A question about brakes
Discussion
When I first got the CV8 I was relatively happy with the brakes in that they had adequate performance/bite right from the off, i.e when cold although ultimately not great on a run.
Gradually I became disastisfied because they were juddering and would not tolerate driving on a circuit and taking the car on a circuit was something that I envisaged doing more of.
I had Performance Friction pads fitted and that cured the juddering and ultimate braking peformance was massively increased (when up to temperature), very impressive considering the standard discs. So all good it seemed...but not quite. The way I am using the car has changed now and it is getting weekend use only 15-20 miles max, mostly dual carriageway and no track days. I simply can't generate enough heat into the pads to make them work properly. There is no bite unless I 'ride' the brakes under power and even then I can't maintain the temperature.
My questions is do AP brakes perform well from cold.
Gradually I became disastisfied because they were juddering and would not tolerate driving on a circuit and taking the car on a circuit was something that I envisaged doing more of.
I had Performance Friction pads fitted and that cured the juddering and ultimate braking peformance was massively increased (when up to temperature), very impressive considering the standard discs. So all good it seemed...but not quite. The way I am using the car has changed now and it is getting weekend use only 15-20 miles max, mostly dual carriageway and no track days. I simply can't generate enough heat into the pads to make them work properly. There is no bite unless I 'ride' the brakes under power and even then I can't maintain the temperature.
My questions is do AP brakes perform well from cold.
My experience is the AP's are OK cold and get better as they get hotter.
After driving with them hot (B-roads), they are surprisingly weak after a dual-carriageway run where they can cool right down, requiring much more pedal, but improve(warm) again quickly.
They are still much better than the std Monaro brakes when cold and many times better when hot.
NB: My GTS is much heavier than any Ro, so heats the brakes quicker!
You really need to find someone with an AP'd Ro who'll let you drive theirs.
After driving with them hot (B-roads), they are surprisingly weak after a dual-carriageway run where they can cool right down, requiring much more pedal, but improve(warm) again quickly.
They are still much better than the std Monaro brakes when cold and many times better when hot.
NB: My GTS is much heavier than any Ro, so heats the brakes quicker!
You really need to find someone with an AP'd Ro who'll let you drive theirs.
Magic919 said:
ARAF said:
Not sure AP is the way for you to go.
IMHO as AP are race developed they are not robust enough for UK winter weather and suffer from siezing due to corrosion.
Hmmm. As a VXR8 owner you should be worried then.IMHO as AP are race developed they are not robust enough for UK winter weather and suffer from siezing due to corrosion.
As mentioned the VXR set up would be the obvious choice but even then you would need to change the pads otherwise get that juddering come back, which im getting on the AP's and a few other kits seem to be suffering the same so they aint immune to it.
Why not look at some EBC or the likes pads which are now available, just get the road or fast road set ups so they dont require daft temps to work?
Why not look at some EBC or the likes pads which are now available, just get the road or fast road set ups so they dont require daft temps to work?
No disrespect to the opinions already aired but nobody able to put some numbers to the comparisons? For VXR or APs to work better than CV8 there must be quantifiable engineering differences, such as greater piston area or act at a greater radius out from the centre.
Subjectively by brother's 3 series BMW has much better brakes than the Monaro, sharper initial bite and perfectly smooth. And from smaller less fancy looking assemblies. The car is only a bit lighter so my advice is fit BMW brakes!
Subjectively by brother's 3 series BMW has much better brakes than the Monaro, sharper initial bite and perfectly smooth. And from smaller less fancy looking assemblies. The car is only a bit lighter so my advice is fit BMW brakes!
Again subjectively, we had a pug 306 and it's brakes would throw you through the windscreen, but wierdly took a while to stop???? Massive initial bite, but then very little!
05 CV8 brakes are apparently only a little way behind vxr, so the change may not be worth while, however 04 to VXR is a bigger step though.
I do know what you mean about cold brakes though, a cat ran out in front of me the other day, the Ro stopped, but not with any confidence....I thought I would be scraping moggy off the wheel arches...
On the other hand, my limited experiences with AP's suggest masssive improvement, even from cold, but corrosion would be a major point to consider.
05 CV8 brakes are apparently only a little way behind vxr, so the change may not be worth while, however 04 to VXR is a bigger step though.
I do know what you mean about cold brakes though, a cat ran out in front of me the other day, the Ro stopped, but not with any confidence....I thought I would be scraping moggy off the wheel arches...
On the other hand, my limited experiences with AP's suggest masssive improvement, even from cold, but corrosion would be a major point to consider.
Wolfracer said:
05 CV8 brakes are apparently only a little way behind vxr, so the change may not be worth while, however 04 to VXR is a bigger step though.
Good point, 04 CV8's were apparantly quite bad so an upgrade to VXR's might do the trick.Where's the OP gone - are his brakes OK ??
granada203028 said:
No disrespect to the opinions already aired but nobody able to put some numbers to the comparisons? For VXR or APs to work better than CV8 there must be quantifiable engineering differences, such as greater piston area or act at a greater radius out from the centre.
Subjectively by brother's 3 series BMW has much better brakes than the Monaro, sharper initial bite and perfectly smooth. And from smaller less fancy looking assemblies. The car is only a bit lighter so my advice is fit BMW brakes!
I know what you mean.Subjectively by brother's 3 series BMW has much better brakes than the Monaro, sharper initial bite and perfectly smooth. And from smaller less fancy looking assemblies. The car is only a bit lighter so my advice is fit BMW brakes!
The AP pads are a totally different compound and will wear discs quicker, produce more dust and are more likely to be noisey than stock which are designed to do none of these.
Piston area shouldn't make any difference in stoppability, but should change feel/feedback, pedal travel and pressure appliable, as will vacuum at booster.
Disc and pad contact area are the most important aspect of braking.
Don't know the Monaro's different brake specs - disc/pad sizes, steel grade, compounds, etc.
It would be interesting to know the differences.
Hawk do a GTO/G8 pad that is supposed to have excellent cold bite and work just as well when hot. I import their LTS pads for the Excursion which only has 1-3/4" x 2-1/2" disc to pad area and weighs 9500lbs.
Trailermasher said:
Disc and pad contact area are the most important aspect of braking.
Leverage and heat control are.And as for AP's being better...that would also depend a lot on the type of pad used.
If you used shyte pads with AP's and the best pads with std....good chance std will perform better.
AP also have a new range of pads out. I'm using the APF404, and would say they are very good, and quite clean also. I had been on DS2500's before.
The car is used in the dry only and lives in a garage with a dehumidifier so corrosion is not an issue I wouldn't have thought. It is hardly ever washed with water just quick detailer as it never gets dirty enough!
I was thinking making more power was next on my list but I am thinking that getting the brakes totally sorted first probably makes more sense. The brakes as they are just don't inspire enough confidence under the sort of use I am putting them under.
I am not heavy on brakes but want the ability to stop on a dime if required and not have to worry about keeping heat in them
I was thinking making more power was next on my list but I am thinking that getting the brakes totally sorted first probably makes more sense. The brakes as they are just don't inspire enough confidence under the sort of use I am putting them under.
I am not heavy on brakes but want the ability to stop on a dime if required and not have to worry about keeping heat in them
Changed all mine to VXR discs and calipers, even yho I had the larger of the CV8 brakes, the VXR fluted surface discs are much better than the smooth ones, no fade so far at hard braking, fairly easy job to do if you have a tool kit and four halfords trolly jacks :-) need to get the car off the ground on all four corners to make life easier.
Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




