Difficult to sell V8 Vantage privately?
Difficult to sell V8 Vantage privately?
Author
Discussion

Clumsy

Original Poster:

33 posts

123 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
I’m reading with interest the thread about Vantage values and what owners perceive what they think they are worth. I have had my V8 Roadster up for sale now for 3 weeks for what I think is a reasonable price after buying it from an AM main dealer 18 months ago. Unfortunately because I am not driving it enough (800 miles last year!) I have decided to part with it. The problem is that I have not even had one enquiry!.....the car is up for 5k less than what I bought it for 18months ago and after phoning a local performance car specialist he told me that cars like these are bought almost always by a company executive that wants a warranty, finance, and probably a part exchange, neither of which I can offer as a private seller.

He did give me an offer of 10k less than what I bought it for and said that he would probably ship it to Malta where they love these type of cars and make a couple of grand.

So my question is this....if I can’t sell privately, it seems that I’m over the proverbial barrel so I may not have a choice.....has anyone else had this problem? And if you’re planning on selling soon how do you think you will do it?

Cheers for any help.

nickv8

1,570 posts

114 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
The warranty is likely to be an important aspect. Not sure if finance is the be-all-and-end-all at this price range.

You could also look to pay AM for a 1 year warranty (around £1k) which can be transferred privately with the car, as I understand (may need checking). That could persuade someone.

But equally, look at many of the dealer stock. Some examples can hang around easily for a year.

Oh - and we're in mid-summer. Convertibles sound nice, but many of the potential buyers are being asked to buy family holidays / expensive day trips instead wink

GameofCars

850 posts

140 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
I'am also thinking of selling my V8VS manual. if i do I shall probably go via a SOR (sale or return) route with a main dealer or indy. The buyer will get all the dealer facilities - finance, warranty & drink their coffee. Your car will look good sat alongside other very nice cars etc. Cost from an indy I might use is 6% + VAT. They sell Porsche's Ferrari, Aston etc. I do know that for some reason their Aston's take longer to sell.

Big Ry

1,682 posts

150 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
nickv8 said:
The warranty is likely to be an important aspect. Not sure if finance is the be-all-and-end-all at this price range.

You could also look to pay AM for a 1 year warranty (around £1k) which can be transferred privately with the car, as I understand (may need checking). That
Not sure where you've got that price from. My 2013 V12V warranty was up in March, and the official price for a 12 month renewal was £2,172. Also remember that there would be a charge to asses the car first assuming it's not a straight warranty extension (which is doesn't sound like it is). On top of that they will insist that anything they pick up is fixed prior to the warranty being issued. The warranty does go with the car though, so is fully transferable.

People do sell these cars privately all the time though, but clearly it's unlikely to sell as quickly as a £5k fiesta, as the pool of buyers is obviously far smaller.

@OP........whilst you say you've got it up for less then you paid you didn't give any details of the car, so it's difficult for anyone to comment as although it might be £5k less, you might have paid £10k too much. I'm not saying you did, just pointing out that it's hard for anyone to comment on that angle really.

johnnyBv8

2,482 posts

222 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Whilst any car at this price probably wont sell as quickly as a cheap car, in my experience they do sell privately for cash - subject to the usual considerations; mileage, history, and correct pricing.

I've bought 2 of 3 of my Vantages privately with no warranty. I've also sold my previous 2 Vantages privately - both times got little response from Pistonheads, but eBay classified surprisingly came up trumps.

murphyaj

1,624 posts

106 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
3 Weeks isn't that long. The market isn't as liquid for these cars as more "normal" brands, there are fewer buyers looking for fewer cars, so you will need a lot more patience than you would with a regular car. It could just be that there is nobody in your part of the country that is in the market for your car right now.

Last year I wanted to sell my V8V privately and advertised it for about 10 weeks, during which time three people came to see it but nobody made a good enough offer. In the end I traded it in for not that much less than I was looking for privately. It is true that the majority of buyers for these cars will go straight to a dealer, but there are always some who will buy privately, it's just that you may need to wait for one to come along.

bogie

17,106 posts

303 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
If you buy from a dealer there is has got to be £5K plus margin in there, and if you sell to one a similar minimum amount. So losing £10k in 18 months cant be avoided on that front (buying and selling trade)

As example last time I traded in my 2006 Vantage, the main dealer serviced, warrantied, fix paint, refurb wheels and then had it up for £8k more than what they gave me. It sold within a few weeks

3 weeks is not a long time at all, if no-one is interested in 3 months then change something .....extended warranty is nice to have option, although not sure you will get it back in the price. So then you start to think about knocking down the price....

Try webuyanycar.com for a laugh to get bottom book price, and work up from there towards a realistic private price. Dont forget all the prices on autotrader etc are screen price and not necessarily what people are paying

S6PNJ

5,856 posts

312 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Where are you advertising it? I can't see it on the PH used cars search but haven't looked any wider.

Bobajobbob

1,599 posts

127 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Maybe worth calling McGurks, Nick Mee or another Indy to see what they’d pay for it. Probably that same as a main dealer but you never know if it’s the right car for a customer search.
For what it is worth when I recently traded my 07 coupe for a roadster the dealers I spoke to were all very keen to take the car, being confident they could flip it quickly though obviously only st the right price.
Can you give us a clue of the age, spec and price you are looking for?

lawtoni

258 posts

187 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Clumsy said:
I’m reading with interest the thread about Vantage values and what owners perceive what they think they are worth. I have had my V8 Roadster up for sale now for 3 weeks for what I think is a reasonable price after buying it from an AM main dealer 18 months ago. Unfortunately because I am not driving it enough (800 miles last year!) I have decided to part with it. The problem is that I have not even had one enquiry!.....the car is up for 5k less than what I bought it for 18months ago and after phoning a local performance car specialist he told me that cars like these are bought almost always by a company executive that wants a warranty, finance, and probably a part exchange, neither of which I can offer as a private seller.

He did give me an offer of 10k less than what I bought it for and said that he would probably ship it to Malta where they love these type of cars and make a couple of grand.

So my question is this....if I can’t sell privately, it seems that I’m over the proverbial barrel so I may not have a choice.....has anyone else had this problem? And if you’re planning on selling soon how do you think you will do it?

Cheers for any help.
I will very shortly (subject to sale of my TVR) be in the market and would actually prefer to buy privately and get more car for my money rather than go to a dealership. Please send me the details of your car if it's a 4.7.
Many thanks

Wilmslowboy

4,773 posts

237 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
I think the idea of buying an Aston from a main dealer, driving it for 18 months and then selling it for only £5k less is very ambitious, even a £10k loss is not a bad result.

Selling private is very hard these days, I sold my car in 4 weeks of it being on AT, in the end to a trader, it was the cheapest on AT by a long way (yet one of the lowest miles and highest spec). It now for sale for 10% more at the dealer.


Get an understanding of your cars fair trade value, ring a couple dealers and see what they will pay for it cash (no PX etc), look at the cheapest similar spec cars (and assume 10% less than them).

Private sale should be ano more than 5% more than this base trade value.




Herbs

5,132 posts

260 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
My last one (N400 Roadster I bought and sold privately) If it is priced realistically then it will sell but they will take a bit of time purely because the pool of potential buyers is that much smaller.

petrolburners

63 posts

117 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Wilmslowboy said:
I think the idea of buying an Aston from a main dealer, driving it for 18 months and then selling it for only £5k less is very ambitious, even a £10k loss is not a bad result.

Selling private is very hard these days, I sold my car in 4 weeks of it being on AT, in the end to a trader, it was the cheapest on AT by a long way (yet one of the lowest miles and highest spec). It now for sale for 10% more at the dealer.


Get an understanding of your cars fair trade value, ring a couple dealers and see what they will pay for it cash (no PX etc), look at the cheapest similar spec cars (and assume 10% less than them).

Private sale should be ano more than 5% more than this base trade value.
This. All of this.

p1stonhead

30,619 posts

198 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Personally, as someone in the market for a V8V, R8 or 997 GTS, I wouldnt consider buying any of them apart from a main dealer.

Maybe that is just me, but its just not worth the risk on such a car. It would have to be a lot less than the equivalent available at the dealer.

Eventually someone will come along I am sure. Could it be the age old - if its not sold, its too expensive?

Edited by p1stonhead on Friday 6th July 15:11

matrignano

4,702 posts

241 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
It took me about 2 months to sell my 2006 Vantage, despite being one of the cheapest in the country at £32k.

I only had 2 serious enquiries, and only one of the two viewed the car. He must have liked it I guess since he bought it! Nice chap too.

This was Sep-Nov last year though, admittedly a slower part of the year for selling this type of cars.

R8Steve

4,150 posts

206 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
I'm looking for a V8 Vantage at the moment if anyone selling wants to send me the details.

Clumsy

Original Poster:

33 posts

123 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Hi.....and thanks for all the replies so far. I didn’t want to be too specific about it because sometimes the mods will jump on it and see it as advertising which I think is against the rules. But if it helps it’s a 2008 Toro Red 4.3 Roadster, 27k on the clock. I took 9 months to find it and I truly believe it must be one of the best condition ones out there as it’s immaculate inside and out. I have it listed for £39995.

I have phoned Mcguirks and a local specialist but they only offered 35k which in my opinion was a bit low. Perhaps I am being a bit impatient but if I can’t sell a convertible in this weather then I’ll have less chance later in the year.

macdeb

8,760 posts

286 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Don't panic, as someone has said three weeks is nothing.

F355GTS

3,875 posts

286 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
I've just bought a V8S roadster for cash, I do admit all the cars I looked at did have the AM warranty.

To the OP I'd have definitely considered a private sale if it had the warranty so maybe a good idea, but if the trade have offered you £5k less than you're asking then it might not be such a bad deal

p1stonhead

30,619 posts

198 months

Friday 6th July 2018
quotequote all
Clumsy said:
Hi.....and thanks for all the replies so far. I didn’t want to be too specific about it because sometimes the mods will jump on it and see it as advertising which I think is against the rules. But if it helps it’s a 2008 Toro Red 4.3 Roadster, 27k on the clock. I took 9 months to find it and I truly believe it must be one of the best condition ones out there as it’s immaculate inside and out. I have it listed for £39995.

I have phoned Mcguirks and a local specialist but they only offered 35k which in my opinion was a bit low. Perhaps I am being a bit impatient but if I can’t sell a convertible in this weather then I’ll have less chance later in the year.
Not sure how much colour matters to most, but Aston approved have a 2007 with 36k miles on the clock for the same money.

https://used.astonmartin.com/en-GB/Search/Details~...

They also have a 2006 with 28k miles on the clock for the same price.

I think warranty on them makes them more appealing personally.

Perhaps a couple grand off would see it go quickly?