So I took my car in for it's 10th year service...
So I took my car in for it's 10th year service...
Author
Discussion

mhurley

Original Poster:

823 posts

164 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
Recieved email saying they had done a "Health Check" and this was what they found. Prices inc VAT and labour:


Front brake discs are below minimum wear limit £516.18

Rear brake disc are very close to minimum limit rear pads are at 4mm and replacement required at 3mm
And handbrake pads at 2mm replacement advised at 3mm £1006.15

Driver’s seat belt fraying £748.12

Passengers window switch inoperative advise replacement £70.81

Door rams weak, advise new £220.37

Engine emission service light caused by faulty sensor, advise new £241.74

Alarm system service light caused by internal fault in sounder unit, advise new £203.86

Split wheel nut due to corrosion £8.53

Brake wear level sensor all in secure, require refitting
(if brakes are authorised as per earlier recommendation price will be included) £89.70

N/S/F headlamp washer jet broken and not producing efficient spray pattern £487.52
on lamp and clearing lamp. New jet advised

Oil separator leaking, advise new £58.01

Fuel filler cap cable seized, advise new £87.52

Clock not working and requires further investigation and checking £89.70
of fuses in CEM.

Outer should of tread on N/S/F tyre low advise replacement of pair £565.73

kev1966900

153 posts

110 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
So what happened at the 9th service, did the technician forget to look, surely some of the items should have been picked up sooner

mhurley

Original Poster:

823 posts

164 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
Good point

TBH i was expecting brakes to be flagged up as they hadn't been mentioned on the previous nine years worth of paperwork

I thought the seat belt and jet washer cost was a tad steep


LordBretSinclair

4,306 posts

208 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
kev1966900 said:
So what happened at the 9th service, did the technician forget to look, surely some of the items should have been picked up sooner
....and what was reported at your last MOT in regard to the tyres and the seatbelt ?????

Typical "stealer" rip offs frown

rovcallum

553 posts

174 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
At the risk of being stoned to death.... did the dealer look like they were in need of a new coffee machine? getmecoat

Three words for you.... Try an indy.

mhurley

Original Poster:

823 posts

164 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
rovcallum said:
Three words for you.... Try an indy.
When i was getting quotes for a service there wasn't much in it between an Indy and AM. Also the dealer in question is far closer than any indy
I have no idea , however, what an indy would charge for the bits and pieces listed previously...

davek_964

11,382 posts

206 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
mhurley said:
When i was getting quotes for a service there wasn't much in it between an Indy and AM. Also the dealer in question is far closer than any indy
I have no idea , however, what an indy would charge for the bits and pieces listed previously...
I can compare a couple of items to an Indy.

I assume the emissions means oxygen sensor - I was quoted £220.38 + vat.
My fuel cap tether has snapped - I was quoted £57.49 + vat to replace

I'm confused by the quote for the door rams. Surely the they're the part being discussed on another thread - which are about £20 each?

ds666

3,185 posts

210 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
That wheel nut looks good value smile

Shrimpvende

961 posts

123 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
I had all 4 discs and pads + handbrake pads + sensors changed for far less than you're being quoted. I bought the parts from Rick @ BMG and had a certain well known Indy do the work. I also had a sticky fuel flap which they sorted for me while the car was there - fantastic service compared to the two MD's I tried.

Most parts can be sourced alternatively through astonbits or places like BMG, then Indy labour rates are at least half MD's so if you want/need to get that work done it would save a small fortune. I also found that although the MD had done a health check a few weeks prior to my visit to the Indy, the Indy health check was far more comprehensive and found stuff the MD didn't, along with the fact that the car had never had a software update, despite the full dealer SH!

I bought my tyres online from tyreleader at a decent discount and had a high end wheel refurb place do the swaps for me so the wheels didn't get damaged. Although, I've just had our range rover tyres replaced on the driveway by kwik fit mobile for the same price I could get them delivered by tyreleader so it pays to check!

Edit to add - Door rams are cheap from astonbits and a fairly easy DIY if you're that way inclined...you need to jack the car up and remove the screws holding the rear part of the archliner in place then with a bit of faffing you can pop the old ones off and the new ones on. From memory they're about £20 per side

Phil74891

1,086 posts

164 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
Just possibly, maybe, you could source a seat belt from somewhere like this. It might be a bit stretched smile and the wrong colour, but you might be able to find a virtually new one in the correct colour for 50 quid? (I've no idea who the companies below are - just a 30 second Google search).

http://www.partshark.co.uk/used-car-parts-breaking...

I wouldn't replace the headlamp washer at that price. Depends how long you want to keep the car, and if you're happy with a few niggles etc. At 10 years old I would say work at a respected Indy would look ok in the book.

Edited by Phil74891 on Wednesday 21st March 17:16

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
Discs n pads the cheapest place to save over dealer pricing.

I was quoted £500 for new rear pads /handbrake pads last time, and did them myself in 90 mins for £180 of parts.

Per axle, pads are £180 fitted at indy e.g. http://www.davidapplebyengineering.com/brakes.html

Your list is typical of main dealer, they find every niggle and suggest new parts and full price to fit (can be £120 ph labour depending where you are)

At an Indy they may suggest fixing the part, an alternative cheaper replacement, at the least they are often 50% cheaper on the labour to fit.


macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
ds666 said:
That wheel nut looks good value smile
hehe
As for the rest,,, yikes they're yanking your chain, go 'indy'.


Ken Figenus

6,011 posts

148 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
Headlamp washer could be an MOT fail...? If it wasn't for that I'd have unplugged the pump years ago - lets face it they are pretty ineffective and are sponsored by CarPlan screenwash!

On a 10 year old car I'd definitely have a look at breakers - there are a few that specialise in higher end marques. I got a perfect new ski slope and as-new glass buttons for mine for a quarter of the cost - that seatbelt cost is particularly ridiculous.

Get Porterfield R4-S pads for it at a fraction of the cost. Less dust and better bite too.

Lots of bits are Jag or Ford or Volvo and an active miserly mind with keyboard skills can save a fortune! Ohh those coils at £120 each x12 but that can be sourced for £30 by same OEM manufacturer!!! And don't get me started on NGK plugs!!!

davek_964

11,382 posts

206 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
I appear to use the wrong Indy, since mine isn't really cheaper than those prices.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
After six and a half years, my driver's seatbelt is frayed. £750! no way!

ds666

3,185 posts

210 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
[quote=Ken Figenus]Headlamp washer could be an MOT fail...?

Definite MOT failure if it doesn’t work at all . Not sure if it only works a bit thou


Edited by ds666 on Wednesday 21st March 18:07

Simon Lane

456 posts

152 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
rovcallum said:
At the risk of being stoned to death.... did the dealer look like they were in need of a new coffee machine? getmecoat

Three words for you.... Try an indy.
I'm not rising to it, but noted!

Ken Figenus

6,011 posts

148 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
Very diplomatic Simon smile After all, it's just market forces on a low volume business with very high standards smile

I have to say my 'new' MD are absolutely excellent. The lovely coffee and charming greetings are part of their business model - but I think the balance is sometimes goes a bit off (ohh those air filters at £250 a pair fitted - my DIY with same OEM filters is LITERALLY £26.47 + £1 Deep Heat for the neck).

As many have indicated Indies can be close to the MD prices these days (one has gone down and the other has gone up) so its fair enough to choose on coffee and organic chocolate quality let alone the quality of the people you are dealing with wink

StevenB

783 posts

228 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
I think you only need headlamp washers if you have HID lights. As for the seat belt get it removed and re-webbed costs about £20 coloured webbing will probably cost a bit more if you have that.

ds666

3,185 posts

210 months

Wednesday 21st March 2018
quotequote all
If they are fitted it is because they are HID