Monaro : how many different versions are there ?
Monaro : how many different versions are there ?
Author
Discussion

OddCat

Original Poster:

2,828 posts

202 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Hi

Am undecided between XKR / S-Type R and Monaro. I love the whole V8 thing but have budget only circa £12k which buys me a decent 2000 XKR or a 2002 S-Type R or (hopefully) a 2005 Monaro.

But am confused re the number of Monaro variants. I see some with exhausts either side and others with single exhausts and some with twin exhausts one side only. I see some 5.7 and some 6.0 with overlap of the two in age terms. I see come called VXR, some called CV8 and some just plain Monaro. I see some with bonnet vents and rear spoilers and some without either. I understand that there are some with large boots and some smaller.

I like the ones with nose vents 5 spoke alloys (like this one http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1612749.htm) and the exhausts each side but not sure what variant this is.

Is there a definitive versions / build numbers / years registered / BHP record on here somewhere for the different ones ?

Thanks

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
You have:

CV8 - early monaro, big boot, no bodykit and single exhaust - 5.7ltr LS1

Early VXR - as above but full bodykit and better interior.

Later VXR - 6ltr engine (LS2), bodykit, 19" rims, nice interior but smaller boot due to fuel tank being in the back of it.

Yr brave looking at XKR's! not heard of bore wear and new blocks at higher miles....?

X type R - nice car and auto as well if thats your thing - Monaro's dont do auto option.

Others more in the know will be along shortly to tell you all the details but basically the later the model the more complete and modern looking they are.

vauxhallman

46 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Ok, from my (limited) knowledge:

There are two model years and two variants of each:

2004 MY

CV8 5.7 V8, 333bhp, single exhaust, large boot, no bonnet vents, crap brakes
VXR 5.7 V8, 387bhp, single exhaust, large boot, no bonnet vents, better brakes, suspension and lower ratio diff, better bodykit.

2005 MY

CV8 5.7 V8, 350bhp, two single exhaust, small boot, bonnet vents, brakes slightly better than 2004
VXR 6.0 V8, 4000bhp, two twin exhausts, small boot, bonnet vents, better brakes, updated suspension, better bodykit.

It's confusing as the 2004 cars were sold in 2004, 2005 and possible 2006, 2005 cars were sold in 2005, 2006 and 2007.

I'm sure someone on here will be able to provide more details but that should give you something to go on.

Edited by vauxhallman on Tuesday 6th April 12:42

Hsv_rulz

957 posts

253 months

OddCat

Original Poster:

2,828 posts

202 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses so far.

S800 - yes I have read about the XKR issues - there is definitely more chance of buying a wrong 'un with those. The simplicity of the Monaros appeals as does the manual box. It is confusing though - Autotrader currently has lots of 06 plate cars with single exhaust (near side) which must be 04 cars. The prices are all over the place (as you'd expect I guess with the rarity) but since last time I looked that have gone up I think (?).

So, what I think I need is a nice cherished private sale 05 / 55 2005 MY 5.7 CV8 (small boot) with max 35/40k miles and full FSH. With the 5 blade standard wheels and the nose vents. Preferably in black, grey/blue or red (not silver, yellow or bright blue). Budget up to £11k (ie same car would be £13k / £14k if retailed trade). I suspect though that if you subtract from those originally sold the high milers, crashed and tatty ones I'm looking at a very small pool of potential choice.....

Re private buying, I sold my beautiful 2006 Mondeo ST220 (20k miles) for £7,400 recently to start getting the cash together (easier to buy with cash of course). Others are asking up to £9,000 for similar ST220's (generally with much higher mileage and couldn't be any nicer than mine was) so I think private sellers sometimes need a reality check. Trouble is if you offer £10k for a car where someone is asking £12,500 they tend to get offended and take it personally !




Edited by OddCat on Tuesday 6th April 13:26


Edited by OddCat on Tuesday 6th April 13:26

vauxhallman

46 posts

206 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Yes, I've been watching the prices now since about last September and the prices have definitely been rising. It doesn't help when you see private ones come on the market at realistic prices and then they disappear only to reappear on a dealers forecourt about £2.5k higher, gutting when you know they won't have paid the asking price in the first place in all likelihood. That was one of the reasons I've started looking towards the VXR8, had the prices stayed realistic (in my opinion), I would have been looking to get a nice 6.0 VXR Ro for around £14k, but they keep going up and all of the ones I am looking at are around £16-17k now, only £2-3k less than a VXR8.

With the world of rising petrol prices and car tax it's beyond me why the prices are rising and not dropping.

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Lots of VXR Monaros being written off with incompetant drivers buying them IMHO, as such the pool is getting smaller. As for the VXR8, nice car, modern but it blends into the background of big BMW's and Mercs in all apart from the engine really, hence why there are so many for sale!, it will never be an iconic car like the Monaro is. People with Monaro's tend to keep and modify them where as R8's change hands quite often in comparison from what Ive seen.

OddCat

Original Poster:

2,828 posts

202 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Well, yes, price aside I'd rather have a VXR8 (to me they look very cool) but they are all band G £435 road tax (to which I object on principle).

Funny how when you finally settle on a car type to buy it's so hard to find nice ones. If i'd bought a Monaro new for £35k in 2005 it would now have 27,000 miles on the clock and be mint. Where are all the people like me ? !!!!


Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
We have a black 56 plate CV8 Monaro(small boot, nostril bonnet etc) and a 59 plate VXR8. I know we payed £400ish for the Monaro and i believe thats gone up now same as the VXR8.

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
I would say try and find a fairly low mileage 04 vxr, big boot, one of the rarest and around £220 a year tax or whatever the lower defered rate is for pre 05 cars. You should be able to pick an 04 vxr with around 40k for around 12-13k

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
S800VXR said:
Lots of VXR Monaros being written off with incompetant drivers buying them IMHO, as such the pool is getting smaller. As for the VXR8, nice car, modern but it blends into the background of big BMW's and Mercs in all apart from the engine really, hence why there are so many for sale!, it will never be an iconic car like the Monaro is. People with Monaro's tend to keep and modify them where as R8's change hands quite often in comparison from what Ive seen.


teeheehee hehe

Roger just care to fill us in on Monaro reliability.... driving

yes I know you had a bet to see if I would say that

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
OddCat said:

Funny how when you finally settle on a car type to buy it's so hard to find nice ones. If i'd bought a Monaro new for £35k in 2005 it would now have 27,000 miles on the clock and be mint. Where are all the people like me ? !!!!

My Dad has a 2005 CV8 in Odyssey, just like mine. He's had it from new and never drives it. It's done about 600 miles and is factory fresh. He's not selling it though so sorry this doesn't help!

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Model__Power__Torque__Weight__Gears__Diff
_______PS_____Nm______Kg

04 CV8__333___475_____1658____MM6____3.46
04 VXR__387___510_____1658____MM6____3.70
05 CV8__354___500_____1695____MM6____3.46
05 VXR__398___530_____1688____M12____3.46
VXR500__500___677_____1688____M12____3.46 Greens/Wortec development of the 6.0VXR (not factory).

Sorry about the under scores, piston heads ignores more than one space so difficult to construct a table.

In my view the change from MM6 to shorter M12 ratios was the most important performance change in the range, making the 6.0VXR the choice version to buy.

Magic919

14,589 posts

232 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Model Power PS Torque NM Weight KG Gears Diff
04 CV8 333 475 1658 MM6 3.46
04 VXR 387 510 1658 MM6 3.70
05 CV8 354 500 1695 MM6 3.46
05 VXR 398 530 1688 M12 3.46
*VXR500 500 677 1688 M12 3.46


  • Greens/Wortec development of the 6.0VXR (not factory).
Sorry about the under scores, piston heads ignores more than one space so difficult to construct a table.

In my view the change from MM6 to shorter M12 ratios was the most important performance change in the range, making the 6.0VXR the choice version to buy.

<<Have a table on me>>

eztiger

836 posts

211 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Presuming it's legit :

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1612895.htm

would be a stonking bargain. I'd wager it was the cheaper tax bracket too but obviously worth checking.

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
S800VXR said:
Lots of VXR Monaros being written off with incompetant drivers buying them IMHO, as such the pool is getting smaller. As for the VXR8, nice car, modern but it blends into the background of big BMW's and Mercs in all apart from the engine really, hence why there are so many for sale!, it will never be an iconic car like the Monaro is. People with Monaro's tend to keep and modify them where as R8's change hands quite often in comparison from what Ive seen.
teeheehee hehe

Roger just care to fill us in on Monaro reliability.... driving

yes I know you had a bet to see if I would say that
What Ro.... oh yea, that one I had sometime last year. (yr going in the river if you come to Germany!)

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
S800VXR said:
stigmundfreud said:
S800VXR said:
Lots of VXR Monaros being written off with incompetant drivers buying them IMHO, as such the pool is getting smaller. As for the VXR8, nice car, modern but it blends into the background of big BMW's and Mercs in all apart from the engine really, hence why there are so many for sale!, it will never be an iconic car like the Monaro is. People with Monaro's tend to keep and modify them where as R8's change hands quite often in comparison from what Ive seen.


teeheehee hehe

Roger just care to fill us in on Monaro reliability.... driving

yes I know you had a bet to see if I would say that


What Ro.... oh yea, that one I had sometime last year. (yr going in the river if you come to Germany!)
roflroflroflPics pleaseroflroflrofl

granada203028

1,500 posts

228 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks Magic. Tried the table format codes I had used before but because preview didn't look right didn't use them. Also not included in "formatting codes" any more. So preview not really preview then.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
monaro5.7 said:
Dont wanna be a party pooper but asked about Monaro`s

So why no one mentioned the Coupe 4 or the CV8-R

Even tho i dont think there is any in the country but iam sure someone will prove me wrong laugh

I just luv the look of the Coupe4 just a shame it got such bad press frown
is harryoz's not a coupe 4 ????

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Tuesday 6th April 2010
quotequote all
007 VXR said:
monaro5.7 said:
Dont wanna be a party pooper but asked about Monaro`s

So why no one mentioned the Coupe 4 or the CV8-R

Even tho i dont think there is any in the country but iam sure someone will prove me wrong laugh

I just luv the look of the Coupe4 just a shame it got such bad press frown
is harryoz's not a coupe 4 ????
No - his is a CV8 or rather it was before all the mods were fitted.