Tuscan to Saggy - should I ?
Tuscan to Saggy - should I ?
Author
Discussion

TuscNick

Original Poster:

817 posts

267 months

Wednesday 19th March 2008
quotequote all
Now I know that it will fit in my garage, the next question is should I make the leap Tuscan to Saggy.

I have a most excellent last of the MK1 Tuscans, in Titanium 54 plate and in mint condition (having taken 6 months to find it) It drives like a dream, no probs.

Obvioulsy it will cost to move to a Saggy, just wondered if those who have made the move think the difference is worth it ? and is the any thing to whatch out for on saggies when buying

Cheers

nickbiggrin


seymourski

304 posts

265 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
I moved from a 54 plate MKII S to a Sag last August.

I loved the Tuscan which I bought and spec'ed from new. However the Sag is just so unbelievable - it's looks will always get attention (especially in Arancio Orange!) and the drive just feels so much more assured.

I have absolutely no regrets and can't help smiling every time I open the garage door.

TuscNick

Original Poster:

817 posts

267 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
seymourski said:
I moved from a 54 plate MKII S to a Sag last August.

I loved the Tuscan which I bought and spec'ed from new. However the Sag is just so unbelievable - it's looks will always get attention (especially in Arancio Orange!) and the drive just feels so much more assured.

I have absolutely no regrets and can't help smiling every time I open the garage door.
Getting more and more tempted

The wife is really not keen on me having Orange or any loud colour !! However I quite like the idea, orange , yellow, flip, reds blacks, green - in fact I like them all !!

Nick

rpa.janwell

1,653 posts

266 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
Go with Orange, and then get some good quality road grime on it......

KillerJim

972 posts

232 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
TuscNick said:
seymourski said:
I moved from a 54 plate MKII S to a Sag last August.

I loved the Tuscan which I bought and spec'ed from new. However the Sag is just so unbelievable - it's looks will always get attention (especially in Arancio Orange!) and the drive just feels so much more assured.

I have absolutely no regrets and can't help smiling every time I open the garage door.
Getting more and more tempted

The wife is really not keen on me having Orange or any loud colour !! However I quite like the idea, orange , yellow, flip, reds blacks, green - in fact I like them all !!

Nick
Likewise my girlfriend didn`t want a loud colour and personally I didnt care for a loud colour either. My brilliant silver sag stands out a mile anyway without having it painted a colour that screams 'look at meeee!!11' biggrin

J

S5TVR

1,239 posts

262 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
Only driven a Tuscan once (S Spec) and never driven a Sag, but given the prices of Sag's compared to T350's, personaly I'd go down the T350 red rose route (they're rare but definately out there for sale). I don't believe the performance differnce between a Sag and T350 RR is such that it warrants the £10-£15k premium in price for the Sag of the same age and to be fair the T350 is a better looking car than the Sag - beauty I know is in the eye of the beholder, but for my liking the Sag is just too fussy in its design - all IMHO.

TGJR

750 posts

257 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
S5TVR said:
Only driven a Tuscan once (S Spec) and never driven a Sag, but given the prices of Sag's compared to T350's, personaly I'd go down the T350 red rose route (they're rare but definately out there for sale). I don't believe the performance differnce between a Sag and T350 RR is such that it warrants the £10-£15k premium in price for the Sag of the same age and to be fair the T350 is a better looking car than the Sag - beauty I know is in the eye of the beholder, but for my liking the Sag is just too fussy in its design - all IMHO.
I would have to agree in all honesty that the T350 has prettier lines than a Sag, however, the extra width of the rear track on the Sag gives it a more meaty stance. I also love the bulge on the drivers side of the roof smile

puckrup

473 posts

229 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
I moved from a Mk1 Tuscan RR to a Sag. No regrets whatsoever - the Tuscan was 'nervous' to say the least, even with Gaz Gold upgrade. Definite possibility that I would have ended up doing some serious damage to myself and the car.

The Sag on the other hand is far more sure footed and composed (also more compact than the Tusc) It handles beautifully and sounds fantastic. The Tusc actually felt a faster car until I changed the diff on the Sag to 3.73 smile

N

mr sagoo

1,735 posts

265 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
Never driven a tuscan but Having come from a griff to a sag, the most noticeable thing for me is the ability to be able push on hard in the sag even in the wet,It always feels extremely composed, recently had a ride drive day on a very wet day and was amazed how hard the instructor had me pushing the car without any brown trouser moments whatsoever,I really believe a properly set up sag is one of the best handling cars out there.

c1dvb

103 posts

245 months

Thursday 20th March 2008
quotequote all
had a tusc s mk2 06 plate, loved every bit of it till i thought i'd just try a sag, once driven the tusc did'nt compare, from looks to handling to the whole feel of it. the tusc always felt slightly twichy to me and the sag is just so planted, even when she does let go its so managable, lovely slides. sag all the way.

The Pits

4,290 posts

269 months

Friday 21st March 2008
quotequote all
I actually went the other way and now have a mk2 tuscan. My main reason was wanting a convertible. A bonnet that didn't wobble at high speed was another and better ground clearance but that was about it. Other than that I'd have put up with those things if only TVR had cut out the slashes in the bodywork. I couldn't quite get over having them filled in (I ordered my car based on the prototype - the best looking car I had ever seen). So the Tuscan kept most of the stuff I loved about the Sag but gave me a convertible version that I didn't want to modify.

I will confirm though that the Sagaris handling is superb. I remember having a ball on a soaking wet nurburgring, whereas my brother frightened himself trying to keep up in his 996 porker turbo (that 4wd remember!). Luckily for me the later tuscans benefitted from the Sagaris suspension development, getting 255 tyres front and rear and the bilstein shocks etc. they lacked was the wide track so and the extra lowness but they are less nervous. As a result I have no regrets about the swap. I just wished Tuscan prices were as firm as Sag ones at the moment!

Gaffer

7,156 posts

306 months

Friday 21st March 2008
quotequote all
The Pits said:
Other than that I'd have put up with those things if only TVR had cut out the slashes in the bodywork. I couldn't quite get over having them filled in (I ordered my car based on the prototype - the best looking car I had ever seen).
winkyes

Agree with the handling, xept I have a chim as well as the Sag....driven umpteen tuscans and can confirm that the Sag isnt as nervous. Feels so planted, roundabouts are fun smile

Best thing (as with all TVRs) is to go and try one, they are not for everyone as the Pits has confirmed.

Claire

CDD

137 posts

279 months

Friday 21st March 2008
quotequote all
Another thing to consider is that the Sagaris is holding its value really well. If anything they are going up in value.

bobd

973 posts

249 months

Wednesday 26th March 2008
quotequote all
S5TVR said:
Only driven a Tuscan once (S Spec) and never driven a Sag, but given the prices of Sag's compared to T350's, personaly I'd go down the T350 red rose route (they're rare but definately out there for sale). I don't believe the performance differnce between a Sag and T350 RR is such that it warrants the £10-£15k premium in price for the Sag of the same age and to be fair the T350 is a better looking car than the Sag - beauty I know is in the eye of the beholder, but for my liking the Sag is just too fussy in its design - all IMHO.
IMHO not qualified to comment then!
Opinions are fine, but if you have not driven a Sag and only driven a Tuscan once then im afraid you have no idea bar an indicative price reason.
By the way the 350 looks nice.

Edited by bobd on Wednesday 26th March 03:25