Whats a realistic cost of forging the bottom end?
Whats a realistic cost of forging the bottom end?
Author
Discussion

after_shock

Original Poster:

8,751 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
I know this is a bit of a vauge question as it will depend on a number of factors and what parts used etc however im getting to the point where I need to make a decision, do I go on a get a bit more power out of the car but if so I must forge it in order to keep things reliable, or if the cost is too high do I have another couple of holidays and buy a second car to play with.

Its easy to work out the price of parts to start a build with the unkwown is obviously the labour side of things to do it and any other parts that will be needed along the way so im asking people who have done this route to give a rough idea so I know what to work with or not to bother?

The cost im after is purely related to doing the bottom end of the engine, if you have changed the boost on the charger for example and had to uprate the fuelling and oil pumps because of that can you exclude that from the cost of doing the bottom end on its own, im just looking for an idea of a starting point and can work from that.

Also from looking at ways of doing it two ways keep coming up, buy a balanced rotating assembly and get it fitted, or simply buy a new shortblock with all the bits in and ready to go, the second option is more expensive up front but will require less labour and it will also give me a standard block with pistons etc in ready to sell on if they have a value?

Can anyone give advice on which is the best and most cost effective way to go and ultimately a budget I should be looking at for doing in?

Cheers

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
How long is a piece of string ??


There are cheap ways, and expensive ways.

Absolute cheapest, using your existing block with no capacity change...and it will work just fine.

Take it apart, fit rods and pistons, put it back together again.

In terms of parts, rods/pistons will likely be around US$1000-1200, give or take.
Pair of head gaskets, $60
New timing chain gear sub $100 ( not essential )
Ideally + ARP head studs $220 or so I think.
New crank pulley bolt $12 i think...not expensive anyway

Then oil, fluids etc.

Now of course there are other items that should be replaced at that time too. But nobody would think twice about fitting heads, cam, whatever to an engine not even looking at oil pump or bearings. So if there is nothing wrong with them, there is no real reason they need changed at this time either.

As for balancing, again...ideally yes this should take place. But it certainly is not essential. Probably wouldnt add a huge cost to the budget anyway...probably sub £200 depending how much work needed done.

After that budget build, the price can just go up and up depending what you need.

Labour costs aside, I see no reason why you couldnt have a very strong bottom end for well under £2k. Obviously you may want to change cam, heads, pushrods, and perhaps other stuff at the same time too.
But all that's needed for a strong bottom end is rods and pistons. You'll never break a crank, and for the most part the block will be fine.

monkfish1

12,516 posts

255 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
after_shock said:
I know this is a bit of a vauge question as it will depend on a number of factors and what parts used etc however im getting to the point where I need to make a decision, do I go on a get a bit more power out of the car but if so I must forge it in order to keep things reliable, or if the cost is too high do I have another couple of holidays and buy a second car to play with.

Its easy to work out the price of parts to start a build with the unkwown is obviously the labour side of things to do it and any other parts that will be needed along the way so im asking people who have done this route to give a rough idea so I know what to work with or not to bother?

The cost im after is purely related to doing the bottom end of the engine, if you have changed the boost on the charger for example and had to uprate the fuelling and oil pumps because of that can you exclude that from the cost of doing the bottom end on its own, im just looking for an idea of a starting point and can work from that.

Also from looking at ways of doing it two ways keep coming up, buy a balanced rotating assembly and get it fitted, or simply buy a new shortblock with all the bits in and ready to go, the second option is more expensive up front but will require less labour and it will also give me a standard block with pistons etc in ready to sell on if they have a value?

Can anyone give advice on which is the best and most cost effective way to go and ultimately a budget I should be looking at for doing in?

Cheers


If you want to go really budget, i understand that GMPP do forged pistons that are the same weight as stock with stock pin size too. So, in theroy, you could pop the heads and sump off in situ, pull the rods and pistons, swap the pistons then reassemble. Risk is that you dont have enough piston/bore clearance.

Its not what i would do, but it has potential to be cheap.

TerryS

1,382 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
If I wasn't so far down the line with parts I would seriously consider a GM Performance Parts LSX376. Do a search and see what you think. The cheapest I have seen is approx. $5700

V8NHH

437 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Slightly off on a tangent has anyone though of lightening and balancing crank?

Have done on racing FJ motorbike and saved over 1KG in weight and was balanced, when compared to standard crank it was amazing to see how poorly balanced they are from factory, all this has had 3years racing abuse (worst kind) and has been totally reliable (won x3 championships)bike picks up and revs so much easier.

Ive not seen it mentioned much, but just think less rotating mass has to be a good thing and it appears standard cranks are way over enginered by the huge amount of power they can take... just a thought probably not a norm though as big old lump of car etc...

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
You can get aftermarket lightened cranks. Callies Magnum XL for example.
There are of course also lightended flywheels available. The ACT twinplate is 40% lighter than stock etc.

Stock cranks are cast. Probably better to look at a balanced assembley if you were going down that route.

On the topic in general I understand the rods are good for a decent amount of power, so the pistons are the weakpoint. So the idea of GM Forged pistons as Roger mentions sounds good. Aftermarket rods will take power potential even higher.
But without doing the heads as well you are limiting your upsite. As usual you need to look at the engine from intake to exhaust and treat it as a complete system when working towards your power goals.

DaveVXR

293 posts

239 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
I'm interested in this. Not really after more power or doing a full build, more in maintaining what I have. So just sticking in some forged pistons and maybe rods would make sense for me.

What sort of labour costs are we talking of for properly fitting a set of standard size pistons and rods?

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
.. In which case you are better off leaving it as is. Unless you are pushing the envelope now, the stock engine is design for extra long life. Forged pistons flex more than stock. So stock are more condusive to a long service life, but not sustained high power loads over factory spec.
Plenty of guys in the US will well over 100,000 miles on their stock engines. Aftermarket engines usually need a clean up well before then. Forged 2618 pistons are not designed for a long service life. They are designed for abuse and high power. But a relatively much shorter engine lifespan. They deform and the rings last less time etc.
NA you should go for 4032 alloy as its harder and less flexible, but lasts longer and is easier on the rings.

One justification for forging the stock engine is because the cam you are trying to jam in needs more piston to valve clearance so you need valve pockets in the piston.

The stock engine can eat any reasonable street cams anyway, so thats not likely to be an issue in most cases. Sure if you are racing your engine you might want to go forged. But a lot of piston life is down to the tune. Detonation will smash an engine in no time.

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
DaveVXR said:
I'm interested in this. Not really after more power or doing a full build, more in maintaining what I have. So just sticking in some forged pistons and maybe rods would make sense for me.

What sort of labour costs are we talking of for properly fitting a set of standard size pistons and rods?
If your Ro is SC your being very sensible! As for a cost, What Roger says regarding the pistons but TBH you really need to drop the block out and strip it to be able to re-hone the bores to give the new pistons a fighting chance at bedding in and also fitting properly. No such thing as a cheap forged engine at this level Im affraid although you can limit the final bill by just having the pistons fitted (plus the other complimentary and required works) and not bothering with cams, rods, cranks, ARP bolts, timing chains, oil pumps etc etc etc.

monkfish1

12,516 posts

255 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
S800VXR said:
DaveVXR said:
I'm interested in this. Not really after more power or doing a full build, more in maintaining what I have. So just sticking in some forged pistons and maybe rods would make sense for me.

What sort of labour costs are we talking of for properly fitting a set of standard size pistons and rods?


If your Ro is SC your being very sensible! As for a cost, What Roger says regarding the pistons but TBH you really need to drop the block out and strip it to be able to re-hone the bores to give the new pistons a fighting chance at bedding in and also fitting properly. No such thing as a cheap forged engine at this level Im affraid although you can limit the final bill by just having the pistons fitted (plus the other complimentary and required works) and not bothering with cams, rods, cranks, ARP bolts, timing chains, oil pumps etc etc etc.


Indeed! As i said, the changing pistons in situ isn't what i would do. Taking it out and doing it properly is the RIGHT way to do it.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Actually comparitively with other engines, BMW, Jag etc I bet the LS engine is way cheaper. Parts are plentiful and cheap in comparison.
Absolute costs are not so good with Labour etc involved. But piston sets can be had from around $700 USD and full rotating assembleys around $1600 USD.
Considering the power output you can get in NA form you are pretty much at the top of the BHP per £ in comparison to other engines..

After_Shock

Original Poster:

8,751 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, if I could get it done circa £2-2.5k its well within budget and would give me the peace of mind I want with the engine, then next year will save up a bit and change the charger to something different and have some fun smile

Any ideas on labour time involved to fit the forged bits, I would only do it balanced as would prefer its done right?

Or is it cheaper to buy the rotating assembly balanced and ready to fit and do it that way?


monkfish1

12,516 posts

255 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
After_Shock said:
Thanks for the replies, if I could get it done circa £2-2.5k its well within budget and would give me the peace of mind I want with the engine, then next year will save up a bit and change the charger to something different and have some fun

Any ideas on labour time involved to fit the forged bits, I would only do it balanced as would prefer its done right?

Or is it cheaper to buy the rotating assembly balanced and ready to fit and do it that way?



£6.5 - 7K dependant on exact spec (based on using existing rods and crank) and exchange rate at the time. That includes everything, drive in, remove from vehicle, strip down engine entirely, new bearings seals etc + the forged bits, studs etc. Reassemble, run on an engine dyno, refit to car and drive out. Includes VAT. Thats an all in inclusive price. No surprises or extras. Assuming that the engine is usuable when it comes in of course!

A bought in rotating assembly from the US will probably be cheaper. Who you going to call when it has a problem though?

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Rogers last comment is one of the reason I decided to get my engine built here so I have some comeback if it does break through a fault.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Yeah well. Not sure my issue would be any different had I got mine locally or not.
Still Roger is doing sterling work for me sorting things out so far.
All the bits are still good. Time to use a higher spec oil by the looks.
Slighty more cubes, compression and a bit more cam overlap will be the result. Im guessing 520rwhp all said and done.. we will see.

doleboy

747 posts

248 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
Yeah well. Not sure my issue would be any different had I got mine locally or not.
Still Roger is doing sterling work for me sorting things out so far.
All the bits are still good. Time to use a higher spec oil by the looks.
Slighty more cubes, compression and a bit more cam overlap will be the result. Im guessing 520rwhp all said and done.. we will see.



LOL, automotive Nietzsche strikes again!

DaveVXR

293 posts

239 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
If you fit forged pistons designed for a SC then would you also need to factor in a re-map?

And when would it be best to do this? Do you need to let the pistons bed in on the original map and then get it done? Or get it done twice, once as a bed in map and then as a final tune?

monkfish1

12,516 posts

255 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
DaveVXR said:
If you fit forged pistons designed for a SC then would you also need to factor in a re-map?

And when would it be best to do this? Do you need to let the pistons bed in on the original map and then get it done? Or get it done twice, once as a bed in map and then as a final tune?


You would only need to change the map if you change the dimensions of something. Not quite sure what you mean? A piston isn't "designed" for a SC. You specify what piston, ie material, dimensions etc that you need.

after_shock

Original Poster:

8,751 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
DaveVXR said:
If you fit forged pistons designed for a SC then would you also need to factor in a re-map?

And when would it be best to do this? Do you need to let the pistons bed in on the original map and then get it done? Or get it done twice, once as a bed in map and then as a final tune?


You would only need to change the map if you change the dimensions of something. Not quite sure what you mean? A piston isn't "designed" for a SC. You specify what piston, ie material, dimensions etc that you need.


Do some pistons not had a thicker top layer that are better for FI applications I would guess as to what the comment meant? It does say on some sites better designed for FI etc but that would probably relate to materials etc as you say, for us that have no idea whats best for what we would just go off the ones that say are better for FI!

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
He probably means a low compression bowled piston with thicker ring lands.