Oils..
Author
Discussion

ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Ok, Gareth mentioned something interesting a day or so back with regards to my accelerated cam wear.
I then went off into research mode and found some interesting info.
Basically newer oils have a much lower concentration of zinc and phosphorous than older skool ones.
This is to protect Satan's cat converters etc. However in regards to the valvetrain this is bad as you can get accelerated wear. Especially with flat tappets.
Now in my case of course I have roller rockers. But I have dual valve springs and over 400lb open pressure which is shedloads more than OEM. So Im now thinking that I need to find a better oil to make sure this doesnt happen again.
The engine was run in with a high zinc breakin oil, but thereafter with the usual Mobil1 0W-40 stuff.
Mobil do some racing oils with more than double the normal levels of phosphorous and zinc. So Im now thinking this is what I need to run. If I combine this with some reduction in oil consumption through the intake by getting a catch can and fitting a breather cap Im hoping to prevent too much oil getting burnt and dumped into the cats etc.
Standard Mobil1 has 800ppm ZDDP and their racing stuff is like 1700ppm. Weights are a bit heavier. I did run a fill of 15-50 in my LS1 and I think Gareth runs this weight in his.

So anyway, comments from anyone with more info on the topic appreciated.


ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Hmm,

http://www.motor.com/article.asp?article_ID=1604

In addition to the need for sufficient levels of ZDDP to protect flat-tappet camshafts during break-in and for long-term use, it’s now recognized within the performance engine building community that a high ZDDP level is beneficial for many roller camshaft applications as well. Specifically, ZDDP protects lifter bodies and lifter bores, and prevents galling or scuffing issues where roller lifters exist in a tight oil clearance environment. ZDDP is also beneficial for roller rocker arms, especially where high valve spring pressures are present, to protect valve tips and pushrod tips. While the flat-tappet issue served to bring the ZDDP content of oil (or lack thereof) to the forefront, a high level of ZDDP may be beneficial to any performance engine application where pressure and scuffing concerns exist.


S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
See...! if you had gone FI then you wouldnt have had such high pressures on yr cam lobes! Bloody NA issues again!. tongue out


BTW - this subject has been discussed to death on 200mph.org as oil there is given a real hard time and a couple of the lads work in labs associated to the oil industry. wink

L2VXR

1,014 posts

244 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Not sure how these tests relate to real life conditions but i found this interesting,the pressure ratings may be of interest

www.iridiumengineering.co.uk/Oiltests.pdf

and also stumbled across this company whilst i was browsing

www.fluidsinmotorsport.co.uk/catalogue/fluids2010motorsport.pdf


Edited by L2VXR on Thursday 22 April 15:49

ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Yeah apparently Redline has a high content. I think Roger uses that at MF. But it doesnt comply with the latest API reg's.
(ie) Regs are for emissions, not for engine life. Typical.

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Was your cam/follower failure even anything to do with oil ??

I suspect my springs are harder than yours, and revved higher too. I think installed seat pressure is around 160lbs. Not sure fully open, but lift is a little over 600thou

Ive never had any lifter, cam wear or other such problem.

I used to use Motul 300V 5/40, but now using Millers CFS 10/60


MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
Was your cam/follower failure even anything to do with oil ??

I suspect my springs are harder than yours, and revved higher too. I think installed seat pressure is around 160lbs. Not sure fully open, but lift is a little over 600thou

Ive never had any lifter, cam wear or other such problem.

I used to use Motul 300V 5/40, but now using Millers CFS 10/60
The real answer is that it is all hypothesis and supposition. I suggested a duff lifter at first, but then wondered about spring pressure, then slippery stuff. Truth is, we'll never know.

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Yes, but what actually failed ???

Was the roller broken ? worn ? pin broke ? lifter internals not working ? Cam worn, damaged ?


ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Cam worn, one lifter munched and stuck in its bore. Some swarf got feed to the mains.
Roger might have some more details.
My cam is/was in theory more like 0.650 patriot gold duals IIRC.

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Lifter has a triangular roller with a very worn hole in the middle!

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Rich when are you going to be getting the car back on the road?? It must be driving you mad

ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
Lifter has a triangular roller with a very worn hole in the middle!
Ah ok, so it was the lifter that trashed it then. Sounds like its bearing died or something.
$29 US for a lifter. Lots more than that to fix its damage frown

ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
Bonnie and Clyde said:
Rich when are you going to be getting the car back on the road?? It must be driving you mad frown
Yes smile

Roger is on the case and its coming together. Issue is non standard pistons. Teach me for getting a custom spec stroker. A 427 would be much easier to get replacement bits for and it would probably be back on the road by now. (Hint for stroker people).

EssexVXR8

1,790 posts

218 months

Thursday 22nd April 2010
quotequote all
I use Torco SR-5, not cheap but i noticed a difference over Mobil one when i used it for my last oil change, got some nice additives too.

TerryS

1,382 posts

279 months

Friday 23rd April 2010
quotequote all
The guys at Opie generally give pretty good oil advice, although limited to the brands they sell. On their advice I switched to Silkolene Pro-S years ago on Supras and still use it now. It seems to work very well.

MadMaxHSV

1,816 posts

229 months

Friday 23rd April 2010
quotequote all
TerryS said:
The guys at Opie generally give pretty good oil advice, although limited to the brands they sell. On their advice I switched to Silkolene Pro-S years ago on Supras and still use it now. It seems to work very well.
yes

Been using Pro-S for a while based on lots of research, in previous cars also, key thing seems to be its Ester based (like Royal Purple) which has higher film strength. Been renamed recently though. Think they dropped the Silkolene name (to be used just for bikes). Now Fuchs something.
Opie do a good price too (discount for Pistonheads users). Works well.
Hearing good things about Torco also. Brothers running it in his V6 Cossie engined Pro-Sport racer.

2blackhats

446 posts

232 months

Friday 23rd April 2010
quotequote all
Yeah another Silkolene/Titan Pro - S user here. Ran it in my 3000Gt and now in the Ro no probs with either.

ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 23rd April 2010
quotequote all
Most oils work, but whats the zinc and phosphrous contents for them!?

stevieturbo

18,105 posts

278 months

Friday 23rd April 2010
quotequote all
The flat tappet issues really arent an issue on modern stuff. It seems to be mostly older engines affected....especially the RV8. It wears cams and followers terribly.

ringram

Original Poster:

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 23rd April 2010
quotequote all
Yeah hopefully it was just a dodgy lifter. Id hate it to do it again. But if your running over 400lb open Stevie then perhaps its fine with rollers smile