Aston as track car
Author
Discussion

SteveZissou

Original Poster:

15 posts

107 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
Hi

I am a currently a Porsche owner with a older generation 911. It's not very suited for track mainly due to lack of power and the whole configuration on the car being optimized for road.

I always wanted an Aston Martin, and the only reason for getting into a 911 back when I bought the one I have now is due to advice given from non-Aston owners - typical warnings about these cars breaking down 5 times for each time the 911 needs a oil change.

Now I am so attached to my 911 which I have lived with for 6-7 years that selling it is not an option. I am however really itching to get into track days and driving some of the amazing tracks we have around europe and doing AutoCross and trackday clubs. It's all gonna be on a hobby level and I will never race nor do I have ambitions to set any records. I'm just in it for the thrill and the smell wink

As per auto-pilot I have so far only looked at 911s - older generation (997) GT3's. But it occured to me that maybe I had an opportunity here to combine my lifelong dream of owning an aston with my trackday itch. Specifically I am looking at older Vantage V8's.

I have searched this forum quite a lot and what I have learned so far speaks both for and against:

- They are heavy, so much so that some people say it's not really worth taking it to the track
- They do have the power
- There might be clutch-issues with hard use

My questions are:

1) Would you advice against a Vantage V8?

2) If not, would a 2007-2009 model be worth looking at?

3) I'd would of course do some track mods. Especially if I got a older V8 vantage I would have some budget to do new suspension, aero, track brakepads, race-bucket seats and such

What upgrades would you recommend? Wing is a obligatory for me as I think Astons with a big wing is just about the coolest thing ever produced by mankind.

If you have any specific recommendations for the best track-focused suspension to fit on a V8 I'd love to hear about brand and model so I can look into it.

4) Since weight is and issue - what can be done about that relatively other than swapping seats for lightweight buckets?

5) It's my impression that the engine is rather solid. Would yo be nervous about using it for track. As I mentioned in the beginning I am not going to race - just run with the VW Golf's and stuff at trackdays and get a lot of hours with an instructor.

6) Is the sportshift auto-gear useable?

7) Am I crazy? Should I just run back to a GT3, Cayman S PDK.


If you have advice or experience you can share I'd love to hear it!


Thanks!


Edited by SteveZissou on Wednesday 27th December 15:41

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
An older Vantage will be the 4.3, which I think you'll find a bit slow for the track. The engines are very robust and there are some good upgrades, but they're not cheap. I doubt there's a huge amount you could do to reduce the weight.

I would say a Cayman would be a better choice as a track car!


RobDown

3,807 posts

159 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
I love these rumours put about as to Aston reliability (and this from Porsche and it’s self-destructing engines!).

My advice would be convert the 911 for the track and get the Aston for the road! smile

SteveZissou

Original Poster:

15 posts

107 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
4.7 model is within in budget if that is a gamechanger.

Caymans has 320 horses - is the weight disadvantage of the Vantage with approx 100 horses more really not making up for that?

Vantagemech

5,733 posts

246 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
I know a little bit about tracking these, but only a bit....
Weight wise, the GT4 with a decent sized cage came in at 1340 kgs, around 200 kgs less than the road car IIRC. If you dont want a cage Id say it would be a little less but the race car was heavily stripped with poly windows, no pass seat, no leather anything etc..

They are ridiculously strong chassis wise, but wings and bumpers fall off at the slightest touch and although 2nd hand bits are around, youll pay £200+ for an old wing and the same for a bumper. Headlights are eye watering... anything from £400 - £1000....

Brakes are the massive weakness. And I mean massive. The standard front discs and calipers (brembo) are cooked within a few high speed laps and once the fluid starts to heat up, the caliper seals go and in worse cases senarios the pedal goes soft and then.....Rears are not so bad. Usually wear 2 - 3 sets of front pads to a set of rears
You need to put a huge amount of cooling to the brakes along with bigger discs.
The TCS/DSC doesnt help much on track so the trick is to keep switching it off or pull the plug off the steering sensor under the column.

4.7 are obviously better due to more torque, for a beginner the sportshift is probably the way to go, Ive seen several V8 manuals st the prop and even throw a leg out of bed on a 6 to 1 downshift... it does happen....the auto wont allow this.

Its a heavy car and will eat tyres - we found the michelin trackday tyre (name evades me) the best - was only a few seconds off the slick times - though horrific in the wet! Budget for a set of rain tyres if you can.

Invest in a set of decent coilovers, the exhausts are OK but keep an eye on the cats (or take them off) as they can destroy themselves and performance rear silencers - saves a bit of weight.










anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
SteveZissou said:
Hi

I am a currently a Porsche owner with a older generation 911. It's not very suited for track mainly due to lack of power and the whole configuration on the car being optimized for road.

I always wanted an Aston Martin, and the only reason for getting into a 911 back when I bought the one I have now is due to advice given from non-Aston owners - typical warnings about these cars breaking down 5 times for each time the 911 needs a oil change.

Now I am so attached to my 911 which I have lived with for 6-7 years that selling it is not an option. I am however really itching to get into track days and driving some of the amazing tracks we have around europe and doing AutoCross and trackday clubs. It's all gonna be on a hobby level and I will never race nor do I have ambitions to set any records. I'm just in it for the thrill and the smell wink

As per auto-pilot I have so far only looked at 911s - older generation (997) GT3's. But it occured to me that maybe I had an opportunity here to combine my lifelong dream of owning an aston with my trackday itch. Specifically I am looking at older Vantage V8's.

I have searched this forum quite a lot and what I have learned so far speaks both for and against:

- They are heavy, so much so that some people say it's not really worth taking it to the track
- They do have the power
- There might be clutch-issues with hard use

My questions are:

1) Would you advice against a Vantage V8?

2) If not, would a 2007-2009 model be worth looking at?

3) I'd would of course do some track mods. Especially if I got a older V8 vantage I would have some budget to do new suspension, aero, track brakepads, race-bucket seats and such

What upgrades would you recommend? Wing is a obligatory for me as I think Astons with a big wing is just about the coolest thing ever produced by mankind.

If you have any specific recommendations for the best track-focused suspension to fit on a V8 I'd love to hear about brand and model so I can look into it.

4) Since weight is and issue - what can be done about that relatively other than swapping seats for lightweight buckets?

5) It's my impression that the engine is rather solid. Would yo be nervous about using it for track. As I mentioned in the beginning I am not going to race - just run with the VW Golf's and stuff at trackdays and get a lot of hours with an instructor.

6) Is the sportshift auto-gear useable?

7) Am I crazy? Should I just run back to a GT3, Cayman S PDK.


If you have advice or experience you can share I'd love to hear it!


Thanks!
1) Absolutely not, they're awesome, the handling's wonderful and there's enough kickback in the steering to know what's going on under you at all times. The myth that they're slow is just that. It's probably easier to drive a Porsche quickly, but not as rewarding (just my 2p worth).
2) As noted above, earlier cars are 4.3's rather than the 4.7. The 4.7 has more grunt, and if it's a track toy, either engine would benefit from a cat delete and change of exhaust system (weight loss and power gain). Not mega expensive in either case, to drop 20kg ish and gain perhaps 40bhp.
3) Budget will dictate what you spend and where. Some fully adjustable suspension kits are available for not mega bucks (£3k ish perhaps).
4) They're heavier than the equivalent Porsche, but put on a strict diet can get down to a useful featherweight. If you have the budget for panel replacement, most of the body should be available in glass or carbon. Taking things to the extreme, from memory the GT4 tipped the scales at around 1350kg (ETA, weight mentioned above!), so not dissimilar to a Cayman S. The elephant in the room here is the amount you'd spend to get there. Undertake the same mods on a Cayman and it'll blow away in a strong breeze.
5) The engine's bullet proof, though it might like some cooling upgrades if it's going to be used dynamically on track.
6) The Sportshift box is great fun when you're pressing on. It probably makes more sense on track than on the road due to its less than buttery smooth operation (race cars are meant to beat you up, it's the rules). I'm unsure on durability for prolonged track driving though.
7) It's one of the more difficult routes to go down to achieve a track weapon. That's not to say it's a bad route, but you'd possibly find a Cayman, 911 etc a cheaper option to achieve the same end goal. The trouble comes when you factor in the sub zero cool factor that comes with having a track focused Vantage that'll look and sound better than most things appearing at a track day... biggrin

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all

One of the people on this forum Steve, with knowledge of what you want to do, is Kevin Bird.
There are some other racers and track day enthusuasts too, but you may enjoy watching a video showing the capabilities of Kevin's Aston Martin Vantage on track.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HGxT_fOGyI

You might wish to consider buying a GT4 Vantage. Quite a number have been produced, and some are road registered, so it appears they can be made road legal. Sometimes buying a ready prepared track car, can be a cheaper way than preparing a road car for track use. A road and trackcar is of course a compromise, probably not being completely suited for either use. I think the Aston Martin Racing Website (ie. Prodrive) sometimes lists customer cars which are for sale.

Be very careful when looking at that website though. wink
You might be tempted by one of the glorious GT3 cars for sale. Imagine the fun you could have with one of those on a track !
You would need a trailer of course.











Edited by Jon39 on Wednesday 27th December 19:05

Vantagemech

5,733 posts

246 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
Problem with buying an N24/ GT4 will be price and parts. I doubt youll find anything under £75k with any sort of spares package.
Plus they arent cheap and to SVA it costs about £8k if youve got all the bits.
There are a handful of N24's road registered but theyre not much fun on the road.

just to add, I ran quite a few of these over the last decade in AMOC, Euro GT4 , Britcar, BGT and Creventic. smile


Edited by Vantagemech on Wednesday 27th December 17:03

OLDBENZ

471 posts

167 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
I have had an Aston Martin N24 race car for 7 years. This is a factory produced racer based on the V8 Vantage.
Production subsequently moved to Prodrive and it became the GT4. My car is a 4.3 and runs through a manual box.

My car has approx. 10,000 km of race and track miles on without any major component failure or rebuild. It originally ran in the Asia Cup Series (before I bought it) and I have run it in the factory GT4 Challenge. I think a power steering pump has been the biggest mechanical issue. All other failures have sadly been driver related. I have no complaints on the reliability front. There was a certain amount of toughening up the mechanics for the race car but not as much as you would think and I would expect the Vantage road car would make a good reliable basis for a track car.

It is a pretty exciting car to drive with a lovely neutral set up. The last few years I have just done the odd track day and have hired a pro BTCC or endurance driver for the day. Invariably, they have good things to say about the car.

I would not get too excited about whether you have a 4.3 or a 4.7 engine if you are not racing. Your progress around the track is much more likely to be influenced by your wheelmanship than those extra 400cc. We - well my BTCC co-driver - put my car second on the grid among a field of 4.7s at Brands Hatch a few years ago. I have also heard it said that the 4.3 is a slightly stronger unit but I cannot comment on that.

I rather enjoy the manual transmission. Undoubtedly the paddle shift is faster to race but for a track day there is something rewarding about the extra involvement you get from third pedal.

In summary, go for it! There are plenty of specialists with experience of running Aston race cars to help with mods and parts if you start with a road car.






ExVantagemech..

5,733 posts

246 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
OLDBENZ said:
I have had an Aston Martin N24 race car for 7 years. This is a factory produced racer based on the V8 Vantage.
Production subsequently moved to Prodrive and it became the GT4. My car is a 4.3 and runs through a manual box.

My car has approx. 10,000 km of race and track miles on without any major component failure or rebuild. It originally ran in the Asia Cup Series (before I bought it) and I have run it in the factory GT4 Challenge. I think a power steering pump has been the biggest mechanical issue. All other failures have sadly been driver related. I have no complaints on the reliability front. There was a certain amount of toughening up the mechanics for the race car but not as much as you would think and I would expect the Vantage road car would make a good reliable basis for a track car.

It is a pretty exciting car to drive with a lovely neutral set up. The last few years I have just done the odd track day and have hired a pro BTCC or endurance driver for the day. Invariably, they have good things to say about the car.

I would not get too excited about whether you have a 4.3 or a 4.7 engine if you are not racing. Your progress around the track is much more likely to be influenced by your wheelmanship than those extra 400cc. We - well my BTCC co-driver - put my car second on the grid among a field of 4.7s at Brands Hatch a few years ago. I have also heard it said that the 4.3 is a slightly stronger unit but I cannot comment on that.

I rather enjoy the manual transmission. Undoubtedly the paddle shift is faster to race but for a track day there is something rewarding about the extra involvement you get from third pedal.

In summary, go for it! There are plenty of specialists with experience of running Aston race cars to help with mods and parts if you start with a road car.
The original 4.3 were build by Ricardo using Arrow rods and had some head work carried out, bigger inlet valves I believe. These were stronger engines than the AMR 4.7 engines which were in the first cars crate engines using standard rods. They took the engine from 380 to around 410 bhp.
Later engines have uprated rods and valves, primarily as they had some failures.

As you mention it, the PAS pumps were/ are a weak point - though they whine loudly they dont seem to fail so often. One put us out of a 3rd in a 12hr race - it was 8 hrs old.....

Clutches are the other point to mention, a road clutch wont handle track running.

AMDBSVNick

7,221 posts

193 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
RobDown said:
I love these rumours put about as to Aston reliability (and this from Porsche and it’s self-destructing engines!).

My advice would be convert the 911 for the track and get the Aston for the road! smile

J12MOC

802 posts

175 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all


Do it!

SteveZissou

Original Poster:

15 posts

107 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
There is so much great information in this thread. Thank you everyone who replied.

At this point I believe consensus is:

- Engine: These cars are powerful enough to enjoy on the track, engine is strong and the 4.3 will have enough power to feel the rush down the Monza straight or through Eau rouge. 4.7 has more grunt, but perhaps somewhat less reliable. If I can make a deal on a 4.7 I'll do that otherwise a 4.3 with more budget for upgrades is also okay. To my surprise everyone here says the engines are rather bulletproof.

- Weight: is an issue and will probably require mega-bucks to make comparable to a Porsche. Generally this car will not be the same technically ideal starting point as a Cayman S, but not much is and the grin-factor with the Aston outweighs technical upperhand (purely my personal preference). My experience is that the fun is when you drive a car to it's limit - something tells me I will be able to do that with the Aston. I have had a hard time getting excited for a second Porsche, but this Aston project would be so awesome.

- Mods: Brakes incl. cooling should be on the top of the list. I would probably begin with "just" upgrading brakes, the wing and tyres. Then a little later on suspension, bucket seats, perhaps cage and at some point I would absolutely upgrade the whole exhaust system to free up some extra power.

- Gearbox: The Sportshift is useable for track duty. Some would probably prefer manual, but I am doing this as a social project where I will bring friends along for most trips, so removing the risk of overrevs is a big positive.


3 questions:

1) Where do I look for parts online - wings/aero, suspension? Europe/UK dealers preferred. I'd like to make a budget.

2) This is just a random car that sits perfectly in my budget + I like the wheels and the fact that it has a black interior (I like coloured interiors for road cars). What do your trained eyes think about this car as a candidate:
https://suchen.mobile.de/fahrzeuge/details.html?id...

3) With mu 911 am used to a service being a change of fluids and filters. Is it more Ferrari-like with these cars? Are there crazy cambelt, timing chains or biennial "Engine out" operations that makes servicing these cars more troublesome than most regular cars? I suppose what I am asking is that everything above sounds pretty good, so I am trying to figure out if I am missing some major downside. To me a downside would be a very limited selection of repair/service shops in Denmark - I believe we have just one "official" dealer.

Graze01

1,203 posts

123 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
you could contact Rich at Redpants for some comments

he regularly tracks his 4.3L and has done quite a bit to reduce weight & improve braking

http://www.redpants.lol/

Graeme

cptsideways

13,904 posts

283 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
Might also be worth looking into the Jag options wink


There were some not that expensive ex Palmersport Jags about, fully prepped & well sorted for track work, if a little worn in places. There was quite a few of them so should be easy to find one.

ExVantagemech..

5,733 posts

246 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
Under racing conditions AMR recommend 7k engine refresh, the body comes off the running gear so a reasonably big job. This in track days would probably be 3 - 4 years. Run them on Castrol (same as the M power 0/60 IIRC). They take between 11 and 13 ltrs .
Gearboxes a little more, they are Graziano (the only UK dealer is in StNeots, a great bunch and if youre nice and say its a race box they will do a refresh) Be aware, the ring and pinion can sometimes become pitted, in that case its about £6k for a rebuilt box with a new R&P. Oil change after every couple of days running.
Watch out for the pas pump overflowing fluid on track. If its bad it will soak the front wheel in fluid..You can block the vent but I had larger res. made up with baffles and a better vent system.
FEAD belts can jump off - especially with cars with AC. It was an option but most of the race cars took them off as its not much fun losing the pas, water pump and alt all at once. Replace the tensioner annually.

The AMR aero kit is pricey, about £13k for the carbon extension and the rear wing. The cars understeer quite badly to start so set up is quite crucial. The race cars were running the same size tyres front and rear in many series (made the car more balanced) but they run 10x18 and 11x18 rims. The V12 bootlid has a bigger rear lip than the V8, it was an upgrade in 2011, before they went to the full aero kit of wing etc.
I certainly wouldnt recommend fitting a rear wing without sorting the front, the car needs balance. You'd get away with more front end but somewhere like Spa you'd need both.

Astonmartinbits often has current bits and bobs theres also a few companies that do polycarb screens and carnbon fenders etc.




BravoV8V

1,858 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
To the OP - fundamentally, road going Astons don’t make for great track cars. Essentially, they are too heavy. And if/when things wear out, they are expensive to replace.

If you go to the bother of stripping out the weight (interior, HVAC, OEM wheels etc etc), you lose the essence of what makes them lovely on the road.

My advice? Buy a Lotus. An Evora is probably what would work best for you, especially if you’re after a very capable road/track car.


(FWIW, I went from a BR’d 4.3 V8V to an Evora S. I’ve never regretted it for a second).

SteveZissou

Original Poster:

15 posts

107 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the input. Really, I really appreciate it!

I am not looking for a GREAT track car, but more the car that gets my blood pumping. I like lotuses, but I like astons a whole lot more. If I choose to go the sensible route I will get a Porsche as I already have the whole network in place.

I watched a bunch of youtube videos tonight with stock V8V's and to me they look like a hoot - more than fullfill my ambitions. And in the second part of this review Tiff gets quite excited about it's track capabilities:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=42wuEYbj9lc

Not trying to argue what you are saying is wrong at all, I respect and value your input. But I knew getting into this discussion that Astons wouldn't be the ideal choice if choose with common sense, but if I figure in the fact that I can have a Aston in my garage with a huge GT wing and over time personalize it and feel how it evolves as money and time allows - I'm quite excited about that journey. And you are the first one to really advice against it.


quench

564 posts

177 months

Wednesday 27th December 2017
quotequote all
Like most street cars, they are alright at 7 or 8 tenths, but as noted above the brakes on the V8 are a massive limitation. CCMs on the V12 - much better.

You referred to Lotus. I know you say that you like Aston more, but you will get far more enjoyment and a far better (consistently faster, more extended and less expensive) experience with a Lotus on track. They are one of the few road cars that really can do track days with little if any modification.

JohnG1

3,487 posts

236 months

Thursday 28th December 2017
quotequote all
OP:

I looked at buying a cat D 4.3 V8 and then rebuilding as a track toy. At that time the rebuild of the tub (it was bent) had to be done by AML in Gaydon and it was very expensive. So that idea died.

Next up was to buy a high miles/ugly colour/unloved 4.3 v8 and hand it to Bamford Rose to strip it down into a track toy. So lighter seat, roll-call, fuel tank, remove nvh, n400 valved inlet system (wonder who's idea that was?), exhaust manifolds, race cats and rework the gearbox. Strip the box, shot-peen, polish, lightweight flywheel and twin-plate clutch.

Big wing and also therefore frontal aerodynamic work to keep the car balanced.

Real life interrupted that plan, but Mike at Bamford Rose would be a splendid port of call for a chat around what to do and how much it would cost.