Will taking Aston Martin public, help or hurt the brand?
Discussion
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-aston-martin-m-...
Curious what an Aston Martin IPO might do? On one hand it would bring in much needed cash. On the other hand it might bring in investors more interested in the bottom line than the product?
Like to what others think about it with more knowledge about this than I have.
Curious what an Aston Martin IPO might do? On one hand it would bring in much needed cash. On the other hand it might bring in investors more interested in the bottom line than the product?
Like to what others think about it with more knowledge about this than I have.
V8 Vantage GT said:
Curious what an Aston Martin IPO might do?
On one hand it would bring in much needed cash. On the other hand it might bring in investors more interested in the bottom line than the product?
Like to know what others think about it with more knowledge about this than I have.
On one hand it would bring in much needed cash. On the other hand it might bring in investors more interested in the bottom line than the product?
Like to know what others think about it with more knowledge about this than I have.
Although I have a long involvement in this subject, I may not have more knowledge than you, Andy.
Will have a go at trying to answer your question though.
1. Private equity (PE) investing firms (often using their client's money), tend to have reasonably short time frames for investing in companies. The exit from any investment, then provides an opportunity for client money to be returned.
2. A private equity exit might be a straight sale, or public share flotation. In this case, the PE firm does not own the whole of AML, so all present shareholders would need to agree to sell at the same time, for a straight sale. A flotation would therefore usually be more practical, than a complete sale.
3. At flotation (initial public offering) stock market investors (the new buyers) like to see a solid track record of profits growth. Even more important is the expectation of future steady growth. That is what I look for anyway, but as with any buying/selling transaction, there can be excitement created to encourage buyers. A recent example of that, was the AO plc flotation. At the time, I thought the flotation valuation was ridiculously high. Take a look at their share price chart below, to see what then happened to the market value of the business after flotation.
4. Motor manufacturers are in a cyclical industry, so obviously when profits growth reverses, shareholder selling can dramatically reduce company market valuations. Sometimes then, predators might see an opportunity to buy. With shareholder approval, they can buy.
5. Money raised at a flotation could simply be paid to the present investors who are selling, but if new additional shares are being offered as well, then the extra money raised could be used to replace some current debt with shareholder equity, thereby reducing future interest payments. Interest payments are a commitment of course, but dividends to shareholders can be reduced or stopped at any time.
6. Certainly investors want their businesses to do well, so demand for good company products are obviously crucial to achieve that.
There you are. Just a few thoughts for discussion.
I know this is a subject that regularly comes up on here. All that I would add to Jon's comments is that an18Q3/Q4 timeline may not be optimal for two reasons:
1. my understanding is that agreeing a Brexit transition timetable is likely to be done with the March EU meeting. So we will be only be 3-4 months into negotiations on a possible new trade deal, probably too early to clearly see the direction and I would expect AMLs value to be sensitive to this
2. While new Vantage will be in production then (with potentially peak orders), if I were covering the stock as a sell-side analyst the really exciting development from a P&L perspective would be DBX. This has he potential to be a massive cash cow for AML (just look at the Cayenne and Bentaga). But iirc production of that won't have begun in 18H2. So if I were Lazards I would be thinking 2019 for an IPO at the earliest
Might be fun to have a few shares in the company. And less likely to lose everything than Bitcoin
1. my understanding is that agreeing a Brexit transition timetable is likely to be done with the March EU meeting. So we will be only be 3-4 months into negotiations on a possible new trade deal, probably too early to clearly see the direction and I would expect AMLs value to be sensitive to this
2. While new Vantage will be in production then (with potentially peak orders), if I were covering the stock as a sell-side analyst the really exciting development from a P&L perspective would be DBX. This has he potential to be a massive cash cow for AML (just look at the Cayenne and Bentaga). But iirc production of that won't have begun in 18H2. So if I were Lazards I would be thinking 2019 for an IPO at the earliest
Might be fun to have a few shares in the company. And less likely to lose everything than Bitcoin

Mainly done to allow current investors a profitable exit in short/medium term - think Brexit has delayed IPO. Stock market downturn in future may also be an issue for timing.
They can already raise loan finance through debt issues.
No need for a carmaker to pay dividends in future as need to invest in future models - if shareholders want cash they can sell some shares.
Presumably they'll need a US listing as well (and a US set of statements every year (200 pages etc) on top of UK financial statements.
Personally I think they can do without 15-30 extra corporate staff and the accounting and reporting requirements.....
More importantly there are loads of management presentations to analysts and the requirements for steady growth and forecasts etc
Far too much time for management and AP in particular could lead to taking eye off the ball possibly.......
Oh and almost forgot in a downturn the shares dive and you're a Daimler Benz sub on the cheap ( or bought by a Chinese car co or Google etc from petty cash)
They can already raise loan finance through debt issues.
No need for a carmaker to pay dividends in future as need to invest in future models - if shareholders want cash they can sell some shares.
Presumably they'll need a US listing as well (and a US set of statements every year (200 pages etc) on top of UK financial statements.
Personally I think they can do without 15-30 extra corporate staff and the accounting and reporting requirements.....
More importantly there are loads of management presentations to analysts and the requirements for steady growth and forecasts etc
Far too much time for management and AP in particular could lead to taking eye off the ball possibly.......
Oh and almost forgot in a downturn the shares dive and you're a Daimler Benz sub on the cheap ( or bought by a Chinese car co or Google etc from petty cash)
Agreed
Not sure about the trade sale option either. I would have thought that any large manufacturer buying would put in jeopardy the Partnership with MB. Not insurmountable but would be a real headache to deal with
So presumably a sale would have to be to MB (or maybe a Chinese manufacturer that MB wants a partnership with?)
Not sure about the trade sale option either. I would have thought that any large manufacturer buying would put in jeopardy the Partnership with MB. Not insurmountable but would be a real headache to deal with
So presumably a sale would have to be to MB (or maybe a Chinese manufacturer that MB wants a partnership with?)
I don’t understand why MB don’t go the whole hog and buy AM. AM have shown what they can do if they have access to the right funding and the right technology. No specialist car manufacturer can expect to invest and generate the profits a venture capital firm or the stock market would demand. MB would gain a super classy top end halo brand with fantastic heritage and brilliant new products, and by sharing tech and the sort of thing MB are good at can make money where pure financial investors can’t.
Without MB Aston Martin are going to return to the old cycle of highs and lows, like a Premiership football team, and most importantly they are not going to have the credibility a high end car firm needs these days. AM is not a pure luxury brand like Moët or Louis Vuitton, they do not prosper by doing things the way they have been done for centuries, they have to be at the leading edge of technology, and the old way of doing things just isn’t acceptable to buyers who can buy cutting edge Bentley and Porsche products.
Without MB Aston Martin are going to return to the old cycle of highs and lows, like a Premiership football team, and most importantly they are not going to have the credibility a high end car firm needs these days. AM is not a pure luxury brand like Moët or Louis Vuitton, they do not prosper by doing things the way they have been done for centuries, they have to be at the leading edge of technology, and the old way of doing things just isn’t acceptable to buyers who can buy cutting edge Bentley and Porsche products.
V8 Vantage GT said:
Jesus, the mere mention of Aston being purchased by a Chinese company, or a Google? Makes me wretch. 

If more than 50% of the shares in a company are sold in a stock market flotation, then in theory, anyone could then buy the business.
Whenever someone decides to sell their entire shareholding, by arranging a public flotation, they will have 'long gone' by the time any subsequent transactions take place.
If that shareholder does not have majority ownership (hint), but is keen to have an initial public offering to sell their stake, do you think it might be considered unfair, that they exit the business, but then leave it at risk of a change of ownership to anyone?
Of course a private limited company can only be purchased by a party, who are approved by the majority of the existing shareholders, so there is an additional safeguard compared to a quoted public limited company, where open bidding can sometimes change opinions.
I don't know very much about it, but TVR was a private company. Was it willingly sold to the buyer?
Edited by Jon39 on Sunday 17th December 16:11
cardigankid said:
I don’t understand why MB don’t go the whole hog and buy AM. AM have shown what they can do if they have access to the right funding and the right technology. No specialist car manufacturer can expect to invest and generate the profits a venture capital firm or the stock market would demand. MB would gain a super classy top end halo brand with fantastic heritage and brilliant new products, and by sharing tech and the sort of thing MB are good at can make money where pure financial investors can’t.
Without MB Aston Martin are going to return to the old cycle of highs and lows, like a Premiership football team, and most importantly they are not going to have the credibility a high end car firm needs these days. AM is not a pure luxury brand like Moët or Louis Vuitton, they do not prosper by doing things the way they have been done for centuries, they have to be at the leading edge of technology, and the old way of doing things just isn’t acceptable to buyers who can buy cutting edge Bentley and Porsche products.
Dear God not Aston to the BWithout MB Aston Martin are going to return to the old cycle of highs and lows, like a Premiership football team, and most importantly they are not going to have the credibility a high end car firm needs these days. AM is not a pure luxury brand like Moët or Louis Vuitton, they do not prosper by doing things the way they have been done for centuries, they have to be at the leading edge of technology, and the old way of doing things just isn’t acceptable to buyers who can buy cutting edge Bentley and Porsche products.
y Germans!cardigankid said:
I don’t understand why MB don’t go the whole hog and buy AM. AM have shown what they can do if they have access to the right funding and the right technology. No specialist car manufacturer can expect to invest and generate the profits a venture capital firm or the stock market would demand. MB would gain a super classy top end halo brand with fantastic heritage and brilliant new products, and by sharing tech and the sort of thing MB are good at can make money where pure financial investors can’t.
Without MB Aston Martin are going to return to the old cycle of highs and lows, like a Premiership football team, and most importantly they are not going to have the credibility a high end car firm needs these days. AM is not a pure luxury brand like Moët or Louis Vuitton, they do not prosper by doing things the way they have been done for centuries, they have to be at the leading edge of technology, and the old way of doing things just isn’t acceptable to buyers who can buy cutting edge Bentley and Porsche products.
Please no. MB taking control would be the end of Aston Martin as Aston Martin. We already have the beginning of badge engineering with the bought-in (and credibility-killing IMO) Benz V8 engine. If Daimler buys Aston it's only a matter of time before an "Aston" is just a rebadged Mercedes. To those who may say that may be the only way for Aston Martin to "survive" -- that would NOT be surviving.Without MB Aston Martin are going to return to the old cycle of highs and lows, like a Premiership football team, and most importantly they are not going to have the credibility a high end car firm needs these days. AM is not a pure luxury brand like Moët or Louis Vuitton, they do not prosper by doing things the way they have been done for centuries, they have to be at the leading edge of technology, and the old way of doing things just isn’t acceptable to buyers who can buy cutting edge Bentley and Porsche products.
Speedraser said:
Please no. MB taking control would be the end of Aston Martin as Aston Martin.
As I have already mentioned, normally once a company as been floated on a stock market (with more than 50% of it's shares), they cannot select who might be the next owner, if a takeover bid occurs.
I see this as follows. Please say if it is wrong.
1. The majority owners following the purchase from Ford, have been Middle East based. They have shown to be content to be long-term owners.
2. When the Italian money arrived, it was from a Private Equity fund (PE). They generally operate on fairly short investment timescales. Often their money is raised from individual investors, who might want it back after say 5 years.
3. A stock market flotation (especially with the glamour and excitement of AML) might achieve a higher selling price than a trade sale. Remember the PE investor owns a significant portion of AML, but are not in a percentage position to sell the entire business.
Number 2 did help by raising more money needed for new model development, but we can now see the future ownership risk that was introduced at that point.
Does this seem logical to you ?
All makes sense (albeit a long long time ago when I worked in PE we used a 7-8 year timescale rather than 5 but sentiment unchanged).
The two complicating factors here are the existing partnership with MB (who I think also own 5%). That makes a trade sale unlikely except to MB (who don’t appear to have any interest in going in that direction).
And as I mentioned above the SUV is the potential cash cow for AML. I can’t see any investor selling before that is launched with a full order book, until then you potentially leave too much value on the table
The two complicating factors here are the existing partnership with MB (who I think also own 5%). That makes a trade sale unlikely except to MB (who don’t appear to have any interest in going in that direction).
And as I mentioned above the SUV is the potential cash cow for AML. I can’t see any investor selling before that is launched with a full order book, until then you potentially leave too much value on the table
Rob,
Why do you think Daimler wanted a 5% stake in AML?
I have not thought of a business reason, that would be of significant importance to them. You have just mentioned possibly influencing a sale, but even then, 5% does not carry much clout in a board or shareholder decision.
Their present supply contract might have future change of ownership conditions, but that can be achieved without needing a shareholding.
I think Daimler have seats on the AML board, so they know what is going on, but why would they want to know?
Daimler have such an enormous worldwide revenue, that even if they had full ownership of AML, it would be almost like a rounding error in their accounts. Almost akin to GSK buying one local chemist shop. A distraction of management time.
Have I overlooked something ?
Jon39 said:
Speedraser said:
Please no. MB taking control would be the end of Aston Martin as Aston Martin.
As I have already mentioned, normally once a company as been floated on a stock market (with more than 50% of it's shares), they cannot select who might be the next owner, if a takeover bid occurs.
I see this as follows. Please say if it is wrong.
1. The majority owners following the purchase from Ford, have been Middle East based. They have shown to be content to be long-term owners.
2. When the Italian money arrived, it was from a Private Equity fund (PE). They generally operate on fairly short investment timescales. Often their money is raised from individual investors, who might want it back after say 5 years.
3. A stock market flotation (especially with the glamour and excitement of AML) might achieve a higher selling price than a trade sale. Remember the PE investor owns a significant portion of AML, but are not in a percentage position to sell the entire business.
Number 2 did help by raising more money needed for new model development, but we can now see the future ownership risk that was introduced at that point.
Does this seem logical to you ?

LordBretSinclair said:
Speedraser said:
The same sad situation would likely occur if VW/Audi got control, or any number of other car firms. I can hope that doesn't happen, can't I 
Why ????? Lambo, Bentley and Bugatti seem to be doing well whilst keeping their own "identities".
Precisely because, to me, they've largely lost their identities. Shared platforms and/or shared engines IMO defeats the purpose of a car in this league. What are the odds that Bugatti, left to its own devices, would've developed a "W" engine configuration? I'd think there's NO chance. The Gallardo and Huracan share their engines and platforms with the R8. A Lambo should only be a Lamborghini, not also be an Audi, no matter how great a car the R8 is. The Urus is a Cayenne/Q7/Bentayga. Yuck. The Aventador is a Lamborghini. Conti GT/Spur are VW Phaetons underneath, which was front-wheel drive and is why the engine is almost cantilevered way out in front of the front wheels and why the proportions are wrong (far too much front overhang, front wheels too far back, etc.). The next one shares everything with the Panamera, etc. I'd want a Bentley to only be a Bentley, not also be a VW/Audi/Porsche. Bentley is making much of how, for the new/next Conti, they had to insist on some things -- that Porsche wanted to do differently -- during the "shared" development of the new shared platform, while also acknowledging that the soon-to-be outgoing Conti was something they had to develop from what they were given by VAG, and was heavily (no pun intended) compromised as a result. Shared platforms/engines are significant compromises for everyone who shares them. For mainstream cars perhaps that's tolerable, but IMO, at the Lambo, Bentley, Aston Martin level, sharing engines and platforms completely defeats the purpose of these cars. I know that gearboxes, brakes, electrical systems, etc. are shared, but for me, the line is drawn at the engine and the platform as these are the heart, soul and bones of a car. An Aston should be an Aston, a Lambo should be a Lambo, a Bentley should be a Bentley, and shared platforms/engines skewers that.Speedraser said:
largely lost their identities. Shared platforms and/or shared engines IMO defeats the purpose of a car in this league.
for me, the line is drawn at the engine and the platform as these are the heart, soul and bones of a car. An Aston should be an Aston, a Lambo should be a Lambo, a Bentley should be a Bentley, and shared platforms/engines skewers that.
The purest in me mostly agrees with you, the realist in me is resigned to the fact that due to crash, emissions, the need for reduced manufacturing complexity and cost share reasons (to name but a few) the default approach to car design is a ‘Group’ share of chassis, underpinnings, engines and electronic architecture with whatever brand ID ‘coach’ and interior plonked on top. In this climate only that approach to car design and production will appeal to shareholders meaning a luxury brand lives to fight another day, because the opposite (all or too many bespoke components) means a loss making venture unless the car company is the size of Porsche. Aston or any automaker at circa 10k units PA needs every bit of component share it can beg borrow or steal to get anywhere close to a profit.for me, the line is drawn at the engine and the platform as these are the heart, soul and bones of a car. An Aston should be an Aston, a Lambo should be a Lambo, a Bentley should be a Bentley, and shared platforms/engines skewers that.
Whilst that is indeed a sad scenario, it will unlikely ever change unfortunately unless Aston gets itself in the +20k units PA game, so all you can do is either leave the premium luxury sports car world or get over it and hope that each car is engineered to have an individual identity, which I think they can and do well. The Conti V8 driven back-to-back with Audi A8 or any other ‘Group’ car with the same platform and engine feels dynamically a totally different car and makes you feel you are in a very special car, imho.
One exception to the rule across the auto industry is Mulsanne, bespoke platform and engine, I’ve driven Mulsanne on road and track lots and beyond the Aston world Mulsanne is arguably the best car (I mean stately home) on the planet.
The final nail in the coffin to cars having bespoke fundamental components instead of Group or parent share is the looming demise of the IC engine, with that headstone in sight no car company like Aston is going to develop anything bespoke because the payback period would be too short.
I really do like to read your contributions and I do mainly share your purest views, but for your own sanity you need to reconcile in your head the reasons why premium luxury sports cars will not be bespoke from wider Group or parent, hope the engineers can create individual identities and enjoy premium luxury ICE sports cars before they become extinct. The only other option is leapfrog premium luxury sports car and go to world of hyper-car
Mike,
Thanks for your insight -- I'm always very interested in your comments given your knowledge and experience in the industry. Thanks, also, for looking out for my sanity
I realize that all of this is extremely expensive, I really do, and of course the companies need to be profitable. But -- in their efforts to maximize profits (yes, I understand shareholder obligations), they're willing to "sacrifice" -- in my view -- the product to so. I do understand that from a business perspective, I really do. However, from my perspective as a consumer/buyer, I want products to be available that I want to buy. Genuine question; if they don't share platforms/engines, would they still be able to make money -- if not as much money? The price of the cars may need to rise (perhaps beyond my reach), but at least it would be the real thing. If it's priced above my ability to afford it, I'd rather buy a used example of the real thing than a new example of a shared-platformed/engined something. The "default approach to car design" as you put it is such a shame. I came to love Aston Martins because they're Aston Martins -- not merely pretty cars with Benz engines. You mention the Mulsanne -- I love that because it's the real thing, whereas the Contis don't interest me at all. I agree that a Conti feels different from an A8, but I simply have no interest in it because I know what it is -- and what it isn't.
I may never buy another new enthusiast car again, and that makes me sad.
How is McLaren doing it? They're not sharing engines or platforms and they're making fewer than 10k cars/year.
Thanks for your insight -- I'm always very interested in your comments given your knowledge and experience in the industry. Thanks, also, for looking out for my sanity

I realize that all of this is extremely expensive, I really do, and of course the companies need to be profitable. But -- in their efforts to maximize profits (yes, I understand shareholder obligations), they're willing to "sacrifice" -- in my view -- the product to so. I do understand that from a business perspective, I really do. However, from my perspective as a consumer/buyer, I want products to be available that I want to buy. Genuine question; if they don't share platforms/engines, would they still be able to make money -- if not as much money? The price of the cars may need to rise (perhaps beyond my reach), but at least it would be the real thing. If it's priced above my ability to afford it, I'd rather buy a used example of the real thing than a new example of a shared-platformed/engined something. The "default approach to car design" as you put it is such a shame. I came to love Aston Martins because they're Aston Martins -- not merely pretty cars with Benz engines. You mention the Mulsanne -- I love that because it's the real thing, whereas the Contis don't interest me at all. I agree that a Conti feels different from an A8, but I simply have no interest in it because I know what it is -- and what it isn't.
I may never buy another new enthusiast car again, and that makes me sad.
How is McLaren doing it? They're not sharing engines or platforms and they're making fewer than 10k cars/year.
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


