Why make the sump nut hollow...
Why make the sump nut hollow...
Author
Discussion

dirty doug

Original Poster:

485 posts

226 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
... so it shears off in situ!!!!!!! furious

I understand having a 'weak link' but why make it so easily breakable!!

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
so you can get an easy out in the middle without having to drill it out and get fash in sump.


dirty doug

Original Poster:

485 posts

226 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
steve_bmw said:
so you can get an easy out in the middle without having to drill it out and get fash in sump.
That was my conclusion but is that not creating a solution to a problem that wouldn't exist if it wasn't hollow?

A 12mm bolt is not going to shear off without being done up by a gorilla.

A 12mm bolt with a 6mm hole can be sheared off by me in an instant!

_bryan_

250 posts

210 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
I thought the sump plugs were made weak for a reason, because of the aluminium sump. What would you rather fork out for, getting the sump re-threaded or just a new sump plug?

steve_bmw

1,591 posts

206 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
dirty doug said:
That was my conclusion but is that not creating a solution to a problem that wouldn't exist if it wasn't hollow?

A 12mm bolt is not going to shear off without being done up by a gorilla.

A 12mm bolt with a 6mm hole can be sheared off by me in an instant!
A 12 mm bolt into aluminium can strip the threads, I would rather snap the sump plug than have to replace the sump because I have buggerd up the threads.

Those sump plugs don't have to be mega tight, just nipped up and then a gentle tug will do.