Guess what's wrong and win a prize (well maybe)
Guess what's wrong and win a prize (well maybe)
Author
Discussion

ArnieVXR

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

214 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
My Monaro started being decidedly unhappy at 155mph on the back straight at RAF Marham this morning. I'll be droppoing it off at the Fish sometime soon (that popular meeting place for broken FI Monaros). Thought I'd poll the Forum to see if anyone had ideas as to what's up.

Symptoms: Very lump idle (think Christine), very lumpy pulling from low revs, very lumpy when pulling at high revs, fairly smooth at around 4000rpm. Still goes like stink until you get to >4500rpm, when the lumpiness hampers progress. No odd mechanical noises or squealing belts. Crank pulley doesn't wobble (is that the harmonic balancer?). Still get 20mpg.

Note(1): Suspect that this has been coming on for a while (recent feeling that wheels need balancing is the same type of lumpiness)

Note(2): Roger told me that the boost shouldn't exceed 0.75 bar. Recently had peak boost showing 0.8+ and now 0.93 on my fatal run.

I've driven it home okay (95-miles), but the symptoms persist.

after_shock

8,751 posts

251 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
Knackered HT lead or spark plug lol

Hex

568 posts

226 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
I'd say missfire too smile

ArnieVXR

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

214 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
Could be - I had a mis-fire on no.1 once before, but that only affected it when moving. The lumpiness is very pronounced at tick-over. Roger told me that you can pull a lead off when it's ticking over and not notice any difference. It tried it, with various cylinders and found he was right (of course). I also changed some of the leads and didn't notice any difference.

after_shock

8,751 posts

251 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
When I had a mis fire on mine I found it quite obvious at idle!

Yours is a complicated set up so wouldnt like to guess.

ArnieVXR

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

214 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
I hope you're right after_shock

Edited by ArnieVXR on Saturday 24th April 18:19

doleboy

747 posts

248 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
Love the Christine metaphore but wonder if its more than a plug or HT lead.

I fried a lead on mine a while back & whilst I noticed it, it was more of an extra kick at idle when that cylinder slightly missfired rather than a WTF, I daren't go past 4500rpm scenario.

Have you tried pulling/reconnecting the HT leads in order to see if one plug doesn't make a difference?

If you can't spot a difference then that would suggest another issue & a reason to conider getting a flatbed to deliver your car to Monkfish.

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
Are you running stock pistons?

ArnieVXR

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

214 months

Saturday 24th April 2010
quotequote all
Stock everything including fuel system

Tried pulling leads - made no difference

Edited by ArnieVXR on Saturday 24th April 23:46

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
Have you done a compression check on each bore...? Just .9something bar boost on stock pistons is alot! Dont ask how I know! wink

ArnieVXR

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

214 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
weeping A compression test means something expensive, doesn't it?

idea Could be time to start looking at bigger, tougher engine

Hex

568 posts

226 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
weeping A compression test means something expensive, doesn't it?
If it shows a noticable drop in one or more of the cylinders then unfortunatly frown

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
Sorry to hear this Arnie but why oh why oh why do all you FI guys insist on building on stock engines?

Simple cheeap check seeing as you've done all the leads is check the plugs. Take each out to check that one isnt cracked/fubar. Personally I would not drive it anywhere now until fully checked.

after_shock

8,751 posts

251 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
doleboy said:

I fried a lead on mine a while back & whilst I noticed it, it was more of an extra kick at idle when that cylinder slightly missfired rather than a WTF, I daren't go past 4500rpm scenario.



When the HT lead went on mine couldnt rev it past about 2k rpm it was horrendous the effect it had on it, to be honest I was convinced something major had broke on the engine, was more than relived to find out it was a HT lead!

SimonV8ster

13,039 posts

259 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
weeping A compression test means something expensive, doesn't it?
A compression test isn't expensive - its what it finds afterwards that might prove to be expensive !!

doleboy

747 posts

248 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
after_shock said:
doleboy said:

I fried a lead on mine a while back & whilst I noticed it, it was more of an extra kick at idle when that cylinder slightly missfired rather than a WTF, I daren't go past 4500rpm scenario.



When the HT lead went on mine couldnt rev it past about 2k rpm it was horrendous the effect it had on it, to be honest I was convinced something major had broke on the engine, was more than relived to find out it was a HT lead!


Well there may be some hope for ArnieVXR then.

Arnie when you disconnected, reconnected the leads did you look at them? When mine was fried, the back of one lead had burnt through and was leaking current. If you've something similar and didn´t check the leads themselves then it might be worth goingback to look.

TerryS

1,382 posts

279 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
Stock everything including fuel system



11 psi with stock fuel system, turbo's and stock pistons yikes

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
TerryS said:
ArnieVXR said:
Stock everything including fuel system
11 psi with stock fuel system, turbo's and stock pistons yikes
.93bar is near as dame it 14psi.... definately dodgy ground!!!

Silent1

19,762 posts

266 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
Stock everything including fuel system

Tried pulling leads - made no difference

Edited by ArnieVXR on Saturday 24th April 23:46
st the bed, seriously?
Stock fuel pressure and you ran nearly double atmospheric pressure through the turbos. No way in hell will the injectors have managed to cope.

IMHO.

ArnieVXR

Original Poster:

2,458 posts

214 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
whistle Hadn't realised I'd abused my car so much. 0.93 bar sounds a lot less that 14psi. I must say it was very quick for a while. I felt like a god; all the souped up track thingies just went backwards and became small, sad rearview mirror dots. Even running badly, it could still crack 155mph on the straight (I suppose that counts as be making things worse getmecoat).

I'd given up on spending any more on the car, as I didn't think the extra power would be worth it. Might start saving for forged internals now(assuming I don't already have to).