V12 Engine Asthetics
V12 Engine Asthetics
Author
Discussion

Squaremeal

Original Poster:

180 posts

170 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
A bit of a niche subject.

But has anyone noticed how much difference the manifold covers make to the profile of the engine?

The early DB9 ones make the engine look a lot shorter and further back.

The DBS with the border short intake manifolds looks a lot wider.

The later DB9 / Vanquish look better again.

On the off chance has anybody swapped out to a carbon manifold cover from the later version?

I'd be interested in purchasing it!

All of which makes the latest DB11 incarnation a bit disappointing.










Edited by Squaremeal on Wednesday 18th October 09:33

silverspeed

1,508 posts

261 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Squaremeal said:
A bit of a niche subject.

But has anyone noticed how much difference the manifold covers make to the profile of the engine?

The early DB9 ones make the engine look a lot shorter and further back.

The DBS with the border short intake manifolds looks a lot wider.

The later DB9 / Vanquish look better again.

On the off chance has anybody swapped out to a carbon manifold cover from the later version?

I'd be interested in purchasing it!

All of which makes the latest DB11 incarnation a bit disappointing.










Edited by Squaremeal on Wednesday 18th October 09:33
You missed of the very recent cover which looses the wings badge and IMO is a step backwards .

Squaremeal

Original Poster:

180 posts

170 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Good spot!

Final wingless version - for completeness!


DB9VolanteDriver

2,661 posts

207 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
DBS looks the best of all the versions. It has more interesting detailing.

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
DB9VolanteDriver said:
DBS looks the best of all the versions. It has more interesting detailing.
+1. New one looks bland by comparison, shame.

quench

564 posts

177 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
You forgot to mention the disappointment that is the magnesium manifold for the V12VS power pack: a featureless blob of black. How on earth Aston thought it was a good idea to increase power but ruin the look of the engine bay is beyond me...

Squaremeal

Original Poster:

180 posts

170 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Is this the one you mean?


IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
On the AMR cars they even lose the wings badge from the central brace. Wonder if it even has the engine size?

Guess that is the same on recent cars so your picture must show it on an older car which had the old style central brace or a newer one that had managed to source one.

Squaremeal

Original Poster:

180 posts

170 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
That's disappointing. Sounds like a backward step IMHO. I bought AM where dedicated to beauty.

Edited by Squaremeal on Wednesday 18th October 17:40

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Squaremeal said:
That's disappointing. Sounds like I backward step IMHO. I bought AM where dedicated to beauty.
Agree - and can’t believe it saves them that much either given the number of cars it affects. Vanquish S, Vanquish Zagato, V12 AMR’s - can’t think of any others.

divetheworld

2,565 posts

166 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Copied from the V12S bonnet vent thread and updated.

If you're going to eat at the top table then there's no replacement for displacement as they say... wink

DB7


Vanq


Vanq - S


DB9 - 450bhp


DB9 - 470bhp


DBS/V12 Vantage


Virage


DB9.2/V12VS/Vanq


V12 with performance pack (GT12)/Vanq Zag


AMR


One-77


Vulcan


DB11 V12


DB11 V8


Cygnet



Squaremeal

Original Poster:

180 posts

170 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
That's comprehensive! Thank you!

ruaricoles

1,243 posts

256 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Had a laugh when I reached the final pic - thanks for those!

quench

564 posts

177 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Squaremeal said:
Is this the one you mean?

Yes, that's it - as noted in later posts also from the GT12. Basically makes for an all black engine bay. I know there's real metal there, but it doesn't have the visual impact of the silver coloured manifolds, which really reinforce the impression of a great big engine shoehorned into a smallish car, which for me is part of the appeal of the V12 Vantage variants. And it does nothing to distinguish itself from every virtually other engine bay on the planet sheathed in black plastic. For that reason alone I would not buy it, never mind the horrendous asking price.

Edited by quench on Wednesday 18th October 23:46

quench

564 posts

177 months

Wednesday 18th October 2017
quotequote all
Also couldn't help but notice the ugly welds on the DB11 cross braces. Contrast those with the earlier model, beautiful, curved and bolted braces!

V8V Pete

2,536 posts

157 months

Thursday 19th October 2017
quotequote all
I can't help but find this quite amusing and now feel compelled to comment.

We have people going out of their way to de-chrome/blacken the exterior of their cars (wheels, window surrounds, side strakes etc.) but AML make the inlet manifolds black and rather than being considered cool & hipster it's dull and plasticky-looking. I accept that removing the wings badge was just silly. However, my understanding is that the black manifolds are magnesium alloy rather than aluminium. You're seriously into the realms of "marginal gains" when you start using magnesium and therefore they presumably thought having big raised moulded letters on them saying ASTON MARTIN would render this pointless. AND while we're at it - lot's of people have been moaning about the DB11 V8 saying ASTON MARTIN across the boot but people still want it to say ASTON MARTIN on their inlet manifolds. I guess it comes back to the fact that some people buy these cars just to look at whilst others want to drive them too.

Sorry if I've offended anyone and I'll go now but I just don't get it sometimes getmecoat

jonby

5,367 posts

188 months

Thursday 19th October 2017
quotequote all
V8V Pete said:
I can't help but find this quite amusing and now feel compelled to comment.

We have people going out of their way to de-chrome/blacken the exterior of their cars (wheels, window surrounds, side strakes etc.) but AML make the inlet manifolds black and rather than being considered cool & hipster it's dull and plasticky-looking. I accept that removing the wings badge was just silly. However, my understanding is that the black manifolds are magnesium alloy rather than aluminium. You're seriously into the realms of "marginal gains" when you start using magnesium and therefore they presumably thought having big raised moulded letters on them saying ASTON MARTIN would render this pointless. AND while we're at it - lot's of people have been moaning about the DB11 V8 saying ASTON MARTIN across the boot but people still want it to say ASTON MARTIN on their inlet manifolds. I guess it comes back to the fact that some people buy these cars just to look at whilst others want to drive them too.

Sorry if I've offended anyone and I'll go now but I just don't get it sometimes getmecoat
I'm sure there's an element of wanting what you can't have

But there is more to it than that

WTDoom has a car which is literally, all black, but most people who go for the stealth look seem to like at least one point of contrast, e.g. yellow callipers, red stitching, tan interior - just something that provides a contrast. Under the bonnet now is just a mass of black and it's hard to tell where the plastic ends and the metals start. A stealth look on the outside is not quite the same as a stealth look under the bonnet

Also, it's one thing saying you don't need big shiny letters on the outside when you have a wings badge and quite another when there is literally nothing on the engine to say it's an Aston, especially when there used to be both a wings badge and some lettering there

Personally, it's the combination of changes under the bonnet that I don't like rather than any one single point - no wings badge, no colour contrasts, no Aston lettering, not even the metal oil cap that the V8 has

DB11 has an under bonnet jewellery pack option so Aston obviously realise it's an important part of the emotive appeal of their cars, plus with the so oft repeated phrase 'largest engine shoe horned into smallest car', many people love opening the bonnet and looking at the engine - much of the drama and charisma of that has basically disappeared.

As you say, removing the wings badge was silly and so it's the cumulative effect of all these changes that narks.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 19th October 2017
quotequote all
The aesthetic side of it is unlikely to improve as things move toward turbocharging - the joy of a N/A engine was the simplicity of its design that allowed for some flamboyant and shapely intake manifolds and such. Unfortunately engines with a hot-v turbo configuration will require some sort of plastic (or similar) cladding on top to cover up the mass of pipework and wiring.

It's just not like the old days, luckily with the race cars we don't have to add plastic covers everywhere biggrin


forward visibility is somewhat hampered, but that's half the fun...

jonby

5,367 posts

188 months

Thursday 19th October 2017
quotequote all
fuelracer496 said:
The aesthetic side of it is unlikely to improve as things move toward turbocharging - the joy of a N/A engine was the simplicity of its design that allowed for some flamboyant and shapely intake manifolds and such. Unfortunately engines with a hot-v turbo configuration will require some sort of plastic (or similar) cladding on top to cover up the mass of pipework and wiring.

It's just not like the old days, luckily with the race cars we don't have to add plastic covers everywhere biggrin


forward visibility is somewhat hampered, but that's half the fun...
Indeed and of course, part of the appeal of V12V/S/AMR/Vanq s right now is that whole end of an analogue era stuff, which includes the aesthetics under the bonnet - shame that's not been fully capitalised

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Thursday 19th October 2017
quotequote all
V8V Pete said:
AND while we're at it - lot's of people have been moaning about the DB11 V8 saying ASTON MARTIN across the boot but people still want it to say ASTON MARTIN on their inlet manifolds
At the new Vantage viewing on Saturday I took the team to task about the Aston Martin script on the boot & they said that, having conducted a survey it was the 2nd favourite & 2nd disliked feature in equal measure; you can’t win really!