Vantage choice / dilemma !!
Vantage choice / dilemma !!
Author
Discussion

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Now you will all have to bear with me on my boring dilemma’s !! Last post before I actually buy something !!

Some of you have been really helpful but I am now at a crossroads and need the benefit of your experiences

Which a change of job looming (no more 150 mile round trips) and the purchase of a range rover for my other half I started looking for a Vantage as my every day car.

When I say everyday, I have a 355 spider and a defender as well.

From April both of us will be working from home and business will mainly be train or plane a couple of times a week.

So I started looking for a cheap £30k (manual) vantage I wouldn’t worry about and then ………

I found that there is such a variety of cars in differing states all at similar prices but unless I spend £45k + I won’t get my absolute perfect car.

Must haves are sportshift (drove manual car but have bad back and didn’t suit) and heated seats. (driven a couple of sportshifts and am happy with them

So basically if I go with what I really want its £44k, Silver coupe with black heated seats

If I compromise it’s one of the following ( prices stated are prices I would actually pay) :

1. 2007 silver with black leather and no heated seats £33.5k if this had heated seats I probably would have bought it.
2. Year newer 2008 4.7 higher miles recent clutch heated seats but burgundy trim to the middle of the seats (could retrim but no idea on cost?) £35k
3. Left field a 4.3 roadster in Black with all bits and bobs + main dealer warranty + recent clutch for £40k (think this is reasonable due to time of year ?)

Or I just wait for the right car to come along but I am impatient and a bloke !!

Haven’t driven a 4.7 but 4.3 seemed plenty fast enough for a daily driver.


Any advice very welcome and thanks in advance
Phib

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
I think the key thing at your price bracket is to find one that has evidence of a clutch change, reasonably recent other consumables such as tyres, and a recent service for peace of mind. If you ignore these you risk spending quite a lot in addition to the purchase price even though they are generally robust and reliable.

If you take the above as requisites, then you just need to fix your budget. Of the options you list, I don’t think you’ll get a 4.7 for £35k, so you either need to discount them from searches or up your budget. They start at around £42k so you could get a higher mileage one for £40k...but then probably find you’re in the situation of needing to spend another £4K on it.

You’ve posted on various threads with your assessment of value; often quoting numbers that are below even CAP average values. Not meaning to be rude but I think you’re going to have a long search and be regularly disappointed until your assessment of value starts to align with the market better. Doing this doesn’t mean that you can’t still come across a bargain!

You’ve narrowed down to a sportshift which is good as they’re a bit cheaper than manuals like-for-like. Sounds like you now really need to narrow down on roadster vs coupe, as you’re paying more for a roadster so need to decide if you want that. I would say that realistic budgets with the £30-48k range for a sportshift with good provence and maintenance as suggested above are, after haggling/negotiation:

£32k: 2007, sportshift 4.3 coupe with c.60k miles.
£37k: 2007, sportshift 4.3 roadster with c.40k miles.
£42k: 2009, sportshift 4.7 coupe with c.45k miles.
£48k: 2009, sportshift 4.7 roadster with c.35k miles.

Asking prices will be more than this obviously. Add 8-9% to the above for a dealer sale asking price as opposed to private. Dealers seem not to drop much on asking prices for AM though. I recently changed to a roadster and can say with some confidence that some of those advertised are not the bargains they might initially appear.

Edited by johnnyBv8 on Monday 5th February 12:16

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
I'd go for Option 2
Recent clutch means no worries even with the higher miles.
Facelifted interior plus other revisions over the early model as well.

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Thanks, these are cars I have seen and been offered at these prices.

The 4.7 would have a service at Aston before it is sold

Infancy all three have recent service and recent clutch ( I need to double check on the silver one)

From what I have found looking at a few, the advertised price and the price you pay ( maybe time of year) are two different things.

Thanks

Phib

Edited by phib on Sunday 4th February 11:28

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
If you have a 4.7 on offer at £35k that has had clutch, no paintwork issues etc etc then snap it up! No question based on the three listed!

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
If that car has no bodywork issues, new clutch, decent tyres etc and genuinely has full history, then it’s a great buy I’d say. If they’ll accept £35k it’s the cheapest 4.7 in the country by about £5k!

I’m not a huge fan of iron ore but it’s only on seat inserts - not dash, carpets etc so overall it looks pretty good.

Edited by johnnyBv8 on Sunday 4th February 12:57

Mr.Tremlini

1,555 posts

132 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Looking at that 2008 4.7 I would have to say that of the selection you list it would be a no-brainer in that condition, with recent clutch work, at that price. If the Iron ore trim bothers you keep in mind that when you are driving the car you aren`t looking at the seats! These colour schemes tend to look better in reality than in photos.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
phib said:
Buy that one if it all checks out, seriously good VFM smile

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Will triple check but when I spoke to them they have dates and dealers for all history and clutch.

Will go and have a look again tomorrow.

It’s sunny today and I can’t help think convertible but the 4.7 was more what I started looking at so that’s probably better

Thanks
Phib

Octavarium

608 posts

138 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
phib said:
Will triple check but when I spoke to them they have dates and dealers for all history and clutch.

Will go and have a look again tomorrow.

It’s sunny today and I can’t help think convertible but the 4.7 was more what I started looking at so that’s probably better

Thanks
Phib
Sunny today perhaps. But probably peeing it down Monday, Tuesday ....

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Bugger they took a deposit on the 4.7 last night !! No surprising I guess.

Back to square one !

Phib

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Option 2: Ask if its got the full Sports Pack or just the wheels. Looks like a very pretty car.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
I prefer a Roadster, so for similar price/spec, go roadster smile

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
phib said:
Bugger they took a deposit on the 4.7 last night !! No surprising I guess.

Back to square one !

Phib
I was looking for 12 months before I bought and that car was a steal for sure. In fact I'd have been asking, 'is it cat D' or summat?

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
To be fair if you look hard enough there are quite a few 4.7’s for under £40k.

Several dealers with part ex’s who just want to move them on.

There is another one 2010 ( 58k) with lightweight seats than can be bought for 38k.

Phib

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
There really aren’t; I know as had a well linked specialist dealer trying to source one using contacts and dealer-only online Autotrade Mail. There’s very little that doesn’t get retailed. So, if you’ve really located an issue-free 2010 with lightweight seats, new clutch etc for under £40k then my advice is to stop messing about on here then and buy your secret bargain!

Edited by johnnyBv8 on Sunday 4th February 16:25

gibbon

2,182 posts

238 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
I'd agree with the comments here.

£40-45k for an early 4.7 with average to a little high (for these cars) miles is more where the market it. The prices havnt moved much in years.

I would be a little weary of £38k 2010 Vantage, sounds too cheap. But hey, if its not, get it bought, you wont find a cheaper one.

Captain Smerc

3,355 posts

147 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Iron ore trim looks great IMO .

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Sunday 4th February 2018
quotequote all
Sorry guys there are quite a few 4.7's about sub £40k

http://www.williamssalesltd.co.uk/used/aston-marti...

The 4.7k with 55k trades at 35k so I am not surprised there are some cheaper ones about

I was offer 2 others this week ( not the colours I liked though)

Phib