Update on the ticking noise my car was making
Discussion
Don't know if anyone remembers but I posted on here in March with a video of the ticking noise my VXR500 was making from the engine, and it seemed likely it could be a crocked piston. Having spent far too much time working away and being at conferences I finally managed to get the car down to Monkfish, and on arrival it seemed possible that it could be even worse than that - the pistons seemed fine, the lifters seemed okay, but it was difficult to determine where the noise was coming from, and Roger thought there was a possibility it could be damage to the cam and bits of crap throughout the engine, requiring a full rebuild and an enormous bill.
However, I had a call off Andy on Friday to say that they'd got the engine apart and really couldn't find anything wrong other than some valve or other not quite functioning right. I'm about as technical as Jeremy Clarkson so I couldn't tell you exactly what it's called or what the problem is
(maybe if monkfish1 has a spare moment (unlikely I'd say but hey!) maybe he could expand further!), but the bit I needed to know what that it's not serious, the engine and lifters/cams/other related expensive bits are fine, and it's just a matter of sorting this valve type thing out and putting the car back together.
So I am a happy bunny and looking forward to picking up my car probably the weekend after next, literally cannot wait to go out for a blast
However, I had a call off Andy on Friday to say that they'd got the engine apart and really couldn't find anything wrong other than some valve or other not quite functioning right. I'm about as technical as Jeremy Clarkson so I couldn't tell you exactly what it's called or what the problem is
(maybe if monkfish1 has a spare moment (unlikely I'd say but hey!) maybe he could expand further!), but the bit I needed to know what that it's not serious, the engine and lifters/cams/other related expensive bits are fine, and it's just a matter of sorting this valve type thing out and putting the car back together.So I am a happy bunny and looking forward to picking up my car probably the weekend after next, literally cannot wait to go out for a blast

ringram said:
Glad you didnt end up with a toasted cam like me 
So was your valve bent?
Ooer mrs 
So was your valve bent?

I'm not 100% sure but something needs to be sent away to be put right by a machine, so I'm guessing that's a yes?

(As I said, I'm really not good on the technical side of things outside of the basics..
)Just happy to hear it's good news and not far off being ready to go back on the road. Nice one Monkfish!

Good news Dave. I was actually going to e-mail you at some point today to see how you were getting on with it all. Bent intake valve, not too bad at all. Makes me wonder how the valve got bent though? Did it not impact with anything?
Hopefully, you should be able to make the next Breakfast Club meet and PVS 2010 in June! If you can make PVS, book your ticket through VXRonline forum, you'll get a stand pass that way for your car. I'm doing the Sunday only, rather than the full weekend. See my thread on PVS 2010 for more details and links to tickets.
Hopefully, you should be able to make the next Breakfast Club meet and PVS 2010 in June! If you can make PVS, book your ticket through VXRonline forum, you'll get a stand pass that way for your car. I'm doing the Sunday only, rather than the full weekend. See my thread on PVS 2010 for more details and links to tickets.
Tiger_kpt said:
Good news Dave. I was actually going to e-mail you at some point today to see how you were getting on with it all. Bent intake valve, not too bad at all. Makes me wonder how the valve got bent though? Did it not impact with anything?
Not that I know of, bit of a bizarre one really it just 'started' making the ticking noise one morning. From what I can remember I'd been driving pretty sedately the few days prior to that as I'd been taking the car to work (I usually use a Fiesta for that, but had loaned the Fiesta to a friend as her car was broken) and the run into work really doesn't allow for any hard driving, certainly hadn't over-revved or missed any gears and such like that I recall
Don't spose I'll ever know, but in either case I'm just glad it's not serious.I'll do my best to get along to the breakfast club, I always enjoy those meets. Will have to check what date it's on as I have a few things happening this next month or so, but will defo try and be there. Would be good to catch up with you again!
ringram said:
Though if it was me Id be upgrading the heads not repairing them..
I've considered doing a few things, but tbh now isn't a good time - had a stop-start extension/work done to the house and I'd be shot if I spent mega bucks on the car whilst it's still ongoing!Eventually I'll get the car intercooled and may even go down the forged route too, but it won't be yet. I'm not so interested in getting more power as just making the power that's there safer.
ringram said:
We were speculating anyway mate. Could be something totally different like a cracked valve seat.
Oh absolutely, but the speculation sounds pretty plausible to me so I'm interested in finding out possible causes and therefore (hopefully) stopping something similar happening again.. simple problem or not it's still not exactly a small bill, so it's worth having that think about! 
ringram said:
Yeah I wish my bust lifter was a simple £30 replacement..

However, even though it's simple, this still isn't going to be a small bill - probably around £1,600 ish I think and that's before they've fit my two new tyres!
Ever noticed though how it always feels like money well spent when it's your pride and joy? When my central heating boiler broke I was pissed at spending a couple of grand on a new one, but when it's the car it seems worth it somehow

ringram said:
Over rev can do that. Or a missed shift 3rd instead of 5th etc.
Probably new valve and a recut seat. Maybe even a repaired guide who knows.
Anyway lucky it wasnt major. Though if it was me Id be upgrading the heads not repairing them..
Probably new valve and a recut seat. Maybe even a repaired guide who knows.
Anyway lucky it wasnt major. Though if it was me Id be upgrading the heads not repairing them..
Could a bent valve be the result of really bad detonation or knock? Especially with an un-intercooler FI setup? I know the factory pistons are the weakness normally, but is a valve a plausable casualty?
Edited by Tiger_kpt on Monday 17th May 15:57
Tiger_kpt said:
ringram said:
Over rev can do that. Or a missed shift 3rd instead of 5th etc.
Probably new valve and a recut seat. Maybe even a repaired guide who knows.
Anyway lucky it wasnt major. Though if it was me Id be upgrading the heads not repairing them..
Probably new valve and a recut seat. Maybe even a repaired guide who knows.
Anyway lucky it wasnt major. Though if it was me Id be upgrading the heads not repairing them..
Could a bent valve be the result of really bad detonation or knock? Especially with an un-intercooler FI setup? I know the factory pistons are the weakness normally, but is a valve a plausable casualty?
Edited by Tiger_kpt on Monday 17th May 15:57
This engine has no signs of det. Its immaculate inside. Pulled the piston out just to be sure.
Havn't stripped the head yet, but its leaking past the valve seat.
Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



