Should the N24 Vantage be included in Jon39's list
Should the N24 Vantage be included in Jon39's list

Poll: Should the N24 Vantage be included in Jon39's list

Total Members Polled: 27

Yes: 63%
No: 37%
Author
Discussion

RobDown

Original Poster:

3,807 posts

159 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
For Jon39 and his list of Vantage Special editions. Should the N24 be included, or is it really just a racing car and therefore excluded?

(yes, yes I know, this is right up there with Brexit and Catalonian independence as one of the important questions of the day)

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
v8vantage said:
From Aston themselves and in their brochure for the N24: "At the 2006 British Motor Show, Dr Ulrich Bez announced that Aston Martin would build a limited production run of cars based on the V8 Vantage that completed the Nürburgring 24-hour endurance race. Just five months later, production commenced at Aston Martin’s Gaydon headquarters. The specification is based on a standard production, European specification (left hand drive), V8 Vantage with the following modifications:" I rest my case!

http://www.v8vantage.com/images/N24/N24BROCHURE.pd...

Edited by v8vantage on Sunday 29th October 20:51
A "limited production run" of cars is not the same as a "limited edition" car, and the cars (the N24) are described in detail based on racing.

Shortly after saying it was a limited production run, the brochure states, "The Vantage N24 is based on a European specification V8 Vantage, with modifications to prepare the car for the racing environment." This is exactly the same as a GT4 would be described. And the final paragraph details the racing series themselves:

"The Vantage N24 provides an ideal base for a wide variety of motorsport uses and is ideal for club racing amongst other categories. As supplied it is eligible for series such as the VLN Endurance Championship at the Nürburgring, the Britcar Endurance Series, the Dutch Supercar Challenge, the Australian GT Championship and the European Endurance Championship. The Vantage N24 is potentially eligible for the proposed European GT4 Series, the Grand-Am Cup and the SCCA Touring Car Class in the USA"

Again, this is the same as would be detailed for the GT4 race car, and even includes reference to the GT4 series which would include the GT4 race cars that replaced the N24.

Jon39 said:


I would doubt that any GT3 or GTE could ever be road registered, although I think some GT4 models might be, but possibly not when they were brand new.
The GT4 is a completely different car than the GT3 or GTE. The GT4 is a production-based race car that shares the vast majority of its components with the road car. The GT3 has very little carry-over in comparison. I'd be perfectly comfortable driving a GT4 on public roads. The GT3, absolutely not. Regardless of the possibility of road registration, the GT4 and GT3 are race cars, just as the N24 was a race car.

v8vantage

203 posts

265 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
You've lost me....a limited production run and limited edition are one in the same! So even if they planned to build 24 but only built 14 it's still not a limited edition! Go figure. It was built at Gaydon by Aston Martin based on a production car in limited numbers, can't get any closer to limited edition in my eyes. At the end of the day more people are aware of it now and its significance as Aston's first "special" from Gaydon.


The proto and 007 together.


The two most special "specials" from Gaydon.

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
The word choice for "limited production run" is simply that they were producing the cars themselves, and it would be a small volume. First, the N24 was a new platform for AML, so there wouldn't be a huge number of customers. Second, Aston's production line could only handle so many cars, and the company was trying to build a ton of DB9s and V8 Vantages - they had to build thousands of cars and couldn't fill up their road car production line with race cars that may or may not have had a huge demand like the road cars were having. Third, there's a big difference between limited edition and limited production.

A limited edition car is something like the GT8, where Aston says, "We're building this car and it's special because [insert marketing fluff here] and we're building them in limited volume."
A limited production car is something like the N24, where Aston says, "We're building this car [for racing] in limited volume."

The fact that Aston built barely more than half of the originally intended cars proves my first point of not enough customers. The N24 was a race car that didn't sell well. That doesn't retroactively make it a limited edition, it makes it a failure. How many Cygnets were made compared to the planned production? That doesn't mean it isn't special - it was a very significant car for Aston Martin Racing, and paved the way for the GT2, GTE, GT4, and GT3 race cars, and the fantastic successes AMR has had. And the limited volume does make it that much more special. But that still doesn't make it limited edition car.

LordBretSinclair

4,306 posts

208 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
Jon's list is for numbers produced - no mention of road going or racing only - so why not include the N24 ??

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
He had started the list for limited edition cars. When the N24 was mentioned, I said it was a race car, not a limited edition car. And if the N24 was listed, then the rest of the race cars would need to be listed as well. But my point in that thread was that race cars aren't limited edition cars, and so there's discussion about whether or not the N24 was a race car or a limited edition.

BamfordMike

1,192 posts

188 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
telum01 said:
The fact that Aston built barely more than half of the originally intended cars proves my first point of not enough customers. The N24 was a race car that didn't sell well. That doesn't retroactively make it a limited edition, it makes it a failure..
Built half the intended run? No!
A failure? Are u nuts?
Proves a point - sorry, you are a little Misinformed

At the time Bez simply wanted to celebrate Rose’s first year at the ring by selling ‘24’ similar spec cars to folk who wanted to go racing with the factory (like Herriman team sharing a garage with the factory at the next year NRing). However, by build 15-17 Prodrive sniffed the value in the project and under the banner ‘we are all racing, you factory are all road car’, Prodrive came and (some might say) stole the impromptu production line off the factory and stopped production. The value Prodrive saw coming was the soon to be established GT4 formula and since acquiring the project +150 chassis have been built and raced around the globe. Hardly a failure! Factory were instructed to cease and desist making the chassis, they were not giving up at chassis 15-17 because of poor order book.

Rose and Kermit paved the way for GT4 which ultimately paved the way to current WEC successes. Also, based on the fact the factory would single vehicle approve each model for the road (should the customer wish), means the N24 build (not the subsequent Prodrive GT4 build) should rightfully take its place in the list - The cars are legends!

v8vantage

203 posts

265 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
Thanks Mike, you summed it up perfectly. As you were there and part of it I doubt anyone knows the story better. As you say they are legends!

One more picture for posterity. 2007 Geneva Motorshow, AML stand, launch of the "limited edition Number 1 of 24" N24 Vantage


telum01

987 posts

146 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
BamfordMike said:
However, by build 15-17 Prodrive sniffed the value in the project and under the banner ‘we are all racing, you factory are all road car’, Prodrive came and (some might say) stole the impromptu production line off the factory and stopped production.
Thus, the N24 is a race car.

Great info, btw. Love being able to learn these fun details and stories smile

v8vantage

203 posts

265 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
If the AMR Pro V8 Vantage is on the list then so too should the N24. They are both limited track cars that can be registered for the road.

AMR Pro Geneva Motorshow 2017, 10 years after the N24 was launched there.



BamfordMike

1,192 posts

188 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
telum01 said:
Thus, the N24 is a race car.

Great info, btw. Love being able to learn these fun details and stories smile
I would say it was sold as much a race car as it was a road car modified so you could take to the track on account when factory released the car there wasn’t actually a formula to enter it in to race, that (GT4) came later. And if the factory didn’t have an eye on selling the car in bigger numbers for road / track what was the rationale behind giving TopGear Rose for this??

https://youtu.be/lUF-N8BsBmU



Edited by BamfordMike on Monday 30th October 16:02

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
Track-only cars and race cars are two different things. The N24 was built to comply with a number of race series and adaptable to others. I found this awesome website that's hosting a copy of the N24's press release:

http://www.v8vantage.com/VantageN24.html

Note the very first sentence:
Aston Martin has confirmed details of its N24 race car, based on the critically acclaimed V8 Vantage road car, which will be showcased at the Autosport International Show this week.

And later on:
As supplied it is eligible for series such as the VLN Endurance Championship at the Nürburgring, the Britcar endurance series, the Dutch Supercar Challenge, the Australian GT Championship and the European Endurance Championship. In addition, the Vantage N24 is also potentially eligible for the proposed European GT4 series, the Grand-Am Cup and SCCA Touring Car Class in the USA.

It may have been registered by some owners for road use, and it did make for a great Top Gear episode, but it was still a race car!

Jon39

15,019 posts

174 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all

v8vantage said:
If the AMR Pro V8 Vantage is on the list then so too should the N24. ...

Oh, I forgot about the track only aspect, when I put the AMR Pro on the list.

Thinking about it, although it is a track car, I believe the suggestion has been made, that there is not a suitable race series for it to be competitive in.
Perhaps it could stay on the list, because it is unlikely to ever be a raced on a circuit. The FoS might have been it's proudest moment.



Edited by Jon39 on Monday 30th October 17:31

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Monday 30th October 2017
quotequote all
The bottom line for my argument is the purpose of the car to begin with. The AMR Pro was built to be a limited edition track-only car. The N24 was built to be a race car.

Of course, it's your list so you can include anything you'd want lol

Mako V12V

3,139 posts

245 months

Tuesday 31st October 2017
quotequote all
Bump.....can’t believe only 15 people have voted on this?

AdamV12V

5,314 posts

208 months

Tuesday 31st October 2017
quotequote all
Mako V12V said:
Bump.....can’t believe only 15 people have voted on this?
I can't believe how much info and amazing pictures Mr V8Vantage has about the original Kermit.

Many thanks - made for some great reading for me! thumbup

v8vantage

203 posts

265 months

Wednesday 1st November 2017
quotequote all
Have a lot more on Kermit than I've posted. here's another for you.



These are the guys that painted the revised kermit: http://www.chippingnortonbodyshop.co.uk/gallery/ga...



Edited by v8vantage on Wednesday 1st November 16:40

v8vantage

203 posts

265 months

Wednesday 1st November 2017
quotequote all
The Geneva showcar with it's first retail customer having added a few mods by Aston Martin SVO at Gaydon.



In the shop at Gaydon




v8vantage

203 posts

265 months

Wednesday 1st November 2017
quotequote all
The N24 wasn't just a limited edition track/race car celebrating the 24 hour race at the 'ring, it was a test bed for production. The Sportshift gearbox was first fitted to Kermit, number 007. Kermit was also the first to receive the higher revised tail spoiler/boot lid that appeared on the V12 Vantage and V8S. The side sills appeared in carbon on the N24 then became standard on the V12 and V8S and now as an option on the AMR. The proto Rose got the larger front splitter and higher tail after Dr. Bez smashed up the original at the 'ring.

V12 Vantage proto.

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Wednesday 1st November 2017
quotequote all
So are we going to add all the test mules to Jon's list along with race cars, too?

Edited by telum01 on Wednesday 1st November 19:34