V12 in the New Vantage? Why?
V12 in the New Vantage? Why?
Author
Discussion

telum01

Original Poster:

987 posts

146 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
Two related questions...

Why do people keep insisting the V12 is the quintessential Aston Martin engine?

The earliest Aston Martins used inline 4-cylinder engines. A straight-6 engine wasn't introduced until the DB2 in 1950. The V8 came in 1969. The V12 wasn't introduced until 1999 in the DB7 V12 Vantage. If someone wants to correct this, please do...

I4: 36 years (first use in 1913, last use in 1949)^
I6: 49 years (first use in 1950, last use in 1999)
V8: 44 years (first use in 1969, still in use)^^
V12: 20 years (first use in 1999, still in use)

^Add 4 years if you count the Cygnet.
^^6-year gap from 2000-2005

Based on that, the V12 isn't Aston's heritage/classic/must-have/quintessential/whatever engine. Not only is it the newest engine, it's also been used for the shortest amount of time. So the argument that the V12 is the de facto Aston Martin engine just doesn't hold up. Or am I missing something? The V8 was introduced far earlier than the V12 and is still in use. And, based on that....

Why should the new V12 TT engine go in the New Vantage?

The Vantage is supposed to be a smaller, lighter, more sporty Aston. The DB11 is supposed to be a bigger, heavier, more comfortable GT. The AMG V8 gives the New Vantage as much power as the outgoing N/A V12, but in a much more lightweight package. Putting a big, heavy V12 into it would upset the weight distribution and defeat the whole purpose of the Vantage model. It did work in the previous Vantage because the power difference was so drastic between the 4.7L V8 and 5.9L V12. But the AMG V8 closed that gap without needing the extra weight. So why should the new V12 TT go into the New Vantage if the "Aston's true engine is a V12" argument can't be used based on what I said at the beginning of this post?

gibbon

2,182 posts

238 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
I thought the same when i read the recent 'quintessentially aston v12' posts.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
telum01 said:
Two related questions...

Why do people keep insisting the V12 is the quintessential Aston Martin engine?

The earliest Aston Martins used inline 4-cylinder engines. A straight-6 engine wasn't introduced until the DB2 in 1950. The V8 came in 1969. The V12 wasn't introduced until 1999 in the DB7 V12 Vantage. If someone wants to correct this, please do...

I4: 36 years (first use in 1913, last use in 1949)^
I6: 49 years (first use in 1950, last use in 1999)
V8: 44 years (first use in 1969, still in use)^^
V12: 20 years (first use in 1999, still in use)

^Add 4 years if you count the Cygnet.
^^6-year gap from 2000-2005

Based on that, the V12 isn't Aston's heritage/classic/must-have/quintessential/whatever engine. Not only is it the newest engine, it's also been used for the shortest amount of time. So the argument that the V12 is the de facto Aston Martin engine just doesn't hold up. Or am I missing something? The V8 was introduced far earlier than the V12 and is still in use. And, based on that....

Why should the new V12 TT engine go in the New Vantage?

The Vantage is supposed to be a smaller, lighter, more sporty Aston. The DB11 is supposed to be a bigger, heavier, more comfortable GT. The AMG V8 gives the New Vantage as much power as the outgoing N/A V12, but in a much more lightweight package. Putting a big, heavy V12 into it would upset the weight distribution and defeat the whole purpose of the Vantage model. It did work in the previous Vantage because the power difference was so drastic between the 4.7L V8 and 5.9L V12. But the AMG V8 closed that gap without needing the extra weight. So why should the new V12 TT go into the New Vantage if the "Aston's true engine is a V12" argument can't be used based on what I said at the beginning of this post?
Some would argue that a true Aston engine should be an inline six. They might be right; we all have different timelines when it comes to appreciation of a certain era of car. For me, I grew up adoring the DB5 and first gen Vanquish - the latter becoming what I aspired to own. In later years I grew fond of the Oscar India Vantage, because that makes a noise I've only heard in NASCAR. Each period has had very different, but always splendid engines.

From a performance and balance perspective, the 5.2 V12 is the last thing the new Vantage needs, but it might well still get it, because despite it making the car perform less like a sports car and more like a GT, or even a muscle car, there's a large demographic for whom it's classed as a 'proper' engine as opposed to the AMG derived V8. It wouldn't matter the M178 and other derivatives will produce up to 800bhp with relatively minor tinkering, because the desire for a V12 is borne out of little more than it being...just more.

Times have changed though, and the vanilla, regular, base spec Vantage available, now slaughters every iteration of the old car. It would be interesting to see what's quicker on the road or on track, the new Vantage or a GT12?

In time, when some test drives have taken place, the ability of the car in base form might change the opinion of what the car needs in regard to extra performance. I can appreciate the gripes some have about the noise, and Aston did an exceptional job on the AM31 to make a turbo'd V12 sound unlike a typical turbo engine, but personally I'd take the better balanced chassis over a better noise.

spyker138

930 posts

255 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
I agree and my point in Vantage posts has been about the origin of the engineering (but we've been told not to talk about that any more).

I have also advocated for an smaller lighter straight six so long as (and that's an important SO LONG AS) the package is lightened considerably and made naturally agile (not electronically assisted agile). Less is more.

I think the V12 made sense when adding cubes was easier than laggy turbos and the car kept getting porkier.

So yes I'd be delighted with a slightly roomier Sagaris with Aston engineered 3.0L straight six, higher build quality, a carbon tub, a few more safety features, and minimal superfluous bits (screens, the mouse, electric seat adjustment etc etc). Say 1250Kg. That would be a real Vantage. IMHO.


DB9VolanteDriver

2,661 posts

207 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
Simple, really. It is the only Aston engine being produced. Choice of that vs the AMG lump? No contest...an ASTON engine.

RobbW

32 posts

112 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
Good posts. It may have something to do with the GT cars competing with Ferrari for exclusivity where the 12 cylinder reigns for dollars and enzo’s Comments about what constitutes a real Ferrari.

The Aston’s are compared against Ferrari on top gear etc...

I also think those shows always marveled at the mystique of “shoehorning” the biggest engine possible into the car.

Those two items have created the “modern expectation”.

I’m good with any engine in the whole package. But also look at Maserati... do you really want a v6 turbo when a V8 turbo is available? Most want the biggest engine.

I could have picked up a v12 vantage but did not see double the cost difference in that case since 90% of the car is the same and there was no real measurable difference in the seat of the pants on driving both it and the V8. They were both great. I bought the V8.

Engines less than V8 don’t really excite me though... so don’t know that I could buy a 6...

Robb

12pack

1,695 posts

199 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
RobbW said:
Engines less than V8 don’t really excite me though...
..could say the same for a V12 wink

AstonV

1,657 posts

137 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
DB9VolanteDriver said:
Simple, really. It is the only Aston engine being produced. Choice of that vs the AMG lump? No contest...an ASTON engine.
Ding ding ding we have a winner! You are correct.

It's also about choice. No one needs an Aston when a Focus will do.

M5MarkM

1,686 posts

202 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
Now I might be wrong BUT I think the one thing all the previous engines had in common was that they were N/A.....

Neil1300r

5,785 posts

209 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
Question - Mr Mallory why do you want to climb Everest
George Mallory - "Because its there!"

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
Because they can (and should).

RobDown

3,807 posts

159 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
You’re quite right Rich in that it’s not a traditional AM engine.

But the bottom line is if it’s technically feasible (and it sounds like it will be), people will want to buy it. Not because it’s made by AM, nor because it’s better for the car (the handling will be worse), but because it’s bigger and therefore seen as better (look at Bentley, the V8 Conti I’m told is the better car, no one wants to buy it).

And if people want to buy it, AML would be mad not to make

Now all we need is Michelin to develop tyres that will cope with a Vantage trying to lay down 730BHP smile

Edited by RobDown on Monday 21st May 23:06

embdenb

170 posts

134 months

Monday 21st May 2018
quotequote all
macdeb said:
Because they can (and should).
I believe the American market dictates, or requires it. It’s a hugely important market for AM, and we cannot have too much horsepower in a country where gas is relatively cheap.
Camaros pushing 650 HP, Roush Mustangs 700 HP, Mopars 7 to 8 hundred HP.
We have become drunk with horsepower that we cannot use.
It’s all about marketing, and the price of admission is now in excess of 600 HP.

old phart

406 posts

141 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
My two cents. It’s all about the sound. A straight 6 sounds sooooo smooth. V12 smoother yet. Growing up I loved my V8 and how my cam made it idle like I had crossed some plug wires. We used to idle them down so that they bounced around even more.
Now A big V8 sounds so crude.
The flat plane V8’s intrigue me. Anyone care to enlighten me? Is the Aston V8 a flat plane? Is that one of the secrets to the Ferrari distinctive sound?

RobbW

32 posts

112 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
Yes Ferrari v8 are flat plane crank.

Robb

AstonV

1,657 posts

137 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
old phart said:
My two cents. It’s all about the sound. A straight 6 sounds sooooo smooth. V12 smoother yet. Growing up I loved my V8 and how my cam made it idle like I had crossed some plug wires. We used to idle them down so that they bounced around even more.
Now A big V8 sounds so crude.
The flat plane V8’s intrigue me. Anyone care to enlighten me? Is the Aston V8 a flat plane? Is that one of the secrets to the Ferrari distinctive sound?
No Aston is cross plane. Ford Voodoo is flat plane, has it's own distinct sound, but not Ferrari like since it has a different firing order.

ChilliWhizz

12,443 posts

192 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
V8 Cerbera's are flat plane......... cloud9

Speedraser

1,712 posts

214 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
DB9VolanteDriver said:
Simple, really. It is the only Aston engine being produced. Choice of that vs the AMG lump? No contest...an ASTON engine.
Exactly. IMO, it's not an Aston Martin if it has a Benz engine. The New Vantage has ZERO appeal to me for that reason.

While I think an Aston must have an Aston engine, I completely agree with Rich that the engine does not need to be a V12. In fact, I've made exactly the same point about Aston's engine history from 4s through 12s on these forums.

BTW, forced induction is not new.

Edit: Rich, no, do NOT count the Cygnet!

RobDown

3,807 posts

159 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
And another thread dies

I think I’m going to take a break from PH. I might scream if I see another speedraser post on this

Or Spyker123 making some snide comment (btw Spyker we all saw your post, before you deleted it, where you complained about photos of people’s cars and how poor their houses looked).

I’m oot

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2018
quotequote all
RobDown said:
And another thread dies

I think I’m going to take a break from PH. I might scream if I see another speedraser post on this

Or Spyker123 making some snide comment (btw Spyker we all saw your post, before you deleted it, where you complained about photos of people’s cars and how poor their houses looked).

I’m oot
It's disappointing that every thread related to the new Vantage ends up in the same state (AMG derived engine bashing). What baffles me though, is that as much there's complaints that it's not a 'real' Aston engine, you don't have to go very far to find other threads where finding a Volvo part number to save a bit of money on something for a previous gen Vantage is welcomed. Surely if we're wanting a 'pure' Aston Martin, it's meant to constructed from Aston bits, not Ford or Volvo bits?

Throughout its history, Aston has made good use of out sourcing the R&D heavy parts (gearboxes more than engines). In current guise, they do a cracking job of making the bespoke items themselves, in house. All the tactile items that a driver would touch, are no longer from a parts bin, hence the cars feel more premium IMO. That, to me is progress.

In regard to the V12 yay or nay; as noted above, there's an expectation it'll happen, probably just because it can, regardless of whether there's a performance benefit. There's a good chance it'll be quicker to develop, as I alluded in another thread, because higher power levels of the M178, are different base engines (granted, sharing similar hard parts architecture across the lineup), which could be a different contract / agreement with AMG, so it's not just turning up the wick with some ECU trickery.