V10 plus R8 to DBS thoughts ?
V10 plus R8 to DBS thoughts ?
Author
Discussion

RSbandit

Original Poster:

3,072 posts

163 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
Hi forum
I've been monitoring DBS prices for a bit , my fav Aston ever TBH ...seems that I could trade my V10 plus R8 in against one for not too much more money now. Anyone made a similar trade and if so how has it worked out ? I've tracked my R8 a few times and it was well suited to that environment especially with ceramic brakes, is the DBS comparable in that sphere ? How are running costs for a 7/8!yr old car ? It seems to be a great way to experience a full fat V12 but I want to make sure it's something that it can be tracked as that's something I look to do with any performance cars I have. I think depreciation on £90k car would be minimal going forward so I could always swap back into the newer R8 for scratch in 2 yrs if it wasn't working out for me ...happy to hear all opinions ...thx!

AMTony

1,130 posts

198 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
Complete polar opposite cars!
IMO DBS is analogue whilst R8 is digital.....probs best way to think about them?

The DBS is nowhere near as fast, will not go round bends as fast as certainly doesn't feel as planted as the R8. Controls are inferior and you have to use your left hand to change gear. Interior is probably better, sound systems same but the electronic features poor in comparison. Cannot compare and AM to an Audi in this respect. Engine noise is on a par with R8.

The R8 is a beast. It is civilised in 'comfort' yet in 'dynamic' is quite mind blowing - savage in fact. Noise is sublime and downshifts an aural delight. LCD dash is amazing and the gearbox, well that is probably the best I have experienced. Engine noise with exhausts open at 9,000 rpm, takes some beating!

Running costs probably about same for both, maybe Aston a touch higher. Aston will hold its money better I suspect.

Which do I prefer.........this is a difficult choice as the R8 is brilliant in virtually every aspect. Having said that, the DBS has to be the winner as it has that magical mysteriousness about it. It pulls on your heart strings and really gets under your skin. Cannot explain why but DBS is the better car whilst in actual case it isn't. Contradictory statement I know but the R8 just leaves you cold whilst the Aston leaves you with a warm feeling, bit like a nice glass of vintage port.

You will miss the R8 but I would at least give the DBS a try. If you go for an auto DBS you will most certainly be disappointed, a manual on the other hand I think you will enjoy.

What qualifies me to say this? My youngest has the latest R8 V10 sport plus and having experienced/driven, I probably have the best of both worlds. Would I buy an R8 with my own hard earned.......that would need some serious thought but would lean towards a yes. Would I trade my DBS for one - never!

M5MarkM

1,686 posts

202 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
As above very different beasts! I've been in an R8 a few times, and was looking at moving to one when I had a DB9. The R8 is faster and handles much better than a DBS, but my experience is that the R8 was "sterile" compared to a DB9 so even more so to a DBS. I do think the DBS is a better looking car and certainly no doubt a better sound car and a better investment for the future. I couldn't imagine myself picking an R8 over a DBS! BUT if you go to the an Audi forum I bet they the opposite!

DBS is unique master piece and imo and I imagine most in an AML forum a better choice than an Audi!

Jeweller70

255 posts

147 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
I have a R8 v10 plus and a v12v. R8 is an amazing car but lacks character. V12v has lots of character and difficult to drive quick as its traction limited but great fun.

I have ordered new vantage to replace the R8 as my daily. In the wet and cold the R8 is awesome when all other super cars are in the garage you are out having fun but it is except the engine a bit dull. They have a huge following in Europe and US where they are often priced more than equivalant age GT3s. They never got the love in the UK and as such they are a bargain.

DBS will certainly go up in value as well but will need to be looked after and mileage kept down.

As for tracking not the natural place for DBS or even R8 really. I feel DBS on track would be expensive and dissapointing. Buy the DBS and hire a Caterham maybe.

So in summary you need both do some man maths to justify....




Grant3

3,710 posts

286 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all

Enjoyed my time with an R8 V10 Spyder because of the V10’s awesome thrust and sound, but despite its capability it didn’t get under my skin in the way Astons do.

As the guys have said the DBS is a very good sports GT and the exterior design, prestige and special interior will likely give you a feelgood factor and emotive attachment above that offered by the R8. But I would say the V12 Vantage S would better fit a move from the R8 and your brief. smile

vpr

3,935 posts

269 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
I couldn’t imagine tracking a DBS.

Would be like game shooting with an air rifle

old phart

406 posts

141 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
vpr said:
I couldn’t imagine tracking a DBS.

Would be like game shooting with an air rifle
Was that tongue in cheek?
I've tracked my pipe and slippers DB9 twice now. Both times a blast. It's heavy and not really geared for acceleration but what fun! Always one or two corners that I just can't get.

AMDBSVNick

7,221 posts

193 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
3 track days in my old DBS with an instructor by my side.

New CCM's needed.

vpr

3,935 posts

269 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
old phart said:
vpr said:
I couldn’t imagine tracking a DBS.

Would be like game shooting with an air rifle
Was that tongue in cheek?
I've tracked my pipe and slippers DB9 twice now. Both times a blast. It's heavy and not really geared for acceleration but what fun! Always one or two corners that I just can't get.
No, I really couldn't. Too heavy, I just wouldn't enjoy it.

vpr

3,935 posts

269 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
AMDBSVNick said:
3 track days in my old DBS with an instructor by my side.

New CCM's needed.
I rest my case

RSbandit

Original Poster:

3,072 posts

163 months

Sunday 1st April 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys some solid thoughts from people with experience of both cars. Just tô clarify I have the gen 1 plus so certainly less digital than the new R8 but with that stonking V10 engine and the well suited S tronic box. I hope to line up a testdrive in the coming weeks unfortunately the manual cars seem to carry quite a premium to the automatics ( obviously !) so budget might only stretch to an auto. Slight concern that the auto box will feel lethargic compared to the S tronic but will wait for testdrive to confirm. Interesting that others mentioned a V12 Vantage I briefly considered one originally but I had an itch to scratch with the R8 and the mid engine layout, thing is the Vantage doesn't quite have the presence of the DBS but might be better suited to track work . Anyway let's see if I can sort a test drive soon cheers!

V12Vin

40 posts

164 months

Monday 2nd April 2018
quotequote all
I have a gen 1 v10 plus stronic and a V12VSM. And I have tracked both. Different animals on the track. Even on the street, I actually think they complement each other quite well. They each fill a different niche, if that makes sense.

If I were you, I'd trade for the DBS manual or V12VSM or V12VM. The AM SportShift can't compare to Stronic.

For track duties, definitely prefer vantage.



RSbandit

Original Poster:

3,072 posts

163 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Just a quick update I managed to have a test drive in a DBS last week, beautiful car and lovely sound however I don't think its what I'm after...main gripe for me was the glacial gearbox which was much too slow for my liking, it was a 2010 car. I think the V12 Vantage S might be more what I'm after but has the auto box improved from the older DBS box?

dbs2000

2,756 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Drop me a line, I can't email/message you but my manual will be up for sale shortly (just having an MOT and service)

Big E 118

2,468 posts

200 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Think R-Tronic for a comparison to the Sportshift Aston gearboxes. If you couldn't live with an R-Tronic on an R8 you won't like the Sportshift III.

I had a V10 R8 (Gen I not Plus) and my current V8 Vantage is a lot slower, doesn't brake or handle as well, isn't as reliable and personally I wouldn't track it as it's too heavy and not good enough dynamically (in road spec) for me to personally enjoy that.

Saying that I do love the Aston for many other reasons and get more excited about taking it out on the road than I did the R8 as I found the R8 too sterile up to very naughty speeds.

"Horses for courses" though, I can only recommend going out and driving a V12S and see if it gets under your skin.


HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
RSbandit said:
Just a quick update I managed to have a test drive in a DBS last week, beautiful car and lovely sound however I don't think its what I'm after...main gripe for me was the glacial gearbox which was much too slow for my liking, it was a 2010 car. I think the V12 Vantage S might be more what I'm after but has the auto box improved from the older DBS box?
The two are very different, V12VS is an automated manual (SportsShift III) mated to a twinplate clutch, the TT DBS is a 6 speed automatic. Very different driving characteristics, you need to try it..... obviously.

RSbandit

Original Poster:

3,072 posts

163 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
So I had a testdrive in a V12 Vantage S during the week , car in question had a lovely spec lots of extra carbon inside and out looked v impressive in the flesh. Drive was only 20 mins, in auto mode the gearbox felt awful, car would lurch noticeably between changes ...it felt a bit better in manual mode but I was staggered that auto mode felt so disjointed. Anyway the seller generously offered me a half day with the car to get a better feel for it , defo want some more time with it and just drive it on the paddles hope more time in the car will help...in terms of looks noise and presence it really tickled my fancy tho .

RSbandit

Original Poster:

3,072 posts

163 months

Thursday 10th May 2018
quotequote all
just bumping this again, I had a two hour unaccompanied test drive today (fair dues to the seller very accommodating)..boy what a difference it makes to have some proper time in the car. Got to grips with the gearbox, auto mode not used at all only drove it on paddles and lifting slightly for upshifts... it all started to make sense. Found a nice flowing country road and it really was fun hustling the car along there, such a lovely noise and actually found the gearbox pretty compliant when used as above. I think its certainly a more special car than the R8 V10 even tho the latter is no doubt quicker and more planted everywhere, at slower speeds the Vantage felt more interesting and engaging that the Audi. In summary I think it was 'getting under my skin' so I am very tempted to change, I'd look to extend the warranty on the car as its out in Sep. How expensive/often is servicing and what are the most common faults (if any) with the newer V12s? Any other things I should consider from those who have owned this model? Thanks in advance

alscar

10,083 posts

244 months

Thursday 10th May 2018
quotequote all
RS , I have owned my V12S from new over 13k Miles and 3 years - mostly as my dd.
Never used auto ( it’s cr&p ) , paddles are great and in traffic much easier than my old manual v8S.
Curling the toes works well unless full bore up shifts in which case keep foot planted.
Annual service ( fixed price ) at Aston Martin Works is iirc £ 750 pa.
Nothing additional in cost. Uses little oil.
Problems - only niggles - rattles , fuel flap etc.
I had mine ( like most ) Secondary decatted with a rocker switch to activate.
Fabulous car ( once u get it and treat as automated manual ) , great noise.
Every journey special.
Just buy one.

RSbandit

Original Poster:

3,072 posts

163 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
alscar said:
RS , I have owned my V12S from new over 13k Miles and 3 years - mostly as my dd.
Never used auto ( it’s cr&p ) , paddles are great and in traffic much easier than my old manual v8S.
Curling the toes works well unless full bore up shifts in which case keep foot planted.
Annual service ( fixed price ) at Aston Martin Works is iirc £ 750 pa.
Nothing additional in cost. Uses little oil.
Problems - only niggles - rattles , fuel flap etc.
I had mine ( like most ) Secondary decatted with a rocker switch to activate.
Fabulous car ( once u get it and treat as automated manual ) , great noise.
Every journey special.
Just buy one.
Thx for the info... you ever tracked yours?