Exhaust Sound Comparison - N/A and Turbo
Exhaust Sound Comparison - N/A and Turbo
Author
Discussion

Jon39

Original Poster:

15,022 posts

174 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all

Two films of Aston Martin GTE cars testing at Monza.

The car in the first film has a naturally aspirated engine, and the second is the 2018 Vantage with turbocharging. The sound difference between the two cars is very noticeable. Do you have a preference ?

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MuOYuuPK01I

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=AxA-U8QbKNc



anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
I think very few people would say the turbocharged engine sounds better. It's by far a better performing engine, but the lack of noise is something inescapable. Turbos act as mufflers in the same way an exhaust system does. I remember back in 2004 when a friend debuted a new pro street race car (a Mercury Cougar with a 598ci big block Ford), it was the first UK car to go the twin turbo route, it made a chunk of power (around 2000bhp) but was almost silent relative to the competition (supercharged and nitrous cars predominantly).

The same is true with F1, the turbo hybrid cars don't produce the outright noise levels, nor rev to the giddy heights of their predecessors. The engineering involved is fantastic, but it does somewhat neutered soundtracks in the majority of cases.

Ex Boy Racer

1,167 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Whether it is by far a better performing engine is debatable. More powerful, more torque; definitely.
Better 'performing' as the centrepiece of an enthusiast's car; not so much

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Ex Boy Racer said:
Whether it is by far a better performing engine is debatable. More powerful, more torque; definitely.
Better 'performing' as the centrepiece of an enthusiast's car; not so much
When I say better performing, I mean in regard of the race cars in question. What it sounds like is of less importance than what it performs like on the track. In the case of the new Vantage, it ought to be more powerful and more economical than the previous car (fuel economy being very handy in endurance racing).

Of course this translates to negativity in the road car offspring as they don't sound as good and lack the theatre and drama that an enthusiast craves.

Ex Boy Racer

1,167 posts

223 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
NFC 85 Vette said:
Ex Boy Racer said:
Whether it is by far a better performing engine is debatable. More powerful, more torque; definitely.
Better 'performing' as the centrepiece of an enthusiast's car; not so much
When I say better performing, I mean in regard of the race cars in question. What it sounds like is of less importance than what it performs like on the track. In the case of the new Vantage, it ought to be more powerful and more economical than the previous car (fuel economy being very handy in endurance racing).

Of course this translates to negativity in the road car offspring as they don't sound as good and lack the theatre and drama that an enthusiast craves.
Ahhh. Should have looked at the videos; I presume they are of race cars???
Apologies

Jon39

Original Poster:

15,022 posts

174 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all

We know lap times for last years car, and some Prodrive staff and any spectators at Monza with a stop watch, will know the lap times of the new car, but I doubt anyone will tell us.

The new Vantage GTE should presumably be faster than its predecessor, but the whole thing is of course complicated by the 'Balance of Performance' system, which endeavours to equalize the lap times of all the cars in the class.




HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
IMHO NOTHING can beat the 'Old' Vantage GTE noise for drama & presence; thank the Lord that it will still be there this year in the WEC wearing the AMR No 98. That said, I don't really care what the new Vantage sounds like as long as it wins races!!

RL17

1,616 posts

124 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Should be 2 and 2 at Le Mans based on entries a while back, hoping to book this week. Anyone else going to see em?

The sound of 95 leaving the pits at about 3.45am about 10 feet in front of us was amazing, Also liked the look & sound of the new one at Brands a couple of months ago and it did corner very well.

As said before good on tyres and ease of changing brakes is the way to get on the podium with a bit of luck the BoP might even allow a win. Probably running with a bit of extra weight at the mo wink

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
RL17 said:
Should be 2 and 2 at Le Mans based on entries a while back, hoping to book this week. Anyone else going to see em?

The sound of 95 leaving the pits at about 3.45am about 10 feet in front of us was amazing, Also liked the look & sound of the new one at Brands a couple of months ago and it did corner very well.

As said before good on tyres and ease of changing brakes is the way to get on the podium with a bit of luck the BoP might even allow a win. Probably running with a bit of extra weight at the mo wink
Hi Reg, we'll be there!! I think the Aston Line-up will be 95 & 97 GTE Pro, 98 & 90 (TF Sport) in Am
Just been told that Red 10 will be on the Driver's Parade on Friday & lead the Parade Lap for the AM Festival Race earlier. As you might imagine we're utterly stoked!

burntout

1,390 posts

185 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
The Naturally aspirated one all day long...... OMG that noise is just amazing....

RL17

1,616 posts

124 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
HBradley said:
Hi Reg, we'll be there!! I think the Aston Line-up will be 95 & 97 GTE Pro, 98 & 90 (TF Sport) in Am
Just been told that Red 10 will be on the Driver's Parade on Friday & lead the Parade Lap for the AM Festival Race earlier. As you might imagine we're utterly stoked!
Driver's Parade excellent and the Festival Race! Is that Saturday morning or lunchtime?

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
HBradley said:
Hi Reg, we'll be there!! I think the Aston Line-up will be 95 & 97 GTE Pro, 98 & 90 (TF Sport) in Am
Just been told that Red 10 will be on the Driver's Parade on Friday & lead the Parade Lap for the AM Festival Race earlier. As you might imagine we're utterly stoked!
Could you really have believed all this would have happened when you bought that ticket thumbup just brilliant and make the most of it!!

Strudul

1,599 posts

116 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
HBradley said:
IMHO NOTHING can beat the 'Old' Vantage GTE noise for drama & presence
Bentley GT3. Video doesn't even do it justice.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYT72xD1La8

Emilio Largo

770 posts

142 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Paul Dalla Lana´s remaining GTE AM #98 Vantage V8 will have field days with the crowds compared to the new car - not only soundwise but also aesthetically.

I´ll keep fingers crossed in the forthcoming season for Dalla Lana/Lamy/Lauda. Last time probably to see "my" car racing.

As to (balance of) performance: Where are the guys in the knowledge? What was the outcome of the pre-test at Paul Ricard? I heard/read nothing about the GTE classes.

David W.

1,952 posts

240 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
The new one’s certainly not going to compeat with the Vetts on noise, lets hope that it can on speed.
DW

RL17

1,616 posts

124 months

Wednesday 18th April 2018
quotequote all
Emilio Largo said:
Paul Dalla Lana´s remaining GTE AM #98 Vantage V8 will have field days with the crowds compared to the new car - not only soundwise but also aesthetically.

I´ll keep fingers crossed in the forthcoming season for Dalla Lana/Lamy/Lauda. Last time probably to see "my" car racing.
Not sure about that as they are running a long season to finish with Le Mans 2019 (still I think as it means the WEC world championship is a potential consolation prize rather than a separate comp to boost another end of season event).

So I don't see how pro-am being in last years car works with a long season (surely makes sense to keep same cars for them??).

GTE Pro win matters, dare I say it but the mid engined 911s in Pro sounded pretty good as well last year getmecoat

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
RL17 said:
HBradley said:
Hi Reg, we'll be there!! I think the Aston Line-up will be 95 & 97 GTE Pro, 98 & 90 (TF Sport) in Am
Just been told that Red 10 will be on the Driver's Parade on Friday & lead the Parade Lap for the AM Festival Race earlier. As you might imagine we're utterly stoked!
Driver's Parade excellent and the Festival Race! Is that Saturday morning or lunchtime?
Here's the full calendar of events for LM24 18 (https://www.lemans.org/en/news/the-crazy-fortnight-of-the-2018-24-hours-of-le-mans-heres-the-program/47965)
The Festival Race is 1015 to 1100 on Sat. Sadly we are not permitted to be in the car due to ACO rules & only their driver will be allowed to take her round the circuit. Needless to say, I'll be having a word beforehand! teacherlaugh

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
IanV12VR said:
Could you really have believed all this would have happened when you bought that ticket thumbup just brilliant and make the most of it!!
Thanks Ian, God no, I'm still shaking my head!
We're trying to make the most of every minute.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
HBradley said:
Thanks Ian, God no, I'm still shaking my head!
We're trying to make the most of every minute.
Not directly linked to this thread, but to add to Ian's comment - I don't think Red 10 could have gone to a better person; the work you do with the benevolent fund is fantastic, Humphrey. It's an excellent cause and you're doing a cracking job supporting them and showing the car at events clap

Anyways, as you were, natural noise or hairdryers, pick yer poison biggrin

RL17

1,616 posts

124 months

Thursday 19th April 2018
quotequote all
HBradley said:
Here's the full calendar of events for LM24 18 (https://www.lemans.org/en/news/the-crazy-fortnight-of-the-2018-24-hours-of-le-mans-heres-the-program/47965)
The Festival Race is 1015 to 1100 on Sat. Sadly we are not permitted to be in the car due to ACO rules & only their driver will be allowed to take her round the circuit. Needless to say, I'll be having a word beforehand! teacherlaugh
Heard they have a couple of Vulcans behind it that'll need to get their tyres and brakes up to temp eek