Valve Spring Selection
Discussion
I'm pretty certain I've got valve control issues, I've got excessive oil consumption, I think the valve stem seals are loose, maybe binding from the inner valve spring, I've got to check. Hopefully not worn guides already?
Set up is LS2 bottom end, L92 heads and intake, 216/229 .330/.331 cam with SLP (Yella Terra) 1.85:1 rockers giving .6105/.61235
Searching has revealed issues with the heavy ~106.5g L92 intake valves with high ratio rockers, Im using patriot gold duals with them, .650" 135/375 Ti retainers. Im not sure and can not find the weight for the dual spring, maybe ~100g?
I'm opting for LS3 stock hollow intake valves ~ 89g, saving ~17g
Keeping the L92 exhaust valves ~90g
I want to replace the duals with single beehives, I intend to stick with the cam, Im sure theres another 35rwhp to gain above the 365 I saw at SRR with modified LS3 Rick Crawford intake (+20CFM thru combined heads and intake), larger diameter intake and air filter, and with lightened valve train.
My choice for springs are
PAC 1500 series Premium springs that have a nitrided surface heat treatment
PAC1518 .625" 130/318 75g
PAC1519 .625" 150/363 67g
or
PAC1219 .625" 135/348 67g
There are a few more grams saved with Ti retainers for the smaller beehive, maybe upto ~ 45g weight reduction.
For those in the know, which valves springs are most suitable for lift and duration?
Thanks in advance
Set up is LS2 bottom end, L92 heads and intake, 216/229 .330/.331 cam with SLP (Yella Terra) 1.85:1 rockers giving .6105/.61235
Searching has revealed issues with the heavy ~106.5g L92 intake valves with high ratio rockers, Im using patriot gold duals with them, .650" 135/375 Ti retainers. Im not sure and can not find the weight for the dual spring, maybe ~100g?
I'm opting for LS3 stock hollow intake valves ~ 89g, saving ~17g
Keeping the L92 exhaust valves ~90g
I want to replace the duals with single beehives, I intend to stick with the cam, Im sure theres another 35rwhp to gain above the 365 I saw at SRR with modified LS3 Rick Crawford intake (+20CFM thru combined heads and intake), larger diameter intake and air filter, and with lightened valve train.
My choice for springs are
PAC 1500 series Premium springs that have a nitrided surface heat treatment
PAC1518 .625" 130/318 75g
PAC1519 .625" 150/363 67g
or
PAC1219 .625" 135/348 67g
There are a few more grams saved with Ti retainers for the smaller beehive, maybe upto ~ 45g weight reduction.
For those in the know, which valves springs are most suitable for lift and duration?
Thanks in advance
I was running Comp 918 beehives with YT superlites and not quite the effective lift you are .583.591 IIRC on a 1.7 ratio on my LS2. (YT superlites are nose heavy when compared to stock due to the weight of the roller itself. And a lot of people running high rpm still say the stock item is OK for that kind of duty.) I never saw any valve float at all and was pleased with my spring choice. I'm not convinced I needed to blow all that money on the YT's though.
Please don't forget that with the L92/LS3/LS7 setup there is an off set rocker, so I suppose there is a small chance of some sideways action on that valve? Given that you have increased the leverage by using s 1.85/1 rocker this could accentuate things, and might explain your valve guide/seal wear???
You may have just overdone it with the dual spring set up???
ETA. I was running stock 243 heads and valves.
Please don't forget that with the L92/LS3/LS7 setup there is an off set rocker, so I suppose there is a small chance of some sideways action on that valve? Given that you have increased the leverage by using s 1.85/1 rocker this could accentuate things, and might explain your valve guide/seal wear???
You may have just overdone it with the dual spring set up???
ETA. I was running stock 243 heads and valves.
Edited by MyM8V8 on Friday 4th April 15:33
id check your guide wear.
That ratio rocker might not be helping and as noted those rockers will be heavier over the nose.
check geometry and swipe.
light will help control, geometry will help wear
If guides are worn; bronze is a bad option as its too soft. better to replace with factory powdered metal or new tfs 255 heads?
let us know what you find out.
for spring pressure ive heard use lightest pressure to give best control with lightest weight.
That ratio rocker might not be helping and as noted those rockers will be heavier over the nose.
check geometry and swipe.
light will help control, geometry will help wear
If guides are worn; bronze is a bad option as its too soft. better to replace with factory powdered metal or new tfs 255 heads?
let us know what you find out.
for spring pressure ive heard use lightest pressure to give best control with lightest weight.
The higher the rpms the stiffer the spring. The stiffer the spring the more strain applied to all the valvetrain components........ The set up I have chosen on my stroker will require new valve springs every 6000 miles (or every year)
This is where a specialist engine builder can help in the selection of components for a build. You will pay a bit more for the components, but his advice may be invaluable.
eg when I did my 1st cam, I spoke to, and ordered the parts from an engine builder (with knowledge of LS motors) over here and there are a few that can help.
Andy, I'm not convinced you have valve float, have you checked your lifters, they may have crapped out, if using the standard LS7 lifters. Did you check your push rod length with the new cam. I know I had to use a longer rod?
Have a look on the Comp cams site, there is some advice on springs, but for your job, I'm pretty sure you will benefit from a set of 918 beehives. Fitting instructions and valve heights should come with your cam card.
This is where a specialist engine builder can help in the selection of components for a build. You will pay a bit more for the components, but his advice may be invaluable.
eg when I did my 1st cam, I spoke to, and ordered the parts from an engine builder (with knowledge of LS motors) over here and there are a few that can help.
Andy, I'm not convinced you have valve float, have you checked your lifters, they may have crapped out, if using the standard LS7 lifters. Did you check your push rod length with the new cam. I know I had to use a longer rod?
Have a look on the Comp cams site, there is some advice on springs, but for your job, I'm pretty sure you will benefit from a set of 918 beehives. Fitting instructions and valve heights should come with your cam card.
Yer, first thing I need to see what the problem is with the oil consumption, searching reveals the inner spring on duals sometimes pop the seals, replacing valve guides with more durable items is not a problem if required, the heads are fine for my power goals.
Id like to keep the 1.85:1 rockers to maintain the valve lift, and the investment is already made. Granted that they are heavier over the nose, so I've got to lighten the valves, retainers and springs.
To complicate matters, Ive just read this forum post from PAC regarding roller rockers and beehives.... my head hurts lol
"Now knowing you are using a roller rocker, I do not think you will have any luck with ANY beehive spring. If you were to go back to the stock rocker I assure you the PAC-1218X would be enough for your application. As of now I would highly suggest going to a dual spring due to the rockers. I think you will need at least 150lbs on the seat and 400+ open to control the rockers, not the valves. I would suggest running a PAC-1207X spring or an equivalent to that."
http://speedtalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t...
Id like to keep the 1.85:1 rockers to maintain the valve lift, and the investment is already made. Granted that they are heavier over the nose, so I've got to lighten the valves, retainers and springs.
To complicate matters, Ive just read this forum post from PAC regarding roller rockers and beehives.... my head hurts lol
"Now knowing you are using a roller rocker, I do not think you will have any luck with ANY beehive spring. If you were to go back to the stock rocker I assure you the PAC-1218X would be enough for your application. As of now I would highly suggest going to a dual spring due to the rockers. I think you will need at least 150lbs on the seat and 400+ open to control the rockers, not the valves. I would suggest running a PAC-1207X spring or an equivalent to that."
http://speedtalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t...
MyM8V8 said:
The higher the rpms the stiffer the spring. The stiffer the spring the more strain applied to all the valvetrain components........ The set up I have chosen on my stroker will require new valve springs every 6000 miles (or every year)
This is where a specialist engine builder can help in the selection of components for a build. You will pay a bit more for the components, but his advice may be invaluable.
eg when I did my 1st cam, I spoke to, and ordered the parts from an engine builder (with knowledge of LS motors) over here and there are a few that can help.
Andy, I'm not convinced you have valve float, have you checked your lifters, they may have crapped out, if using the standard LS7 lifters. Did you check your push rod length with the new cam. I know I had to use a longer rod?
Have a look on the Comp cams site, there is some advice on springs, but for your job, I'm pretty sure you will benefit from a set of 918 beehives. Fitting instructions and valve heights should come with your cam card.
Power comes in around 3K, pulls hard up to 5.6K, really feels like a struggle to get to 6K. When I check SLP dyno charts for my combo install, I should have been up 75HP, add the 1.85:1, 85HP, I gained 63 and I added headers and cat back, AFR wasn't optimum. This is where a specialist engine builder can help in the selection of components for a build. You will pay a bit more for the components, but his advice may be invaluable.
eg when I did my 1st cam, I spoke to, and ordered the parts from an engine builder (with knowledge of LS motors) over here and there are a few that can help.
Andy, I'm not convinced you have valve float, have you checked your lifters, they may have crapped out, if using the standard LS7 lifters. Did you check your push rod length with the new cam. I know I had to use a longer rod?
Have a look on the Comp cams site, there is some advice on springs, but for your job, I'm pretty sure you will benefit from a set of 918 beehives. Fitting instructions and valve heights should come with your cam card.
I used longer push rods, Roger checked geometry when installing. Sometimes it ticks a little when cold. Could use a thinner head gasket next time?
Gelf VXR said:
Yer, first thing I need to see what the problem is with the oil consumption, searching reveals the inner spring on duals sometimes pop the seals, replacing valve guides with more durable items is not a problem if required, the heads are fine for my power goals.
Id like to keep the 1.85:1 rockers to maintain the valve lift, and the investment is already made. Granted that they are heavier over the nose, so I've got to lighten the valves, retainers and springs.
To complicate matters, Ive just read this forum post from PAC regarding roller rockers and beehives.... my head hurts lol
"Now knowing you are using a roller rocker, I do not think you will have any luck with ANY beehive spring. If you were to go back to the stock rocker I assure you the PAC-1218X would be enough for your application. As of now I would highly suggest going to a dual spring due to the rockers. I think you will need at least 150lbs on the seat and 400+ open to control the rockers, not the valves. I would suggest running a PAC-1207X spring or an equivalent to that."
http://speedtalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t...
Interesting. I can only go by what I installed and used, my results on track with the Ute in the 1/4 and mile speak for themselves. The great thing about the beehives is they look very light compared with the stock corvette ones anyway. When I first looked at them I thought "these don't look right" but they worked OK.Id like to keep the 1.85:1 rockers to maintain the valve lift, and the investment is already made. Granted that they are heavier over the nose, so I've got to lighten the valves, retainers and springs.
To complicate matters, Ive just read this forum post from PAC regarding roller rockers and beehives.... my head hurts lol
"Now knowing you are using a roller rocker, I do not think you will have any luck with ANY beehive spring. If you were to go back to the stock rocker I assure you the PAC-1218X would be enough for your application. As of now I would highly suggest going to a dual spring due to the rockers. I think you will need at least 150lbs on the seat and 400+ open to control the rockers, not the valves. I would suggest running a PAC-1207X spring or an equivalent to that."
http://speedtalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t...
ringram said:
Well from reading that (good find) it seems my choice of those tiny 918's was good?Never heard or read anything about them not being any good with roller rockers??? Anyone?
I have a set of 918's but got some patriot gold duals instead for the camaro due to being paranoid.
Comp do new conical s too which they reckon are the next step forward.
http://www.compcams.com/whatsnew/NewsDetails.aspx?...
Comp do new conical s too which they reckon are the next step forward.
http://www.compcams.com/whatsnew/NewsDetails.aspx?...
Do you have standard rockers to revert/upgrade back to, just to actually test in case a problem lies elsewhere ?
Assuming your pushrod length is correct for the standard rockers.
Going for such a high ratio rocker is maybe ok if retaining a standard cam. Go much beyond that, and really you're far better off having the lift built into the cam itself.
Assuming your pushrod length is correct for the standard rockers.
Going for such a high ratio rocker is maybe ok if retaining a standard cam. Go much beyond that, and really you're far better off having the lift built into the cam itself.
I do have a set of stock off set inlet rockers about some where.
Is does need some investigative surgery, I want to plan ahead, as I'm abroad working, not wait n see.
Plan A, I think I'll probably just order a new cam and valve train package from FTI or to be decided, and ask MF to install
Is does need some investigative surgery, I want to plan ahead, as I'm abroad working, not wait n see.
Plan A, I think I'll probably just order a new cam and valve train package from FTI or to be decided, and ask MF to install
For my cam application form I need some exhaust info, can anyone confirm the primary diameter and length, collector diameter and length, and confirm the system is 2 1/2"? Thanks in advance
Exhaust Details – Wortec cat back
Manifolds [headers]
Shorty []
Mid-Length []
Long Tube [X]
Primary Size:
Collector Size:
H-Pipe or Y-Pipe or X-Pipe: X pipe
Exhaust System Diameter: 2 ½”
Type of Muffler: Volume switching back box
Full Exhaust [Yes, no center boxes]
Dumps [No]
Exhaust Details – Wortec cat back
Manifolds [headers]
Shorty []
Mid-Length []
Long Tube [X]
Primary Size:
Collector Size:
H-Pipe or Y-Pipe or X-Pipe: X pipe
Exhaust System Diameter: 2 ½”
Type of Muffler: Volume switching back box
Full Exhaust [Yes, no center boxes]
Dumps [No]
Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



