up, down or sideways?
up, down or sideways?
Author
Discussion

xcentric

Original Poster:

746 posts

250 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
Mix of perspectives on a car buying problem:

  • wife would love an Aston Martin V8 Vantage. I'm quite happy to drive one too
  • a friend's currently been diagnosed with serious health issues -> push to enjoy life now
  • we have a number of fun cars already
  • looking near bottom of market, but probably just into 4.7 territory
  • would be tying up 'investment' money in this, i.e. money that might otherwise go into ISA etc.
the question is, what is the future like?

i.e. how much am I likely to lose if I buy one of these? I am assuming keeping up with the maintenance and putting maybe 5k miles a year on it - will it retain its value, drop, or rise?

The other option is a 993 Porsche, and I think those values are going to go only one way. But we'd both prefer the Aston. But not if it will lose a chunk of money.

We'll not be selling for 3-5 years, probably longer, so would appreciate views from those that either follow the market better than I have, or have experience in this.....

Looking at buying from specialist e.g. McGurk rather than main dealer, would then be selling on either privately pr back to similar specialist.

(yes, I know predicting the future is hard, but seasoned watchers are better at it than just us amateurs.....)

help/advice welcomed.....

Shnozz

30,693 posts

302 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
Personally I’d expect any rise to be negated by running costs of an earlier car. Yes, you can mitigate against big bills early on with a warranty but assuming with a 3-5 year ownership plan you’d run it partly without one during your tenureship. I certainly wouldn’t expect meteoric appreciation purely due to numbers built, although present day they look undervalued when everything else with a nice badge, manual box and a normally aspirated lump has gone bonkers.

I see a market correction shortly and not sure if be investing any savings in cars at all for that reason. However, with the Aston’s having never really got caught up in the massive bubble, it’s surely more immune to a correction and it simply has less to fall in the first instance.

tonyhall38

4,194 posts

247 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
Buy a car to enjoy it....not to make or lose money.....otherwise you get hung up on all that crap it becomes a worry.....and not thing of pleasure....life is too short...if it’s advice you want...don’t buy a car...buy the isa.....at least you will be getting some sort of return...but how boring is that....

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
tonyhall38 said:
Buy a car to enjoy it....not to make or lose money.....otherwise you get hung up on all that crap it becomes a worry.....and not thing of pleasure....life is too short...if it’s advice you want...don’t buy a car...buy the isa.....at least you will be getting some sort of return...but how boring is that....
+1!!!!

IanV12VR

2,749 posts

186 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
Tony is spot on with his comments thumbup

kbooker

728 posts

170 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
A 4.7 Vantage is not a place to invest money looking for a small return, as said, any increase in value, and I don't think there will be especially if you intend to by from a dealer, would be swallowed by running costs. You need to look for an extremely good private buy to get in and out with minimal financial damage.

Air cooled market looks like its beginning to cool, however, if the correction comes I think you'd lose less in a 4.7 as prices are now where near as over inflated as the 993 market.

All just my opinion of course so could be a load of old balls....good luck

GameofCars

850 posts

140 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
tonyhall38 said:
Buy a car to enjoy it....not to make or lose money.....otherwise you get hung up on all that crap it becomes a worry.....and not thing of pleasure....life is too short...if it’s advice you want...don’t buy a car...buy the isa.....at least you will be getting some sort of return...but how boring is that....
+1
If buy an Aston Vantage at the entry level as you say you shouldn't get rinsed but you will have running costs, so not likely to make any money from having an Aston Vantage as they are not rare. Manuals may prove slightly better place for your money. Buy one to enjoy & have fun it will not be an investment. IMO 993 prices have cooled down quite a bit. Also when i was looking last year I didn't find McGurk prices much cheaper - I was after a manual V8VS - and you don't get the timeless warranty.

Edited by GameofCars on Monday 23 April 10:15

ChilliWhizz

12,443 posts

192 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
This is really easy...

The 10 steps to Aston ownership

Step 1: Find Vantage similar year/spec to the one you're thinking of buying
Step 2: Go and view and become totally smitten
Step 3: Take above mentioned car for a drive whilst trying to supress smug smiley look on face
Step 4: Fight off overwhelming urge to buy it there and then. Remember, this is the first one you've looked at
Step 5: Go home and spend considerable amount of time with calculator
Step 6: Throw calculator in bin as it doesn't have man maths function
Step 7: Experience sleepless night filled with images of Aston Martins
Step 8: Wake up next morning with full realisation that you have to have one in your life
Step 9: Sod the ISA, leg it over to McGurks and buy one, probably going over budget in process
Step 10: Live happily ever after knowing that you are a man of great taste, who gets the things he wants in life, and doesn't overly concern himself with such trivia as 'investments'

Ask me how I know this biggrin

dwell

74 posts

114 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
ChilliWhizz said:
This is really easy...

The 10 steps to Aston ownership

Step 1: Find Vantage similar year/spec to the one you're thinking of buying
Step 2: Go and view and become totally smitten
Step 3: Take above mentioned car for a drive whilst trying to supress smug smiley look on face
Step 4: Fight off overwhelming urge to buy it there and then. Remember, this is the first one you've looked at
Step 5: Go home and spend considerable amount of time with calculator
Step 6: Throw calculator in bin as it doesn't have man maths function
Step 7: Experience sleepless night filled with images of Aston Martins
Step 8: Wake up next morning with full realisation that you have to have one in your life
Step 9: Sod the ISA, leg it over to McGurks and buy one, probably going over budget in process
Step 10: Live happily ever after knowing that you are a man of great taste, who gets the things he wants in life, and doesn't overly concern himself with such trivia as 'investments'

Ask me how I know this biggrin
Brilliant response - I gave in after Step 4, five years ago - in that time never regretted it. Over those 5 years it has been the least depreciating car I've had in the last 20 years - go for it!! Dave

murphyaj

1,625 posts

106 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
Astons in general haven't been caught up in the investment bubble, especially the vantage. They follow a more usual downward depreciation curve, usually leveling out after 10 - 15 years. There is a real risk of Ferrari and Lambo values tanking in a year or two, but the market is quite different for the car you're looking at.

An early 4.7 vantage will be close to the flat part of it's curve, it might rise or fall a little bit in the short term, but probably by a few thousand. Over a long period running costs are likely to exceed depreciation, and if you look after it you won't suddently see it dropping by 40%, simply because they've never had that kind of investor market. If "a few thousand" is a large enough amount to swing it for you then 5+ years of Aston ownership probably isn't the best idea. They're pretty reliable if looked after, but it takes some money to do it properly.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
It will still lose money, even if it maintains value in line with inflation and the depreciation has near bottomed out.

You will lose the buy/sell margin, then you are then going to put 25k miles on it - thats perhaps £10-15k total there

then it will cost you say £5k to run a year inc service, consumables, fuel, insurance - thats another £25k over 5 years

thats £40k cost over 5 years for the pleasure of driving your dream car (seems quite reasonable)

.....or put £40k in ISA, invest it and maybe you have £70k in the pot after 5 years

Only you can make the decision based on personal circumstances; how much do you have to have saved up before you feel well off enough to lose £8k a year enjoying the dream car ?

...you can lose £8k in a year buying a new family saloon like millions do every year.........

CMYK

19 posts

103 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
dwell said:
ChilliWhizz said:
This is really easy...

The 10 steps to Aston ownership

Step 1: Find Vantage similar year/spec to the one you're thinking of buying
Step 2: Go and view and become totally smitten
Step 3: Take above mentioned car for a drive whilst trying to supress smug smiley look on face
Step 4: Fight off overwhelming urge to buy it there and then. Remember, this is the first one you've looked at
Step 5: Go home and spend considerable amount of time with calculator
Step 6: Throw calculator in bin as it doesn't have man maths function
Step 7: Experience sleepless night filled with images of Aston Martins
Step 8: Wake up next morning with full realisation that you have to have one in your life
Step 9: Sod the ISA, leg it over to McGurks and buy one, probably going over budget in process
Step 10: Live happily ever after knowing that you are a man of great taste, who gets the things he wants in life, and doesn't overly concern himself with such trivia as 'investments'

Ask me how I know this biggrin
Brilliant response - I gave in after Step 4, five years ago - in that time never regretted it. Over those 5 years it has been the least depreciating car I've had in the last 20 years - go for it!! Dave
Brilliant!!! Follow this mantra but just do it - buy one. I did 4 years ago at step 4 and, 3 AM later still cannot stop grinning whenever I get behind the wheel. Life is short - please enjoy it.

murphyaj

1,625 posts

106 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
bogie said:
It will still lose money, even if it maintains value in line with inflation and the depreciation has near bottomed out.

You will lose the buy/sell margin, then you are then going to put 25k miles on it - thats perhaps £10-15k total there

then it will cost you say £5k to run a year inc service, consumables, fuel, insurance - thats another £25k over 5 years

thats £40k cost over 5 years for the pleasure of driving your dream car (seems quite reasonable)

.....or put £40k in ISA, invest it and maybe you have £70k in the pot after 5 years

Only you can make the decision based on personal circumstances; how much do you have to have saved up before you feel well off enough to lose £8k a year enjoying the dream car ?

...you can lose £8k in a year buying a new family saloon like millions do every year.........
£5k a year feels like it's on the high side to me for a v8v. Insurance was £430 a year for my vantage, and the DB9 is about the same, servicing was under £900 for the service itself. Sure there's fuel and consumables, but the OP states they have "a number" of cars already (their profile lists 5 other cars) so presumably it's not a daily driver and they thus won't be doing big miles. You have to budget for repairs in case of something going wrong, but something big would need to go wrong a few times to spend £20k+ in 5 years, especially if buying from a dealer with a warranty. I might budget that for a DB7, but the vantage is rather better built. Have I just been really lucky with my Astons?

vernierMike

397 posts

125 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
We bought a leggy manual 09 4.7 and part of the decision was that after driving it out of the dealer (prices comparable with specialists in this case) thus taking that first £4-5k hit it should not depreciate too much.

But on the other hand we do expect to swap depreciation with higher general running costs and loads of said grinning. So far, so good!

They truly are fantastic things. A good choice and seemingly one of the more reliable super-sports.

The Man Maths calculator is a wonderful thing, and my wife will ONLY drive manual cars, which helped... I am sure you can imagine the conversation.

sundayjumper

531 posts

313 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
ChilliWhizz said:
This is really easy...

The 10 steps to Aston ownership

Step 1: Find Vantage similar year/spec to the one you're thinking of buying
Step 2: Go and view and become totally smitten
Step 3: Take above mentioned car for a drive whilst trying to supress smug smiley look on face
Step 4: Fight off overwhelming urge to buy it there and then. Remember, this is the first one you've looked at
Step 5: Go home and spend considerable amount of time with calculator
Step 6: Throw calculator in bin as it doesn't have man maths function
Step 7: Experience sleepless night filled with images of Aston Martins
Step 8: Wake up next morning with full realisation that you have to have one in your life
Step 9: Sod the ISA, leg it over to McGurks and buy one, probably going over budget in process
Step 10: Live happily ever after knowing that you are a man of great taste, who gets the things he wants in life, and doesn't overly concern himself with such trivia as 'investments'
Fixed. You're just over-complicating things biggrin

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
murphyaj said:
bogie said:
It will still lose money, even if it maintains value in line with inflation and the depreciation has near bottomed out.

You will lose the buy/sell margin, then you are then going to put 25k miles on it - thats perhaps £10-15k total there

then it will cost you say £5k to run a year inc service, consumables, fuel, insurance - thats another £25k over 5 years

thats £40k cost over 5 years for the pleasure of driving your dream car (seems quite reasonable)

.....or put £40k in ISA, invest it and maybe you have £70k in the pot after 5 years

Only you can make the decision based on personal circumstances; how much do you have to have saved up before you feel well off enough to lose £8k a year enjoying the dream car ?

...you can lose £8k in a year buying a new family saloon like millions do every year.........
£5k a year feels like it's on the high side to me for a v8v. Insurance was £430 a year for my vantage, and the DB9 is about the same, servicing was under £900 for the service itself. Sure there's fuel and consumables, but the OP states they have "a number" of cars already (their profile lists 5 other cars) so presumably it's not a daily driver and they thus won't be doing big miles. You have to budget for repairs in case of something going wrong, but something big would need to go wrong a few times to spend £20k+ in 5 years, especially if buying from a dealer with a warranty. I might budget that for a DB7, but the vantage is rather better built. Have I just been really lucky with my Astons?
Im not estimating £20k of stuff going wrong over 5 years, I was just including all the running costs inc fuel, insurance, road tax etc.

The OP says he will do 5k miles a year - so thats about £2k of fuel towards that £5k yearly running cost, then insurance £800 and £500 road tax...say £3300...only leaves £1700 for servicing/consumables pot....you may get lucky and have £1k spare one year, then the next year the clutch goes or you need a set of tyres and disc/pads and that adds £2500 to the service bill.

Ive had my latest Vantage 19 months, a 2012 4.7 so not far away from what the OP is looking at. So far its had pair tyres, rear pads, 2 services and now a clutch ...over £5k in maintenance, then ive done 14k miles so spent about £5k in fuel and £1200 insurance...an easy spend of £10-12k in a 19 month time frame.

On occasion you may get lucky with a cheap year or two, but as a longer term ownership proposition you are going to see some bigger bills to bring up the average...

mmmm...thinking about it, perhaps its not a good idea to work out the true running costs and just get on with driving it smile




Edited by bogie on Monday 23 April 13:36

murphyaj

1,625 posts

106 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
bogie said:
mmmm...thinking about it, perhaps its not a good idea to work out the true running costs and just get on with driving it smile
Can certainly agree on that.

xcentric

Original Poster:

746 posts

250 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
lots of interesting input here.

Am not realistically expecting it to be an investment (through some cars we have are that). Am just wanting it to be a flattish curve, which it seems it is. Fuel costs can be ignored, not cos they are not there, but cos we'd be putting it into something else if not this.

Insurance should probably be about £600. Tax £500, or £250 if I SORN it for the winter. So it's servicing, and disks/pads etc. I can do disks/pads myself, but I suspect it's the cost of them and not the labour that kills. Servicing I'll keep the stamps going into the book.

And depreciation - which is the one imponderable.....

Agree on the life is short thing: but also having had my pension slashed recently, need to have one eye on that.

Loved the checklist, however. Keep the thoughts coming.....

nickv8

1,571 posts

114 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
xcentric said:
Loved the checklist, however. Keep the thoughts coming.....
OK... forget the maths bit. If it wasn’t your favourite subject as a kid, it still won’t be now.

When we’re all in incontinence pants housed up in a home our offspring chose for us for all the right reasons, and you strike up a conversation with a fellow inmate, which topic will still make you have a gummy grin?

The one about how you gained 3.86% compound interest payment through careful ISA selection? Or the one about how you gazed upon your Aston day in, day out and every other occasion between having drives of your life?

What is an ISA, anyway? wink

V12VMan

365 posts

214 months

Monday 23rd April 2018
quotequote all
xcentric said:
Mix of perspectives on a car buying problem:

  • wife would love an Aston Martin V8 Vantage. I'm quite happy to drive one too
  • a friend's currently been diagnosed with serious health issues -> push to enjoy life now
  • we have a number of fun cars already
  • looking near bottom of market, but probably just into 4.7 territory
  • would be tying up 'investment' money in this, i.e. money that might otherwise go into ISA etc.
the question is, what is the future like?

i.e. how much am I likely to lose if I buy one of these? I am assuming keeping up with the maintenance and putting maybe 5k miles a year on it - will it retain its value, drop, or rise?

The other option is a 993 Porsche, and I think those values are going to go only one way. But we'd both prefer the Aston. But not if it will lose a chunk of money.

We'll not be selling for 3-5 years, probably longer, so would appreciate views from those that either follow the market better than I have, or have experience in this.....

Looking at buying from specialist e.g. McGurk rather than main dealer, would then be selling on either privately pr back to similar specialist.

(yes, I know predicting the future is hard, but seasoned watchers are better at it than just us amateurs.....)

help/advice welcomed.....
I have three points to offer, 1. life is not a rehersal you’re only passing through! 2, regret the things you did rather than you didn’t do, and finally you can’t take the money with you. So as many replies have said go buy the Aston, live/drive with a permant smile of your face and enjoy the respect of other road users - sadly from previous experience young don’t get with a porker!