Alternator belt problem or my driving style?
Alternator belt problem or my driving style?
Author
Discussion

rocklandboy

Original Poster:

831 posts

225 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
Anybody here had this problem before? I got stuck in a series of monumental traffic jams on the M25 last night which cost me an extra 3 hours on my journey time. However, after clearing the poxy M25 i decided it was time to drive the car like i had stolen it, good idea at the time you might think??? About 40 miles up the next motorway the car suddenly sprung a strange noise from the end, which lasted just under a mile or so then stopped - problem gone, noise forgotten, lets drive it like i just did a bank job this time...

When cleaning the car today i lifted the bonnet to wipe down inside the bonnet shuts and noticed a piece of black belt wrapped around a jubilee clip (strange i thought, was this something i had picked up off the motorway yesterday?) as i did i looked up at the sound proofing under the bonnet and noticed that it looked like a cat of 9 tails had been at it... At this point i investigated further to notice that 5mm or so of the alternator belt had stripped clean of the edge of the belt...

Anybody ever had this happen before or was it self destruct because of the hammering the car was getting? Its just been fully serviced so i can't imagine that it passed through without any wear not being noticed and to be honest the remaining part of the belt still looks to be in good order, no cracks, nothing... confused

Wolfracer

2,074 posts

237 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
Just bad luck i reckon, if it was going, it would have gone soon anyway, regardless of driving style. Never heard of this before though....

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
unusual!
check ya altenator is bolted up nice n tight and that the pulleys are in line etc
they shouldnt be out of line, probably a bad belt

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
If its a vxr8 its a known problem. There is a GM Technote I think.

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
If its a vxr8 its a known problem. There is a GM Technote I think.
Its a 6ltr VXR Monaro

badboyburt

2,043 posts

208 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
If its a vxr8 its a known problem. There is a GM Technote I think.


Hi Ringram, what does the Tech note say regarding belts ?

Got a whine on the pulleys at the front of the block need to get it in.

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
rocklandboy said:
Anybody here had this problem before? I got stuck in a series of monumental traffic jams on the M25 last night which cost me an extra 3 hours on my journey time. However, after clearing the poxy M25 i decided it was time to drive the car like i had stolen it, good idea at the time you might think??? About 40 miles up the next motorway the car suddenly sprung a strange noise from the end, which lasted just under a mile or so then stopped - problem gone, noise forgotten, lets drive it like i just did a bank job this time...

When cleaning the car today i lifted the bonnet to wipe down inside the bonnet shuts and noticed a piece of black belt wrapped around a jubilee clip (strange i thought, was this something i had picked up off the motorway yesterday?) as i did i looked up at the sound proofing under the bonnet and noticed that it looked like a cat of 9 tails had been at it... At this point i investigated further to notice that 5mm or so of the alternator belt had stripped clean of the edge of the belt...

Anybody ever had this happen before or was it self destruct because of the hammering the car was getting? Its just been fully serviced so i can't imagine that it passed through without any wear not being noticed and to be honest the remaining part of the belt still looks to be in good order, no cracks, nothing... confused
Does the rest of the belt that is left on the pullys look worn, ie can you see the number of the belt on the face?

Sounds like you have got a brittle belt that decised to delaminate and shred, very easy to change and MF supply them quite cheaply :-)

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
If you have not got it sorted by the time you come down for 10am bbq get the belt and I change it for you while you eat ya burger :-)

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Sunday 30th May 2010
quotequote all
snowwolf said:
If you have not got it sorted by the time you come down for 10am bbq get the belt and I change it for you while you eat ya burger :-)
clap

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Sunday 30th May 2010
quotequote all
Seen this many times on all cars its just one of them things that happens sometimes i would carefully check anything that the belt could have caught while it was whipping around though as they can do all sorts of damage!

stevemj

919 posts

227 months

Sunday 30th May 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
If its a vxr8 its a known problem. There is a GM Technote I think.


I must have missed this - has there been postings about this? So far I've seen no problem on mine, but then would I until some problem occurs?

Steve

rocklandboy

Original Poster:

831 posts

225 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
Is this the alternator belt tensioner? If so how much effort should it take to move it? I don't want to be breaking anything through brute force and stupidity...



stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
why would you not stop and check as soon as you heard a strange noise instead choosing to cary on at full tilt?

rocklandboy

Original Poster:

831 posts

225 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
So back to the original question folks, are there any clues as to whether this is the tensioner or not and are there any tips on how to slacken it without breaking something if this is the tensioner? And with respect, i'm not looking to be questioned of "why didn't i pull over?" or "why did i keep on driving?" as i find this totally irelevant to the original post and all i'm looking for is an answer to my question... biggrin

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
rocklandboy said:
So back to the original question folks, are there any clues as to whether this is the tensioner or not and are there any tips on how to slacken it without breaking something if this is the tensioner? And with respect, i'm not looking to be questioned of "why didn't i pull over?" or "why did i keep on driving?" as i find this totally irelevant to the original post and all i'm looking for is an answer to my question... biggrin
well it sort of is part of the "is it the way i drive" question isnt it as if you have no mechanical sympathy to pull over when you hear a foreign noise for over a mile then it kind of leads to the impression you dont treat engines particularly kindly

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
I agree that if there was a noise, then I'd stop, but in fairness, Stig, the OP didn't rag it again until after the strange noise had disappeared. Talking about the history doesn't help fix the problem.

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
ARAF said:
I agree that if there was a noise, then I'd stop, but in fairness, Stig, the OP didn't rag it again until after the strange noise had disappeared. Talking about the history doesn't help fix the problem.
sure it doesnt but the question was "belt problem or driving style", I think the answer is a bit of both. I've never ever after hearing a noise driven like I stole it after it had gone. To labour the point whilst in France last year in teh s2000 a noise appeared the day before we left. I drove it home like miss daisy and immediately replaced the tyres as I had diagnosed the noise to be related to them. Noise then gone. Now a belt makes a totally different noise and having seen the damage that can be done by a belt I'd have immediately stopped and the issue would have been instantly apparant.

Yes no point talking about the history unless, as in this case, it is directly related to part of the question

tinker-27

835 posts

255 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
this is not uncommon if you rev the car hard,we fit a manual tensioner whch cures the belt walking about on the pulley,

rocklandboy

Original Poster:

831 posts

225 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Not that that I feel I should be explaining my actions to a simple question but to confirm. I did stop when it was safe to do so and as I was a motorway i waited until the next service station where i looked under the car as the noise sounded more like debris that I had possibly picked up off the motorway and did not sound mechanical. However, at that point of the journey it was in “limp mode” as I was more concerned it may have been something in a tyre blar blar blar. If the noise or feel of the car had of changed or the noise sounded more serious then yes I would have pulled onto the hard shoulder, this isn’t the 1st car that I have owned nor have I only just started driving , so I’m im not entirely green and would treat events accordingly… My explanation of my “driving style” and journey in general (i.e sat in traffic for hours prior to the noise) was simply a build up to the event and was it a combination of things that lead the damaged belt??? I didn’t see the need to put a full list of events during the period of the noise as I also had a Malboro light, 1 x polo mint, swig of water and also changed the radio station but would that have been useful to my question???

Thanks to the majority that have given constructive advice to my question…. thumbup


Edited by rocklandboy on Tuesday 1st June 12:16

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Tuesday 1st June 2010
quotequote all
Its always best to change the belt when you get a car, atleast you have a new belt fitted and the old one goes in the boot just in case things happen like this.