Forrester turbo or Impreza turbo/wrx for 2k?
Forrester turbo or Impreza turbo/wrx for 2k?
Author
Discussion

TwistingMyMelon

Original Poster:

6,488 posts

229 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
Hiya

I have around 2grand to spend ( I can spend more but am trying to save for travelling!!). I'm after a smallish estate, that is a good drive, currently I have an MX5, great car but too small. Really want to stay Japanese, so obviously been looking at Imprezas, uk turbos and import WRXs. There is alot to choose from, but also there is a lot of chav'd up crap as well.

Then I spotted that Turbo'd Forresters can be had from around £1800. Any owners on here? Are they any good (up to 2.k to spend)? What do they drive like, is there much body roll? Would love to test drive one, but the nearest is a 100 mile drive.

Also any tips on sub 3grand imprezas?

Thanks in advance guys.

cptsideways

13,835 posts

276 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
They are essentially an imprezza underneath, just taller on raised subframes. Watch for cold start rattles/piston slap as this is eventually terminal. Very common problem so always check from cold. Quick cars in manual trim, jap cars are good spec but rarely leather, UK cars are single turbo with leather/suede normally & not as quick as the JDM cars which are TT's.

TwistingMyMelon

Original Poster:

6,488 posts

229 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
Cheers for the quick reply! I take it Piston slap usually entails a engine rebuild? I have seen some people run them with it, but I presume this is borrowed time!!

What are the tell tails signs of ps, is it the noise on startup, also what helps cause it,?

CheerSsmile

jr502

487 posts

198 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
ok, been reading the forum for a long time, but never bothered to register, but had to for this. the above is not true.

piston slap is common (almost every one has it) with late 90's ej20 engines, and as long as it goes away once warm is not a problem. a rebuild will probably not get rid of it anyway. its a question which gets asked lots see http://www.subaruforester.org/vbulletin/f75/piston...

All foresters are single turbo, JDM ones use the same TD-04 turbo as the imprezas, and so put out 240BHP by JDM standards ( a bit less by our standards), UK models use a smaller turbo and so have around 160-170 BHP.

This info is relevent for SF5 foresters, not the later models. But for £2000 thats the shape you will be looking at.

markCSC

2,987 posts

239 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
UK cars are single turbo with leather/suede normally & not as quick as the JDM cars which are TT's.
Sorry but you've been mis informed.

As stated all Forester are single turbo. You can get a JDM "T/tb" but it stand for Touring Turbo".
I have an S/tb (Sport Turbo).

UK cars have a smaller turbo and different cams. Apart from that they are basically the same. However this means UK cars are arounf 170bhp and JDM cars are 220bhp N.B. they are meant to be 250bhp but this is on 100 RON fuel and the Japanese measure their bhp differently to us.


What are they like to drive? A bit wallowy really. However that can be fixed really cheaply by putting a 20mm rear anti roll bar on (STi Imprezas have them, normal cost £50 ish).

Any other questions just ask



TwistingMyMelon

Original Poster:

6,488 posts

229 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
Cheers for all the responses, all taken on board!

How do you find the ownership experience Mark? Anything to watch out for?

Cheers

jr502

487 posts

198 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
I also own a JDM forester, its an S-Tb as well.
although ive only had it 6 months, so long term stuff i cant comment on, but in the time ive had it ive enjoyed it. Its much more subtle than an impreza and so surprises quite a few people. ive managed to get 32 MPG, but that was making an effort, i normally get 27-28 mpg.

markCSC

2,987 posts

239 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
It's great really.

On the whole nobody knows what it is, so nobody tries to race you, steal it etc. As an estate it isn't that big and rear leg room is tight if you are tall.

Even though it is a JDM parts are OK and most Impreza parts and tuning goodies fit, which is nice.

It's been fairly reliable in the 40K that I have had mine (and it has had piston slap for all those 40k).
I've had the rocker gaskets leak (very common), O2 sensor fail and the other week the front cat destroyed itself. Apart from that it has just been normal servicing.

Fuel economy, like the Imprezas, is shocking, 27mpg on a run, 24 is normal. The JDM are mapped for 100 fuel so need 97 RON as a minimum.

I led the Pistonheads East Anglia Autumn run yesterday and had an RS4 and a 300bhp Atom behind me. I don't think I held them up too much so the old girl does me proud smile



Edited by markCSC on Monday 19th October 17:59

markCSC

2,987 posts

239 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
jr502 said:
Iive managed to get 32 MPG, but that was making an effort, i normally get 27-28 mpg.
I must take my lead boots off!!! wink

TwistingMyMelon

Original Poster:

6,488 posts

229 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
I like that, looks different! Anybody know how tunable the uk forester engine model is? ideally I would be after at least 200bhp

jr502

487 posts

198 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
to be perfectly honest theres not much point buying a UK model if you want 200 bhp, might as well buy a JDM, the easiest/reliable way to 200 BHP with a uk forester would be to put the TD-04 turbo on just like a JDM. then insurance will probably increase more than insuring an import. plus the JDM ones come better equipped, and if its a recent import should be rust free, lower mileage and generally tend to be better condition. although i am biased!

micron750

845 posts

256 months

Wednesday 21st October 2009
quotequote all
I have an Imported wagon to be honest i nearly bought a uk spec but changed my mind as the imports have more power and yes the insurance is a fair bit more depending on your age even at 43 three companys refused to insure me make sure too that the car if you do go up the imported route its been insured in this country before as a lot of insurers get a little twitchy on newly inported cars due the the history even wiv the correct documents.
Mines been modified a bit 'chav'd' up as you say so its pretty dam quick and thirsty if you keep on the boost
it runs ok on 97 ron but to get the best out of it 99 ron is by far the best option just a shame the nearest garage to me is 30 mins away so have no choice but to use 97,good luck with the search.........e-bays agood place as is the pistonhead classifieds.smile



Edited by micron750 on Wednesday 21st October 12:45

TwistingMyMelon

Original Poster:

6,488 posts

229 months

Wednesday 21st October 2009
quotequote all
Cheers for al the advice, pretty much what I thought in that there is no point buying a UK model and then trying to get more power out of it!

The JDM models look great, but they seem too rare and then out of my price range, will keep my eyes peeled!

Zead

377 posts

231 months

Wednesday 21st October 2009
quotequote all
Reading this with much interest as I am wanting exactly the same. Need a small 'van' that is good to drive and is a bit different. I found one recently, UK spec, but not much history. Need I worry? It has a bit of a hesitant slow acceleration, which to me is MAF sensor, but it's just been done! Slightly harsh front end, bushes? shocks? but looks well cared for and only 80k

Silver with black wheels is a good look for these.

Z