Cheapest Main dealer for a service
Cheapest Main dealer for a service
Author
Discussion

Vet Guru

Original Poster:

2,222 posts

271 months

Saturday 3rd February 2018
quotequote all
I have a 2014 Vantage S bought from Stratstone last year.
I had an awful experience with them and would not use them for service.
Needs a 4 year service after phone around for prices every dealer is all over the place!
AM do a fixed price service for £680 basic oil and brake fluid.
Then I am told pollen filters £80 and gearbox oil £141 and air filter £357!!!
So not sure what the £680 is all about.
The cheapest dealer is AM Bristol, with -20% off sadly 300 miles return trip.
Harwoods wanted £900 for the basic and then when I advised you are advertising £680 they then said they would match it but they no longer offer it!!
AM works offer the fixed price but no cheaper
Grange Brentwood wanted £850
Lancaster Sevenoaks offered the fixed price but no cheaper
HWM were the most expensive and would do the full service but wanted £1350!!!
Looking at the history it will need the pollen and air done this year as it was not done last year.
Has anyone got a deal from any main dealer?
I might just do an overnight stay and do Bristol and get the full service done on the car.
So I'm confused on what the AM website says the fixed price service is all about

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Saturday 3rd February 2018
quotequote all
I think they are all similar, other than labour rate for the "extras"

the base price is just that - a base fixed price for the "regular" service. On services where you need gear oil, plugs, air filter etc, its list price parts plus labour.

Obviously a dealer in Mayfair has a higher labour rate than Newcastle

I have used 6 dealers (inc Works) and 3 specialists and the latter win out if you need significant other work doing....4 hours labour at a £50 ph saving is worthwhile.

Last year I used Works, got the fixed price then another £170 ish on top for gearbox oil change. Then the usual "brake pads are low" advice and £500 fitted on rear so left those and did myself in an hour for under £200 of parts.

I would find somewhere you dont mind driving to, where you get treated well and "OK" on price.There is a network of great specialists out there for the modern Aston. No need to keep up a main dealer stamp.

Ken Figenus

6,011 posts

148 months

Saturday 3rd February 2018
quotequote all
Don't be scared to ask for a discount - many are OK with that as it's quite toppy for an oil change. Been very impressed with the deal and service at the MD just over the bridge from me 3 great indies I know of near Gaydon too...

ian448

171 posts

129 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
I also use Works, they are quiet happy for you to provide your own oil and the last service I had on my DB9 they quoted £457.As for the pollen filters there from an RX8 and take 10 minutes to change, the air filters a bit longer but as long as youve a jack and are capable of removing a wheel arch liner thats also an easy job and also satisfying knowing youve saved some beer money

zygalski

7,759 posts

176 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Can you not arrange a good finance deal for the service costs?

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Vet Guru said:
Looking at the history it will need the pollen and air done this year as it was not done last year.
Has anyone got a deal from any main dealer?
I might just do an overnight stay and do Bristol and get the full service done on the car.
So I'm confused on what the AM website says the fixed price service is all about
Interesting that the air filters were not replaced last year. Probably due to the £357 cost!
I can't believe this is a "additional recommended item". These should be replaced every 20-30K miles.
As said above the pollen filters are a 10 minute job. Check Youtube and other thread on PH somewhere for RX-8 elements.
I'll be replacing both the above but not with AM stuff. Cost (total) is around £40.

I don't think the MDs have too much flexibility due to the high overheads. From another recent thread on here, it seems like a nightmare. If you can collate your quotes vs the actual work to be done, you will probably find they are all similar prices. The website can be a little confusing. I'm still working out how a pre-2012 car can cost so much more to service than the same car but newer. Same parts are they not? It almost encourages you to go to a specialist when the car gets older.

There are many specialists about and I think you will get better value by trying them. As said above, the labour rate is lower for starters so any extra work will not be too much of a shock. They still stamp the book and many of them have a good or better reputation than MDs. I've yet to hear of a crap specialist - they wouldn't be in business for very long.

GingerMunky

1,287 posts

288 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Vet Guru said:
I have a 2014 Vantage S bought from Stratstone last year.
I had an awful experience with them and would not use them for service.

The cheapest dealer is AM Bristol, with -20% off sadly 300 miles return trip.
Its worth the 300 miles round trip, great service and some fantastic cars in stock to keep you entertained. They are very competitive on transport costs too, if you want them to bring the trailer to pick up your car, especially if they can pick up another on the way.

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
ian448 said:
I also use Works, they are quiet happy for you to provide your own oil and the last service I had on my DB9 they quoted £457.As for the pollen filters there from an RX8 and take 10 minutes to change, the air filters a bit longer but as long as youve a jack and are capable of removing a wheel arch liner thats also an easy job and also satisfying knowing youve saved some beer money
Can you not remove the air filters by removing the front underneath tray only?

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
^^^Yes, you can

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Thanks, Callum.

ilikeAstons

275 posts

135 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Works. Just yes.

GameofCars

850 posts

140 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Out of interest wonder if you get an indy to service your Aston but then down the line you try to sell your car back into the Aston MD network whether they are not interested or use that as an excuse to offer you a bad deal?

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
I was told by am leeds that am service history will give me more money when i trade in. Cant say if its true but certainly they can throw that back at me if i go indy for servicing.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
GameofCars said:
Out of interest wonder if you get an indy to service your Aston but then down the line you try to sell your car back into the Aston MD network whether they are not interested or use that as an excuse to offer you a bad deal?
I did just that in 2016 and made no difference on my early Vantage, it had 4 dealer stamps and 5 indy. Didnt even look at the history when quoting me a trade in value. Had previously asked me if it had history and I said "full but not all main dealer". I handed over a file with every invoice from new with the car the following week.

They did take it for a test drive and give it a quick inspection on drop off day, technician was happy, all AM parts had been used on the car.

Dont think its so much where its been serviced, particularly on a 5yr old plus car...but having proof of work done as per schedule is important

Edited by bogie on Sunday 4th February 20:36

RobDown

3,807 posts

159 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
bogie said:
I did just that in 2016 and made no difference on my early Vantage, it had 4 dealer stamps and 5 indy. Didnt even look at the history when quoting me a trade in value. Had previously asked me if it had history and I said "full but not all main dealer". I handed over a file with every invoice from new with the car the following week.
That was my experience too when trading in my DB9

Sebastian Tombs

2,160 posts

223 months

Monday 5th February 2018
quotequote all
Try Chiltern Aston Centre if you want an Aston stamp in there but would rather go to an Indy.