My knob snapped!
Discussion
the_ferret82 said:
how did you snap it???I have to say, it was rather a surprise when it happened. At first I thought the box had broken or the linkage had come apart, so I guess it could have been a lot worse.
moosepig said:
the_ferret82 said:
how did you snap it???I have to say, it was rather a surprise when it happened. At first I thought the box had broken or the linkage had come apart, so I guess it could have been a lot worse.
granada203028 said:
Could you post some close ups of the broken pieces please. What has actually snapped? I'm interested to know what makes them buzz. Thanks.
The metal shaft of the gear knob has simply snapped in two. There are signs that it was cracked before it went. I'm no metallurgist but the texture of the metal is not the same right the way across the break. I'll see if I can get some close-ups.Here's the bit of the knob that broke off:

Here's a view of the metal shaft that's encased in hard plastic - there's something fishy about that break, it's not uniform:

Close-up of the break. It looks as though the metal part of the shaft was almost cracked in two long before it broke - note how it's only the narrow darker strip in the middle that looks like a metal fracture, the rest of it looks worn smooth:


Here's a view of the metal shaft that's encased in hard plastic - there's something fishy about that break, it's not uniform:

Close-up of the break. It looks as though the metal part of the shaft was almost cracked in two long before it broke - note how it's only the narrow darker strip in the middle that looks like a metal fracture, the rest of it looks worn smooth:

Edited by moosepig on Tuesday 15th June 23:48
the_ferret82 said:
was lucky it was not worse. think this has to be a first though.
ooooo....common on the 2003 onwards cars! Only at the drags mind you!!!
I did have a large post for here but will have to try again as my keyboard is playing up.
Bit amazing how much messing around I went through to replace mine.
Back soon....needless to say it looks like motomk spares dept has a spare one that I don't need...I have 2 Autos now. Drop me your address MoosePig and it is yours. Take a few days to get there as I do live in upsidedown-world.
motomk
One of my hired guns that drove my car at the drags broke the gearknob on my car.
I too had to drive home with just the bottom part of the gear lever.
After that I did have an item similar to a RIP shift put in my car.
I would recommend getting a RIP shifter if it was my car.
The older cars VT/VX have a different lever in them to the newer cars. (my car was similar to the UK Monaro in Vintage) but I did have a 2001 VX II SS Commodore to compare it too.
On the newer cars the gear lever shrunk to a metal tab (2mm x 8mm) surrounded by rubber. If you look in the bottom of the lever the metal tab is there surrounded by rubber or similar. The ident at the top of the gear lever is also offset about 30 degrees.
On a VT/VX lever it is perpendicular at the top. It also is a lot stronger by default as the gear lever rod goes through the rubber at the bottom as a rod....ie it is an 8mm diameter rod when viewed from the bottom not a 2mm x 8mm tab.
It is my understanding they reduced the metal to the 2x8mm tab so they could increase the rubber around the gear lever to reduce vibration?? or noise?
Unfortunately it is not easy to swap them over...sorry it is easy just you have to get your head around whether your gear lever has the 30 degree offset or not which it does in your case.
My car was given the earlier mechanism underneath so it all lined up perpendicular.
www.ripshift.com/rip_holden.html
You will find there is difference when you order a VT/VX STREET RIPshift as opposed to a VY/VZ(UK Monaro) STREET RIPshift. This is to combat the 30 degree turned ident at the top of the lever. On their RACE shifters it doesn't matter as the whole mechanism is replaced.
Keeping up? or lost in the gibberish!
I too had to drive home with just the bottom part of the gear lever.
After that I did have an item similar to a RIP shift put in my car.
I would recommend getting a RIP shifter if it was my car.
The older cars VT/VX have a different lever in them to the newer cars. (my car was similar to the UK Monaro in Vintage) but I did have a 2001 VX II SS Commodore to compare it too.
On the newer cars the gear lever shrunk to a metal tab (2mm x 8mm) surrounded by rubber. If you look in the bottom of the lever the metal tab is there surrounded by rubber or similar. The ident at the top of the gear lever is also offset about 30 degrees.
On a VT/VX lever it is perpendicular at the top. It also is a lot stronger by default as the gear lever rod goes through the rubber at the bottom as a rod....ie it is an 8mm diameter rod when viewed from the bottom not a 2mm x 8mm tab.
It is my understanding they reduced the metal to the 2x8mm tab so they could increase the rubber around the gear lever to reduce vibration?? or noise?
Unfortunately it is not easy to swap them over...sorry it is easy just you have to get your head around whether your gear lever has the 30 degree offset or not which it does in your case.
My car was given the earlier mechanism underneath so it all lined up perpendicular.
www.ripshift.com/rip_holden.html
You will find there is difference when you order a VT/VX STREET RIPshift as opposed to a VY/VZ(UK Monaro) STREET RIPshift. This is to combat the 30 degree turned ident at the top of the lever. On their RACE shifters it doesn't matter as the whole mechanism is replaced.
Keeping up? or lost in the gibberish!
continuing!
You will have to put the metal rod on the gearknob in a vice and then pull upwards to remove the gearknob from the broken shaft. DO NOT TWIST IT even if you are tempted. Try not to pull it upwards and hit yourself in the head though!
The bottom section will involve some trim removal. There is a screw under the stereo where you have put the broken gearknob. Undo that. Then pull upwards on the gearlever surround starting from near the small compartment between the seats. The surround clips on. You will have to disconnect the electric window switch and Traction control switch if you have it, Plugs on the back of the switches. Once the surround is removed the gear lever surround leather lifts out(held on by little clips) Then you can see the workings underneath. The broken bottom part of your lever will be held on my two bolts. Undo them and voila! ready for replacement well sort of, if you are only going to replace the top part.
If you are going down the RIP shift route then visit a specialist as it involves a bit more work. It can be done in the car if you have some fancy tools but are normally put on with the gearbox lowered a little to get at the bolts on top of the gearbox.
Mr Holmart is selling new gearlevers still for about $70 if you don't want the one I have. Incidentally the one I have is only the metal rod, not the gearknob and leather so will involve a little work to attach your leather and gearknob too. (not too difficult)
http://holmart.com.au/online/prod653.
motomk
You will have to put the metal rod on the gearknob in a vice and then pull upwards to remove the gearknob from the broken shaft. DO NOT TWIST IT even if you are tempted. Try not to pull it upwards and hit yourself in the head though!
The bottom section will involve some trim removal. There is a screw under the stereo where you have put the broken gearknob. Undo that. Then pull upwards on the gearlever surround starting from near the small compartment between the seats. The surround clips on. You will have to disconnect the electric window switch and Traction control switch if you have it, Plugs on the back of the switches. Once the surround is removed the gear lever surround leather lifts out(held on by little clips) Then you can see the workings underneath. The broken bottom part of your lever will be held on my two bolts. Undo them and voila! ready for replacement well sort of, if you are only going to replace the top part.
If you are going down the RIP shift route then visit a specialist as it involves a bit more work. It can be done in the car if you have some fancy tools but are normally put on with the gearbox lowered a little to get at the bolts on top of the gearbox.
Mr Holmart is selling new gearlevers still for about $70 if you don't want the one I have. Incidentally the one I have is only the metal rod, not the gearknob and leather so will involve a little work to attach your leather and gearknob too. (not too difficult)
http://holmart.com.au/online/prod653.
motomk
motomk said:
continuing!
You will have to put the metal rod on the gearknob in a vice and then pull upwards to remove the gearknob from the broken shaft. DO NOT TWIST IT even if you are tempted. Try not to pull it upwards and hit yourself in the head though!
The bottom section will involve some trim removal. There is a screw under the stereo where you have put the broken gearknob. Undo that. Then pull upwards on the gearlever surround starting from near the small compartment between the seats. The surround clips on. You will have to disconnect the electric window switch and Traction control switch if you have it, Plugs on the back of the switches. Once the surround is removed the gear lever surround leather lifts out(held on by little clips) Then you can see the workings underneath. The broken bottom part of your lever will be held on my two bolts. Undo them and voila! ready for replacement well sort of, if you are only going to replace the top part.
If you are going down the RIP shift route then visit a specialist as it involves a bit more work. It can be done in the car if you have some fancy tools but are normally put on with the gearbox lowered a little to get at the bolts on top of the gearbox.
Mr Holmart is selling new gearlevers still for about $70 if you don't want the one I have. Incidentally the one I have is only the metal rod, not the gearknob and leather so will involve a little work to attach your leather and gearknob too. (not too difficult)
http://holmart.com.au/online/prod653.htm
motomk
Effin' ace desription, fancy writing a manual for the VE GTS?You will have to put the metal rod on the gearknob in a vice and then pull upwards to remove the gearknob from the broken shaft. DO NOT TWIST IT even if you are tempted. Try not to pull it upwards and hit yourself in the head though!
The bottom section will involve some trim removal. There is a screw under the stereo where you have put the broken gearknob. Undo that. Then pull upwards on the gearlever surround starting from near the small compartment between the seats. The surround clips on. You will have to disconnect the electric window switch and Traction control switch if you have it, Plugs on the back of the switches. Once the surround is removed the gear lever surround leather lifts out(held on by little clips) Then you can see the workings underneath. The broken bottom part of your lever will be held on my two bolts. Undo them and voila! ready for replacement well sort of, if you are only going to replace the top part.
If you are going down the RIP shift route then visit a specialist as it involves a bit more work. It can be done in the car if you have some fancy tools but are normally put on with the gearbox lowered a little to get at the bolts on top of the gearbox.
Mr Holmart is selling new gearlevers still for about $70 if you don't want the one I have. Incidentally the one I have is only the metal rod, not the gearknob and leather so will involve a little work to attach your leather and gearknob too. (not too difficult)
http://holmart.com.au/online/prod653.htm
motomk
Hi Moosepig,
I have an almost brand new CV8 gearknob with 3rd party metal shaft (from Aus, makes it same height of the VXR) but also have the original shaft - only done about 100 miles on it as was an expensive experiment !! Its easy enough to put the original shaft back on. I could send it to you but postage may be a bit. Would probably accept £35 ish plus postage.
Only other bit left of the Monaro except for some Vauxhall VZ CV8 wheel centres !!
Cheers
Steven
I have an almost brand new CV8 gearknob with 3rd party metal shaft (from Aus, makes it same height of the VXR) but also have the original shaft - only done about 100 miles on it as was an expensive experiment !! Its easy enough to put the original shaft back on. I could send it to you but postage may be a bit. Would probably accept £35 ish plus postage.
Only other bit left of the Monaro except for some Vauxhall VZ CV8 wheel centres !!
Cheers
Steven
Edited by swordfishcoupe on Thursday 17th June 21:43
Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff








