2nd car discussion and debate
2nd car discussion and debate
Author
Discussion

WelshBoltonBen

Original Poster:

133 posts

109 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
Afternoon all!
Now, not that i don't want to drive my lovely V8 every day, and the fact that I can't stop looking out of the window at it aside, I need a daily drive. I've got £2-£3k to spend, want something reliable, not bothered about mileage. Anyone got any thoughts or recommendations? Preferably low tax, as I pay enough of that, and lower insurance - assuming Aviva will mirror my current NCB. Oh, and preferably 5 seats.
Advice welcomed!!

Edited by WelshBoltonBen on Wednesday 15th November 14:02

steveway

947 posts

115 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
we have just gone for a lease on a Kia Nero hybrid, £2000 deposit and £200/month for three years, does 70mpg and is excellent, might be an option, you can get better deals as well

WelshBoltonBen

Original Poster:

133 posts

109 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
Hi Steveway, thanks for the tip! I'm looking for something to purchase outright so I can keep the fuel tank of the V8 full wink

Dewi 1

285 posts

153 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all

If you can get yourself to a BCA auction you will be astonished at the low prices. The traders there would just call the prices realistic, whereas owners might say,
"I will certainly not sell to you at that price". No need to dress up !

Years ago, I bought a couple of cars for our youngsters.
This is purely an example, not saying it is the ideal car. Obviously had to have small, for insurance.

14 month old Fiat Punto Grande, the air con model, 10,000 miles, £4,200. New list price then was just over £10,000.
Two years maker's warranty remaining. Choice of 20 cars, so could even choose colour and condition.
They delivered the car to my home.

That car has run perfectly, still in daily use now at about 150,000 miles.

With the recent significant fall in the number of new cars sold, there will be even more brand new 'pre-registered' cars at auctions.
Don't be tempted by 'cheap' PCP deals. Think hamster on treadmill.










Edited by Dewi 1 on Wednesday 15th November 14:54

WelshBoltonBen

Original Poster:

133 posts

109 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
Thanks Dewi- hadn’t thought of BCA, I’ll have a look. Just off the PCP treadmill, I know cars don’t appreciate (often) but you are right, I’m trying to stay away from monthly payments and the depreciation pay-off.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
I needed something to pop to school/shops etc same sort of budget with not wanting to take the AM into certain car parks etc (curbing issues in York). Went and had a chat with my local car garage in the village (who also has a great rep). They had just taken in a citroen C3, 58 plate, 60k miles, manual 1.4 petrol, AC, 6 months warranty, clean as a whistle inside and out. £2k, i couldnt say no. Its a hoot to drive, more like a go kart. If it sits in the corner of the drive unused for a week, month or year it doesn’t matter but it has taken away the dread of some local journeys in the AM. And it has a digital speedo, gasp!

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
Forgot to add... £150 tax, insurance i added to my aviva policy was £130.

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
Toyota Aygo or Yaris or a Honda Jazz. Buy the best that your money will stretch to. Cheap to insure and run, plus good tech.

bentley01

1,199 posts

167 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
You cant go wrong with a Ford Focus. Reliable and good to drive.

steveatesh

5,385 posts

195 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
bentley01 said:
You cant go wrong with a Ford Focus. Reliable and good to drive.
This.
Spares everywhere you go and you will have another ford whistle

WelshBoltonBen

Original Poster:

133 posts

109 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
steveatesh said:
bentley01 said:
You cant go wrong with a Ford Focus. Reliable and good to drive.
This.
Spares everywhere you go and you will have another ford whistle
Best buy a Volvo then...

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
Unfortunately the days of bargains at BCA (or any car auction) are long gone - prices are now often similar to private sale prices; sometimes higher!

My city runaround is a Mk5 Golf GTI, but to be honest if I were you I'd just have a browse of Gumtree and see what appeals. If you're ok with a smallish car, then something like the Alfa Mito is around £3k, or you might get a Civic from around 2007?

WelshBoltonBen

Original Poster:

133 posts

109 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
I’ll have a quick look at BCA, see what stuff there is- there must be a ton of stuff about with carwow etc killing the used market?

bogie

17,107 posts

303 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all
WelshBoltonBen said:
steveatesh said:
bentley01 said:
You cant go wrong with a Ford Focus. Reliable and good to drive.
This.
Spares everywhere you go and you will have another ford whistle
Best buy a Volvo then...
I think you will find many a Volvo on the drive next to an Aston when we last did the 2nd car survey....Volvos and Land Rover products are very popular 2nd cars it seems wink

We have had a Volvo in the fleet for nearly 20 years now. Buy them 4-5 years old with lowish miles for a few grand, put 100-150k more miles on them and keep until they need major repairs (rare) or someone runs into them and writes them off ...the last S60D5 did 180k miles with just consumables changing and near 50Mpg. The best £5k car we ever had.

Dewi 1

285 posts

153 months

Wednesday 15th November 2017
quotequote all

johnnyBv8 said:
Unfortunately the days of bargains at BCA (or any car auction) are long gone - prices are now often similar to private sale prices; sometimes higher!

I don't have any further knowledge of auctions, since buying cars for my children in about 2008.
In those days it was clear that most of the buyers were dealers. Of course they cannot overpay, otherwise after all their overheads, they risk making a loss.

If auction prices are no longer attractive for private buyers (who obviously are not seeking an immediate resale profit), where do traders buy their stock from now?
I know BCA then had some trade only auctions, perhaps there are more of those these days.






South tdf

1,830 posts

226 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
In answer to dealer stock I would class 4 types of mainstream dealer so excluding marque specialists etc. It is not uncommon for some dealers to have only a few hundred pounds if not a loss in some used cars after preparation and stocking costs. There is also increased potential in the current market of zombie stock where cars have been in stock 60-90 days and are worth less retail than they were purchased for but are not being reduced in price to reflect this.

Main dealers - Demo fleet / courtesy cars, manufacturers direct cars, auctions (closed auctions), rental buy backs, rental sales, PCP returns, general customer PX’s (sometimes across a group eg Land Rover franchise take in a 1 year old Audi it gets moved to Audi franchise).

Supermarkets - Auctions, rental companies and some lease companies direct

Average independents- Auctions, main dealer PX auctions, PX’s, local customer base and sometimes local private sellers

Low end independents - Auctions, Gumtree, e-bay, independent traders (underwritters)

sundayjumper

531 posts

313 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
Agreed about BCA, last couple of times I've been to my local (Blackbushe) prices haven't been very good at all. It's baffling where those cars are going.

Back OT, I'm a big fan of German cars so I'd ideally go for a BMW. There should be lots of E46s in budget, maybe bottom end of E90s ? I've not looked recently.

Failing that, Golf/Passat. We're on our second Passat and my parents & brother both have Golfs. They've all been good but I much prefer a BMW !




Jon39

15,020 posts

174 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all

sundayjumper said:
... I'm a big fan of German cars so I'd ideally go for a BMW.
... I much prefer a BMW !

Ah good, that is handy, a BMW enthusiast.

My E30 starts normally and initially idles correctly at 800 rpm.
As soon as the engine temperature reaches the normal level, the idle speed rises to 1,500 rpm and will not go below that. My local mechanic is mystified. What has happened?




WelshBoltonBen

Original Poster:

133 posts

109 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
sundayjumper said:
Agreed about BCA, last couple of times I've been to my local (Blackbushe) prices haven't been very good at all. It's baffling where those cars are going.

Back OT, I'm a big fan of German cars so I'd ideally go for a BMW. There should be lots of E46s in budget, maybe bottom end of E90s ? I've not looked recently.

Failing that, Golf/Passat. We're on our second Passat and my parents & brother both have Golfs. They've all been good but I much prefer a BMW !
Thanks for that, considered a Passat or golf but heard mixed things about the 2l tdi. Maybe the 1.9 is better?

sukh_m

1,325 posts

223 months

Thursday 16th November 2017
quotequote all
I have run a Ford Focus Titanium for 3 years approx as a DD. Surprisingly reliable, cheap to insure and parts/servicing direct from the Ford dealer were also reasonable (I took out a 3 year service plan). For your budget, it would be perfect wink

Edited by sukh_m on Thursday 16th November 12:06