Lets start a debate......
Lets start a debate......
Author
Discussion

behold81

Original Poster:

2,931 posts

200 months

Saturday 10th April 2010
quotequote all
Superchargers... Which are the best and why.....

Root
Screw
centrifugal???

The way i see it Root/Screw will get your power more even over the revs and add more low down.

CF will give a more high end increase and a gradual increase over the range....

But which works better on a daily and track use???

cv8gto

410 posts

204 months

Saturday 10th April 2010
quotequote all
behold81 said:
Superchargers... Which are the best and why.....

Root
Screw
centrifugal???

The way i see it Root/Screw will get your power more even over the revs and add more low down.

CF will give a more high end increase and a gradual increase over the range....

But which works better on a daily and track use???



Root & Screw sound good ;-)
Centrifugal, I might have to strech up first for that.rolleyes

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 10th April 2010
quotequote all
Twin screws like the Wipple make big power but compress between the rotors so are always making boost. This hurts fuel consumption. Centri blowers act like turbos so do their best work beyond 3k rpm. The new TVS PD blowers are simply awesome making great torque low down and big power up top. Also, they make no boost and draw practically no power when cruising. I am biased but the TVS is the most advanced blower our there as far as I'm concerned.

crisisjez

9,209 posts

236 months

Saturday 10th April 2010
quotequote all
PD for a daily driver and Centri for the track.

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
crisisjez said:
PD for a daily driver and Centri for the track.
I'm liking the sound of centri.

SimonV8ster

13,035 posts

259 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
crisisjez said:
PD for a daily driver and Centri for the track.
I'm liking the sound of centri.
Plus they're half the price of a PD aren't they ?? scratchchin

ArnieVXR

2,458 posts

214 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
The ones powered by exhaust gas (best in pairs)

after_shock

8,751 posts

251 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
Just look on the US forums huge debates all the time about these!

Dont think theirs an ideal solution if your wanting road and track use.

Personally I do like the idea of the centri style ones as out on the road its less likely to catch you out in the lower revs and its ideal for the track as in higher revs.

PD ones are constantly on and running so instant power regardless but it feels like they are strangling the engine at higher revs or so ive found at the likes of thunder road (new TVS style as in wormus's one may be very different tho) especially when the N/A cam/head guys are eating into the lead ive made low down at quite a rate!

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
crisisjez said:
PD for a daily driver and Centri for the track.
I'm liking the sound of centri.
ute? procharger, vortech, or something else?

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
Which proves itself the fastest and most reliable package ? :P

There is no definitive answer.


Everyones goals are different, so just decide what the user wants, and take it from there.

But building a big engine torque monster that keeps breaking st and wont get any traction....well, IMO thats just daft. But again, thats up to each individuals needs.

And a twin screw blower is more efficient than the TVS. Thats just fact

ferb

3,112 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
gsd2000 said:
MyM8V8 said:
crisisjez said:
PD for a daily driver and Centri for the track.


I'm liking the sound of centri.


ute? procharger, vortech, or something else?

For a ute you just add corners driving hehe

SimonV8ster

13,035 posts

259 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
So Stevieturbo, whats the centri like ? Is it more akin to a turbo like some say or completely different.

Do you get a gradual increase in acceleration or does it come in with a bang at higher rpm's ?

Edited by SimonV8ster on Sunday 11th April 23:21

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
SimonV8ster said:
So Stevieturbo, whats the centri like ? Is it more akin to a turbo like some say or completely different.

Do you get a gradual increase in acceleration or does it come in with a bang at higher rpm's ?

Edited by SimonV8ster on Sunday 11th April 23:21
its been covered so many times, and it also baffles me why anyone would think its like a turbocharger in its power delivery.

And...power delivery will also depend on the overall package.

But generally speaking they provide small amounts of boost at low rpm, and this rises with rpm. So power delivery is very linear. There wont be any big spikes or sudden rushes of power. Its mostly gradual...but again, other aspects can change that. Like camshaft. So it may exaggerate the traits of any camshaft. So if you had a cam that really didnt come on song to say 4500rpm...then that would of course till apply, just with more aggressive results than if it were n/a due to the added boost.
Power is still instant like n/a, just more of it. It doesnt make any huge doses of torque at 2000rpm.....but with a 6.0 engine, do you really need much more there ?

All in all, its a friendlier easier to use package, that is also less likely to break stuff all the time. And you can actually fit a proper intercooler too !

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
My mate has a cammed and vortech centri. The car goes really well. Not so great off the start, but its definately progressive and quite brutal once wound out. I never floored it 100%
I still preferred NA. But compared to the PD VXR8 I drove his Centri VESS was vastly superior.
Maybe I need to drive some more to draw any final conclusions. But so far my stroker would be far more responsive than either the PD or the Centri off the mark.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:

And a twin screw blower is more efficient than the TVS. Thats just fact


I have literature that proves otherwise. The world has moved on old chap.

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
wormus said:
stevieturbo said:
And a twin screw blower is more efficient than the TVS. Thats just fact
I have literature that proves otherwise. The world has moved on old chap.
Im sure Maggie have such literature...

The same way Procharger have literature over Vortech
The same way Vortech have literature over procharger..
The same way Paxton has literature....well, you get the picture.

And true, the world has moved on....centrifugal compressors are the way forward tongue out for an all round package.

My centri works fine....and didnt break stuff :P

Couple of vids from the weekend. Although even with the Hoosiers traction was still difficult. They are the best tyre Ive used so far though

a little burnout.....damn thats hard on tyres though frown

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3LfWsFSeuA

and brief in car

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOrNHdXG-Ak

and messing about

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JzhJVN9Mi_A

Edited by stevieturbo on Monday 12th April 10:13

drew ss

2,683 posts

215 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
how did u get on stevie that bonnett looks like it needs a few clips in it i didnt make it yesterday work took place....

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
drew ss said:
how did u get on stevie that bonnett looks like it needs a few clips in it i didnt make it yesterday work took place....
Think 11.24 was my best. Came 2nd overall ( although 3rd fastest there ). Dont think it'll ever do a 10 there unless I can make leaps and bounds with grip.

Only 2 Evo's faster. Kenny Wylie ran a 9.93 although split the gearbox casing and couldnt finish.

Martin Tracy was the winner beating me in the elims. He was running mid 10's

Edited by stevieturbo on Monday 12th April 11:03

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
My mate has a cammed and vortech centri. The car goes really well. Not so great off the start, but its definately progressive and quite brutal once wound out. I never floored it 100%
I still preferred NA. But compared to the PD VXR8 I drove his Centri VESS was vastly superior.
Maybe I need to drive some more to draw any final conclusions. But so far my stroker would be far more responsive than either the PD or the Centri off the mark.
So why do you lag behind off the line behind me then?