A nice problem to have: Which Aston to purchase
A nice problem to have: Which Aston to purchase
Author
Discussion

bazzabee

Original Poster:

37 posts

183 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
I have a problem, albeit a slightly nice problem to have. I have £45-50k to spend on my first Aston and I’m completely torn on which to go for V8 vantage or a Db9. Based on what I’ve seen on Autotrader I could get a 2006 DB9 or a 2007 Vantage for this price range.

To help you opine on which is best, I thought a little info on me will be useful. I’m 28 and live in London. I have a girlfriend in Bath so am down the M4 once every 2 weeks. I probably only clock up 2-3,000 miles a year as I only ever use the car for grocery runs / clock in with the old dear in Kent.

I haven’t seen a lot of Astons with more than 40k on the clock, is there a reason for that. If I was to get a good deal on a 2007 db9 / 2008 Vantage with 30-40k on the clock, should I ensure it has had a large service first?

My girlfriend and I go for weekends away quite a lot, and she rarely travels light – so luggage space is a key requirement. Does the Vantage have enough, is the Db9 that much spacer? Does a volante / convertible trade off luggage space?

Secondly, the kudos factor. As a typical young man, I’m a tad self conscious – will I get stick for buying an ‘entry level’ Aston, if I was to go for the Vantage, will the whole ‘that’s the same as buying an entry Porsche, like a Boxter’ crop up?

Thirdly running costs, I have every intention to buy a decent warrantee, so major faults should be covered in my £1.2k fee, how much will a large service costs for these machines? Is it actually worth getting a warrantee if I was to go for a slightly older car with lower miles?

Fourthly, I live in London and have secure underground parking, but what worries me is that when I play designated driver for a mate on a night out, and am forced to park it in the street, it will be prone to the local feral youths scratching it. Are there any warrantees which cover keying damage with minimal excess?

I do appreciate this topic has been done to death, but was hoping by the fact that my questions are more targeted I can engage with you Subject Matter Experts out there.

petecowie

190 posts

258 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Hi, first excellent decision you won;t regret it, I currently have a DB7 Volante and can set your mind at rest about a few things. First luggage wise I can get more than enough in this car so if you do decide to go for a DB9 Volante you should have no problems, you do get the extra space on the +2 seats as well as space in the boot to put a suitcase or maybe 2, just buy the right cases to efficiently fit in the boot. Second I have owned a few cars from an MX5, a couple of RX7s and a Corvette and can honestly say that Aston's seem to get respect from a wider demographic and are far less prone to random acts of damage, in fact I have never had any, the nearest people get it is take a picture!

Oh and if you can extend your budget (a little), have a look here and contact Oblio
https://skydrive.live.com/?cid=02e3419b81e36183&am...

Good luck with your hunt.
Pete

michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
bazzabee said:
I have a problem, albeit a slightly nice problem to have. I have £45-50k to spend on my first Aston and I’m completely torn on which to go for V8 vantage or a Db9. Based on what I’ve seen on Autotrader I could get a 2006 DB9 or a 2007 Vantage for this price range.

To help you opine on which is best, I thought a little info on me will be useful. I’m 28 and live in London. I have a girlfriend in Bath so am down the M4 once every 2 weeks. I probably only clock up 2-3,000 miles a year as I only ever use the car for grocery runs / clock in with the old dear in Kent.

I haven’t seen a lot of Astons with more than 40k on the clock, is there a reason for that. If I was to get a good deal on a 2007 db9 / 2008 Vantage with 30-40k on the clock, should I ensure it has had a large service first?

My girlfriend and I go for weekends away quite a lot, and she rarely travels light – so luggage space is a key requirement. Does the Vantage have enough, is the Db9 that much spacer? Does a volante / convertible trade off luggage space?

Secondly, the kudos factor. As a typical young man, I’m a tad self conscious – will I get stick for buying an ‘entry level’ Aston, if I was to go for the Vantage, will the whole ‘that’s the same as buying an entry Porsche, like a Boxter’ crop up?

Thirdly running costs, I have every intention to buy a decent warrantee, so major faults should be covered in my £1.2k fee, how much will a large service costs for these machines? Is it actually worth getting a warrantee if I was to go for a slightly older car with lower miles?

Fourthly, I live in London and have secure underground parking, but what worries me is that when I play designated driver for a mate on a night out, and am forced to park it in the street, it will be prone to the local feral youths scratching it. Are there any warrantees which cover keying damage with minimal excess?

I do appreciate this topic has been done to death, but was hoping by the fact that my questions are more targeted I can engage with you Subject Matter Experts out there.
I think a Vantage would be more suitable for you:

1. its a younger mans car than the DB9
2. it has more luggage space
3. cheaper to service and run
4. the only warranty worth having is the one from Aston
5. No you wont get stick for having the smaller Aston, apart from me
6. no problem with buying higher millage Astons...but check why it has higher millage i.e its not be a hire car
7. you dont have to spend your full budget....plenty of well looked after V8V's for around 40K
8. above all.....it must have a perfect history.


Good luck.....the hunting is half the fun

Neil1300R

5,785 posts

209 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
michael gould said:
bazzabee said:
I have a problem, albeit a slightly nice problem to have. I have £45-50k to spend on my first Aston and I’m completely torn on which to go for V8 vantage or a Db9. Based on what I’ve seen on Autotrader I could get a 2006 DB9 or a 2007 Vantage for this price range.

To help you opine on which is best, I thought a little info on me will be useful. I’m 28 and live in London. I have a girlfriend in Bath so am down the M4 once every 2 weeks. I probably only clock up 2-3,000 miles a year as I only ever use the car for grocery runs / clock in with the old dear in Kent.

I haven’t seen a lot of Astons with more than 40k on the clock, is there a reason for that. If I was to get a good deal on a 2007 db9 / 2008 Vantage with 30-40k on the clock, should I ensure it has had a large service first?

My girlfriend and I go for weekends away quite a lot, and she rarely travels light – so luggage space is a key requirement. Does the Vantage have enough, is the Db9 that much spacer? Does a volante / convertible trade off luggage space?

Secondly, the kudos factor. As a typical young man, I’m a tad self conscious – will I get stick for buying an ‘entry level’ Aston, if I was to go for the Vantage, will the whole ‘that’s the same as buying an entry Porsche, like a Boxter’ crop up?

Thirdly running costs, I have every intention to buy a decent warrantee, so major faults should be covered in my £1.2k fee, how much will a large service costs for these machines? Is it actually worth getting a warrantee if I was to go for a slightly older car with lower miles?

Fourthly, I live in London and have secure underground parking, but what worries me is that when I play designated driver for a mate on a night out, and am forced to park it in the street, it will be prone to the local feral youths scratching it. Are there any warrantees which cover keying damage with minimal excess?

I do appreciate this topic has been done to death, but was hoping by the fact that my questions are more targeted I can engage with you Subject Matter Experts out there.
I think a Vantage would be more suitable for you:

1. its a younger mans car than the DB9
2. it has more luggage space
3. cheaper to service and run
4. the only warranty worth having is the one from Aston
5. No you wont get stick for having the smaller Aston, apart from me
6. no problem with buying higher millage Astons...but check why it has higher millage i.e its not be a hire car
7. you dont have to spend your full budget....plenty of well looked after V8V's for around 40K
8. above all.....it must have a perfect history.


Good luck.....the hunting is half the fun
Blimey!
never thought i would see the day - I agree totally with Mr Gould!
smile

yeti

10,704 posts

306 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
To pinch the above comments:

I think a DB9 would be more suitable for you:

1. DB9 is an old man's car if it's driven like one. Look for a sports pack manual DB9, an incredible sports GT.
2. Luggage space is similar between the two and yes I'm afraid you lose a lot with a Volante. DB7 Volante owners (I was one) didn't suffer from the roof having to fold into the car. Takes huge space but worth it for the looks. I have toured extensively, there is still plenty of space however, back seats are very useful!
4. The only warranty worth having is the one from Aston
5. You may not get stick, but you'll always know you could have had the mighty V12 for the same money. Plus the modern V8s are 4.7 and much improved. The 4.3 was the first attempt at a 911/F360 rival but the the 4.7 nailed it and that's currently out of budget. The 450bhp DB9 compared to 470bhp isn't reported to be much different. 4 extra cylinders, 1700 extra CC, 70 extra BHP and a lot more torque for negligable weight difference.
6. no problem with buying higher millage Astons...but check why it has higher millage i.e its not be a hire car
7. DB9 was £120k new, it represents incredible value for money, but the Vantage only slightly less so.
8. above all.....it must have a perfect history.


Good luck.....the hunting is half the fun smile


Edited by yeti on Wednesday 10th August 11:22

XlBilbo

65 posts

194 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
yeti said:
To pinch the above comments:

I think a DB9 would be more suitable for you:

1. DB9 is an old man's car if it's driven like one. Look for a sports pack manual DB9, an incredible sports GT.
2. Luggage space is similar between the two and yes I'm afraid you lose a lot with a Volante. DB7 Volante owners (I was one) didn't suffer from the roof having to fold into the car. Takes huge space but worth it for the looks. I have toured extensively, there is still plenty of space however, back seats are very useful!
4. The only warranty worth having is the one from Aston
5. You may not get stick, but you'll always know you could have had the mighty V12 for the same money. Plus the modern V8s are 4.7 and much improved. The 4.3 was the first attempt at a 911/F360 rival but the the 4.7 nailed it and that's currently out of budget. The 450bhp DB9 compared to 470bhp isn't reported to be much different. 4 extra cylinders, 1700 extra CC, 70 extra BHP and a lot more torque for negligable weight difference.
6. no problem with buying higher millage Astons...but check why it has higher millage i.e its not be a hire car
7. DB9 was £120k new, it represents incredible value for money, but the Vantage only slightly less so.
8. above all.....it must have a perfect history.


Good luck.....the hunting is half the fun smile


Edited by yeti on Wednesday 10th August 11:22
I agree with all of that. Volante is not for me though.

speech

387 posts

187 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Hehe, I'm hoping to have a similar problem in a few months, planning to spend £45-50k to get my 2nd Aston (moving on from DB7) and not sure yet whether to get V8V or DB9.

My thoughts:
- In my opinion DB9 is better looking, in fact, it's the best looking car ever.

- DB9 is better if you're doing mostly motorway and town driving. Vantage is better if you're bombing down winding A and B roads and going on tracks. So I think this is a factor in choosing which is better for you.

- Vantage is touted as younger person's car. Maybe something Aston has done better than Porsche is the Vantage isn't really considered a junior DB9 but a different car aimed at a different type of driver. Not sure they've been so successful at differentiating DBS or Virage from DB9. Anyway, I don't think you'd get much of the "you bought it cos you couldn't afford the DB9" and nobody has suggested I bought a DB7 cos I couldn't afford the DB9 even though they'd be right in saying so!

- The designated driver bit is tricky. One of my mates finds it hilarious that having spent all that money on a flash car I hardly drive it anywhere because I don't trust that some g*t won't vandalise it. But you're going to have the same problem whether you get Vantage, DB9 or any other flash car so I don't think this can influence your decision. On the plus side, Astons are more subtle than most of the other high end sports cars so the chances of anything happening are lower. You may want to go for one of the more common colours such as black or silver so they don't stand out too much.

- As someone has already mentioned, don't forget the extra space you get with the rear seats. They're useless for seating anyone other than young kids but great for bunging a couple of bags on, especially if you need to get anything from them during your journey.

Ultimately I think you should test drive both models and see which you feel most comfortable in and/or leaves you with the biggest smile!

Happy hunting!


oblio

5,604 posts

258 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Space wise we have just come back from 2 weeks touring the Continent. More than enough room in the car for luggage and shoe collection. The back seats are great for 'stuff' and extra stowage space.

Can't speak for the V8V but the DB9 eats the miles and is very, very comfortable for these kind of trips.

petecowie

190 posts

258 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
To me looking at the V8V is like looking at a really good looking girl whereas the DB9 gives me that tingly supermodel feeling.... Seeing both of them in the flesh meant I could only ever go for a DB9 as my next car

oblio

5,604 posts

258 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
petecowie said:
Oh and if you can extend your budget (a little), have a look here and contact Oblio
https://skydrive.live.com/?cid=02e3419b81e36183&am...
Cheers Pete thumbup

Adam2S

5,314 posts

208 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
You are 28 and have a girlfriend - the V8V is therefore definitely the car for you! If you were 78 and a widower then the DB9 would have been the better choice. wink

Seriously though, Michael's answer is spot on - he has nailed the reasons you should buy a V8V and not a DB9.

Edited by Adam2S on Wednesday 10th August 19:41

hartley

704 posts

230 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Adam2S said:
You are 28 and have a girlfriend - the V8V is therefore definitely the car for you! If you were 78 and a widower then the DB9 would have been the better choice. wink

Seriously though, Michael's answer is spot on - he has nailed the reasons you should buy a V8V and not a DB9.

Edited by Adam2S on Wednesday 10th August 19:41
Lycra or tweed is what I think he's trying to say wink

matg

284 posts

256 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
michael gould said:
I think a Vantage would be more suitable for you:

1. its a younger mans car than the DB9
2. it has more luggage space
3. cheaper to service and run
4. the only warranty worth having is the one from Aston
5. No you wont get stick for having the smaller Aston, apart from me
6. no problem with buying higher millage Astons...but check why it has higher millage i.e its not be a hire car
7. you dont have to spend your full budget....plenty of well looked after V8V's for around 40K
8. above all.....it must have a perfect history.


Good luck.....the hunting is half the fun
Just a comment on point 8. A perfect history service wise does not mean it has to be Aston dealer service. Rick @ DMS does a fantastic job, if you see his name in a service book then it HAS been well looked after.


michael gould

5,698 posts

272 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Adam2S said:
You are 28 and have a girlfriend - the V8V is therefore definitely the car for you! If you were 78 and a widower then the DB9 would have been the better choice. wink

Seriously though, Michael's answer is spot on - he has nailed the reasons you should buy a V8V and not a DB9.

Edited by Adam2S on Wednesday 10th August 19:41
And you may have noticed .....I own a DB9 ......buy the V8V

TJB69

141 posts

201 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Having moved from a 4.3 V8V to 470 DB9.

I can only add that after 2 months the DB9 is getting replaced by a 4.7 V8V.

No contest imo smile

George H

14,714 posts

195 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
Adam2S said:
You are 28 and have a girlfriend - the V8V is therefore definitely the car for you! If you were 78 and a widower then the DB9 would have been the better choice. wink
nono

Well, maybe the coupe smile

But the Volante - most certainly not! The V8V does sound the more suitable car for the OP though.

Rex Racer

340 posts

185 months

Wednesday 10th August 2011
quotequote all
V8V.

DavidV12V

150 posts

190 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
Sounds to me like the V8V is the one - although I do agree with the other comments - maybe it's the marketing machine at work, but I couldn't see me, as a 27 yr old behind the wheel of a DB9, but hey, I was driving a Ford Escort Mk III when I was 27....

As for
- luggage space, we did 2 weeks camping with everything (tent. etc.) for 2 weeks all within a V8V with no problems - in fact the space only limited the number of bottles of Spanish plonk we could bring back...
- the planned use - motorway miles, etc. - I have not driven a DB9 - but the V8V is great for eating the miles...
- trouble on the streets, I totally understand but, as other have said, the AM doesn't (in my experience) usually attract any negative issues, of any kind....but having said that, I would't leave mine on the streets of Manchester either

And yes, the hunting is half the fun, well initially anyway and then driving it knowing it's yours to look at while you're not driving it is more....

Murph7355

42,057 posts

287 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
Do a search. Been covered extensively.

Try searching for "smelling like a fusty old fart" or "be a thrusting young gentleman" if all else fails.

bazzabee

Original Poster:

37 posts

183 months

Thursday 11th August 2011
quotequote all
Wow - thanks for all the feedback. It seems the general consensus is that I should be a lycra rather than a tweed man.

Through conducting my own research it seems the Vantage boot is oodles bigger than the DB9, but the backseats, would I presume compensate for the lack of room in the boot, here's a few other stats:

DB9: 186 litres
Vantage: 300 litres
Girlfriend's SLK 350: 225

Db9 new: £125k
0-60 4.6
Max: 190mph
Combined fuel: 17.2
Cost to fill tank: £140
Range to empty: 303 miles
Length: 4710mm (15'5")

v8 4.3 vantage new: £90k
0-60: 4.7
Max: 180mph
Combined fuel: 20.4
Cost to fill tank: £140
Range to empty: 359miles
Length: 4,380 (14'4")

The Vantage is more fuel efficient, but a fraction slower both to 60 and topspeed than the DB9.

One thing which hasn't been covered in your answers is running costs:
How much is an Aston Warantee, I've got a quote from warantee-direct for £1.3k which seems to cover everything and will allow me to go to an approved Aston dealer to get any required work done. Has anyone got experience of a non-Aston warantee?
How much is a small and a large service?