On an na engine aim for 12.5:1 to 13:1 not over 14:1

THUNDER STORM

1,261 posts

200 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
pah250 said:
Forgot to add, it's fed with Shell Nitro+ super unleaded
Hope you get this sorted Paul, dont want pistons or valves burning out.yikes

Adebyebye

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Its not ideal. Likely a tune tweak required.

That being said, unless you are on full throttle around a track etc I doubt anything would happen.
So its more a question of power loss.

Especially if you have no knock. The car runs 14.7:1 99% of the time anyway!

As mentioned 13:1 is best. Your bhp curve is bashed at 5500 rpm. Could be fuelling or more likely valve springs.
Maybe draw that to their attention too biggrin


ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
jonnM said:
There's definately something amiss there. 360 rwhp for a cammed LS3 sounds very low, should be nearer 400.
Definitely!
360rwhp is tune only territory.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
ringram said:
jonnM said:
There's definately something amiss there. 360 rwhp for a cammed LS3 sounds very low, should be nearer 400.
Definitely!
360rwhp is tune only territory.
Did Sarge have the yellow peril cammed though? I thought that was the white Bathurst S?confused

As for the mixture, that could be down to the tune, or maybe the fuel pump is not as efficient as it was?

Sarge 4x4

2,371 posts

236 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
All the work was done by WP including the cam, I never had it on the rollers.

My old "S" ran lean when I first put it on the RR so I got WP to put a bigger pump in to sort that, I am lead to believe the "E" GTS (Banana) had a high flow pump so would not think it can be the pump.

Only way is to ask WP and get them to sort it Paul.

You only know these things when you get it on the rollers I suppose.

Makes sense because I think it should make more power than that.

TimDaciaBumdart

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
this is the issue with mods and mapping without roller time or wideband at a minimum

I wouldn't worry it wont denoate but I would look to see if someone could, as a dirty fix lower the commanded fuel at wot, you have an AFR read out that you could do a quick and dirty adjustment to your fuel

alternatively go to another dyno for a second test to see if you get AFR the same. if so you know you have something to look at. If you were to get a friend with EFI live, get in touch with Oztrack down under, show him the AFR map he will sort it fairly cheap

Ignore the power figures, different dynos read wildly different that's why our SRR days always spark debate as people forget its a like for like comparison on the same dyno.

pah250

Original Poster:

3,270 posts

186 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the feedback guys, really appreciate it.

Out of interest, what damage could be done by running lean? I do have some track days planned for it where it will be driven hard, so I want to be sure it's OK before I track it smile

I'm going to call WP in the morning and ask for their opinion. I'm sure they'll be able to sort it out.

Cheers

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
pah250 said:
Out of interest, what damage could be done by running lean? I do have some track days planned for it where it will be driven hard, so I want to be sure it's OK before I track it smile
You can burn exhaust valves and melt the crowns of pistons.

TimDaciaBumdart

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
pah250 said:
Out of interest, what damage could be done by running lean? I do have some track days planned for it where it will be driven hard, so I want to be sure it's OK before I track it smile
You can burn exhaust valves and melt the crowns of pistons.
This!

you can do a lot, do not track the car till you have this sorted. It could be any number of simple issues, poor fuel pump, poor tune but the result will be costly either way

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Yeah dont track it. I very much doubt its the pump. Pump is good for 500rwhp at least.

WP should sort it for you. Fueling is very likely tune based. Especially when you look at the lower rpm fueling. Its even leaner. So its not going to be injectors or pump down there! Thats tune, through and through.

pah250

Original Poster:

3,270 posts

186 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
TimDaciaBumdart said:
ARAF said:
pah250 said:
Out of interest, what damage could be done by running lean? I do have some track days planned for it where it will be driven hard, so I want to be sure it's OK before I track it smile
You can burn exhaust valves and melt the crowns of pistons.
This!

you can do a lot, do not track the car till you have this sorted. It could be any number of simple issues, poor fuel pump, poor tune but the result will be costly either way
Oh poo!

I've driven it fairly hard sometimes as it is. I shall be driving like a granddad from now until it's fixed

AMD87

2,004 posts

233 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
pah250 said:
Oh poo!

I've driven it fairly hard sometimes as it is. I shall be driving like a granddad from now until it's fixed
http://youtu.be/87qeaLamNSc

pah250

Original Poster:

3,270 posts

186 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
ringram said:
Yeah dont track it. I very much doubt its the pump. Pump is good for 500rwhp at least.

WP should sort it for you. Fueling is very likely tune based. Especially when you look at the lower rpm fueling. Its even leaner. So its not going to be injectors or pump down there! Thats tune, through and through.
It's done at least 5000 miles with current map. Some of them driven hard. Would it be worth opening up the engine to inspect any damage? Or is that just as costly?

Sorry, complete novis at this

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
pah250 said:
It's done at least 5000 miles with current map. Some of them driven hard. Would it be worth opening up the engine to inspect any damage? Or is that just as costly?

Sorry, complete novis at this
It's very likely fine but if your worried a compression & leak down test will tell you if there is an issue without taking the engine apart.

pah250

Original Poster:

3,270 posts

186 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
AMD87 said:
pah250 said:
Oh poo!

I've driven it fairly hard sometimes as it is. I shall be driving like a granddad from now until it's fixed
http://youtu.be/87qeaLamNSc
Good vid. I'm worried now...

Gary H 2008

3,507 posts

220 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Don't be Paul - I've done far worse with far less safety nets...;)