Seriously, what is wrong with you lot?
Seriously, what is wrong with you lot?
Author
Discussion

Ex Boy Racer

Original Poster:

1,167 posts

223 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
I have read this forum regularly since getting my first Aston Martin about 3 years ago. Always found it quite active and, on the whole, interesting and enjoyable.
There have been times when I have winced (people 'in the know' boasting about seeing the new Vantage so early and how amazing it looked for instance. Or rather unpleasant references to 'lady boys' etc. I could go on) but I kind of thought that's the point of forums on the interweb - lots of opinions, not all of them what I would have thought appropriate but it's my choice whether I read them or not.
Recent developments have made me wonder what's going on and, frankly, how mature people who are successful enough to buy very expensive cars can behave in a way that I wouldn't accept from my children.
Surely no-one (except Haymarket) owns this forum? Which means any person's opinion is just as valid as anyone else's?
If you don't like that someone hates the AMG engine and wants to say so, then argue against it or ignore it. Don't tell them they're not allowed to play in your playground any more (which isn't yours anyway). It smacks of the thought police telling us what we're allowed to think and say.
To a casual observer it is all so childish it beggars belief.
Right. Got it off my chest. Won't be posting again.

Ps. What is impossible to argue against is that Aston Martin has scored an own goal here. A new, vital product should not get this level of bile directed at it on launch. At the very least their PR machine should have anticipated it and dealt with it well before it got like this. I have launched a number of products for clients in my time and would have been very concerned if one of mine had gone like this

CSK1

1,833 posts

155 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
Completely agree.
I think the AMOC forum is starting to look more interesting than this one.
I never thought I would say that!

Venturist

3,472 posts

226 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
The issue is that any thread on new Vantage seems to derail into the same handful of voices loudly expressing the same opinions they have done for the last 12 months, completely drowning out any other discussion...

Loose_Cannon

1,602 posts

284 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
Ex Boy Racer said:
There have been times when I have winced (people 'in the know' boasting about seeing the new Vantage so early and how amazing it looked for instance.
The pages and pages of personal opinions on the new Vantage do look tiresome, however they are easy to ignore if like me you have no interest or will never own one.

However the oh so subtle one upmanship that occasionally occurs here is less so; your reference to "I'm so special" visits to the factory is a good example, plus certain people's off-topic and irrelevant references to tennis courts/thatched houses in the Cotswolds/villas in Tuscany are indeed bile inducing (you know who you are).

There really is no need, this is a forum for marque enthusiasts not people who can't enjoy being rich without everyone else knowing they are.



GameofCars

850 posts

140 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
True, but absolutely no comparison to the slanging matches on the Porsche forum. On the whole the AM forum is more gentlemanly.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
Loose_Cannon said:
However the oh so subtle one upmanship that occasionally occurs here is less so; your reference to "I'm so special" visits to the factory is a good example, plus certain people's off-topic and irrelevant references to tennis courts/thatched houses in the Cotswolds/villas in Tuscany are indeed bile inducing (you know who you are).
In my defense, I was bursting for a wee wee, and it was dark, and I had no idea it was a swimming pool.

HBradley

1,037 posts

212 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
NFC 85 Vette said:
In my defense, I was bursting for a wee wee, and it was dark, and I had no idea it was a swimming pool.
hehe

B4rnst4ble

799 posts

180 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
come on people lets have a group hug and get back together

I was just reading this to my butler who was so shocked he rushed into the west wing to tell the maid but slipped on a drop of the methuselah of dom pom 1996 Rosé Gold he was pouring and went crashing down the rococo stairs, I have promised him the bad feelings wont continue and am now driving him to the hospital in the Bugatti, lets not let these bad feeling happen again as its hard finding good hired help


dbs2000

2,756 posts

223 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
B4rnst4ble said:
come on people lets have a group hug and get back together

I was just reading this to my butler who was so shocked he rushed into the west wing to tell the maid but slipped on a drop of the methuselah of dom pom 1996 Rosé Gold he was pouring and went crashing down the rococo stairs, I have promised him the bad feelings wont continue and am now driving him to the hospital in the Bugatti, lets not let these bad feeling happen again as its hard finding good hired help

Sent from my iPhoneX
In my Tuscan Villa

AdamV12AMR

1,389 posts

187 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
Ex Boy Racer said:
What is impossible to argue against is that Aston Martin has scored an own goal here. A new, vital product should not get this level of bile directed at it on launch. At the very least their PR machine should have anticipated it and dealt with it well before it got like this.
I disagree this is impossible to argue against.

The Aston owners here on PH are a tiny subset of the current and future ownership base. And those that don't like the new Vantage's engine are a further niche-within-a-niche, so I really think there needs to be a reality check here on 'the level of bile' there actually is, outside of the bubble that is Pistonheads > Forums > Other Marques > Aston Martin. It's practically the Dark Web down here biggrin

The press reception around the engine has been surprisingly and universally positive, and if you're a Porsche / Merc / Audi owner in the market for a new c£140k sportscar, you'll be more likely to get your buying advice from YouTube, Top Gear, evo or Autocar than you are from a bunch of passionate owners how love their n/a V8 and V12 dinosaurs.

Given Aston are in the business of making money, saving on the development, testing, approval and manufacturing costs associated with a new 'Aston Martin' engine (built in a shed in Cologne), whilst engineering-in what is widely regarded as the best V8 available, mated to the best gearbox on the market... ...I'd hardly call that an own-goal scratchchin

Edited by AdamV12AMR on Tuesday 8th May 13:02

davek_964

11,377 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
Loose_Cannon said:
The pages and pages of personal opinions on the new Vantage do look tiresome, however they are easy to ignore if like me you have no interest or will never own one.
Yep, I've missed the whole thing - I can't / wouldn't buy a new Vantage so haven't even read the thread. I've not noticed any animosity on other threads, so guess it's just there.

GameofCars said:
True, but absolutely no comparison to the slanging matches on the Porsche forum. On the whole the AM forum is more gentlemanly.
Absolutely true. I had a 996 turbo before I got the Vantage - I don't miss the Porsche forum. It's like a school playground.

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all

B4rnst4ble said:
come on people lets have a group hug and get back together

I was just reading this to my butler who was so shocked he rushed into the west wing to tell the maid but slipped on a drop of the methuselah of dom pom 1996 Rosé Gold he was pouring and went crashing down the rococo stairs, I have promised him the bad feelings wont continue and am now driving him to the hospital in the Bugatti, lets not let these bad feeling happen again as its hard finding good hired help

~ wink

Generally I consider this forum is reasonably polite compared to others. I rarely venture on to others, but have seen enough to know that I do not wish to read many of the comments. After all, we even do punctuation on this forum, which seems rare.
The occasional references to wealth here are sometimes humorous. I forget the joke I made about my butler and chauffeur, but actually I am the only employee in my household, so my wife makes clear. ~ wink

The very fact that we are AM owners and enthusiasts, probably indicates that we are more understated, than show offs by nature. Being of age, I could not own a Ferrari, Lamborghini etc. even though I admire their design and engineering. A sports car for me needs to be slightly old school, with understated beauty, but still capable of 'adequate' performance.

When I see the references to ' I've just bought this ', which might have cost £200,000, I don't think bragging, I am just pleased that AML have received more much needed revenue. We saw from my topic about multiple AM owners, that repeat buyers have been extremely important to AM sales.

The recent kerfuffel probably arose as the result of repeating an identical opinion so many times, and nothing to do with actual opinion itself. We like different opinions. I think China, fuel consumption, and emissions, are why engines now need to be under 4 litres. Smaller engines need turbochargers to raise the power levels, which in turn changes the exhaust sounds that we have so enjoyed.
Several matters have resulted in these changes, but it seems to be just the way things are.









Edited by Jon39 on Tuesday 8th May 13:20

pggroves

92 posts

246 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
I’m sorry if you don’t post again. It’s a broad church with all sorts commenting. I’m not a fan of either the new Vantage or DB 11 as I can live with the exterior but not the interiors.
I’m not however bothered about the AMG engine as I realise from a purely commercial and financial perspective it makes perfect sense. I’m ex TVR and remember the damage the speed 6 problems did to the marque. Mine was never problematic but you always had the feeling that it might go pop at any moment. AMG Mercedes have huge funding and research facilities and it makes sense to me .
Frankly if I had £100k plus to spend on a change from my current Vantage I’d be looking for a second hand Vanquish as to me that sums up everything Aston Martin should be,so I hope they don’t make cock of that replacement, but my dearly beloved says I’m boring old fart , red trousers and all.

Bobajobbob

1,599 posts

127 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
As forums go this is pretty civilised and good humoured. Read what you want and ignore the rest. Isn't that the best policy when it comes to the internet?

For what it is worth it isn't the Mercedes engine that puts me off buying the new Vantage. It's the looks and the cost. At the new price point there are a lot other very good cars to choose from but even if there wasn't and the car was cheaper I still don't want one because I just don't think the front end is a good enough design. If I have made that point a few times on different threads is because it's frustrating to me that they are so close but yet so far. Small subtle changes and/or improvements to bonnet and lights could and probably will in the future evolve into something special but in its current guise to coin an internet phrase.......meh.

avinalarf

6,438 posts

173 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
I have been a member of this forum for several years and have always found fellow members very helpful when asked for their advice and this forum a good resource for AM related info.
I quite often bookmark advice on topics for further reference when and if required.
I also enjoy the banter that some of us indulge in,albeit some of the banter has a history that newer members will be unaware of and therefore the context is not apparent,however the camaraderie is heartwarming and although you find it tiresome and childish others do not but simply recognise it for what it is ....harmless banter.
Many owners of Astons on this forum have formed friendships through their banter and that is surely a good thing.
The conversations over the new Vantage has been a bit devisive and repetitive but the Topic headings are perfectly clear for all to see and avoid if required.
It is not surprising,to me, that as the new Vantage has a Merc derived engine and new design grill that it has not appealed to everybody but I remember when the DB's morphed into the Vantage in the 1970's it was not to everybody's taste.
I believe we have conversed on this forum and never got the impression that you were so critical of its content.
Sorry to see that you find it necessary to leave the forum
All the best
Steven

RobDown

3,807 posts

159 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
I’ll be sorry if Ex Boy Racer feels the need to go elsewhere

This forum is about expressing opinions on the cars (good and bad), helping people with issues (preferably car related), organising get togethers, sharing the joy of Aston Martin ownership

I make no apologies. If someone is being rude I will object to it. If someone persists in high-jacking threads (as has happened with a potentially interesting thread with peoples impressions of actually driving the new car) then I will also comment on it. Others will just simply ignore and turn a cheek. That is their choice and I respect it

Politeness costs nothing, even on an Internet forum

beer

Edited by RobDown on Tuesday 8th May 13:55

telum01

987 posts

146 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
There are a lot of unspoken "rules" when it comes to Aston Martins. Breaking one of those rules is usually met with loud disdain. It happens here and elsewhere. There's a FB group where someone posted some interior lighting he did and a bunch of people were pretty harsh with their reactions to it. What I've found makes PH difficult is that there are also bandwagons that, when crossed, will be vocal in their "corrections" to whatever was said.

It took me a long time to post on PH because I didn't want to get pulled into any of the squabbles I saw popping up regularly. Many people don't post on PH at all. The Aston section, while small and obscure in its 'other marques' section compared to other PH sections, does get a ton of traffic by viewers that never register and never participate in conversation. It's just not worth risking being pulled into a meaningless internet spat.

I try to find positive ways to engage people because I remember when I was the one trying to figure out how to get involved but being worried about crossing the wrong clique. You never know who's reading the things we post, and how what we say affects those people. One thing we all have in common is wanting to see the marque succeed. We aren't helping that if we scare people away when they approach PH to explore a brand they might buy into.

Just my opinion, of course.

avinalarf said:
I also enjoy the banter that some of us indulge in,albeit some of the banter has a history that newer members will be unaware of and therefore the context is not apparent,however the camaraderie is heartwarming and although you find it tiresome and childish others do not but simply recognise it for what it is ....harmless banter.
This is an unavoidable challenge for any group of people, all the more difficult when online and there's so much context, tone, and inference missing when looking at plain text on a screen. That, and British humor is really dry compared to others so it's that much more difficult to figure out what's said in seriousness and what's said in jest lol

divetheworld

2,565 posts

166 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
avinalarf said:
I have been a member of this forum for several years and have always found fellow members very helpful when asked for their advice and this forum a good resource for AM related info.
I quite often bookmark advice on topics for further reference when and if required.
I also enjoy the banter that some of us indulge in,albeit some of the banter has a history that newer members will be unaware of and therefore the context is not apparent,however the camaraderie is heartwarming and although you find it tiresome and childish others do not but simply recognise it for what it is ....harmless banter.
Many owners of Astons on this forum have formed friendships through their banter and that is surely a good thing.
The conversations over the new Vantage has been a bit devisive and repetitive but the Topic headings are perfectly clear for all to see and avoid if required.
It is not surprising,to me, that as the new Vantage has a Merc derived engine and new design grill that it has not appealed to everybody but I remember when the DB's morphed into the Vantage in the 1970's it was not to everybody's taste.
I believe we have conversed on this forum and never got the impression that you were so critical of its content.
Sorry to see that you find it necessary to leave the forum
All the best
Steven
Or you could ignore him as one of the deviants we’re always slagging off. smile

I’d suggest sticking around as when we get to know you better, you may find we’re equally at home taking the pi ss out of you too.
Very few have been elevated to the lofty title of “knob”.

Sigh. Unlike Steven, we can only aspire.

P.S.
These are all ‘in jokes’.

avinalarf

6,438 posts

173 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
divetheworld said:
Or you could ignore him as one of the deviants we’re always slagging off. smile

I’d suggest sticking around as when we get to know you better, you may find we’re equally at home taking the pi ss out of you too.
Very few have been elevated to the lofty title of “knob”.

Sigh. Unlike Steven, we can only aspire.

P.S.
These are all ‘in jokes’.
Dearest DTW
I find your post a tad confusing.
Are you referring to me as a deviant ?
Are you referring to me as a knob ?
Do you include me as a pisstaker ?
If so....how very dare you.......laugh

B4rnst4ble

799 posts

180 months

Tuesday 8th May 2018
quotequote all
[quote=Bobajobbob]As forums go this is pretty civilised and good humoured. Read what you want and ignore the rest. Isn't that the best policy when it comes to the internet?

no delete viewing history is the best policy biglaugh