Harrop Supercharger and LPG Fuel
Harrop Supercharger and LPG Fuel
Author
Discussion

boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
Hi All,

Whilst having a service last week I was talking to Monkfish about my plans for the car. They expressed concern about an LPG conversion with a Harrop S/C installation, specifically the location of fitting the gas injectors. Due to the Harrop nestling between the heads, manifold space is at a premium so there is little room for drill sites to fit the gas injectors.

Has anyone successfully fitted LPG to a Harrop S/C car?

Thanks
B

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
concern about a future installation, or concern about one thats already done ?

boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
I was planning on having it installed in the next couple of weeks. Kind of the whole point of buying my Monaro, I like the idea of around 500BHP at the equivalent of around 50MPG.

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
Assuming the injector nozzles can be suitable located, I dont see a problem ? Although space is likely to be tight.

Just make sure whoever implements the system is aware of the gas flow requirements for such power though.

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
boggie said:
Hi All,

Whilst having a service last week I was talking to Monkfish about my plans for the car. They expressed concern about an LPG conversion with a Harrop S/C installation, specifically the location of fitting the gas injectors. Due to the Harrop nestling between the heads, manifold space is at a premium so there is little room for drill sites to fit the gas injectors.

Has anyone successfully fitted LPG to a Harrop S/C car?

Thanks
B
Where are you going to have the LPG tank?

djwilk

1,693 posts

200 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
I am running LPG on VXR8 and have asked myself the same question.

Will probably go Cam in the future and diss the idea of the S/C.

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
Someone here must surely have tried LPG with the Harrop? I had a look at a friends LPG installation on his non-supercharged VXR. The gas nozzles are much smaller than you might imagine, being around 10mm diameter and 25mm high (not unlike a NOS system). From the top of the nozzle a simple, fuel line sized rubber pipe runs from each nozzel to the 2 evaporators, one mounted to each engine cover. I removed the engine covers on my car and looking at the space available between the Harrop and the inlet ports, it looks like there is enough room.

They need to remove the Harrop and the inlet manifold, drill 8 holes near the fuel injectors and refit. They have various tanks available; if there is not enough room to sling one under the car they have a spare wheel shaped tank that replaces the spare wheel. It is a little deeper than the Monaro space-saver but only by an inch so no real loss to boot space. I think it holds 60L which should give a range of around 260 miles.

The cost is circa £2.5K but it will pay itself back if I keep the car long enough.

Edited by boggie on Monday 12th April 20:49

djwilk

1,693 posts

200 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
I had my tank fitted in the spare wheel well. Squeezes in 54l of LPG so I guess, given a 20% air cushion, it is something near 70l total. The conversion cost me £2250 and BRC Sequent has been fitted. It runs to evaporators but the max power it will hold is 500bhp. With S/C you have to bear in mind that you will need more of a power capability. Another issue that builds up is the speed the LPG is injected into the cylinders at. And from my experience (not backed by any dyno yet), the car is weaker towards its max revs from 5k upwards.
Regarding the range, you have to account for the fact that it will burn 20% fuel than Petrol. My current range in town only works out to be 100 - 110miles and about 220miles on a motorway.

kjmac

561 posts

264 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
Boggie said:
... It is a little deeper than the Monaro space-saver but only by an inch so no real loss to boot space. I think it holds 60L which should give a range of around 260 miles.

The cost is circa £2.5K but it will pay itself back if I keep the car long enough.


I've got a 6.0 VXR which I've been running on LPG for over a year now. I've got a 62L tank in the spare wheel area which equates to 50L of gas, on a motorway this = a maximum range of 220 miles, not 260. During my mostly extra-urban commute I average 170 - 180 miles to a tank.

As comparison on petrol I average 26mpg on a motorway and 20mpg on my commute. I think I paid just over £2000 for my conversion, I'll double-check. £2500 sounds on the steep side. I've got a twin vaporiser BRC multi-point system. I was informed this was good to ~400hp, but mine's normally aspirated and I don't intend to supercharge.

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the info. In my ignorance I assumed that 60 L was 60 L, I didn't think to include room for air! :+)

The guys I am talking to say that their system, £2400, is good for at 550BHP which just about covers what I need. As this car is my daily driver and I will do a fair few miles, I am hoping it will pay back the installation over the next two years.

djwilk

1,693 posts

200 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
Breaking even is one thing, and saving money is another. If the install is good for 550bhp and you are about to run 550bhp then I would say you need something more efficient. On the other hand if you want to have a blast with someone it only takes a press of a button and you are back on real juice with no hesitation or fuel supply at any point. Also if you are going to run S/Ced 550bhp on LPG I guess you will achieve less power or at least the torque/power curves will be different although peak figures might remain the same. That is what I have noticed on mine, haven't done a dyno yet though.

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
It would be interesting to see a dyno print out. The engineers I have been speaking to suggest that on a supercharged Range Rover the power loss using LPG was around 10%. I can quite happily live with a loss of around 50 bhp whilst commuting and dropping the kids off etc but as you say; as soon as I see a Scooby in my rearview mirror with one hit of a button I'm gone!

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
For some reason i thought forced induction worked well with lpg, produced more power.

I could be wrong hasnt lpg got a higher octane rating than petrol.

kjmac

561 posts

264 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
gsd2000 said:
For some reason i thought forced induction worked well with lpg, produced more power.

I could be wrong hasnt lpg got a higher octane rating than petrol.


Indeed it is higher octane, but I'd guess you'd need a bespoke mapping to really harness this to your advantage, potentially at the expense of petrol performance I'd guess.

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
gsd2000 said:
For some reason i thought forced induction worked well with lpg, produced more power.

I could be wrong hasnt lpg got a higher octane rating than petrol.
It has higher octane, but thats about it.

It will require more for any given power output, and you also lose a little of the cooling effect squirting fuel into the airstream would achieve. Squirting gas in, cools nothing.

Ideally if you could run two proper maps. One for LPG, and one for petrol, then you could optimise both setups.

But if they claim their LPG system is good for 550bhp...no way would I run it at 550bhp. Far too risky.

I know the changeover is supposed to be silky smooth between LPG and petrol. If you want the best of both worlds..perhaps sort something so that anything below say 4000rpm is LPG, and above is petrol. SO 90% of your driving will be on LPG, and when you give it some beans, it'll be safely runnng on petrol

eliot

11,999 posts

285 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
I know the changeover is supposed to be silky smooth between LPG and petrol. If you want the best of both worlds..perhaps sort something so that anything below say 4000rpm is LPG, and above is petrol. SO 90% of your driving will be on LPG, and when you give it some beans, it'll be safely runnng on petrol
That would seem the best and safest approach.

wallsjay

408 posts

229 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
i have a supercharged ute on gas but its the votech system all works fine took some fiddling to get enough gas but well worth it u do feel a drop in power but worth it for 56p a litre

i am sure i read somewhere u can get the standard injectors with the lpg built into them might be worth a search

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
You feel a drop in power because it hasnt been tuned to make use of the LPG.

There is no doubt if the ecu was re-tuned to optimise running on the LPG, there would be no loss of power.

Obviously most LPG installers wouldnt know how to do that though.