E39 touring - what to look for
Discussion
suspension, suspension, suspension.
any wheel wobbles, engines seem pretty strong, but check the alternator is all ok on earlier V8's as they're a very pricey fix. minor rust around the arches, gearboxes if you're going for an auto, missing pixels on the dash.
plenty of common faults but very few major ones to be honest. diesels have a bigger tendency for bork due to turbo failure, injectors etc etc and they initially cost more, so unless doing really big miles it's often more economically viable to go for the much nicer petrols as they don't harm the wallet quite so much, generally.
any wheel wobbles, engines seem pretty strong, but check the alternator is all ok on earlier V8's as they're a very pricey fix. minor rust around the arches, gearboxes if you're going for an auto, missing pixels on the dash.
plenty of common faults but very few major ones to be honest. diesels have a bigger tendency for bork due to turbo failure, injectors etc etc and they initially cost more, so unless doing really big miles it's often more economically viable to go for the much nicer petrols as they don't harm the wallet quite so much, generally.
They're all old enough now to be an economic write off in the event of a mechanical disaster, so don't spend £5000 on one when a clean £2000 example will do. The rear suspension has airbags and a compressor in the 'spare wheel' area. As well as the airbags going pop (not that expensive to replace - around £400 for both with labour) the pump can drown in leaked in rain water.
Diesels are a great idea until they go bang, which they do quite spectacularly. Petrols are a better bet and the 523i and 525i are okay. Autoboxes can go tits up, but they're not that bad. The cooling system is a weak point, most radiators are ripe for replacement at 8-10 years old and whilst the plastic impeller water pump is supposed to be a weak point, they seem to last 10 years okay.
In short, E39's are heading firmly into banger territory and the older ones are already there. They are a nice old thing though, especially compared to the horror show that replaced it.
Diesels are a great idea until they go bang, which they do quite spectacularly. Petrols are a better bet and the 523i and 525i are okay. Autoboxes can go tits up, but they're not that bad. The cooling system is a weak point, most radiators are ripe for replacement at 8-10 years old and whilst the plastic impeller water pump is supposed to be a weak point, they seem to last 10 years okay.
In short, E39's are heading firmly into banger territory and the older ones are already there. They are a nice old thing though, especially compared to the horror show that replaced it.
we have a 525i sport touring with about 80k miles. had first service recently no adverse findings and no replacements of above items as yet
cam cover gasket is known to be weak spot so check head esp towards to rear for signs of weep. its usually the gasket but covers are known to crack - difference is 20gbp part vs 200gbp part plus a few hours labour
usual precautions with belts and pullies so look for evidence of them being done or get all clear that current items serviceable
check puddle lights on front and rear doors. tailgate for rust and for the sport check the black plastic under bumbers undearneath front bumper for damage
if door hinges stays do not stay in open position ie are broken then repairs can be costly
cam cover gasket is known to be weak spot so check head esp towards to rear for signs of weep. its usually the gasket but covers are known to crack - difference is 20gbp part vs 200gbp part plus a few hours labour
usual precautions with belts and pullies so look for evidence of them being done or get all clear that current items serviceable
check puddle lights on front and rear doors. tailgate for rust and for the sport check the black plastic under bumbers undearneath front bumper for damage
if door hinges stays do not stay in open position ie are broken then repairs can be costly
iSore said:
They're all old enough now to be an economic write off in the event of a mechanical disaster, so don't spend £5000 on one when a clean £2000 example will do.
Interesting perspective. I was thinking don't spend £2k on one that will need masses of work when I've got the budget for a really decent one. If £2k decent ones exist I can't find them, so far anyway.Looking at petrol only by the way, 530i sport.
Nothing wrong with the composite impeller pumps. They're good for a lot of miles and I've seen them last 12-13 years. Yes, they eventually go wrong but what water pump doesn't? I would certainly remove it for inspection during a cooling system overhaul however on a 9-10 year old E39.
eastsider said:
iSore said:
They're all old enough now to be an economic write off in the event of a mechanical disaster, so don't spend £5000 on one when a clean £2000 example will do.
Interesting perspective. I was thinking don't spend £2k on one that will need masses of work when I've got the budget for a really decent one. If £2k decent ones exist I can't find them, so far anyway.Looking at petrol only by the way, 530i sport.
sparks_E39 said:
eastsider said:
iSore said:
They're all old enough now to be an economic write off in the event of a mechanical disaster, so don't spend £5000 on one when a clean £2000 example will do.
Interesting perspective. I was thinking don't spend £2k on one that will need masses of work when I've got the budget for a really decent one. If £2k decent ones exist I can't find them, so far anyway.Looking at petrol only by the way, 530i sport.
sparks_E39 said:
£1100ish from a specialist. Previous owner of my car spent £3000 on it in 2007!
ah, far from the end of the world if it does go bang then really. sure, it's a big bill but to be fair, treated well the engines will go on for huge mileages.....if you keep on top of the cooling system and the gearbox is good to go the E38 and E39 cars should be able to reach huge mileages. the other problem is the fuel tanks, only effected on the E38's though....that's about a £1k job, or just under.BliarOut said:
Cooling system refurb is about £200 for the parts, easy enough DIY job. If you get one that's been looked after they're cracking cars.
i'm USELESS with cars, i'd have to get someone else to do it. i'd also struggle for space to be honest. my car had a new radiator in Dec 2010 so that's good for a while, it had a new thermostat Dec 2011 and the water pump wasn't making any excess noise nor was the bearing loose so they left it be. maybe something for the cooling system will go in Dec 2012? 
iSore said:
They're all old enough now to be an economic write off in the event of a mechanical disaster, so don't spend £5000 on one when a clean £2000 example will do.
I couldn't disagree more - firstly there is no such thing as a clean £2000 530i Sport Touring and secondly they are not economic writeoffs in the event of a mechanical disaster. Heck even if the entire engine explodes on you another one fitted is about a grand! Hardly a write-off on a £4k car?It'll be a bloody shame if they all begin to die for want of a gearbox refurb or something because they begin to get bought by people who would rather scrap a perfectly good car than repair it for more good service.
Ask hornetrider how many good 530i Sport Tourings there are advertised at much under 4k. He has spent the last few months trying to find one. I found zero last year and I'd imagine it hasn't changed much since.
E38Ross said:
BliarOut said:
Pump was only about £60 IIRC, while everything was out I thought I'd swap it anyway as they're a bit of a PITA to bleed 
was that for an official BMW one? if/when mine fails, i'll almost certainly get an official BMW one.

I always use OEM parts where available, quality is as good without the fancy box. Helps keep costs down

Gassing Station | BMW General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


