E46 330ci tyres - Any recommendations?
E46 330ci tyres - Any recommendations?
Author
Discussion

VanBas

Original Poster:

124 posts

183 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
Tried the search but it didn't seem to be working at the moment so.....

I will need 4 new tyres very soon and was wondering what people would recommend to put on my 330? It has Dunlop’s on the back atm and Falken (456?) on the front and it does tramline a fair bit as has been said before. I will definitely get the same tyres all round because of this and do not want budget Chinese rubbish. I have only had smaller hot hatches before and have always put Toyo Proxy T1R's on them; however I have heard these are no good on bigger cars.

So what experiences have people had with different tyres and what is a good mix of reasonable cost/performance?

Thanks,

Van

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
FK452 are ok if they are the 18" staggered types.

Cheap, good grip, nice ride, ok life. They do wear funny though which is why they end their life early, but they are cheap, soooo.


T1-R are horrible, they are horrible on bigger cars and smaller ones. The T1-S if you can find them are/were infinitely better.


I've been running Eagle F1 Asymmetric on my Z4 but they have recently re-formulated them which means they cost more and do the same as before, but look crapper, grip more (whyyyyy moreee!), and wear about the same, so I'm also looking for an alternative in the mean time.

I think the Continental 5's are worth a look. A bit more expensive but I've heard nothing but good thinks about a good blend of life and grip and flat wear performance.


Hmmm

Dave

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
Another one running F1 Asymmetrics on my Z4 and pleased with them. Also using them on the (daily driver)TT and expect @ 12-15k miles.

We had bad tramlining on the 330ci M Sport which had Pirellis on the front and Bridgestone's on the rear. Was thinking I may have to change them all for F1s maybe but dealer advised Michelins or Bridgestone were best so we put Bridgestones on the front to make them all the same. V pleased with the results so far, almost no tramlining.


Luca Brasi

885 posts

205 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
Currently running Kumho Ecsta SPTs on my 325i, not as good as the PS2s I had before but more than acceptable none the less.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
I've been running Eagle F1 Asymmetric on my Z4 but they have recently re-formulated them which means they cost more and do the same as before, but look crapper, grip more (whyyyyy moreee!), and wear about the same, so I'm also looking for an alternative in the mean time.
An odd view, the Eagle F1 Assymetric 2 is an improvement in every way (Well, they do look a bit crap). It offers slightly better performance (Though performance was never a weak point) but has addressed the poor rolling resistence the Assymetric 1 offered. They claim to have improved wear as well, though I won't know for a while. I got about 10k out of the Assymetric 2 and 13k out of a ContiSport Contact 3. Hoping for more from the AS2!

I'd fit either Assymetric 2 or Contisport Contact 5's to the 330Ci. Which one you prefer is up to you. I was forced into the Eagles as Conti dont do the CS5 in my rear size.

No need to be messing about with Falkens unless you particularly want to spend less, they are a bit of an internet-hero tyre because they are cheap, they managed to come about 25th in the big wet weather stopping distance comparison a German mag did a few months back.

rumple

15,415 posts

182 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
If money is tight I'd go for vredestein, they are on mine and pretty good, you can't compare them to ps2's but they are very good and you can get them for 130 for the rear, 255/35/18 that would be, and for that they are bargain of the century.

Patrick Bateman

13,219 posts

205 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
Eagle F1 Assymetric 2.

I don't really see them as costing more, I could have had the older tyre for the same/more money when I got mine so not exactly loads either way. They're one of the best tyres available, just look at the reviews, not to mention still significantly cheaper than rivals from Continental and Michelin.

The appearance of tyres isn't really something I 'get' either, not a consideration at all.

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Wednesday 16th May 2012
quotequote all
Fox- said:
Mr Whippy said:
I've been running Eagle F1 Asymmetric on my Z4 but they have recently re-formulated them which means they cost more and do the same as before, but look crapper, grip more (whyyyyy moreee!), and wear about the same, so I'm also looking for an alternative in the mean time.
An odd view, the Eagle F1 Assymetric 2 is an improvement in every way (Well, they do look a bit crap). It offers slightly better performance (Though performance was never a weak point) but has addressed the poor rolling resistence the Assymetric 1 offered. They claim to have improved wear as well, though I won't know for a while. I got about 10k out of the Assymetric 2 and 13k out of a ContiSport Contact 3. Hoping for more from the AS2!

I'd fit either Assymetric 2 or Contisport Contact 5's to the 330Ci. Which one you prefer is up to you. I was forced into the Eagles as Conti dont do the CS5 in my rear size.

No need to be messing about with Falkens unless you particularly want to spend less, they are a bit of an internet-hero tyre because they are cheap, they managed to come about 25th in the big wet weather stopping distance comparison a German mag did a few months back.
My main gripe is that on my Z4 at least, there is almost TOO much grip already, and the AS2 are even more grippy. They really don't NEED to have more outright grip as it just makes the car more dull.
Give me longer life and retain the same grip.

I agree on the Falkens, they are cheap but for a reason. The odd wear behaviour alone had me moving to different tyres after the first batch!


I was tempted by the SP001 or Conti 5 for my next set. The fronts seem to go about twice as long as the rears so right now I'm on AS2 rear and AS1 front, but they should all be gone by winter ready for new boots all round!

Dave

VanBas

Original Poster:

124 posts

183 months

Thursday 17th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies, some interesting points mentioned. My Falkens i have on at the moment don't seem to be wearing uneven so i am supprised by this. They seem good value to me, blackcircles have them for £152 each, £50 per tyre cheaper than other things people have pointed to. I know you probably get what you pay for.

Has anyone tried these: Hankook Ventus V12 Evo K110? £170 each.

If not i might go for eagle f1 asy 2's, £200 each fully fitted at blackcircles.

PS2's seem to be really expensive £275 each!! Are they really worth around £100 per tyre more than Falkens? I expect people will say yes smile

sinizter

3,348 posts

217 months

Thursday 17th May 2012
quotequote all
Vredstein Ultrac Sessanta ....

I have them on my 530D now, and they seem pretty good.

Fox-

13,577 posts

277 months

Thursday 17th May 2012
quotequote all
You can get the F1s for less. I have never found blackcircles to be anything other than expensive.

Try tyreshopper or HiQ. I paid 197 fitted at HiQ and that was for 265 35 18 which are more expensive than your size.

x 7usc

1,443 posts

226 months

Thursday 17th May 2012
quotequote all
also try http://www.camskill.co.uk

not sure about fitting but prices are excellent thumbup





Edited by x 7usc on Thursday 17th May 11:16

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Thursday 17th May 2012
quotequote all
Yeah, £200 for an F1 fitted is a complete rip-off.

A 330Ci is big enough to fit tyres in the boot/back seats, so buy them from camskill at £168 each, and take them to a fitters. They shouldn't charge more than £10 a corner.

So about £180 each, that is £40 saved for the rear pair.



Or if you want the FK452 they are £120 on camskill for the rear ones.

As said, they are not a bad tyre per se, just on the Z4 if you ran recommended pressures then they wore badly in the centres at the back, and if you lowered them to compensate the handling went a bit iffy... so I ended up with inside shoulders on the fronts worn down at about 10k and thus a bit iffy for the MOT, and rear centres to wear bars at about 9k.

F1's straight on and the rears were 10k and wore totally flat both times, and the fronts are still on and wearing pretty much flat too except wear on the very inside edge but nowhere near as bad as the FK452.


FK452 are also narrower than equivalents from others, I think about 10mm for rears and fronts are about 12mm narrower than F1 AS1 across the wear area.


Dave

VanBas

Original Poster:

124 posts

183 months

Thursday 17th May 2012
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Yeah, £200 for an F1 fitted is a complete rip-off.

A 330Ci is big enough to fit tyres in the boot/back seats, so buy them from camskill at £168 each, and take them to a fitters. They shouldn't charge more than £10 a corner.

So about £180 each, that is £40 saved for the rear pair.



Or if you want the FK452 they are £120 on camskill for the rear ones.

As said, they are not a bad tyre per se, just on the Z4 if you ran recommended pressures then they wore badly in the centres at the back, and if you lowered them to compensate the handling went a bit iffy... so I ended up with inside shoulders on the fronts worn down at about 10k and thus a bit iffy for the MOT, and rear centres to wear bars at about 9k.

F1's straight on and the rears were 10k and wore totally flat both times, and the fronts are still on and wearing pretty much flat too except wear on the very inside edge but nowhere near as bad as the FK452.


FK452 are also narrower than equivalents from others, I think about 10mm for rears and fronts are about 12mm narrower than F1 AS1 across the wear area.


Dave
Camskill do seem like a good option, think i will have to give them a go. They also do the Hankook's aswell as the eagle f1's.

How do you know the FK452's are narrower?

Mr Whippy

32,453 posts

272 months

Friday 18th May 2012
quotequote all
The FK452 are narrower as you could compare/contrast by rolling them up to mounted F1's on the same dimension wheels.

I have a worn down set still on my old 108 style wheels.


They literally do have a narrower rolling surface, and MUCH less rim protection. The new AS2 in comparison has about 7-8mm more overhang on the sidewall at each side vs the 255 FK452, and that carries on up the wall to the contact patch and across the tyre width!


I'm not sure it's a bad thing, but could be why they wear funny, or not last as long, or are cheaper?!

In any case they were better than the standard RE050 RFT... that said I liked the feel of those tyres, I wonder what non-RFT RE050 are like... hmmmmm...


Cheers

Dave

NelsonR32

1,777 posts

202 months

Friday 18th May 2012
quotequote all
Pirelli P-Zero Rosso's for me. They seem to offer a specific 3 series version which may help my tramlining woes.

s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Friday 18th May 2012
quotequote all
Conti Sport Contacts seem to be pretty good ime

VanBas

Original Poster:

124 posts

183 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replys.

Does anyone have any experience of Eagle F! asy2's and whether they tramline alot?

I have a mate who has them on the front of his 330 and falkens on the back and he gets a fair bit of tramlining.

I dont want to make it worse by putting F!'s on all round if they do this.

I know someone before said the dealer told them put bridgestones or michelin on insted of F1's all round. Is this just dealer brand loyalty?

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Saturday 19th May 2012
quotequote all
VanBas said:
Thanks for all the replys.

Does anyone have any experience of Eagle F! asy2's and whether they tramline alot?

I have a mate who has them on the front of his 330 and falkens on the back and he gets a fair bit of tramlining.

I dont want to make it worse by putting F!'s on all round if they do this.

I know someone before said the dealer told them put bridgestones or michelin on insted of F1's all round. Is this just dealer brand loyalty?
That was me, re Bridgestones or Michelins. Dealer chap was an enthusiast too, who took an interest, and had had several E46s himself. I'd had 4 wheel alignment done first, bushes and pressures checked, but it was matching a set rather than brand which made a big difference. That tied in with what I'd read online such as it is. I was thinking of changing the whole set to F1s but went with matching to cut costs.

The Bridgestones feel fine in other respects too, and comparable with my old E46, which had GSD3s, though that was on 17s with which tramlining isn't an issue afaik.

I put F1 Asy's (not Asy 2s) on my Z4 (18s) and tramlining pretty well disappeared. That's compared to rfts though. I've no complaints and I've used them on the Audi and they're fine, and they'll be my first choice again.

Only caveat is I don't do many miles, so can't say how they wear compared to others. Oh, and I'm by no means a tech, so just my view.

Know where you're coming from though, not cheap, don't want to be disappointed.






Ruskie

4,530 posts

231 months

Tuesday 22nd May 2012
quotequote all
sinizter said:
Vredstein Ultrac Sessanta ....

I have them on my 530D now, and they seem pretty good.
Had a pair of these on the rear of my 330 and although they look good and the grip levels have been good the wear has not been great. I am looking for some at the moment but unsure of which way to go. Got Avon's on the front and they seem pretty good.