Thoughts on using a non specalist garage for servicing a v8v
Thoughts on using a non specalist garage for servicing a v8v
Author
Discussion

Tom_GGG

Original Poster:

81 posts

112 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
Does any one have any thoughts (pros or cons) on using a non specialist / non main dealer garage for servicing an 09 v8 vantage.

Theres no specialists or main dealers on my door step, but i do have a trusted garage that have done good work on other cars Porsche and Audi in the past.

I got a quote from a main dealer who wanted about £1100ex vat and a specialist who wanted about £600 ex vat.

Would a non specialist be particularly any cheaper than a specialist (not that im looking to cut corners on it) but surely the break down of the costs for parts would be similar and the labour would generally be £60-80 ph.

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
I think it comes down to your personal view.
Would you buy a car which did not have an AM specialist or AM dealer stamp?
Would it put you off if Joe Bloggs Garage Services did the work?

Some would not look at a car unless it was all AMFSH, others not so bothered.

Phil74891

1,086 posts

164 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
All about resale. If you're going to keep the car for a very long time you'd probably be ok, certainly for oil change type services.

If you wanted to trade it into a main dealer you might have issues. Also many private buyers wouldn't touch an Aston without a main dealer history. Others would though.

I'm sure the above doesn't help very much.......

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
Doubt there is a cost saving to be made as labour rates should be similar for non franchised garage. Use of AM parts will be similar, they are not marked up *that* much, seem to be the same everywhere for genuine.

For an oil change and check over likely OK, but if it needs AM diagnostics, software updates etc then you need to go to the specialist who has invested in this expensive kit.

The service schedules can be downloaded on line, but there is generally 5.5 hours in there if the job is done properly.

Personally id take the drive to the specialist. The good ones are known by dealers too, so the stamp in the book with AM badge and non franchised dealer is not that bad, certainly no issue on trade in for me.


johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
For most servicing, any garage would be able to do the basic requirements - it only gets more complicated for diagnostics. However, it will significantly affect resale, both in terms of price and number of people interested.

I always go main dealer, but if there was an AM specialist near me I'd consider that. I wouldn't use a standard garage for annual servicing though...ok for brakes etc if you trust them.

vernierMike

397 posts

125 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
I’d go specialist too, at that age, and yes it is all about resale at the values of these cars.

I have an 09 v8v too with full dealer history and will probably go recognised indie when a service is required, depending on the price difference at the time, although like many here I am happy to do straightforward non-stamp jobs myself, or get a trusted ‘normal’ mechanic to do them as I did for a clutch on my erstwhile Cayman. At resale I’m sure a winged stamp will more than pay for itself, in time if not money, with the thought that the car has been at least looked over by an expert. Personally I wouldn’t really expect a 9 year old car to still be main dealer. But no matter how good your non-non garage is there will be doubt in the mind of a concerned private buyer who may not be an expert, or the trade-in dealer who is looking for margin. I also find that a mechanic not familiar with the car takes longer, as it’s the first time they’ve done it and won’t want to make an expensive mistake, so in the end the specialist/non-non price comes out in the wash.

Along those lines I generally maintain my own motorcycles too, but a dealer stamp for the Ducati is a must for easy resale.

steveatesh

5,387 posts

195 months

Monday 12th February 2018
quotequote all
Be specialist Indy or main dealer for me, I wouldn’t consider an AM without solid service history.

I used main dealer, then specialist, back to main dealer now though since fixed price servicing came in and the Indy lost it’s AM service centre status.


macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
I think you'd be saving pennies to lose pounds by using local whoever.

SL500UK

374 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
Where's the OP located? AM Works did mine last for £651 Incl VAT and I believe they collect FOC if within 50 miles.

Big Ry

1,682 posts

150 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
As many have said, it's MD or Indie and no exceptions, for me at least. Personally I wouldn't consider buying a car that's been looked after by a generic garage. That's not doing a disservice to the garage, they may well be very good, it's just that they are not specialists in the AM field, so they won't know about any of the foibles and quirks that these cars can develop.........and develop them they do..!

Financially I doubt there's much in it, as if you did look to move it on then money you'd have saved by using the local garage would be negated by the fact you would arguably get less for the car.

All personal opinion of course, and for what it's worth I would be saying the same if we were on a Porsche forum. Specialists are specialists for a reason. They are usually guys (and girls) that have worked very closely with the brand for a long time and know their craft inside out, at times I'm sure far better than MD's do.

Edited by Big Ry on Tuesday 13th February 12:59

Ian350

316 posts

209 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
I have run several Jaguar XJs over the years and whilst not in the same league as my V8VR I have found that the good indys were generally just as good if not better than main dealers. However on using non-specialists I found that they struggled now and again with jobs you would have thought routine, leaving me to subsequently go to a specialist to put things right. So for me I will always use a good independent specialist whether its for the Aston or the Jag.

Tom_GGG

Original Poster:

81 posts

112 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
SL500UK said:
Where's the OP located? AM Works did mine last for £651 Incl VAT and I believe they collect FOC if within 50 miles.
Im based in around north london

raceboy

13,943 posts

311 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
Tom_GGG said:
Theres no specialists or main dealers on my door step...
Tom_GGG said:
I'm based in around north london
Now I appreciate 'on the door step' can imply different distances to different people but 'North London' wasn't the location I was expecting, you're probably less than an hour from Aston Martin Works, Desmond J Smail, Nicholas Mee, and a couple of Main Dealers. driving

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
HWM is not too far either, would be my choice. Saying that i have had a small service done by my local trusted garage, but they are not in the uk.

Tom_GGG

Original Poster:

81 posts

112 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
Aston Service London - http://www.astonservicelondon.com/contact-us/ (specialist in Acton) seem to be the nearest, any one got any feedback on them ?


GameofCars

850 posts

140 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
Tom_GGG said:
Aston Service London - http://www.astonservicelondon.com/contact-us/ (specialist in Acton) seem to be the nearest, any one got any feedback on them ?
Haven't used them but probably quite good as its part of Desmond Smail - who's main garage is near Aston Works & has a very good reputation.

SL500UK

374 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th February 2018
quotequote all
If based in north London Aston Martin Works will probably collect FOC (on their trailor) and might charge a similar price to the independent garage that was mentioned.