Deposit paid... inspection frustration!?
Deposit paid... inspection frustration!?
Author
Discussion

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Wednesday 8th November 2017
quotequote all
Hello, newbie to the AM forum here.

I have taken the plunge and have a 2009 V8 Vantage awaiting next steps at HR Owen Cheltenham. Recent clutch, brakes, good provenance, looks a peach. I realise the topic of whether to inspect has been done before. I think a thorough report by an independent experienced in the marque would be valuable but not at any price and it'd need to be really thorough. I hope you don't mind me asking;

What to AM buyers normally get by way of indie report? I had one done on my Porsche 18 months ago that was pages of dense report with photos, record analysis, data analytics and incredibly detailed, descriptive and thorough. Full of useful stuff. An AM specialist seemed to offer 2 sides of A4 tick list confirming mainly of the switches, lights etc worked, for a lot more money than the Porsche one (which was done at the seller's gaff). Definitely not worth it for me...

Another AM specialist, well respected so am tempted to take advice, suggested proceeding with the purchase as HR Owen would not scrimp (and it'll have 12months warranty), and then they would do an inspection at their place.

Are there specialists who will do a thorough report and travel to Cheltenham? I'm having trouble finding them...

I generally do quite a lot of work on my own cars and bikes and have the annual service/check at the dealer. Excepting internal engine and gearbox work I have worked on AMG Mercedes V8's, Porsche etc but not Astons. If I fail to find a good indie inspector, I am tempted to ask if I can do my own with one of the dealer's tech's dong the actual fiddling. Health and Safety allowing etc. It'd be interesting anyway...

Recommendations and thoughts welcome!

Thanks


Jon39

15,018 posts

174 months

Wednesday 8th November 2017
quotequote all

Your dealer has a good reputation on here. I cannot even remember a criticism.

It seems that you have a good knowledge yourself, so you should be able to spot any bodywork and major component issues during your viewing and test drive. I have used that dealer for some services, and the service manager at the time, did allow me to look under my own car, when lifted on a hoist. Also look closely for any paint bubbles, sometimes found on doors, particularly near the door handles, and external mirror arms.

The warranty should help with any after purchase issues. A recent clutch should eliminate that risk, which of course would not be a warranty item.

The suggestion that you were given about a subsequent inspection, would enable you to promptly sort things under warranty, but I get the impression that you would probably discover anything yourself anyway.

Enjoy your car.






Edited by Jon39 on Wednesday 8th November 20:47

tvrbod

112 posts

212 months

Wednesday 8th November 2017
quotequote all
Can only say just had my second Vantage of HR Owen and and there give a very good service, Just put my 2009 vantage in as a part x for a 2014.

petop

2,410 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th November 2017
quotequote all
Being a ex 911 C4S owner I know in Porsche circles that Indie inspections were the norm because of the IM/RMS issues and bore scoring which the usual tick box Porsche dealer checks would not cover, although I think they started going looking more when the early 997's with rev-ranges being exceeded.

In the case of the Vantage you rarely hear of prospective owners going down the same route as above, mainly because faults are usually easy to spot including the ones that are more common like corrosion around the door handles, mirror arms and "weak" clutches (more so on the S/S's).

As people have stated the dealer in question has a good rep so don't be too concerned not having an indie inspection. And unlike Porsche who will refuse a Warranty claim because you put your favourite air freshener in the car, AM are little more accommodating.

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Thursday 9th November 2017
quotequote all
Thanks, really helpful and great to hear of a dealer with a solid reputation.

Yes the Porsche has a few other dormant ones too, like the use of aluminium and steel in the same bayonet coolant hose connectors - so they corrode like mad. Full replacement of the cooling system from the engine forward including the pump, all the pipes, a new low temperature stat and the radiators but at least I'd had the inspection and went in with my eyes open, priced accordingly. But this in not the marque-forum for that conversation.

I'm going to ask to take a look myself and find out more about the car too, I think I would enjoy that.

tvrbod, I wonder if I've bought your car...






Ken Figenus

6,011 posts

148 months

Thursday 9th November 2017
quotequote all
I think there is far less fragility and engineering howlers on these cars than you have been used to! However I guess one can not be over-diligent in verifying an used car and some of the 'Timeless' stuff is marketing guff rather than engineering checks (they dont scope bores for e.g. but might freshen the carpets wink ) so its your call. However with a 12month Aston premium (not classic...) warranty and what seems like an experienced potential owners eyes on it I would not personally be paying more to have a main 'good rep' franchised dealers car inspected. Especially if they pop it on a ramp for you to have a look there too smile Always take a mate though!

Sebastian Tombs

2,160 posts

223 months

Thursday 9th November 2017
quotequote all
I bought mine from an independent classic car dealer, but as part of the purchase he had it serviced at Chiltern Aston, and at the same time I asked for an inspection, with a view to taking a year's extended warranty on it. They did this for free as most was covered by the service anyway, but usually they would charge for this. Anyway the report, such as it was was merely a confirmation on the phone (and possibly by email) that there was nothing wrong with it at all. This has so far turned out to be true.

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Friday 10th November 2017
quotequote all
It seems I am buying tvrbod's ex-car, thank you very much indeed for the chat about the car, much appreciated.

So, heartened but acknowledging caveat emptor, I have arranged to look over the car with one of their technicians doing the work on the car and getting it up on a ramp. No problem for the dealer to arrange. Looks very promising!

Thanks again for all the input, will let you know how I get on.


Manx V8V

482 posts

113 months

Friday 10th November 2017
quotequote all
I think making contact with the previous owner for a chat on the phone is as valuable as any inspection.

I was a bit cheeky and traced the previous owner of mine through an internet search which threw up his business phone number, and he was more than happy to take my call and confirm a few things, like for example a recent clutch which the dealer was claiming had been done, but showed only as a short hand written note in the service log which anyone could have scribbled, had definitely been done.

I felt so much more comfortable after our chat, and the fact that he also confirmed that the car had been no bother to him over his 3 years of ownership, and had only been traded up.for a newer V8V.

vernierMike

Original Poster:

397 posts

125 months

Friday 10th November 2017
quotequote all
+1 beer