Moving from a Vantage Coupe to a Roadster
Moving from a Vantage Coupe to a Roadster
Author
Discussion

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
I'm thinking about switching out my Vantage Coupe for a more modern Roadster both for the engine upgrade but also do some hair in the air in the summer months.

Any feedback from those who have made the same move. Did anyone regret it?

justin220

5,764 posts

235 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
Thanks Justin, very helpful.

CraigV12V

304 posts

184 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
My Aston journey has been;
  1. V8V 4.3 Coupe Manual. Nice noise but too slow and for some reason regular seats gave me back ache.
  2. V12V Coupe Manual. Much quicker, better handling, ton of fun, really a completely different car to the 4.3. There are better gear boxes and better placed gear knobs but doesn't diminish the fun factor. Lightweight seats solved back ache.
  3. V12VS Roadster Auto, again with lightweight seats. Even quicker again especially now I have had primary cats removed and 200 cell secondary cats fitted, circa 600 Bhp yum. Regrets? None. You can definitely hear more from the exhausts with the roof down, tunnels can be deafening clap. Wind in the hair is life affirming but you actually have to put roof back up in sunnier climes when you roll into town, you simply cook in the sun over 30 degrees C when moving slowly. Air con just cannot cool you enough. I imagine a lot depends on how you use car. A daily driver might better be a Coupe, I don’t think a soft top exposed regularly to UK weather will fair that well. Mine hardly ever sees rain and little sun really as she is in garage most of the winter. But going for a drive on a nice dry day even if a bit nippy, roof off is just the mutts. I do miss a little luggage space which if touring with the other half can be problematic given their excess baggage requirements.
And just saying, but having had manual and auto (never use D, just paddles) the auto is way more fun on a V12VS when you have so many gears to play with and you can get through the rev bands so so fast. This is admittedly partially due to the cat removal which means engine spins up more quickly now.

So yes if I had to choose an Aston for high days and holidays it would be Roadster over a Coupe. If I bought a second Aston then I think I would then get the Coupe and if it was my daily driver I think I would lean more to a Coupe.

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
Well put Craig!

I bought a second Aston when I had a roadster and ........... went for a roadster hehe Just can’t see the need for a coupe biglaugh

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
I'm convinced. It's not a daily driver for me so no need for practicality. It's just a weekend fun car and I really miss soft top motoring so now I just need to find a good one. Thanks for all the feedback. Now to decide whether to stick with a manual or try a sport shift.

embdenb

170 posts

134 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
CraigV12V said:
My Aston journey has been;
  1. V8V 4.3 Coupe Manual. Nice noise but too slow and for some reason regular seats gave me back ache.
  2. V12V Coupe Manual. Much quicker, better handling, ton of fun, really a completely different car to the 4.3.
V12 more powerful, yes.
Faster ( in a straight line), yes
Better handling than the V8, No.
Handling has nothing to do with horsepower. Some of the best handling cars have low horsepower engines.
There is a reason that the Vantage race cars use the V8 engine instead of the V12. The V8 car handles better, and is therefore faster on the track.
The V12 has 51% of its weight over the front wheels. The V8, 49%. As long as the V8 can produce the required horsepower that the race car needs, it will always be faster.

embdenb

170 posts

134 months

Monday 12th March 2018
quotequote all
embdenb said:
V12 more powerful, yes.
Faster ( in a straight line), yes
Better handling than the V8, No.
Handling has nothing to do with horsepower. Some of the best handling cars have low horsepower engines.
There is a reason that the Vantage race cars use the V8 engine instead of the V12. The V8 car handles better, and is therefore faster on the track.
The V12 has 51% of its weight over the front wheels. The V8, 49%. As long as the V8 can produce the required horsepower that the race car needs, it will always be faster.
Before the Vantage V12 group put a price on my head let me clarify my post.
The V12 Vantage, because of its increased horsepower and torque is a better street car in every aspect from the V8, except handling. (Smile)

moveover

370 posts

194 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all

I had a V8 roadster for a few years. Great fun, but I had two roof modules fail on me. I got very nervous of attempting to open or close the roof in traffic, as failure mid-way was a cause of much embarrassment. No coincidence that the last 2 cars I've had were both coupes.

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
In the perfect world I'd be looking for a V12 Roadster but the budget won't run that far for what is one of many toys competing for attention at the weekend.

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
moveover said:
I had a V8 roadster for a few years. Great fun, but I had two roof modules fail on me. I got very nervous of attempting to open or close the roof in traffic, as failure mid-way was a cause of much embarrassment. No coincidence that the last 2 cars I've had were both coupes.
If it does jam are you able to manually push it down?

Grant3

3,710 posts

286 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
I think the Roadster is a great choice, it really adds a whole new dimension to the Vantage experience, roof off sun on face, V8/V12 turned up to 10, wind in the hair... it really doesn’t get much better on the right day.

Downsides, smaller boot, less head room and a few extra creaks otherwise it’s all good and very refined hood up (although a bit less exhaust noise inside compared to the Coupe).

Personally I think the V8S Roadster is the sweet spot, in terms of the balance between handling, ride quality, performance and feelgood (the special interior), closely followed by the 12.25MY V8. The Sportshift II also makes a good case for itself on a Roadster with those whip crack changes and heel/toe style down-change revs, providing you use the paddles wink

Just do it smile

LordBretSinclair

4,306 posts

208 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
Bobajobbob said:
If it does jam are you able to manually push it down?
Yes, as long as you have your "book" with you. Better to put it up - it's quite easy but everything has to be done in the right order with the "key" to lock it shut to the header rail smile

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
Mind made up. Now just need to find a good one. Has anyone bought a car from Quirks in Essex?

I quite like the look of this China Grey car.

https://www.quirkscarco.co.uk/aston-martin-vantage...


Big Ry

1,682 posts

150 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
Would you not be better looking for a V8S Roadster ? The carbon alone in the early ones (yeah I know they charged for it later in life) would make it a winner for me, plus a few other odds and sods.

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
Hmm remind me of the differences in the later cars? I was reading the bible last night and my interpretation was that for cars after about MY12.5 most of the S updates were included as standard? What did I miss?



Grant3

3,710 posts

286 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
Bobajobbob said:
Hmm remind me of the differences in the later cars? I was reading the bible last night and my interpretation was that for cars after about MY12.5 most of the S updates were included as standard? What did I miss?
True...... the main variances beween S and upgraded V8 are at the end of the 12.25MY pages...

Note - the changes make the “S” look less attractive than before, but it has the following extra standard equipment - a slightly more powerful free revving engine (+10bhp/15Ib-ft) - Sports exhaust - Sports Mode (pre-14MY) - 7-speed Sportshift II (pre-13MY) - Carbon-fibre additions (front splitter & rear diffuser) - Clear rear lenses - Sat-nav (13MY+) - Wider sills - Cruise control - Bluetooth (pre-16MY) and many special interior touches (three stitch folded leather on doors, seats and centre tunnel sides, V8S logo on seats, Piano Black part fascia, etc), helping justify its higher price, which was also reduced. (the pre-notes above relate to the items becoming standard equipment or options on the V8 from that MY!!)

It depends on the price variance between S and standard and your personal taste, also (of course) on the options fitted to a 12.25MY standard V8. The Carbon additions are expensive to add if they appeal, also the Sports Exhaust and clear rear lenses - the interior is also unique as is the slightly more free revving grunty engine (N430 aside!).

Edited to add changes in italics!!

Edited by Grant3 on Tuesday 13th March 15:04

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Tuesday 13th March 2018
quotequote all
Grant3 said:
True...... the main variances beween S and upgraded V8 are at the end of the 12.25MY pages...

Note - the changes make the “S” look less attractive than before, but it has the following extra standard equipment - a slightly more powerful free revving engine (+10bhp/15Ib-ft) - Sports exhaust - Sports Mode (pre-14MY) - 7-speed Sportshift II (pre-13MY) - Carbon-fibre additions (front splitter & rear diffuser) - Clear rear lenses - Sat-nav (13MY+) - Wider sills - Cruise control - Bluetooth (pre-16MY) and many special interior touches (three stitch folded leather on doors, seats and centre tunnel sides, V8S logo on seats, Piano Black part fascia, etc), helping justify its higher price, which was also reduced. (the pre-notes above relate to the items becoming standard equipment or options on the V8 from that MY!!)

It depends on the price variance between S and standard and your personal taste, also (of course) on the options fitted to a 12.25MY standard V8. The Carbon additions are expensive to add if they appeal, also the Sports Exhaust and clear rear lenses - the interior is also unique as is the slightly more free revving grunty engine (N430 aside!).

Edited to add changes in italics!!

Edited by Grant3 on Tuesday 13th March 15:04
Thanks Grant, the changes are greater than I thought though it does depend on the spec of the non-S car.

Bobajobbob

Original Poster:

1,599 posts

127 months

Saturday 24th March 2018
quotequote all
Picked up a roadster today. Love the soft top and love the power upgrade.