I need help on choosing DB9 Volante or Vantage Roadster
Discussion
Hi fellow members,
Newbie here from Sweden who is trying to achieve a boyhood dream with an Aston Cab!
Ive had the privilege of driving 3 summer cars the last 3 summers and coming out not loosing a fortune.
1st. S5 cab. 2nd Dodge viper and 3rd summer (last summer) 997.2. Loved them all!
But now I´d really like to have an Aston. Im thinking of an DB9 Volante (2009) or Vantage Roadster from 2012.
The thing I need help with is what you think would be the best buy for me based on this:
-I will only have the car for a year starting now.
- I will not drive the car on tracks, I only use it for weekends to play golf basically.
- Ill drive approx 10000 km - maximum.
- I have a VERY long journey to test drive both of the cars so hence your advice is appreciated.
- The deprecation is a key - and a gamble of course, but there are so few cars here to compare so I have no other good people to ask.
The 2 cars that Ive narrowed it down to is TWO 2012 VantageV8 models.
Nr 1, is a VantageS with basically all equipment and B&O system. Sportshift. 25000 km. 78K euro. All Black.
nr 2, is a regular Vantage with premium audio system. Sportshift. 73K Euro. 25000 km. All black.
Nr 3. The DB9 is a Volante from 2009 with standard equipment all the way, no really extras. All black. 28000 km. 77K euro.
I love both looks equally much. I dont drive live a maniac - just fast on highways. I use it to get Icecream in the sun. Shopping trip to the city.
I love a great stereosystem - but does other people pay premium for B&O, or is it just me :-)
What would you guys recommend? Id love to realize the dream but I like them all so much but the second market resell is very important so I can look aside from B&O for instance if thats just expensive and no one else likes it :-)
I hope I dont break any rules by asking this way, its for me personally but have no contacts to ask so I hope you can give me some hints based on your experience.
Cheers and Happy easter holiday to you all,
Regards Henk
Newbie here from Sweden who is trying to achieve a boyhood dream with an Aston Cab!
Ive had the privilege of driving 3 summer cars the last 3 summers and coming out not loosing a fortune.
1st. S5 cab. 2nd Dodge viper and 3rd summer (last summer) 997.2. Loved them all!
But now I´d really like to have an Aston. Im thinking of an DB9 Volante (2009) or Vantage Roadster from 2012.
The thing I need help with is what you think would be the best buy for me based on this:
-I will only have the car for a year starting now.
- I will not drive the car on tracks, I only use it for weekends to play golf basically.
- Ill drive approx 10000 km - maximum.
- I have a VERY long journey to test drive both of the cars so hence your advice is appreciated.
- The deprecation is a key - and a gamble of course, but there are so few cars here to compare so I have no other good people to ask.
The 2 cars that Ive narrowed it down to is TWO 2012 VantageV8 models.
Nr 1, is a VantageS with basically all equipment and B&O system. Sportshift. 25000 km. 78K euro. All Black.
nr 2, is a regular Vantage with premium audio system. Sportshift. 73K Euro. 25000 km. All black.
Nr 3. The DB9 is a Volante from 2009 with standard equipment all the way, no really extras. All black. 28000 km. 77K euro.
I love both looks equally much. I dont drive live a maniac - just fast on highways. I use it to get Icecream in the sun. Shopping trip to the city.
I love a great stereosystem - but does other people pay premium for B&O, or is it just me :-)
What would you guys recommend? Id love to realize the dream but I like them all so much but the second market resell is very important so I can look aside from B&O for instance if thats just expensive and no one else likes it :-)
I hope I dont break any rules by asking this way, its for me personally but have no contacts to ask so I hope you can give me some hints based on your experience.
Cheers and Happy easter holiday to you all,
Regards Henk
Hi Henk, your intended usage description suggests you are more of a DB9 man than Vantage, the DB9 is more of.a relaxed cruiser rather than sports car, and has more space for the golf clubs too, but both have all the class and looks.
I think you should try both, although that will mean a lot of travelling, but if you don't try both you will forever wonder!!
I think you should try both, although that will mean a lot of travelling, but if you don't try both you will forever wonder!!
I have no idea about residual values in sweeden but my 2c is:
If you are cruising rather than driving hard, the db9 volante would be the easier option, although its a 09 car and the tech is quite old, plus more room for golf clubs and friends. No idea if you can get golf clubs in the back of a vantage roadster?
If you are cruising rather than driving hard, the db9 volante would be the easier option, although its a 09 car and the tech is quite old, plus more room for golf clubs and friends. No idea if you can get golf clubs in the back of a vantage roadster?
Hi Henk
Also a AM newbie, living in Skåne, Sweden. Did have the same considerations 1.5 years ago. Sold my 997 Turbo, to sterile and mainstream for me, and went looking for an AM cab. At that time there were no DB 9 Volantes meeting my demands available in Sweden. So after some time i went for a 2008 Vantage N400 roadster, and i havent regret for one second. Not as fast as the Turbo, but the sound, the looks and the feeling is just perfect. The usage is very semilar to you, 5-10.000 km year, no tracks, icecream and golfdriving :-).
The Premium sound system is ok for me.
Good luck and keep us updated :-)
Also a AM newbie, living in Skåne, Sweden. Did have the same considerations 1.5 years ago. Sold my 997 Turbo, to sterile and mainstream for me, and went looking for an AM cab. At that time there were no DB 9 Volantes meeting my demands available in Sweden. So after some time i went for a 2008 Vantage N400 roadster, and i havent regret for one second. Not as fast as the Turbo, but the sound, the looks and the feeling is just perfect. The usage is very semilar to you, 5-10.000 km year, no tracks, icecream and golfdriving :-).
The Premium sound system is ok for me.
Good luck and keep us updated :-)
I went from a 4.7V8V manual to a 2009 DB9 Vol - ultimately I thought that the Vantage fell between 2 stools ( as we say in the uk!)
I thought it wasn t sharp or light enough to be a pointy darty sports car and not comfortable or spacious enough to be a GT cruiser -
You sound like a GT Cruiser sort of guy so I d go for the DB9 !! - Sportshift in the vantage was also a no no for me - be sure to try it out thoroughly if you do go down that route
Dave
Vantage is more focused, DB9 more GT cruiser.
And you have to consider the gearbox, Sportshift in the Vantage is an automated manual and should not be driven in D mode but as a manual with the paddles and a slight lift off the throttle on gear change. DB9 has a conventional torque converter auto and is probably better suited for a relaxed drive or fast cruise.
And you have to consider the gearbox, Sportshift in the Vantage is an automated manual and should not be driven in D mode but as a manual with the paddles and a slight lift off the throttle on gear change. DB9 has a conventional torque converter auto and is probably better suited for a relaxed drive or fast cruise.
Thank you all for the input!
The DB9 volantes I can only see one available locally...and 1 Vantage...so a trip it is :-)
But in general - which model is easier to resell, or are they equally popular as convertibles?
The thing I thought of to the Vantage is that its a 3 year "younger" car and I can also get Insurance for any motor issuses (8 year deadline) which was a plus.
Regards Henk
The DB9 volantes I can only see one available locally...and 1 Vantage...so a trip it is :-)
But in general - which model is easier to resell, or are they equally popular as convertibles?
The thing I thought of to the Vantage is that its a 3 year "younger" car and I can also get Insurance for any motor issuses (8 year deadline) which was a plus.
Regards Henk
I can't speak much for the Swedish market, but here in the UK prices are pretty stable for older cars. I'd expect the Vantage to depreciate more purely because it is newer. At 6 years old a 2012 Vantage will have a little way to fall, but a 2009 DB9 will be pretty close to the bottom of the value curve already. Over such a short ownership period depreciation is almost impossible to guess, it could be zero (my previous 2006 vantage lost nothing during 2 years), but is unlikely to be more than a few thousand pounds (or tens of thousands of krona).
You haven't mentioned if you are buying privately? If your plan is to buy from a dealer and then sell back to a dealer in a year then I'd expect what you would lose in the dealers profit margin would be much higher than any loss in value due to depreciation. If you are buying and then selling privately then that is not an issue, but if Sweden is anything like the UK you will find very few private sale cars around, they are almost always at dealers, so most of the drop in value will occur on day one when you drive it out of the dealership.
Last year I changed from a Vantage coupe to a DB9 Volante. I agree with the others here that the DB9 is more of a cruiser, it's great on fast open roads rather than driving hard. The softer suspension also makes it more relaxed around town, the Vantage could be a little harsh at times. They are both great cars though and I think my next car might be a V12 Vantage roadster as I miss the smaller more nimble feel.
You haven't mentioned if you are buying privately? If your plan is to buy from a dealer and then sell back to a dealer in a year then I'd expect what you would lose in the dealers profit margin would be much higher than any loss in value due to depreciation. If you are buying and then selling privately then that is not an issue, but if Sweden is anything like the UK you will find very few private sale cars around, they are almost always at dealers, so most of the drop in value will occur on day one when you drive it out of the dealership.
Last year I changed from a Vantage coupe to a DB9 Volante. I agree with the others here that the DB9 is more of a cruiser, it's great on fast open roads rather than driving hard. The softer suspension also makes it more relaxed around town, the Vantage could be a little harsh at times. They are both great cars though and I think my next car might be a V12 Vantage roadster as I miss the smaller more nimble feel.
Henk78 said:
The thing I thought of to the Vantage is that its a 3 year "younger" car and I can also get Insurance for any motor issuses (8 year deadline) which was a plus.
You can buy warranty from an Aston Martin dealer, even for cars older than 8 years, you don't have to buy the car from an approved dealer, you have the car checked by the dealer and they will sell you a warranty for the required period, see below:https://global.astonmartin.com/en-gb/ownership/ext...
If I were to buy privately or from an indenpendent car dealer, I would make this part of the negotiation and buy on condition it has been thoroughly checked by an Aston dealer.
I think both DB9 Volante and Vantage Roadster should hold their value well. Classic timeless shape, relatively low production numbers.
If there is still some remaining Aston warranty by the time you are selling your car, I guess this would help maintain value.
CSK1 said:
You can buy warranty from an Aston Martin dealer, even for cars older than 8 years, you don't have to buy the car from an approved dealer, you have the car checked by the dealer and they will sell you a warranty for the required period, see below:
https://global.astonmartin.com/en-gb/ownership/ext...
If I were to buy privately or from an indenpendent car dealer, I would make this part of the negotiation and buy on condition it has been thoroughly checked by an Aston dealer.
I think both DB9 Volante and Vantage Roadster should hold their value well. Classic timeless shape, relatively low production numbers.
If there is still some remaining Aston warranty by the time you are selling your car, I guess this would help maintain value.
Thanks! I thought it was only possible when buying from AM dealer. But that is very interesting!
@murphyaj: The Volante is private seller, today an other Volante showed up from independent dealer. The Vantage is from AM dealer.
Ill have to go test them and spend a couple of days trying for real. Im scared the sportshift will be to "racy" for me, prefer the PDK feeling and as I understand it wont be that smooth. Perhaps smooth if you learn to master the paddles as I got recommended.
Regarding clutch:
Is the DB9s as weak as the sportshift - around 3000 km?
On a Vantage - is the Manual box stronger/ (should) last longer than sportshift? also to prefer on resale basis perhaps?
I bought the AM bible but this is easier for me to understand when you write so I understand :-)
Thanks again for your help! Much appreciated!
https://global.astonmartin.com/en-gb/ownership/ext...
If I were to buy privately or from an indenpendent car dealer, I would make this part of the negotiation and buy on condition it has been thoroughly checked by an Aston dealer.
I think both DB9 Volante and Vantage Roadster should hold their value well. Classic timeless shape, relatively low production numbers.
If there is still some remaining Aston warranty by the time you are selling your car, I guess this would help maintain value.
Thanks! I thought it was only possible when buying from AM dealer. But that is very interesting!
@murphyaj: The Volante is private seller, today an other Volante showed up from independent dealer. The Vantage is from AM dealer.
Ill have to go test them and spend a couple of days trying for real. Im scared the sportshift will be to "racy" for me, prefer the PDK feeling and as I understand it wont be that smooth. Perhaps smooth if you learn to master the paddles as I got recommended.
Regarding clutch:
Is the DB9s as weak as the sportshift - around 3000 km?
On a Vantage - is the Manual box stronger/ (should) last longer than sportshift? also to prefer on resale basis perhaps?
I bought the AM bible but this is easier for me to understand when you write so I understand :-)
Thanks again for your help! Much appreciated!
DB9 is a torque converter auto so no clutch.
3,000 km with a Sportshift clutch? You should do much more, at least 10 times that, I think some here have more than 50,000 km on the original clutch.
Mine has done 18,000 km and am still on the original clutch and that includes two track days.
3,000 km with a Sportshift clutch? You should do much more, at least 10 times that, I think some here have more than 50,000 km on the original clutch.
Mine has done 18,000 km and am still on the original clutch and that includes two track days.
Gassing Station | Aston Martin | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


