Still searching for my dream car...
Still searching for my dream car...
Author
Discussion

Robert_F

Original Poster:

100 posts

102 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Hi guys,

I'm in the process of looking for a sporty GT as a second car. I started a couple of months ago and got very close to pulling the trigger on a 2009 DBS in Lightening Silver. But ultimately balked at the idea of spending upwards of £80k on a 10 year old car (even though I love the looks). I've been flirting with the Maserati GT-S given they are now very reasonably priced and have seen 3 different examples, but ultimately I feel like the interior really hasn't aged well / lived up to the occasion of driving the car.

So I've slightly gone full circle and I'm now back to the Aston's!

I'd be interested to hear what people think about the 13MY car vs. a 2009 model? I've seen a 2014 car for around £75k with low mileage (14k), or a 09 car for £55k with 25k miles on the clock.

Whilst the newer car is really pushing my budget, it feels like you are also getting a lot more car for the money given the model updates. I also reckon the depreciation over 2-3 years may be broadly similar (perhaps 10-15k over that period).

Cheers

Loose_Cannon

1,602 posts

284 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Just personally the newer car is far better looking, and as with most Astons the newer = better built.

You are in the world of totally irrational purchases anyway, just go with your heart!

Robert_F

Original Poster:

100 posts

102 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Loose_Cannon said:
Just personally the newer car is far better looking, and as with most Astons the newer = better built.

You are in the world of totally irrational purchases anyway, just go with your heart!
A very good point! The refreshed looks is probably my main reason for preferring the newer car as well.

Loose_Cannon

1,602 posts

284 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Indeed, I was watching Astons own promo video for the facelift DB9 which included side by side footage in the Alps with a silver DB5. IMHO the newer car actually eclipsed the old for looks...not something that happens often.

If I had stretched to a facelift DB9 when I had the financial opportunity I may not be selling my 07 now.....if you can do it go for it.

Jon39

15,022 posts

174 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all

Loose_Cannon said:
Just personally the newer car is far better looking ...

Just personally the older car is far better looking.

Design detail perfection, and how Ian Callum intended. Model Years 2009 to 2012 are the sweet spot of the Vantage. 4.7 engine and still with the original classic design. Take a look at the new V600. The original smooth rounded sills are back. They visually enhance the width of the rear arches.

Pleasing that we all like different things though, Loose_Cannon.

OP - Many Aston Martins have a pampered life, so don't necessarily compare a 10 year old Aston, with an average 10 year old car. Condition of course is the important aspect when buying.

I like the design of Maseratis, but hear that they depreciate in value rapidly. If so, then total ownership cost would be high compared to a 10 year old DBS.

Best of luck with your search. They are wonderful cars to own.











Edited by Jon39 on Monday 14th May 13:33

Robert_F

Original Poster:

100 posts

102 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Jon39 said:

Just personally the older car is far better looking.

Design detail perfection, and how Ian Callum intended. Model Years 2009 to 2012 are the sweet spot of the Vantage. 4.7 engine and still with the original classic design. Take a look at the new V600. The original smooth rounded sills are back. They visually enhance the width of the rear arches.
Just realised I didn't specify that I was looking at the DB9... sorry!

shuzzy

294 posts

245 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Having owned a 2007 DB9 myself for some time I loved the car and it was a pleasure to own. That's not to say it didn't have its niggles, but this was eclipsed by the overall ownership experience. I did however hanker after the DB9.2 new model. Fortunately I was in a position last year to upgrade to a 2013 DB9, and the joy of ownership has multiplied by 10. It really is far superior to the older model in every way. However the running costs have also increased, so everything is relative. The new car was twice the price of my old DB9, I have to pay for annual tracker subscription and the front brake pads cost almost as much as discs and pads all round on the old one. Routine servicing is the same price, so as long you don't have any nasty surprises. So if you are able to stretch to the newer model, then I would say it's the right choice every time. Anyway any excuse for some gratuitous shots





The interiors are almost the same

Old model


new model


Robert_F

Original Poster:

100 posts

102 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Thanks Shuzzy, that is really useful to know!

Loose_Cannon

1,602 posts

284 months

Monday 14th May 2018
quotequote all
Tough one for you! The DB9.1 is drop dead gorgeous. The DB9.2 is sell the house and wife into prostitution type gorgeous (all IMHO of course!).

The only thing that puts me off the facelift (apart from financial paucity) is the ridiculous costs of carbon brakes components, apart from that its hard to think of a more desirable car.