Exhaust noises help please!
Exhaust noises help please!
Author
Discussion

blue666uk

Original Poster:

690 posts

155 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
Hi chaps - a bit of assistance please? Maybe one for the more techie people here.
I may be completely barking up the wrong tree here, but I have a 2004MY CV8 with Wortec cat-back exhaust which exits left side only due to fuel tank location. Exhaust obviously set to loud, sans silencers! Now whilst this is a pleasing noise, and a good volume, it doesn't sound as deep rumbling V8'y as I was expecting. I haven't done anything else yet, headers & cats is probably a bit out of my reach for now, although a Wortec CAI will be going on soon, and a re-map shortly after. I understand from reading other posts, that you can get H and X pipes in the mid-section for mixing the 2 pipes, whereas, I think as standard, the CV8 cat-back is a separate system right through to exit. Would this help with the noise getting an X or H pipe fitted in the mid-section or am I just barking up the wrong tree? It might even be that both pipes exit the same side for me, unlike the 05 CV8 and VXR's which are both sides, I wondered whether that helped give it a more bassy rumble if the pipes are split, and therefore I just have to accept my lot?
confused
or save for a 05 5.7 or 6.0 litre).
Thanks peeps i advance.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
From what I understand, it's the firing order that gives the old-school rumble you're after, so you'll not achieve that.

As for the cross-over pipes, X pipe gives the best performance, and H pipe gives the best noise, I believe. I can't believe that your left and right banks are completely separate. There must be a join somewhere, surely?

jet_noise

6,108 posts

213 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
Dear b,

our cars will sound in general different from a traditional V8 as their firing order is unusual IMHO.
There are ways I daresay to make things more rumbly (technical term smile ) and our more knowledgeable members will reply but there's always this to bear in mind,

regards,
Jet

blue666uk

Original Poster:

690 posts

155 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
Thank you for responses so far. I guess it seems more like drone noise than engine noise which I was hoping the exhaust would amplify a bit as stock is ridiculously quiet.
If you look on 'fish website, 04 Wortec cat-back, they have install pics of the underside, the pipes meet, as in look as if they are welded at one point where you might put a H or X branch, but don't look as though they 'join'.
If it's worked, I have uploaded pic of my set up on ramps.

Monaro5.7

7,337 posts

210 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
I have a Wortec cat back and what I did was cut out the middle boxes, there is an x-pipe on my set up.

There is vids of my car and its exhaust on u-tube but they are of the car with headers and cat`s then later on with the cam so not a good example for you, but cutting the boxes out the middle does change the noise.

I have a 2004 CV8

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
blue666uk said:
Thank you for responses so far. I guess it seems more like drone noise than engine noise which I was hoping the exhaust would amplify a bit as stock is ridiculously quiet.
If you look on 'fish website, 04 Wortec cat-back, they have install pics of the underside, the pipes meet, as in look as if they are welded at one point where you might put a H or X branch, but don't look as though they 'join'.
If it's worked, I have uploaded pic of my set up on ramps.
If thats a wortec system in the pic, where it joins together it is called a kiss joint not H or X and looks like they are just welded together but there as you notice the weld is quite long and there is a hole between the ipes at the weld where they kiss together. I believe this is a feature on all wortecs

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
The kissing pipes is an 'X' pipe.

If your problem is that you are suffering from drone, then moving the rear silencer might help. Donk had the same problem on his big-boot VXR. smile

Wyld Stallyn

2,056 posts

159 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
The kissing pipes is an 'X' pipe.

If your problem is that you are suffering from drone, then moving the rear silencer might help. Donk had the same problem on his big-boot VXR. smile
WHS ^^^ Extending it out a bit on the sleeve or fitting longer tail covers can cut the drone down significantly thumbup

Monaro5.7

7,337 posts

210 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
Exit just behind front wheel should help with the drone wink

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
The kissing pipes is an 'X' pipe.

If your problem is that you are suffering from drone, then moving the rear silencer might help. Donk had the same problem on his big-boot VXR. smile
Okay, but "The man at Wortec he says" their Kiss pipe is different to the std X pipes, what do I know..... nothing confused

SturdyHSV

10,443 posts

198 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
preciousmetal said:
Okay, but "The man at Wortec he says" their Kiss pipe is different to the std X pipes, what do I know..... nothing confused
This made me giggle (apologies, bit of a messy copy/paste):

jonermart
144 posts

43 months

[report] [news] Monday 29th October 2012 quote quote all
Never seen this pic before - So the wortec cat back system is just that - tubes, back boxes and no middle boxes just an x pipe? Is it a true x pipe or just joined (I think we've been here before)? If so apologies but - remind me - does the x pipe add any hp or just change the soundtrack?
Also - anybody prepared to explain how the lump on the top of the back boxes works?
Cheers



mik_ok
997 posts

121 months

[report] [news] Monday 29th October 2012 quote quote all
Not sure - from that image it looks half way between a kiss-pipe and an x-pipe ?? But I'm not in a position to comment. My car has the Magnaflow 16795 system on it, which definitely has an x-pipe.

blue666uk

Original Poster:

690 posts

155 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
If where the pipes kiss there is just a hole, that is quite different to what I would call a traditional 'X pipe' where both pipes meet and converge fully with full bore size transfer of gasses?
The drone was terrible when it was first fitted, but shiney stainless I guess would do that - after a couple of long drives, it sooted up quite nicely and took away a lot of the really bad drone. But I was just hoping for more of the throbby V8. I'm getting the impression that messing about with X or H pipes might not really change that much. Extending the tips might be one option to cut the drone, but to be honest, its not that it's droning too much, just that it's slightly the 'wrong' noise, but would you get more engine noise (rather than just pure extra noise) with the headers/cats or would it literally be like turning up the volume of whatever noise I currently have? I mean it's not exactly a shrinking violet now.... biggrin

Or do I really have to throw caution to the wind and getting a lumpy cam!

blue666uk

Original Poster:

690 posts

155 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
This made me giggle (apologies, bit of a messy copy/paste):

jonermart
144 posts

43 months

[report] [news] Monday 29th October 2012 quote quote all
Never seen this pic before - So the wortec cat back system is just that - tubes, back boxes and no middle boxes just an x pipe? Is it a true x pipe or just joined (I think we've been here before)? If so apologies but - remind me - does the x pipe add any hp or just change the soundtrack?
Also - anybody prepared to explain how the lump on the top of the back boxes works?
Cheers



mik_ok
997 posts

121 months

[report] [news] Monday 29th October 2012 quote quote all
Not sure - from that image it looks half way between a kiss-pipe and an x-pipe ?? But I'm not in a position to comment. My car has the Magnaflow 16795 system on it, which definitely has an x-pipe.
sowee getmecoat

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
blue666uk said:
If where the pipes kiss there is just a hole, that is quite different to what I would call a traditional 'X pipe' where both pipes meet and converge fully with full bore size transfer of gasses?
The drone was terrible when it was first fitted, but shiney stainless I guess would do that - after a couple of long drives, it sooted up quite nicely and took away a lot of the really bad drone. But I was just hoping for more of the throbby V8. I'm getting the impression that messing about with X or H pipes might not really change that much. Extending the tips might be one option to cut the drone, but to be honest, its not that it's droning too much, just that it's slightly the 'wrong' noise, but would you get more engine noise (rather than just pure extra noise) with the headers/cats or would it literally be like turning up the volume of whatever noise I currently have? I mean it's not exactly a shrinking violet now.... biggrin

Or do I really have to throw caution to the wind and getting a lumpy cam!
now you have opened up a completely different can of cams biggrin

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
Have you actually heard the car from outside with someone else driving it, these cars can mask the sound of the exhaust when your inside

monkfish1

12,516 posts

255 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
blue666uk said:
If where the pipes kiss there is just a hole, that is quite different to what I would call a traditional 'X pipe' where both pipes meet and converge fully with full bore size transfer of gasses?
The drone was terrible when it was first fitted, but shiney stainless I guess would do that - after a couple of long drives, it sooted up quite nicely and took away a lot of the really bad drone. But I was just hoping for more of the throbby V8. I'm getting the impression that messing about with X or H pipes might not really change that much. Extending the tips might be one option to cut the drone, but to be honest, its not that it's droning too much, just that it's slightly the 'wrong' noise, but would you get more engine noise (rather than just pure extra noise) with the headers/cats or would it literally be like turning up the volume of whatever noise I currently have? I mean it's not exactly a shrinking violet now.... biggrin

Or do I really have to throw caution to the wind and getting a lumpy cam!
Fitting headers will change the noise significantly, though you would want to put the centre silencers back in if you were doing that. But its never going to sound like and old mustang or Rover V8. Thats down to the engine. And the high idle speed. Best way to get a traditional sound seems to be to strap a pair of turbos to it..........................

blue666uk

Original Poster:

690 posts

155 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
Granby said:
Have you actually heard the car from outside with someone else driving it, these cars can mask the sound of the exhaust when your inside
To be fair, no - but even tunnel runs could sound better. Maybe I'm just too demanding!

For some reason, everyone seems a bit apprehensive on sitting in the drivers seat!

blue666uk

Original Poster:

690 posts

155 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
Best way to get a traditional sound seems to be to strap a pair of turbos to it..........................
I haven't had the opportunity to hear Emma's motor yet.....

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
blue666uk said:
If where the pipes kiss there is just a hole, that is quite different to what I would call a traditional 'X pipe' where both pipes meet and converge fully with full bore size transfer of gasses?
The drone was terrible when it was first fitted, but shiney stainless I guess would do that - after a couple of long drives, it sooted up quite nicely and took away a lot of the really bad drone. But I was just hoping for more of the throbby V8. I'm getting the impression that messing about with X or H pipes might not really change that much. Extending the tips might be one option to cut the drone, but to be honest, its not that it's droning too much, just that it's slightly the 'wrong' noise, but would you get more engine noise (rather than just pure extra noise) with the headers/cats or would it literally be like turning up the volume of whatever noise I currently have? I mean it's not exactly a shrinking violet now.... biggrin

Or do I really have to throw caution to the wind and getting a lumpy cam!
Fitting headers will change the noise significantly, though you would want to put the centre silencers back in if you were doing that. But its never going to sound like and old mustang or Rover V8. Thats down to the engine. And the high idle speed. Best way to get a traditional sound seems to be to strap a pair of turbos to it..........................
rofl

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Tuesday 29th April 2014
quotequote all
blue666uk said:
Granby said:
Have you actually heard the car from outside with someone else driving it, these cars can mask the sound of the exhaust when your inside
To be fair, no - but even tunnel runs could sound better. Maybe I'm just too demanding!

For some reason, everyone seems a bit apprehensive on sitting in the drivers seat!
Can do that for you biggrin