From my classic subaru to a 1.0 VAG
From my classic subaru to a 1.0 VAG
Author
Discussion

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I am about to change my car, and I am wondering if anyone has had any positive experiences, or am I going to be driven to distraction, literally??!!

I could possibly go for a 1.4 but the reason for the change is that my car hardly ever gets used.

I have also thought about some type of multi car insurance and keeping both cars on the road, but I am trying to be sensible on not let my love for the car rule over my head.

Basically the subaru leaves the drive every morning for the school run, and then sits at home until it's time to do the school run again.
With the price of fuel, and the fact the engine barely warms up, I just want something that is going to be more economical.

I just don't know what to do!

amccan10

589 posts

201 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I'll straight swap you my 1.6 leon ;-)

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
amccan10 said:
I'll straight swap you my 1.6 leon ;-)
Lol! Could be interesting....

If you were serious pm me wink

mmcd87

629 posts

226 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I wouldn't go to the complete extreme if you like your cars. Get a Panda 100hp or at least something that would be good fun on a weekend blast and you wouldn't mind giving the odd clean. Suzuki Swift/Ignis Sport also worth a look. You could service both yourself too so could be nice and cheap to run.

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I have seen a few swift's and thought they could be an option.

But I do like the VAG wink never had anything go wrong with one.

But I have never had anything go wrong with my Subaru either.

I do think that a 1.0L might be to the extreme but I have a company car also that isn't slow.

Drop Test b3nxj

1,091 posts

237 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
What you need is a golf GT TDI.

I currently have a 90bhp tdi and it does 55mpg every morning, its a bit slow but it gets the job done. thumbup

amccan10

589 posts

201 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I was joking, mine has done 110K miles so dont think you'd want that.

But I'd def recommend VAG I've had it for over 5 yrs and have driven over 80K miles in it and have never put my hand in my pocket, well apart from the usual wear and tear for a 9 year old car:
Servicing
Exhaust
Brakes
Suspension (potholes!!)
Tyres

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

221 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
Hysteria1983 said:
I have seen a few swift's and thought they could be an option.

But I do like the VAGwink never had anything go wrong with one.

But I have never had anything go wrong with my Subaru either.

I do think that a 1.0L might be to the extreme but I have a company car also that isn't slow.
Don't we all.

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
Drop Test b3nxj said:
What you need is a golf GT TDI.

I currently have a 90bhp tdi and it does 55mpg every morning, its a bit slow but it gets the job done. thumbup
Yes, that would be great, but as it's only going to be a run around/social car it doesn't really need to much poke.
My children are only 5 and almost 4 so it doesn't need to be big.

Basically it needs to be a reasonable price, and I'm going to be paying a few £££ for a gt tdi.
But if I get rid of the scoob, then I have a bit more £££ to play with.

I would probably be happy with a deisel that has a few extra miles on it as I only do about 3500-4000 miles a year.

mmcd87

629 posts

226 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
A diesel on short journeys wouldn't be a great idea. Engine takes longer to warm up and mpg won't be the best either.

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
mmcd87 said:
A diesel on short journeys wouldn't be a great idea. Engine takes longer to warm up and mpg won't be the best either.
Nope.

But if I had a car that was more economical I would go out more, and use it more socially.

paulmoonraker

2,850 posts

186 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I got a diesel Focus for the week day / work hack. Great MPG when its warm, however, rubbish for popping to the shops etc. I would have thought a small engined petrol car would be better... I think 5th Gear did a comparison between petrol and diesel and found that, given the mark-up and additional fuel costs of a diesel, you needed to do 10K+ miles a year to be quids in (I don’t recall the exact mileage they quoted)...

Diesels are a necessary evil wink

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
The mark up price isnt going to make a huge difference to me as im not looking for a brand new car.

I am fully expecting that an oil burner is going to be a little more expensive that a petrol of the same age/car.....
But It will still be cheaper to run a deisel.

Insurance up in a week, so will probably stick with what I have. I don't want to rush and buy a car. Just not sensible.



paulmoonraker said:
I got a diesel Focus for the week day / work hack. Great MPG when its warm, however, rubbish for popping to the shops etc. I would have thought a small engined petrol car would be better... I think 5th Gear did a comparison between petrol and diesel and found that, given the mark-up and additional fuel costs of a diesel, you needed to do 10K+ miles a year to be quids in (I don’t recall the exact mileage they quoted)...

Diesels are a necessary evil wink

paulmoonraker

2,850 posts

186 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
I paid 5.5K for my Focus (MY06 1.8 Zetec 50K). The petrol equivalent was about 4.5K (IIRC).

japgt

349 posts

187 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
I have the perfect solution, get rid of the subaru and buy a subaru!! Buy a justy, still in a scoob but an economical one!!

mneame

1,486 posts

234 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
If the engine doesn't warm up does that mean you live within walking distance of the school? Just an idea but if you do, walk to school on the days the weather is ok and then you won't need to change the car for something more economical.

Or get a diesel. What you save on fuel costs will happily pay for the insurance to keep the the Impreza. However you'll then be in my position when the Impreza doesn't get used at all and sits on the drive 24/7. frown So yep, my Impreza is up for sale due to non use as a second car, double frown.

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
mneame said:
If the engine doesn't warm up does that mean you live within walking distance of the school? Just an idea but if you do, walk to school on the days the weather is ok and then you won't need to change the car for something more economical.

Or get a diesel. What you save on fuel costs will happily pay for the insurance to keep the the Impreza. However you'll then be in my position when the Impreza doesn't get used at all and sits on the drive 24/7. frown So yep, my Impreza is up for sale due to non use as a second car, double frown.
Not quite walking distance.

The engine is technically warm, but It literally is warm as I'm just pulling onto the carpark. Thus causing lack or charge to the battery, thus causing me to get stuck in random places like asda car park or shell petrol station!!

It needs regular longer runs to keep her tip top, and I'm just not doing it.

In all honesty I'm thinking of keeping hold until the summer as it will sell easier.
But I am going to advertise it now also.
If it goes GREAT, if not... I get to enjoy it until it does.

mneame

1,486 posts

234 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
Hysteria1983 said:
If it goes GREAT, if not... I get to enjoy it until it does.
That's what I;m doing with mine. No doubt if it goes though I'll want another one in a few months and then I'll be onto Impreza number 4 lol.

Hysteria1983

Original Poster:

1,616 posts

181 months

Friday 25th February 2011
quotequote all
mneame said:
That's what I;m doing with mine. No doubt if it goes though I'll want another one in a few months and then I'll be onto Impreza number 4 lol.
That's the problem.

But being a mum of two, I suppose I should start being a bit more sensible! wink

Mr. Potato Head

1,176 posts

242 months

Saturday 26th February 2011
quotequote all
Hysteria1983 said:
I could possibly go for a 1.4
A 1.0 Lupo or Arosa is often less economical than the 1.4 75bhp versions, and the insurance is about the same.
I presume a Polo, being heavier, is the same.

Get the 1.4.