New Vantage: Yay or Nay
New Vantage: Yay or Nay

Poll: New Vantage: Yay or Nay

Total Members Polled: 154

Yes: 45%
No: 55%
Author
Discussion

KarlFranz

Original Poster:

2,008 posts

301 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
It's seems the new Vantage design is very polarizing. Now that you've had a few days to ponder, I think it's time to cast your vote.

A simple Yes or No vote because, in the end, that's the only two choices that really matter. So none of this "if they did this or that, then maybe" answers.

Could yield interesting results.

AMDBSVNick

7,221 posts

193 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
It is what it is., if you don't like it, move on.

Graze01

1,203 posts

123 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
I would like to see one in the metal

Graze

philmorton

165 posts

175 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
yes

This is what happens with replying before logging in rolleyes
Long day

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
It’s a bit like London buses. You don’t get a poll on the new Vantage ever and then multiple polls...........

petop

2,410 posts

197 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
Exactly......talk about jump on the bandwagon! smile

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
petop said:
Exactly......talk about jump on the bandwagon! smile
Yours was a better question Petop smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
...I like it. I'm in the minority though (which I find surprising). Admittedly, I'd rather have a DBS when they appear, but that'll be a huge amount of money and the Vantage is just about achievable if I sell some organs and stuff next year (but not the Corvette, nope, keeping her).

Genuinely, I'm surprised that the car's been this much of a miss with existing customers. I knew when I saw it that it would divide opinion, but I've seen less positive vibes about it than negative ones. It might be it drives wonderfully and people come around to the styling, or perhaps compromise because of its driving dynamics, but I have a small worry that it just might not be the success it needs to be.

Vet Guru

2,222 posts

271 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
Looks amazing!! 😊

Bincenzo

2,606 posts

210 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
NFC 85 Vette said:
...I like it. I'm in the minority though (which I find surprising). Admittedly, I'd rather have a DBS when they appear, but that'll be a huge amount of money and the Vantage is just about achievable if I sell some organs and stuff next year (but not the Corvette, nope, keeping her).

Genuinely, I'm surprised that the car's been this much of a miss with existing customers. I knew when I saw it that it would divide opinion, but I've seen less positive vibes about it than negative ones. It might be it drives wonderfully and people come around to the styling, or perhaps compromise because of its driving dynamics, but I have a small worry that it just might not be the success it needs to be.
Vette, don’t be fooled, this has not been a miss with existing customers, it has been a miss with some existing customers who feel strongly enough to put fingers to keypad. There are a lot out there that like it, a lot that don’t and a lot that can’t make their mind up, but the vocalists tend to be those with relatively extreme views in both camps. Only when sales happen and data is valid for existing versus new owners can anyone make that statement with any convinction.

sparkyph

56 posts

109 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
Yes but not sure if I’d have one over a McLaren 540C at £130k+ with options. Tough to choose.

FrankieMac

763 posts

153 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all
sparkyph said:
Yes but not sure if I’d have one over a McLaren 540C at £130k+ with options. Tough to choose.
Oops have I chosen wrong then??biggrin

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Tuesday 5th December 2017
quotequote all

Bincenzo said:
Only when sales happen and data is valid for existing versus new owners can anyone make that statement with any convinction.

We are ready for a UK sales comparison.
During 2019, if more than 1436 Vantages are sold, then it will be more succesful than its predecessor.
The first full year of production.

AML only publish their annual production figures (overall), so we only have the UK numbers to work with for individual models.



V8 Vantage GT

1,657 posts

137 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all
Jon39 said:

We are ready for a UK sales comparison.
During 2019, if more than 1436 Vantages are sold, then it will be more succesful than its predecessor.
The first full year of production.

AML only publish their annual production figures (overall), so we only have the UK numbers to work with for individual models.
The first year production, isn't it already set? Aston said all sold out. So if there is a large unsold inventory next year, but manufacturing maxed out is it still a success?

I hope it is. But it's a "Butterface". Going to be hard to get past that. It's just a shame what A. Palmer and what Marek R. have done, a shame. I have to believe a lot of unhappy investors.

mhurley

823 posts

164 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all
Looks better in the flesh

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all
Bincenzo said:
Vette, don’t be fooled, this has not been a miss with existing customers, it has been a miss with some existing customers who feel strongly enough to put fingers to keypad. There are a lot out there that like it, a lot that don’t and a lot that can’t make their mind up, but the vocalists tend to be those with relatively extreme views in both camps. Only when sales happen and data is valid for existing versus new owners can anyone make that statement with any convinction.
Very good point, I hope it's a good seller, and perhaps the later variants might sway those who aren't keen yet (though that's some way off). Throughout all the discussion in the main thread, the main talking point has been about the looks, very little has been said about performance. That for me was the selling point - an entry level model that outperforms the outgoing V12S in its basic format, before any talk of a savage version has begun. Personally I think it looks great. I like the DB10 elements, the Vulcan inspired elements and the general aggression to it.

It makes a great noise, as good as you could hope for when turbochargers are involved (and doesn't like the Mopar style AMG engine importantly), it has one of the best gearboxes available and the cabin feels like a DB11 that's lost some weight and gone to the gym. Time will tell how it's received when the first cars reach customers and we've had test drives.

Buster73

5,643 posts

184 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all
sparkyph said:
Yes but not sure if I’d have one over a McLaren 540C at £130k+ with options. Tough to choose.
Until I've both seen and driven one the answer is no .

If I like the looks and the drive of the Aston ,then the McLaren scenario enters the equation .

Round figures it would cost me £80k to change at the moment into either from my N430 .

At that balance to change I'd be in the maybe camp but leaning towards a no.

I'll have a decent road test in both next spring then make my mind up.

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all

Buster73 said:
Round figures it would cost me £80k to change at the moment into either from my N430 .
£80k ?

I think you could be the owner of a V12 Vantage AND your N430 for the same money.

Wow.

And possibly then followed by minimal depreciation.







Graze01

1,203 posts

123 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all
I've Been giving this some thought

No one has discussed the all important driving feel of te car ( obviously as no one has driven it yet). But it's a BiIG issue

The previous vantage was an 11 out of 10 on looks but probably only 8.0-9.0 on performance and maybe 9.0 on handling(depending on which version)

But it was a big hit as an overall package and people accepted a bit less performance with the compromise of achingly good looks

The new one isn't as good looking ( my view based on photos as here in Aus we are yet to see one as far as I know) but from the figures it will be a stellar performance car. We will have to wait for info on handling but again based on the published specs and the video with Matt Becker and Max V it looks to be right up there

So the test will be driving one, and what weighting people put on looks vs performance/handling as an overall package

I expect the looks will grow more comfortable (even for the die hards) but the performance and handling will sway a lot of people - maybe even me

I wish Aston only good fortune. I love owning one , feel privileged to be part of the Aston family and will certainly buy another in the future. Which one? Not sure

Graeme

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Wednesday 6th December 2017
quotequote all

V8 Vantage GT said:
The first year production, isn't it already set? Aston said all sold out. So if there is a large unsold inventory next year, but manufacturing maxed out is it still a success?

That comparison reference Andy, is directly with the initial UK sales of the Mk1 Vantage, during the first full calendar year.
Here in the UK, we can see figures for new cars when first licensed for use on public roads (ie sold cars and dealer demonstrators), so not including cars manufactured but unsold.

Mk1 sales began 2005, first full year 2006 = 1436 cars.
Mk2 sales begin 2018, first full year 2019 = ?

Cannot do worldwide figures, although I think in your country they are published, but behind a 'paywall'.




Edited by Jon39 on Wednesday 6th December 11:42