Bmw 3 series diesel touring
Bmw 3 series diesel touring
Author
Discussion

jinkster

Original Poster:

2,429 posts

187 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
Looking for a second hand diesel touring. 320d or 330d.



Which would you buy and why?

Has anyone experience of using them in winter with winter tyres?

Looking forward to any comments.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
Google BMW swirl flaps, and get to know the issue, other than that, good luck !

eg ; http://www.swirlflaps.co.uk/

jinkster

Original Poster:

2,429 posts

187 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for your reply. I understood this was on the earlier models 2003 - 2004. Obviously not after reading the article - thanks!

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Saturday 7th April 2012
quotequote all
You are so very welcome, I have a few mates who are mechanics, I've seen peoples wallets hurt badly by this.

I am a BMW fan, but issues like this are annoying, but as long as you're aware, you can factor it in your decision(s).

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
What model are you looking at buying, E46 or E91

I have both, the E46 is a 330d, early model, manual with no swirl flaps, I think it's possibly the pick of the E46 330d range as it doesn't have auto box issues or swirl flaps to worry about, that if either fails can write one of these cars off in once swift hit. BTW it has also done 180k and has been reliable so far.

E91 is my favourite 3 series, I'm on my 3rd one now, they have all been 6 cylinder diesels and have all been faultless as a whole, current car has required a gearbox software update, red boost hose replacement and diff input seal, all covered under warranty, which is currently only £44 per month so worth having IMO

If it was me I'd buy a 330d, slightly heavier on fuel than a 320d, but it's a small price to pay for the better car.

Billyray911

1,086 posts

235 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
I agree with Martin,the 330d is a great car.If you're thinking of the 330d as an option and buy the 320,you may quickly feel that you should have bought the other...
Also,if your after an auto,why not just get a 335d?(!)
Re winters.If you do not have the use of another car,I would strongly advise getting some winters.
If you do decide on a car,budget for a set of winter wheels and tyres-you can get 2nd hand wheels quite easily and cheaply from ebay.Research and buy some tyres in September(when they tend to be released)-don't wait for the bad weather to come as limited stock and high prices as poor weather hits,will make it difficult to source anything decent.
I've a set of vredestein wintrac extremes and they haven't put a foot wrong in 2 years.
A set of winters should last 4 years before they start to degrade and can be sold on at a premium,so you can recoup some cash.

JOHNC74

139 posts

235 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
I have a LCI 330d touring, the best all round car I have ever run. The only downside is I didn't spec the auto box, hindsight is a great thing.

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Sunday 8th April 2012
quotequote all
It's worth noting that my 335d which has been remapped is returning better mpg figures than my friends E90 330d auto that is 100% stock

Just in case the OP is looking at E9x range of vehicles

Panda76

2,583 posts

181 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
I run the 320d version.Great car and ideal for my needs,albeit I no longer require a diesel engine but why change just for the sake of getting petrol is my thinking atm.
Late 2006,one of the very last updated manifolds before the 177 bhp 320d was introduced.
I have zero worry about the flaps buying this model and year,earlier than that I would be a little more worried.
Dodgy thermostats can screw the mpg on them too.My main thermostat is due to be changed as it's faulty and the coolant won't go above 80°C,optimum running temps are 90°C-94°C.MPG on motorway runs gone from mid 50's to low 40's so it's worth checking.

cerb4.5lee

45,275 posts

211 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
I would go 330d all the way, we have a e90 330d & its all the car you will ever need imo, i have a 2009 520d & the engine is a very poor relative to the 6 pot diesel by a long way.

Its worth paying the extra for the better engine & i dont rate the 20d engine much, its louder less smooth & lacks power & the difference in economy between our two cars is one mpg.

I think its better having a 3 litre that has to work less hard than having a 2 litre thats struggling its backside off!

Its just my opinion but in this case bigger is better.

boyoM3

160 posts

208 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
Ive had an 07 325d Touring and loved it. I had it mapped in the end so now would definitely go with a 330d. The sound is so much more cultured. You could barely notice it was a diesel most of the time, especially when warm.

You wont get the fuel efficiency of the 320d but IMO its worth the extra.

LukeSi

5,780 posts

192 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
The 09 onwards 325d is mechanically identical to the 330d so if you can get one of them and remap it they are the exact same car.

boyoM3

160 posts

208 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
LukeSi said:
The 09 onwards 325d is mechanically identical to the 330d so if you can get one of them and remap it they are the exact same car.
AFAIK so was my 57 plate 325d(it was the 3.0 TDI common rail engine). Ive read that the only difference was the injectors and possibly the clutch/flywheel. Were these items exactly the same on the '09 onwards?

LukeSi

5,780 posts

192 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
boyoM3 said:
AFAIK so was my 57 plate 325d(it was the 3.0 TDI common rail engine). Ive read that the only difference was the injectors and possibly the clutch/flywheel. Were these items exactly the same on the '09 onwards?
Yup, mechanically identical, simply a 330d running a lower engine map (204bhp).

roofer

5,136 posts

242 months

Monday 9th April 2012
quotequote all
Put 130k on this;


Only major drama was front pulley shearing at 100k which lead to this;


Never needed winter tyres on it just turn the traction off and the torque on tickover got it out of anywhere.

This is now on 113k (330d)



No real dramas, bit boring though.

Had this for a couple of months (320d)



Most boring BMW i've ever driven, total waste of combustion. If you have choice, get a 335d, they don't need mapping, and are good fun on track, the difference in fuel compared to a 330d is negligble.

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Tuesday 10th April 2012
quotequote all
LukeSi said:
boyoM3 said:
AFAIK so was my 57 plate 325d(it was the 3.0 TDI common rail engine). Ive read that the only difference was the injectors and possibly the clutch/flywheel. Were these items exactly the same on the '09 onwards?
Yup, mechanically identical, simply a 330d running a lower engine map (204bhp).
Not so the 325d and 330d were only the same bar the software from
The LCI facelift

LukeSi

5,780 posts

192 months

Tuesday 10th April 2012
quotequote all
martin mrt said:
Not so the 325d and 330d were only the same bar the software from
The LCI facelift
That is what I meant. The LCI is 2009 model year. My father has got a 325d LCI and even though it is a 2008 build it is a 2009 model year car.