Ro vs. R8 (inc. reliability)
Ro vs. R8 (inc. reliability)
Author
Discussion

jwoodVXR

Original Poster:

258 posts

194 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Hi All

I previously had a 2006 VXR which I absolutely loved but had to sell in order to fund the purchase of our first home. I'm pleased to say we're now moved in, the DIY is underway and I should be in the market for a new pride & joy soon.

I really want another V8 and briefly looked at corvettes but decided if I was going to get a vette it'd have to be a Z06 - which is out of my price range and too big for the garage! So (naturally) I find myself gravitating back to HSV, driven by fond memories of the Ro! I'm struggling to decide between a Monaro or VXR8 though!

I love the looks of the Monaro where as I'm not really a fan of the looks of the VXR8 (at least in standard form) plus the lighter kerb weight of the Ro is definitely appealing - it was heavy enough so the thought of adding c.200kg to that does make me wonder about the life span of the suspension on the VXR8.

The major negative point on the Ro though was the threat of the dreaded spigot bearing failure - luckily this was caught early in mine before any gearbox issues occurred, however it did result in a knackered clutch (excuse to upgrade to LS7 smile )

If all goes to plan I'd have a modification budget which I'd hope would cover complete exhaust, OTR, cam and rip shifter if required. I know a TVS is a more cost effective way of getting power out of these LS engines but a cammed nasp V8 really appeals to me (the sound at idle is a big part of that lol)

My main questions are what would you say the pro's & cons of each are (LS2 Monaro VXR vs VXR8 (both LS2 & LS3)), which would you consider more reliable and what are the main points to look out for on the R8 when viewing??

Thanks in advance and it's good to be back on the forum!

TimDaciaBumdart

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
The VXR8 is the much better car in regards to chassis and drive train, it really is but its also a different car. I had both a Ro and an R8, the Ro had the much better interior and build but the R8 had the much better package. I'd go for either again however I currently have an e39 m5 which is, well, the tops. Have a look for one of those too wink

as an ex owner I'd be equally happy with an 5.7/6.0VXR ro or LS2/3 VXR8. If I didn't have the beemer right now I'd be looking to swap to either of them and be happy, probably a Ro if I am honest BUT the downide with the ro (other than small boot models) is the 20 years it takes for the seats to move.

jonnM

1,102 posts

170 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
If a Z06 is too big for your garage, a VXR8 will be too (both around 2100mm wide inc mirriors, IIRC).


jwoodVXR

Original Poster:

258 posts

194 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
jonnM said:
If a Z06 is too big for your garage, a VXR8 will be too (both around 2100mm wide inc mirriors, IIRC).
Ah, this was something which had crossed my mind. It's the garage opening which is the issue. Does the R8 have power fold mirrors??

r8black

1,405 posts

160 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
No

jonnM

1,102 posts

170 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
jwoodVXR said:
Ah, this was something which had crossed my mind. It's the garage opening which is the issue. Does the R8 have power fold mirrors??
They are power fold...human power, lol! Mine goes in with about 2 inches clearance either side. (no smutty remarks please BumDart) laugh

TimDaciaBumdart

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
jonnM said:
jwoodVXR said:
Ah, this was something which had crossed my mind. It's the garage opening which is the issue. Does the R8 have power fold mirrors??
They are power fold...human power, lol! Mine goes in with about 2 inches clearance either side. (no smutty remarks please BumDart) laugh
I never thought such a thing until you mentioned it!

jwoodVXR

Original Poster:

258 posts

194 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
I'll re-measure and see what sort of clearance is likely. Any comments on which is more reliable or the common issues on R8's (am I right in thinking control arms is one issue)?

jonnM

1,102 posts

170 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
jwoodVXR said:
I'll re-measure and see what sort of clearance is likely. Any comments on which is more reliable or the common issues on R8's (am I right in thinking control arms is one issue)?
Regarding reliability all I can say is I've had both and never had any issues with either. Most makes of car will have their specific weak points, but they're nothing that can't be fixed. smile



Edited by jonnM on Sunday 2nd March 16:20