Pre-face lift for me, I had a 2001 325ci convertible and a 2004 M3 and although the M3 never received the facelift I prefer the early look, although saying that I do like the later cars as well, just not as much.
Pre facelift, that's why I brought one, I think the prefacelift E46 coupe with the sport package is BMW's best looking car ever, with the exception of the M3 and CSL versions, the facelift was bangles little mess with it and he ruined it, that is of course just my opinion.
Facelift Saloon/Estate, the lights on the facelift Coupe/Convertible don't quite look right. But that photo of the US spec Coupe looks perfect, removing the front plate makes such a difference IMO. I mean I'm not at all biased...
Prefacelift, having owned both. The indicators halfway along the wing look better on the face lifted cars but I really don't like the shape of the indicator lens next to the headlights on face lifted cars. I think the face lifted cars have a softer/ more feminine face.