Tyres?
Author
Discussion

T40ORA

Original Poster:

5,177 posts

248 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Before someone says 'search on it', I've tried several times but either my laptop is fooked or the search facility isn't doing what it should!

Simple question; Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetrics vs Toyo R1Rs? New tyre time (probably sticking with standard sizes) and just looking at the most appropriate brands. I've had the Toyos suggested but as I've always liked the old F1s I wondered if there is any first hand experience of the new ones on here.

slowtypa

86 posts

260 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Lee,

We have been using F1 asymmetrics on our Sag for some time.(2nd set on rear ). Not bad in the wet, don't overheat

too easily on track days.

I would recommend them.


Ray

T40ORA

Original Poster:

5,177 posts

248 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Thanks Ray.

T350 Al

624 posts

220 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Just recently had Asymmetrics fitted to the front, with GSD3s on the rear. Got to say that, although they're not properly worn in yet I quite like them. Yet to test them in the wet but other than that they're looking good so far.

I had considered the R1Rs but couldn't find any locally so ended up with the Eagles.

Mattt

16,664 posts

247 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
The GSDs are quite old tech now though aren't they? I've heard good things about the toyos but not on tvrs.

Druid

1,312 posts

210 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Got Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetrics fitted 3 weeks ago on all corners, very happy, grip from new is excellent.

Dowks

449 posts

275 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Got Goodyear asymetrics on my Sag and so far have been excellent, tried to get T1R's but couldn't find anywhere.....

T40ORA

Original Poster:

5,177 posts

248 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
The R1Rs seem to have been well recommended but I'm starting to feel good about the F1s now.

TVRMARKUB

2,312 posts

208 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Druid said:
Got Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetrics fitted 3 weeks ago on all corners, very happy, grip from new is excellent.
same here and very pleased with em, though I hear good things about the Toyos which maybe better for track.

Barry Ashcroft

1,958 posts

250 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Just changed from Assy's to R1R's so far very impressed.
The F1's are a very good tyre but the R1R is not a direct comparison.
Compare the F1 to the T1R but not the R1R.

Madmatt V8

478 posts

221 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
F1s are the way to go for an all round option. If you are a fair weather only guy then look at the toyos. :-)

jon-

16,534 posts

245 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Barry Ashcroft said:
Just changed from Assy's to R1R's so far very impressed.
The F1's are a very good tyre but the R1R is not a direct comparison.
Compare the F1 to the T1R but not the R1R.
How does the R1R feel compared to the F1 Assy? I'd imagine the R1R behaves a lot more like a track tyre in that it needs some heat and will wear quick quickly in comparison?

Edited by jon- on Saturday 10th July 18:25

Barry Ashcroft

1,958 posts

250 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
Madmatt V8 said:
F1s are the way to go for an all round option. If you are a fair weather only guy then look at the toyos. :-)
Not anymore Matt
Do you know anything about the R1R?

Barry Ashcroft

1,958 posts

250 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
jon- said:
Barry Ashcroft said:
Just changed from Assy's to R1R's so far very impressed.
The F1's are a very good tyre but the R1R is not a direct comparison.
Compare the F1 to the T1R but not the R1R.
How does the R1R feel compared to the F1 Assy? I'd imagine the R1R behaves a lot more like a track tyre in that it needs some heat and will wear quick quickly in comparison?
Only done a 1000 miles so far. I have my first TD in a fortnight so will report on them after.
I read alot about them online before buying and also spoke to Alan the TOYO rep who's opinion I value.
My mate also put them on his Tam and he's an ex sprinter so knows his stuff.

I have no doubts they will wear quicker than F1's after all the wear rate is 140 compared to 260 for the f1's but not as bad as 888's which are 100

T40ORA

Original Poster:

5,177 posts

248 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
OK, so for relatively low mileage with frequent track days R1Rs. But for high mileage with less frequent track days F1s.

Or am I getting this wrong?

Barry Ashcroft

1,958 posts

250 months

Monday 5th July 2010
quotequote all
If you want.

Personally I see the R1R as the perfect tyre for the car after all it's a high performance car & I want high performance tyres. I dont see F1's as high performance tyres I'd put them on my diesel mondeo which is currenty running pilot sport2's you get the idea?

As for how long they last I rekon 2 years and any tyre has gone way past it's best and gone hard.

These apparent excellent low milage cars with origonal tyres must be like drivng around on solid tyres.


OatSy

1,550 posts

245 months

Tuesday 6th July 2010
quotequote all
T40ORA said:
OK, so for relatively low mileage with frequent track days R1Rs. But for high mileage with less frequent track days F1s.

Or am I getting this wrong?
Spot on :-)

I have had both on the Tam, R1Rs are st in the wet but great in the dry.
I have the F1s at the moment and prefer them for "overall" driving. If you are a track day nut then go for the R1Rs

T40ORA

Original Poster:

5,177 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th July 2010
quotequote all
OatSy said:
T40ORA said:
OK, so for relatively low mileage with frequent track days R1Rs. But for high mileage with less frequent track days F1s.

Or am I getting this wrong?
Spot on :-)

I have had both on the Tam, R1Rs are st in the wet but great in the dry.
I have the F1s at the moment and prefer them for "overall" driving. If you are a track day nut then go for the R1Rs
Well, TBH wouldn't most of us prefer to take these cars on the track all the time? I would biggrin but it's not practical for me time or money wise, so I do most of my fun driving on fast roads where the limitations of the road and my skills are way under that of the car - and hopefully the F1s.

So, at about 15k miles per year, I think I'll be looking at the Goodyears.

Although I am totally consistent in my inconsistency so may change at the last moment!

d18mca

314 posts

226 months

Tuesday 6th July 2010
quotequote all
Lee

Either F1's or T1R's should give good grip in all round conditions.
Davy

T40ORA

Original Poster:

5,177 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th July 2010
quotequote all
T1s on the front have worn on the shoulders, due to soft side walls apparently. So I'll try the F1s Davy.