Lister Thunder or new Vantage
Discussion
Launch of the Lister Thunder is interesting, looks like it has the performance and actually looks good.
I so wanted the new Vantage to be beautiful, in fact the plan was to buy my 4.7, then trade up when the new one was available. However I don't think the new design is for me, and the AMG engine...
Don't want to start another "ugly Vantage" thread, but the Lister comes at a very interesting time. Home grown 600+ V8, long history to the company and only 99 cars- for £140k!
The F-type shape has always been good, just no AM Vantage, but the AM competition is now not so strong, and limited edition Lister is very tempting.
I so wanted the new Vantage to be beautiful, in fact the plan was to buy my 4.7, then trade up when the new one was available. However I don't think the new design is for me, and the AMG engine...
Don't want to start another "ugly Vantage" thread, but the Lister comes at a very interesting time. Home grown 600+ V8, long history to the company and only 99 cars- for £140k!
The F-type shape has always been good, just no AM Vantage, but the AM competition is now not so strong, and limited edition Lister is very tempting.
Mmm...V12V Roadster for me at that price ....the Lister Thunder seems like a similar concept to an Overfinch Range Rover. Its the best Jag F type you can make... bespoke build by a good company...but it still looks like a Jag F type. Great car no doubt but I dont prefer the Jag over a Vantage cosmetically, no matter how much power it has.
If you are a power junkie then a used V12 Vantage and get the engine modded with the spare cash...
If you are a power junkie then a used V12 Vantage and get the engine modded with the spare cash...
new Vantage
I'm in a minority but I prefer it to the old Vantage. Not a fan of the jag. But really you shouldn't be worried about the AMG engine, it's great, OK it has turbos which I'm not a fan of but so will the jag. The AMG engine has a great sound track (for a turbo) and delivers the power really well, you will love it!
I'm in a minority but I prefer it to the old Vantage. Not a fan of the jag. But really you shouldn't be worried about the AMG engine, it's great, OK it has turbos which I'm not a fan of but so will the jag. The AMG engine has a great sound track (for a turbo) and delivers the power really well, you will love it!I'd prefer the V12V or new Vantage options over that I think. Nothing against F-types but at that price it seems expensive, plus that one is black on black with extra black.
The other thing with the F type that has always bugged me is the interior. Is the average age of a Jag owner that old that they need to put a grab-handle on the centre console? It's like a toilet in a retirement home. Still, I'm sure DB9 owners will appreciate it
The other thing with the F type that has always bugged me is the interior. Is the average age of a Jag owner that old that they need to put a grab-handle on the centre console? It's like a toilet in a retirement home. Still, I'm sure DB9 owners will appreciate it

David W. said:
Thanks, David i wondered what it was.My vote goes for a V12V.
Nice though that Lister, but they can't even get the rear number plate bolts straight so i,m out.
Edited by cayman-black on Sunday 4th February 10:10
M5MarkM said:
new Vantage
I'm in a minority but I prefer it to the old Vantage. Not a fan of the jag. But really you shouldn't be worried about the AMG engine, it's great, OK it has turbos which I'm not a fan of but so will the jag. The AMG engine has a great sound track (for a turbo) and delivers the power really well, you will love it!
Jag - turbos? Have Lister removed the supercharger and fitted turbos?
I'm in a minority but I prefer it to the old Vantage. Not a fan of the jag. But really you shouldn't be worried about the AMG engine, it's great, OK it has turbos which I'm not a fan of but so will the jag. The AMG engine has a great sound track (for a turbo) and delivers the power really well, you will love it!Can't see they can any more inside space in F Type, although they can get rid of awful plastic cover between/just behind seats.
F Type cosseted ride very different to current AMs and can F Type handle the extra power even with AWD I assume.
Ltd edition Project 7 (80 made) very different and more striking than normal F Type - but no great gains.
F Type cosseted ride very different to current AMs and can F Type handle the extra power even with AWD I assume.
Ltd edition Project 7 (80 made) very different and more striking than normal F Type - but no great gains.
M5MarkM said:
new Vantage
I'm in a minority but I prefer it to the old Vantage. Not a fan of the jag. But really you shouldn't be worried about the AMG engine, it's great, OK it has turbos which I'm not a fan of but so will the jag. The AMG engine has a great sound track (for a turbo) and delivers the power really well, you will love it!
For the record, I didn't specifically reply to Wayne's concern about the AMG engine, tempting though it was, but now I'm responding to this, not bringing it up
I'm in a minority but I prefer it to the old Vantage. Not a fan of the jag. But really you shouldn't be worried about the AMG engine, it's great, OK it has turbos which I'm not a fan of but so will the jag. The AMG engine has a great sound track (for a turbo) and delivers the power really well, you will love it!
So...The problem with the AMG engine isn't that the engine might not be good, or doesn't sound good (sound is a matter of opinion, or course), or that it isn't powerful enough (it surely is powerful). For me, it's not even that it's turbocharged. It's simply that it's a bought-in, off-the-shelf someone-else's engine. That, IMO, is a complete and total travesty that completely defeats the purpose of having an Aston Martin. It obliterates any and all interest in the New Vantage (or DB11 V8) because, crazy though it seems to some (and completely understandable to others), for me an Aston Martin MUST have an Aston Martin engine (I won't go in to detail here, but IMO the outgoing V8, and the old and new V12s, are Aston engines). How good it turns out to be simply doesn't matter, because my interest ends at the AMG engine in an "Aston." Ferrari wouldn't put someone else's engine in their cars -- because it wouldn't be a Ferrari. I know it's very expensive, etc., but now Andy is talking about building an F1 engine??? If they can do that, they can do their own road car V8, which is FAR more important IMO.
Speedraser said:
For the record, I didn't specifically reply to Wayne's concern about the AMG engine, tempting though it was, but now I'm responding to this, not bringing it up
So...
The problem with the AMG engine isn't that the engine might not be good, or doesn't sound good (sound is a matter of opinion, or course), or that it isn't powerful enough (it surely is powerful). For me, it's not even that it's turbocharged. It's simply that it's a bought-in, off-the-shelf someone-else's engine. That, IMO, is a complete and total travesty that completely defeats the purpose of having an Aston Martin. It obliterates any and all interest in the New Vantage (or DB11 V8) because, crazy though it seems to some (and completely understandable to others), for me an Aston Martin MUST have an Aston Martin engine (I won't go in to detail here, but IMO the outgoing V8, and the old and new V12s, are Aston engines). How good it turns out to be simply doesn't matter, because my interest ends at the AMG engine in an "Aston." Ferrari wouldn't put someone else's engine in their cars -- because it wouldn't be a Ferrari. I know it's very expensive, etc., but now Andy is talking about building an F1 engine??? If they can do that, they can do their own road car V8, which is FAR more important IMO.
That' was my point really. The Lustet is a car completely made by Jaguar, ( apart from the stuff from suppliers who don't make cars themselves ) then modified by a very long standing racing builder with a history linked to the base car.
So...The problem with the AMG engine isn't that the engine might not be good, or doesn't sound good (sound is a matter of opinion, or course), or that it isn't powerful enough (it surely is powerful). For me, it's not even that it's turbocharged. It's simply that it's a bought-in, off-the-shelf someone-else's engine. That, IMO, is a complete and total travesty that completely defeats the purpose of having an Aston Martin. It obliterates any and all interest in the New Vantage (or DB11 V8) because, crazy though it seems to some (and completely understandable to others), for me an Aston Martin MUST have an Aston Martin engine (I won't go in to detail here, but IMO the outgoing V8, and the old and new V12s, are Aston engines). How good it turns out to be simply doesn't matter, because my interest ends at the AMG engine in an "Aston." Ferrari wouldn't put someone else's engine in their cars -- because it wouldn't be a Ferrari. I know it's very expensive, etc., but now Andy is talking about building an F1 engine??? If they can do that, they can do their own road car V8, which is FAR more important IMO.
The new Vantage is a car not wholly made by AM losing some brand value as a result . It's not what's technically better, but what the car represents
bTW probably keeping the 4.7 for while longer ..,
Speedraser said:
I know it's very expensive, etc., but now Andy is talking about building an F1 engine??? If they can do that, they can do their own road car V8, which is FAR more important IMO.
But you're missing the point. AML has not built an engine in-house for road use since Tadek Marek V8. Cosworth and other partners have done the design, AMEP in Cologne has built and a firm near Telford do the casting.So, would AML design and build an F1 engine? No more than Valkyrie...
And an F1 engine is a much cheaper proposition than making an emissions compliant road legal engine.
I would prefer if AML had engineering build in-house. I even suggested to AP that he should acquire Bamford Rose and run them as AMG for AML.
But this is all about economics and not romantic visions. Romance kept the firm alive for the first century. Economically sound business practise will keep it alive and allow it to thrive in the second century.
And hopefully, at the point tens of thousands of ladies called Charlotte have bought a DBX, there will be a return to exclusive to AML powertrain. Whether that's V8, V12, gas turbine or hybrid...
Wayne95 said:
That' was my point really. The Lister is a car completely made by Jaguar, ( apart from the stuff from suppliers who don't make cars themselves ) then modified by a very long standing racing builder with a history linked to the base car.
5.0L AJ V8 Gen III engines made by Ford at Bridgend & Vantage 4.3 & 4.7 engines have connection back to an earlier version[edit: both great as have both a 5.0 and a 4.7 one but 5.0 ones hidden under plastic cover]
Edited by RL17 on Sunday 4th February 22:33
John, I assure you I'm not missing the point. I said in my post I wouldn't go into why I consider the 4.3/4.7 V8 and the V12s Aston engines, but now, well... No, there hasn't been a clean-sheet Aston engine since the Marek V8. It would be wonderful if that could happen. However... The V12 was developed from Ford's concept engine specifically for Aston, and it has never been used in anything other than an Aston Martin. It was initially built by Cosworth specifically for Aston Martin, and then Aston took over production in its dedicated, Aston-only facility within the Ford plant in Cologne. This, for me, qualifies it as an Aston engine. The V8 is "based" on the Jaguar V8, but has its own bespoke block, crank, conrods, pistons, heads, cams, valves, etc. -- essentially everything is unique to the Aston engine. It, too, is built by dedicated Aston-only personnel in that same Aston-only facility. For me, this makes it an Aston Martin engine. This is completely different from a bought-in, off-the-shelf someone else's engine that is also found in tens of thousands of someone else's cars.
Of course they have to pay attention to economics. But if the romance goes away, then what's the point of Aston Martin???
Of course they have to pay attention to economics. But if the romance goes away, then what's the point of Aston Martin???
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




