Overheating issues
Author
Discussion

Mr Red Barron

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
Hey guys,

With the warm weather now here, i've recently noticed that the car is overheating much more regularly. I've checked the cooling level and it seems fine (although the dipstick isn't the easiest to read). Every time the fan kicks in the temprature gauge fluctautes wildly which makes me think a sensor may be dodgy somewhere? Also, after a long drive a few weeks ago parking the car up i saw some fluid leaking from the engine bay......definetley water. Is there an overflow pipe somewhere on the right of the engine bay as you look at teh front of the car?

I'm hoping to sell the car soon and the 'Ro is starting doing this now.....maybe it's putting up a fight and trying to tell me not to get rid of it?

Can i just go to any garage and get a coolant top up or does it need to be a specialist (the Monk)?

Any help would be greatly appreciated

the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
yes there is a over flow pipe in the area your saying. but if its getting that hot to make it over flow i would deffently say a sensor has gone. but as for which one i dont know..

you could phone monkfish and see what they say...

i would take it as a omen to keep the car, its a good excuse to the misses hehe

L2VXR

1,014 posts

244 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
There was a thread recently on here with simalar issues suggested start points where;

Ignor the dipstick its usless check the coolant by removing the radiator cap under the lid of the plastic cover (when cold !!)

radiator caps have been reported to be faulty allowing coolant to escape via the expantion tank and generally cocking up the efficiency

Mr Red Barron

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
So is it a case of having a look and if the coolant is too low, replace it myself? Or does it need to go into a shop?

the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
Mr Red Barron said:
So is it a case of having a look and if the coolant is too low, replace it myself? Or does it need to go into a shop?
if its low in the rad cap just top it up and keep and eye on it. no need for a shop... unless your like 007 hehe

Tiger_kpt

708 posts

212 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
Yes, the recent post was mine. Have a search for it and read it. First thing you should do is ignore the dipstick reading and take a look at the level inside the radiator itself. Remove the plastic air dam cover and then the radiator pressure cap on the radiator fill neck.

After experiencing similar problems to what you have described, when I first checked, my level in the radiator was around half full (half empty). It should be full (around an inch from the top of the neck) and the radiator should hold this level and not drop off at all.

Mine ended up being two faults. The overflow pipe on the radiator fill neck (expansion return from the radiator back to the header tank) had worked its' way loose and was spewing coolant out when up to temperature. With the plastic air dam cover in place, you cannot see this. Hence, the dramatic loss of coolant, which thankfully I caught in time. This hose is push fitted onto the port on the radiator, from factory - not good. After time (with heat) the rubber hose becomes hard and loose. I ended up having to clamp mine up with a jubilee clip for it to stay on the port, as it kept working itself loose.

With the above fixed, problems were lessened - the coolant loss was not as dramatic, however it was still occuring slightly. I tried replacing the radiator pressure cap with a new one and this didn't help. The problem actually turned out to be a split radiator. The radiators on these cars are of a flawed design and when the fibrous plastic end caps split, they either go one of two ways, split completely, ditching all coolant at once. Or develope a hair line crack that oozes coolant when up to temperature only. Mine was the latter. It is currently in the workshop, having a new OEM radiator fitted to it.

With these cars being 5 years old now. I suspect we will see alot more of these radiators go down the same path in the near future - so keep an eye on them everyone!

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Thursday 24th June 12:12

Mr Red Barron

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
Excellent, thanks for the advice. I'll have a look when I get home from work. Final question then, what do I need to top it up with? Just water?

the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
Mr Red Barron said:
Excellent, thanks for the advice. I'll have a look when I get home from work. Final question then, what do I need to top it up with? Just water?
depepnds on how empty it is.. my view if its just a little bit down then water is ok. but if its a lot then it will need topping up with coolant / water. not sure which one though as mine has been ok so far.

Tiger_kpt

708 posts

212 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
It doesn't have to be the genuine GM coolant. If it is down a little, use de-ionised water to top it back up, try not to use mains water, but don't get too hung up on it if you have to. Failing that, and you find that the level is down a great deal, then go and buy any concentrate or pre-mixed coolant that is red, orange, pink, etc - they are all OAT coolants - like the genuine GM stuff. Just do not top up with the green or blue variety of coolants - they are all non-OAT coolants. You shouldn't mix OAT coolants with non-OAT coolants - a big no no.

From what you've described, I wouldn't be suprised if you find your radiator at least half empty. I needed around 5 litres to fill mine back up initially I think. It may be best to go and buy some anyway - it's always handy stuff to have at hand!

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Thursday 24th June 12:28

Mr Red Barron

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

239 months

Thursday 24th June 2010
quotequote all
Excellent, thanks guys. Hopefully it's not a cracked radiator like Tiger experienced and just a simple fix. Seriously though, how crap is the coolant dipstick? I know when they came out of the factory they skimped on brakes, exhaust etc.....but how much money did that horrible yellow plastic thing save them? hehe

Mr Red Barron

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

239 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
Right, update.

Yesterday I removed the plastic radiator cover and had a look inside the resevoir. Sure enough, it was nearly half empty. Couldn't see any resedue of leaks anywhere so bought some halfrauds OET coolant and topped it up (bout 2 and a bit litres). Took it for a quick blast and no overheating issues or warning beeps at all. Pulled up, had a look under the bonnet and couldn't see anything leaking at all. I get to the car this morning and notice the level has gone down again, not by much, but noticable. I topped it back up again and ran the car for a couple of mins. After I switched it off, I spotted a dribble coming from the radiator pressure cap.
Now I don't know if this is from me filling it up too much or if it's the common problem that tiger was going on about. But I reckon thats where the leak is coming from. I also reckon there might be some air trapped in the system as when I filled it up the first time. There were noticable gargles and pops of air escaping as i was pouring the stuff in.

So.......do I need to get a new radiator cap from somewhere (or does anyone have one spare I could have?) or do I need to have a look at bleeding the system?

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
What year/type is your car?

Have I read somewhere that:

04 cars don't have a radiator cap, only a cap on the expansion bottle?
05 cars have a radiator cap (which can leak), and a cap on the expansion bottle?

There has also been recent talk of radiator weaknesses - does this affect 04 or 05 cars? Would like to check mine for any signs of imminent failure.

I ask because I will shortly be taking mine for a high speed blast on the Autobahn, don't want any problems in this hot weather!

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
Just checked mine (although i haven't had any overheating problems) and noticed the coolant level to be down (about 2 inch's below the rad cap)

Topped it up and it only took 3/4 litre (was expecting more), also noticed the overflow pipe had no clip on it and there had been some leakage so that was fixed as well

Will keep a eye on it and see how it goes, will also need to get some antifreeze as the only stuff i have is blue

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
Tiger_kpt said:
Yes, the recent post was mine. Have a search for it and read it. First thing you should do is ignore the dipstick reading and take a look at the level inside the radiator itself. Remove the plastic air dam cover and then the radiator pressure cap on the radiator fill neck.

After experiencing similar problems to what you have described, when I first checked, my level in the radiator was around half full (half empty). It should be full (around an inch from the top of the neck) and the radiator should hold this level and not drop off at all.

Mine ended up being two faults. The overflow pipe on the radiator fill neck (expansion return from the radiator back to the header tank) had worked its' way loose and was spewing coolant out when up to temperature. With the plastic air dam cover in place, you cannot see this. Hence, the dramatic loss of coolant, which thankfully I caught in time. This hose is push fitted onto the port on the radiator, from factory - not good. After time (with heat) the rubber hose becomes hard and loose. I ended up having to clamp mine up with a jubilee clip for it to stay on the port, as it kept working itself loose.

With the above fixed, problems were lessened - the coolant loss was not as dramatic, however it was still occuring slightly. I tried replacing the radiator pressure cap with a new one and this didn't help. The problem actually turned out to be a split radiator. The radiators on these cars are of a flawed design and when the fibrous plastic end caps split, they either go one of two ways, split completely, ditching all coolant at once. Or develope a hair line crack that oozes coolant when up to temperature only. Mine was the latter. It is currently in the workshop, having a new OEM radiator fitted to it.

With these cars being 5 years old now. I suspect we will see alot more of these radiators go down the same path in the near future - so keep an eye on them everyone!

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Thursday 24th June 12:12
www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=855740&mid=120616

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Friday 25th June 2010
quotequote all
Mr Red Barron said:
Excellent, thanks guys. Hopefully it's not a cracked radiator like Tiger experienced and just a simple fix. Seriously though, how crap is the coolant dipstick? I know when they came out of the factory they skimped on brakes, exhaust etc.....but how much money did that horrible yellow plastic thing save them? hehe
not sure if the ls2 blocks are prone to the sharp blocks cutting the coolant pipes at the back...

Tiger_kpt

708 posts

212 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Mr Red Barron said:
Right, update.

Yesterday I removed the plastic radiator cover and had a look inside the resevoir. Sure enough, it was nearly half empty. Couldn't see any resedue of leaks anywhere so bought some halfrauds OET coolant and topped it up (bout 2 and a bit litres). Took it for a quick blast and no overheating issues or warning beeps at all. Pulled up, had a look under the bonnet and couldn't see anything leaking at all. I get to the car this morning and notice the level has gone down again, not by much, but noticable. I topped it back up again and ran the car for a couple of mins. After I switched it off, I spotted a dribble coming from the radiator pressure cap.
Now I don't know if this is from me filling it up too much or if it's the common problem that tiger was going on about. But I reckon thats where the leak is coming from. I also reckon there might be some air trapped in the system as when I filled it up the first time. There were noticable gargles and pops of air escaping as i was pouring the stuff in.

So.......do I need to get a new radiator cap from somewhere (or does anyone have one spare I could have?) or do I need to have a look at bleeding the system?


Don't worry about air in the system, mine did exactly the same thing. The coolant systems on these vehicles self bleed and hold their own level anyway. I would keep an eye on the fluid level and top up before each and every journey. It is worth a shot by fitting a new radiator pressure cap (£10inc delivery) to see if that solves the issue of the persistant leaking. Monkfish keep stock of the radiator pressure caps and the delivery was very quick.

Make sure that you also check that the two hoses on the radiator filler neck are secure and although they are not clamped up at factory, get a couple of jubilee clamps on them for peace of mind - factory should have thought about that for sure! To be honest, it all sounds too familiar and I think that the cap will not make much difference - and you do have a leaking radiator. It's worth a shot though. I just went for a replacement OEM radiator, circa £280 plus fitting, etc. The leaks are not obvious on these radiators and can be easily missed, trust me on that. To check if yours is leaking, whilst the vehicle is switched off and right up to temperature, slide your hand down the driver side and passenger side of the radiator plastic end caps and you will more than likely get a wet hand!

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Well, to answer my own question, I can confirm that 04 cars do not have a radiator cap!

My temp guage has always sat between 1/3 and 1/2 temp, never seems to move even when stuck in traffic. It's never lost any coolant, but I took the top shroud off mine today to have a good look at the radiator and all the pipework. No signs of any leakage around the radiator end caps or pipework. 04 car radiators seem to have two big pipes going in and out of the engine via the water pump. The expansion bottle has two small pipes, one goes into the engine block, the other seem to route down to the bottom of the engine bay somwehere, couldn't see where it ends up.

Only thing I did find was a lot of dead flies and leaves stuck between the air con rad and the engine rad, mainly at the top. Managed to clean most of it out using a tooth brush attached to length of coat hanger wire.

Mr Red Barron

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

239 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Once again, thanks for all the help guys. I've been checking it the past few days and topping up every now and again to see if it properly settles down which it now seems to be doing. The overflow pipe trickles out every now and again after a drive but nothing too major so I don't suspect a cracked radiator. I'm gonna keep an eye on the levels and maybe purchase a new cap to see if it makes a difference. Seems silly not to for a tenner really.

It's all this kind of help that'll make me miss this forum when and if the car sells. Never been a part of a community thats been so helpfull.

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
When I checked mine it was low in the rad, about 3/4 litre, topped it up, that was about three weeks ago, have checked it a few times and all if fine.

THUNDER STORM

1,261 posts

200 months

Monday 28th June 2010
quotequote all
To All, If you are having water level low in radiator then please fit a new rad cap, not expensive
and I should say it will solve 99% of issues.

It is a known problem,solved mine.

Adebyebye