Selling my V8Vantage Roadster....did I make a mistake?
Discussion
Ok, I spent about 9 months looking for my perfect V8 4.3 Vantage Roadster and finally found it in October 2016 at the Walton on Thames dealership. Toro Red, with only 25k on the clock and with unmarked paintwork and interior. It was by far the best I’d looked at and thought to myself....how much better would the next one need to be for it to be better than this? So I pulled the trigger and went for it.
My initial thoughts were for my wife to use it once or twice a week for work and for the odd nice weekend trip out to the pub at the near by South Downs. However, the problem seemed to be that because it was so good I found myself not wanting to ruin it or run up the mileage too much to retain some residual value. This became such a problem that we ended up hardly using it at all, with only the occasional trip here and there just to keep the mechanicals from seizing. The upshot is that it did 1700 miles last year....mot to mot and I took it out yesterday for the first time since December 4th! nearly 2 months ago.
So, the conclusion is that I think I made the mistake of buying a too nicer car when I should’ve bought a cheaper one with a few bangs and scrapes that I wouldn’t of worried about. I’ve now decided to put it up for sale soon because it’s just not being used in the way I thought it would.....am I right? Have you ever made the same mistake? Will try and post a pic if I can work out how to do it.....
My initial thoughts were for my wife to use it once or twice a week for work and for the odd nice weekend trip out to the pub at the near by South Downs. However, the problem seemed to be that because it was so good I found myself not wanting to ruin it or run up the mileage too much to retain some residual value. This became such a problem that we ended up hardly using it at all, with only the occasional trip here and there just to keep the mechanicals from seizing. The upshot is that it did 1700 miles last year....mot to mot and I took it out yesterday for the first time since December 4th! nearly 2 months ago.
So, the conclusion is that I think I made the mistake of buying a too nicer car when I should’ve bought a cheaper one with a few bangs and scrapes that I wouldn’t of worried about. I’ve now decided to put it up for sale soon because it’s just not being used in the way I thought it would.....am I right? Have you ever made the same mistake? Will try and post a pic if I can work out how to do it.....
Big Al. said:
I would advise against that or the thread may get pulled for advertising. 
Eh? I’m not advertising.....just posing the question....it’s not up for sale yet. This post was only spurned by me looking at it on the drive and thinking that it’s too good to drive....which is ridiculous! I’ve got myself into a position with it that I was determined not to get into. 
I do think perhaps you are over cautious. They dont drop a huge amount in value due to being used (avg miles). I put 83k miles on my old one, had the wheels refurbished a couple of times over 9 years, it did need paint in places when i traded it in. But the difference in trade in value between mint and needs a few jobs...well its not that much when the dealer is doing the prep work at cost price.
They are meant to be used and enjoyed...the MORE miles you put on it, the CHEAPER per mile of fun it becomes
e.g. I could have sold my old car 5 years earlier with 1/2 the mileage on it for xxx value. I decided to keep it and wait for the right 4.7 I wanted. 5 years later I had doubled the mileage and the trade price had dropped by £6k. fair enough there is inflation in there, but £6k to drive a Vantage for another 40k miles seems pretty good VFM for me.
So if you put 20k miles on your mint car, it might have cost you a few grand .....you are going to lose that just in the margin buying/selling cars, so you may as well at least get the 20K miles of pleasure out of it first...at least thats my logic
They are meant to be used and enjoyed...the MORE miles you put on it, the CHEAPER per mile of fun it becomes

e.g. I could have sold my old car 5 years earlier with 1/2 the mileage on it for xxx value. I decided to keep it and wait for the right 4.7 I wanted. 5 years later I had doubled the mileage and the trade price had dropped by £6k. fair enough there is inflation in there, but £6k to drive a Vantage for another 40k miles seems pretty good VFM for me.
So if you put 20k miles on your mint car, it might have cost you a few grand .....you are going to lose that just in the margin buying/selling cars, so you may as well at least get the 20K miles of pleasure out of it first...at least thats my logic

I think it is quite easy to get into the mindset of wanting to keep the car mint. Oh it might rain, oh not sure where i would park, oh putting a few miles on.... you are not alone. It is perfectly natural to want your car to remain pristine, thats what washing it does
.
Surely you bought it to enjoy it. So forget about what it might be worth one day if you decide to sell it and enjoy having and using it now. If the financial cost of using it is too great then yes you should sell, otherwise enjoy the fruits of your labour.
.Surely you bought it to enjoy it. So forget about what it might be worth one day if you decide to sell it and enjoy having and using it now. If the financial cost of using it is too great then yes you should sell, otherwise enjoy the fruits of your labour.
My thoughts FWW
I doubt however much you keep the miles down it will have a significant effect on value unless you are going to keep it for 10/20 years but there will still probably too many of them around for it to have huge value. That’s if we are collecting/driving such cars then.
If the paintwork is as immaculate as you say then have it protected with PPF. My car collected someone else’s parcel shelf in Italy once and looked like there was a far bit of damage. Once it was all polished out you would never have know.
Kerbed wheels. It will happen and just get them fixed!
Keeping the interior looking good. You sound like someone who looks after his car, the interior will be fine.
All in all I would say use your car and enjoy it. It is a fabulous car and needs to be driven. If you can’t get over your concerns then probably best to pass it on to someone else’s custodianship. Only you can make that decision.
I doubt however much you keep the miles down it will have a significant effect on value unless you are going to keep it for 10/20 years but there will still probably too many of them around for it to have huge value. That’s if we are collecting/driving such cars then.
If the paintwork is as immaculate as you say then have it protected with PPF. My car collected someone else’s parcel shelf in Italy once and looked like there was a far bit of damage. Once it was all polished out you would never have know.
Kerbed wheels. It will happen and just get them fixed!
Keeping the interior looking good. You sound like someone who looks after his car, the interior will be fine.
All in all I would say use your car and enjoy it. It is a fabulous car and needs to be driven. If you can’t get over your concerns then probably best to pass it on to someone else’s custodianship. Only you can make that decision.
As the youngsters say now YOLO (which I think translates as you only live once).
Use it and enjoy it. As many have said the value:mileage ratio on a V8 Vantage is stacked in favour of using it. And who cares if you kerb an alloy, it’s a £100 fix, annoying but not the end of the world
Its a car, not a family heirloom!!!
Use it and enjoy it. As many have said the value:mileage ratio on a V8 Vantage is stacked in favour of using it. And who cares if you kerb an alloy, it’s a £100 fix, annoying but not the end of the world
Its a car, not a family heirloom!!!

I have been looking for a cheap sport shift for a little while with the same view, basically buy something cheap and just use it.
The problem I am finding is that a crappy 60k 2007 sport shift is probably £33k and a really nice 30k one is probably £35k
Maybe it because I am looking at the bottom of the market but there doesn't seem to be much spread I pricing.
The cost to rectify issues on the cheap one I saw last week is probably £3k for a clutch, £1k for a service couple of wheels and paint call it £750 and a few other bits and bobs, so your probably £5k
So £38k all in makes the cheap one look expensive if that makes sense !!
I would keep it and use it ! Better a car you know.
Phib
The problem I am finding is that a crappy 60k 2007 sport shift is probably £33k and a really nice 30k one is probably £35k
Maybe it because I am looking at the bottom of the market but there doesn't seem to be much spread I pricing.
The cost to rectify issues on the cheap one I saw last week is probably £3k for a clutch, £1k for a service couple of wheels and paint call it £750 and a few other bits and bobs, so your probably £5k
So £38k all in makes the cheap one look expensive if that makes sense !!
I would keep it and use it ! Better a car you know.
Phib
phib said:
I have been looking for a cheap sport shift for a little while with the same view, basically buy something cheap and just use it.
The problem I am finding is that a crappy 60k 2007 sport shift is probably £33k and a really nice 30k one is probably £35k
Maybe it because I am looking at the bottom of the market but there doesn't seem to be much spread I pricing.
The cost to rectify issues on the cheap one I saw last week is probably £3k for a clutch, £1k for a service couple of wheels and paint call it £750 and a few other bits and bobs, so your probably £5k
So £38k all in makes the cheap one look expensive if that makes sense !!
I would keep it and use it ! Better a car you know.
Phib
I agree that there’s often not much range, and it can be a false economy to buy right at the bottom of the market....better to spend a bit more on one with recent consumables done. Incidentally, I doubt you’ll find any early roadster (never mind a “really nice one” with 30k miles for £35k - even a sportshift is going to be more like £40k+.The problem I am finding is that a crappy 60k 2007 sport shift is probably £33k and a really nice 30k one is probably £35k
Maybe it because I am looking at the bottom of the market but there doesn't seem to be much spread I pricing.
The cost to rectify issues on the cheap one I saw last week is probably £3k for a clutch, £1k for a service couple of wheels and paint call it £750 and a few other bits and bobs, so your probably £5k
So £38k all in makes the cheap one look expensive if that makes sense !!
I would keep it and use it ! Better a car you know.
Phib
OP - if you don’t think you’ll get enjoyment out of ownership then sell, but as others have said - a bit of use won’t kill the value, and if you kerb a wheel it can be easily repaired! I find that my concern/care for my cars is irrespective of value; it’s just whether you’re someone that looks after stuff!
Edited by johnnyBv8 on Sunday 4th February 09:31
Option 1, Sell it, buy a cheap old knacker to run around in, something that you can park anywhere, then every night before bed log in to your bank account and look at those extra digits sitting there making 0.05% interest, if you sit on the money for long enough it can then eventually be used help with your care home costs to save the government having to give you any of your tax & NI contributions back.
Option 2, Keep it and enjoy it while you can.
Option 2, Keep it and enjoy it while you can.
These cars are meant to be driven and owned by people that adore them and cherish them. If you can afford to service it and insure it - then who cares about the miles. I say keep it, enjoy it, mod it, show it off, wash it, polish it, and smile in it as much as you can. You get one go around - don't waste it because of a few quid.
I often have similar thoughts as I moved a couple of years ago and the Aston does not fit the garage, well it does but I would need to put the roof down to get out and it seems a shame to leave it outside, add this to having a back problem that limits my use it sometimes feels pointless having it (7k in 4 years).
Only a couple of weeks ago someone I know died at 42, he was older than me and dare I say it much healthier and for the last couple of years had been looking at buying an F Type or Vantage as he was going to do it for his 40th but his wife talked him out of it. Sad thing is despite being able to afford it he never took the plunge which reminds me we should enjoy what we have.
I also take the attitude to enjoy the car and not leave it as a garage queen, not neglect it but I try not to worry about stone chips etc as they can be put right when you upgrade, I do however store the car for the winter months and avoid any salted roads.
If you can afford it and it gives you pleasure keep it!
Only a couple of weeks ago someone I know died at 42, he was older than me and dare I say it much healthier and for the last couple of years had been looking at buying an F Type or Vantage as he was going to do it for his 40th but his wife talked him out of it. Sad thing is despite being able to afford it he never took the plunge which reminds me we should enjoy what we have.
I also take the attitude to enjoy the car and not leave it as a garage queen, not neglect it but I try not to worry about stone chips etc as they can be put right when you upgrade, I do however store the car for the winter months and avoid any salted roads.
If you can afford it and it gives you pleasure keep it!
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




